News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by js8 on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @04:27AM (#23464827)
On some level, I love this, it's just wonderful, lots of neat diagrams and words and numbers that make intuitive sense. But "explains" is a rather strong word. It's pseudoscientific mysticism, in the spirit of Pythagoreans or Jordan B. Peterson. As long as we all understand this, good.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by Garlef on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @05:18AM (#23465046)
The reason why it seems so appealing might be some kind of barnum effect [0] - the effect that makes horoscopes work:

There's a lot of tiny bits of concepts that might resonate with someone (or rather resonate with the learned cultural stereotypes carried by this person) and so one buys into the whole package, disregarding the parts that don't pattern match.

This idea is also applied at a larger scale by Susan Blackmore in her definition of a `memeplex` [1].

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barnum_effect [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memeplex

(Sidenote: I think a lot of the current cultural clashes in the western world can be interpreted as two big memeplexes fighting each other, having each developed strategies to be incommensurable [2] to the other side.)

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jean-Fran%C3%A7ois_Lyotard

Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by belly_joe on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @08:39AM (#23466087)
I think this is basically correct, and that the comparison to the way memeplexes (lol memeplices?)construct worldviews is a good point that goes unnoticed in a great deal of political discussion. Almost every ideology is anchored to the real world by some element of truth.

Regarding the OP taxonomy, it makes me wonder if there's a way to aggregate these taxonomies to see if extracting the relevant principal components (that do map to the real world) from the subjective noise is possible.

One could imagine testing the Barnum effect in this way, writing a large number of these personality descriptions and seeing if real personality traits can emerge by having individuals rank which Barnum profiles best describe them.

Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by pegasus on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @05:41AM (#23465145)
Yeah, "explains" is rather strong, but "pseudoscientific mysticism" is straight-up harsh. It's an inevitably subjective way to organize the world of human behavior and motivation. Like colors themselves, which reside just as much in our internal perception of the world as they do in objective physical processes.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by gitrog on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @06:35AM (#23465374)
I think "pseudoscientific mysticism" is just in response to the fact that many people don't see it as being subjective, but rather objectively measurable/common sense/blatantly obvious.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by dataduck on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @07:17AM (#23465564)
Surely common sense is subjective? And many blatantly obvious things are not objectively measurable.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by gitrog on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @12:01PM (#23467781)
Definitely, but I guess I'm implying many people don't think it's subjective. Should have probably put "common sense" and "blatantly obvious" in quotations.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by bambax on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @05:54AM (#23465198)
The author says as much at the end, and also underlines that the area where it helped him a lot was in writing fiction, which inevitably deals with stereotypes.

This isn't a system to describe the human psyche as one how society likes to think about it.

Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by stared on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @10:35AM (#23467006)
It is one of my favorite stimuli in psychometrics and the philosophy of science. I already sent it to quite a few people, as a long-read remark on the applicability of models.

Of course, as long as you read it at the meta-level, comparing with other tools (scientific, pseudo-scientific), for example: Four Temperaments, MBTI, Big Five, Western Zodiac, Chinese Zodiac, etc.

While many predictions are bogus (e.g. month of birth and relationship comparability, vide https://www.gwern.net/docs/psychology/okcupid/howyourraceaff...) they capture various traits of character people consider important.

The difference between science and pseudo-science is much more smooth than most scientists would like to admit. While MBTI is not up to academics standards, it is highly correlated with Big Five, trait by trait (still, AFAIR there is reason to use it in the place of Big Five). Plus, there is too much Jungian interpretation for MBTI, which is not up to current scientific standards. Still, I defended MBTI (in a dating context, e.g. as a self-identification) more times than I care to admit (for some insights, this https://www.16personalities.com/ is decent).

There is also a corollary that psychology is still in its infancy, much like biology before the discovery of bacteria, viri, or DNA.

...

In mathematics, there is a concept of a basis - more or less, directions, or orientation. We can express the same thing is a few different ways. Some bases are better (unit length, dimensions are orthogonal (uncorrelated)), but otherwise there is a lot of room here.

In this case, Colors of Mana are one basis. Just because it is an impromptu psychological explanation, does not mean it does not work. Yet:

- Some explanations or interpolations may not be valid.

- It is likely that we can find a more refined way.

All in all, I would love to make people2vec, where we embed various psychological trains as vectors, as see which other parameters (scientific or not) we can reproduce. All in all, even IQ can be considered a personality trait (as it is correlated with other traits of personality, it is not a separate entity) http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/beautiful-minds/2014/04/...

Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by m12k on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @06:47AM (#23465429)
I approach this the same way I approach concepts like karma and reincarnation. Are they literally true, physical forces, laws or similar acting on the world? No, of course not. Are they useful metaphors to try to model and discuss tendencies and emergent phenomena arising from patterns in human behavior? Yes, often, if used with the right disclaimers and caveats.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by preordained on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @05:03AM (#23464983)
Spoken like a blue mage ;)
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by michaelbuddy on Wednesday June 10, 2020 @12:59AM (#23474094)
Jordan Peterson? So are you saying now that having a PhD in Clinical Psychology makes you a pseudo-scientist?

Hundreds of scholarly papers cited thousands of times. But it's pseudo-science. Psychology might not be an exact science but it IS a genuine scholarship meant to understand human behavior.

