News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fatness and Thinness in the Middle Ages by klmadfejno on Thursday June 11, 2020 @09:19PM (#23495007)
The paper you linked does not say what you think it says. It merely claims that, due to a lack of proof otherwise, calories don't evade thermodynamic laws.

It also says the exact opposite of what you seem to believe, which is that diets with different macronutrients compositions have different weight outcomes despite having the same number of calories.

Re:Fatness and Thinness in the Middle Ages by ulisesrmzroche on Friday June 12, 2020 @12:42AM (#23496096)
It doesn’t say that, copy paste please
Re:Fatness and Thinness in the Middle Ages by klmadfejno on Friday June 12, 2020 @09:59AM (#23499282)
Literally just read the abstract.

> Neither macronutrient-specific differences in the availability of dietary energy nor changes in energy expenditure could explain these differences in weight loss. Thermodynamics dictate that a calorie is a calorie regardless of the macronutrient composition of the diet.

Note:

* Thermodynamically, the amount of energy in a calorie is fixed

* The differences in these energies cannot explain weight loss changes driven by macronutrients as found in other studies

Re:Fatness and Thinness in the Middle Ages by ulisesrmzroche on Friday June 12, 2020 @09:28PM (#23505827)
I said calorie is a calorie. Why are you saying I said otherwise?

Is anyone here under ten percent body fat and a muscular physique? I really doubt it.

Re:Fatness and Thinness in the Middle Ages by bena on Thursday June 11, 2020 @09:30PM (#23495072)
But the paper is clear to state that only about a third of the difference can be attributed to composition.

And that difference is basically how hard the body works to break down the nutrients.

There is no magic food that makes it impossible to gain weight. And at the end of the day, a calorie is a calorie. Want to control your weight? Control your intake.

Re:Fatness and Thinness in the Middle Ages by klmadfejno on Thursday June 11, 2020 @09:55PM (#23495223)
I don't know what you think you're saying. A third of the total effect size is a lot. Nobody denies that the volume of food is going to be a significant driver of your weight change. The issue being debated is that the composition matters, and it does.

And for what its worth, I'd imagine the effect size to be even stronger for weight gain.

Re:Fatness and Thinness in the Middle Ages by AareyBaba on Thursday June 11, 2020 @11:15PM (#23495659)
"The paper you linked does not say what you think it says"

"I don't know what you think you're saying"

Let your reasoning speak for itself. The unnecessary snark diminishes the point you are trying to make.

Re:Fatness and Thinness in the Middle Ages by klmadfejno on Friday June 12, 2020 @09:39AM (#23499099)
That's fine. The point of those particular statements is to say that they are not only factually incorrect, but not even self consistent, which is intrinsically snarky. We're not in a formal debate.
Re:Fatness and Thinness in the Middle Ages by bena on Thursday June 11, 2020 @11:55PM (#23495862)
The total effect was statistically significant, but still not great. The difference is about 1 or 2 pounds over a couple of months (when intake was controlled).

The conclusion of the study was stated in the study. It says what it says. And what it says is that calories are pretty much fungible.

Re:Fatness and Thinness in the Middle Ages by klmadfejno on Friday June 12, 2020 @09:43AM (#23499137)
The difference between statistically significant and meaningfully different is an important distinction. It's not the one you're making. The 1 or 2 pounds is out of the average prediction of 6 pounds, which is set by the arbitrary conditions of the particular setting. The correct way to think of it is a third of the total effect size.

The study is NOT saying the macronutrient composition controls, in any general condition, 1 to 2 pounds.

Re:Fatness and Thinness in the Middle Ages by bena on Friday June 12, 2020 @10:22AM (#23499488)
Sorry, I meant to imply that the difference in total weight loss was about one to two pounds.