Re:Audio Engineers Built a Shield to Deflect Police Sound Ca...
by mdorazio on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @04:36PM
(#23481789)
You have a strange definition of 'retaliation'. If you throw a ball at a brick wall and it bounces back and hits you, the wall didn't retaliate or act in self-defense. The entire impetus and result is 100% on you. The same applies here.
Re:Audio Engineers Built a Shield to Deflect Police Sound Ca...
by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @06:38PM
(#23483006)
The first use of “retaliation” should be “retaliation and/or self-defense”, like the other. I was staying a broader principle which applies to but extends beyond the immediate case.
I will agree that the proposed device might (if targeted appropriately) be more defensive than retaliatory, though the fact that it only causes harm to the focussed-on target if someone attacks it doesn't make it purely defensive or non-retaliatory, in fact, if not carefully targeted it makes it quite indiscriminate retaliation.
Re:Audio Engineers Built a Shield to Deflect Police Sound Ca...
by ambicapter on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @04:26PM
(#23481668)
This looks like self-defense to me. It literally doesn't do anything unless you are attacked.
Yes, violent retaliation is still violence.
Violence only in retaliation and/or self-defense may be a valid approach to protest in some circumstances, but it's not non-violent protest.