Feel free to make your case based on "I just don't like him" though, I'm sure it will be very interesting and will include the "R" word.

Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by notkaiho on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @06:26AM (#23465329)
Yet people heartily continue to believe in Peterson :D
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by swebs on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @06:33AM (#23465363)
What did he say that was false?
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by owllllllllll on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @10:36AM (#23467009)
If anyone's lurking and wants to self-educate, this video is a good (and entertaining!) starting point: https://youtu.be/SEMB1Ky2n1E
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by notkaiho on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @06:52AM (#23465451)
I don't want to derail the discussion with irrelevant material, but to suggest that eating a beef-only diet cures autoimmune disorders is utterly unsupported by medical science, for one.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by scottLobster on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @09:53AM (#23466654)
As someone who's mother died of a rare/poorly understood cancer after fighting it for 10 years and multiple experimental treatments, and met others in similar boats along the way (support groups), there are tons of niche medical conditions that science hasn't even bothered/had the resources to investigate.

Is a beef-only diet a good idea for the general population? Probably not. Could it be ideal for people with extremely rare auto-immune conditions that have an allergic reaction to virtually everything else? Sure, and that existing doesn't sound crazy to me at all.

I've noticed a trend where scientifically minded people tend to get hung up the "proven" at the expense of the "plausible", forgetting that everything they rightfully treat as proven once could have been dismissed in a similar manner. Real people in the real world have to make decisions based on nothing more than plausibility all the time, and I don't see why diet should be any different. Particularity if none of the "proven" solutions are working for you.

Put another way, there's a difference between "the evidence says this is wrong" and "there is no evidence that this is true".

Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by prepend on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @07:34AM (#23465652)
I think you’re right. But people have all sorts of crazy diets for unsupported reasons.

I don’t think Peterson is promoting the carnivore diet, but I did hear him explain his diet on a podcast and it seemed pretty couched in curiosity, not resolution. The thing I remember is lots of “I don’t knows” and attribution of any benefits to it being an elimination diet vs any special property of beef.

Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by mat4magic on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @07:39AM (#23465691)
The meat only diet worked for his daughter(she has autoimmune disorder) and him apparently for whatever reason.

He also says its not a healthy diet in general and that he doesnt know if it will work for other people.

I think a lot of people try to twist his words(or assume the worst interpretation) even on "normal" topics because they dont like his Politics.

Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by speeder on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @10:56AM (#23467176)
Many autoimmune disorders react to food, for example the infamous Celiac disease is an autoimmune reaction to gluten, that is present in many cereals (not only wheat).

So why beef only wouldn't work?

I have autoimmune diseases myself and have a very meat heavy diet, to me is what works, as soon I move to a more typical diet my health declines quickly.

Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by swebs on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @07:03AM (#23465500)
Well he has a PHD in clinical psychology, not nutrition. I think people like the OP throw these jabs at him purely because they're angry he spoke out against the Canadian pronoun law, rather than any complaints about the validity of his research itself.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by notkaiho on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @07:45AM (#23465734)
Nope, not the reason I said it but nice assumption.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by swebs on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @08:11AM (#23465886)
Well until someone develops mind-reading technology, that's the most likely explanation someone reading your comment would have.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by Loughla on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @08:31AM (#23466032)
Or, alternate option, you can take it at face value in that he claimed a meat only diet helped him, using his public persona to push an agenda that is completely unsupported by science.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by brankoB on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @11:46AM (#23467636)
He wasn't "pushing an agenda". He was telling people about how a diet he went on helped him and his daughter. He explicitly stated multiple times that he wasn't a doctor and that his experience was anecdotal.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by gitrog on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @12:10PM (#23467861)
Peterson does have a way of trying to tie all of his beliefs into a larger world view, and selling that, though. It's the same thing with the Mesopotamian gods and his beliefs about gender.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by brankoB on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @01:00PM (#23468364)
That's true, however I do think the meat-only anecdote came from a good place. Him and his daughter had been suffering from clinical depression and a host of other problems for decades and the diet seemed to help them. I think if I was in a similar situation I'd try to let other people know too.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by gitrog on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @12:12PM (#23467882)
Why is /that/ the most likely explanation? Peterson has said many controversial things on topics that aren't his area of expertise.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by NoOneNew on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @06:55AM (#23465464)
Take responsibility for your actions.

Take care of both your mental and physical health.

Do something important with your life that's meaningful to you.

Respect yourself.

Life is bloody hard and you should be easy on yourself when you screw up. As long as you learn something from your mistakes and attempt to push forward again with new found knowledge, you're on the right path.

Clean up your room.

All of that is the utter nonsense Peterson spews out all of the time. None of that is useful or true. What a monster.

Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by minitech on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @07:04AM (#23465511)
You can sarcastically toss out a list of uncontroversial useful or true things that have been said by literally anyone, no matter how often they’ve otherwise been wrong or harmful. It’s not a refutation.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by swebs on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @08:05AM (#23465857)
To be fair, there was nothing to refute. Still, nobody has listed anything he said that was wrong or harmful.
Re:How the Magic: The Gathering Color Wheel Explains Humanity by NoOneNew on Tuesday June 09, 2020 @07:08AM (#23465529)
Then by that, everyone's thoughts on anything and everything should be thrown out. Everyone is an asshole if you dig deep enough. There is no such thing as a perfect person.