News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by Udo on Friday March 18, 2011 @08:29PM (#2342575)
> G = E x M x D x F x V x B x P

It's the Drake equation for spam! $7000/day is not too shabby, either...

Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by waitwhatwhoa on Saturday March 19, 2011 @12:01AM (#2342938)
Hi guys, I worked with Julie in writing this article. I'd be happy to answer any questions you have about the work. I was indeed inspired by the Drake equation in coming up with this interpretation of our results :)

If you'd like to learn more about this experiment, the Wired article is based off of: http://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~savage/papers/CACMSpam09.pdf

Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by jamesshamenski on Saturday March 19, 2011 @01:14AM (#2343022)
Was this a technically difficult operation to undertake? How long did it take to plan and execute? i'm assuming that it's not that tedious of a task to scale and automate.

In going through this exercise were you able to come up with ideas to combat spam more effectively?

Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by waitwhatwhoa on Saturday March 19, 2011 @06:32AM (#2343297)
I wouldn't say it was incredibly technically difficult, the worst parts were probably reverse engineering the somewhat funky custom encoding that the botmaster was using for the C&C communication, and then writing the custom router software to allow us to rewrite live tcp flows (we used click: http://read.cs.ucla.edu/click/click).

We first started experimenting with the storm botnet about six months before doing this experiment. Once we realized what their architecture allowed us to do (MITM on the botnet's C&C), it probably only took a month or two to put together the infrastructure needed to conduct the experiment. Scaling to more nodes would have been relatively trivial, as the VMs running the Storm nodes were completely unmodified and we could have easily brought more online behind our flow-modifying router if necessary.

A colleague of mine did come up with one idea called "botnet judo" (paper here: http://www.cs.ucsd.edu/~voelker/pubs/judo-ndss10.pdf) whereby we run spamming bots within a contained environment that "seems" to have SMTP connectivity but actually just sinkholes all the spam, and then we developed highly effective and specific regular expressions from each bot's spam corpus.

Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by jamesshamenski on Saturday March 19, 2011 @09:49AM (#2343563)
Wow, that's really great. Thanks for the insight!

Was this project done as a thesis paper or was there an alternative purpose for undertaking such a long project? I'm pretty impressed with the execution of your team.

Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by waitwhatwhoa on Sunday March 20, 2011 @04:26AM (#2345820)
I wouldn't consider it "a thesis paper," but this project will eventually be part of my PhD thesis. Overall I would just say that we just seized the opportunity and wrote a decent paper. I, too, am impressed with our team and certainly would be nowhere without it. Glad you've enjoyed our work!
Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by lsc on Saturday March 19, 2011 @02:45AM (#2343121)
have you considered doing something to, uh, "educate" the "victims?" I mean, spam will exist for as long as it is profitable.

Not that I have any idea how to educate those sorts.

Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by waitwhatwhoa on Saturday March 19, 2011 @06:42AM (#2343305)
That's an interesting question. Interacting with people in an unsolicited manner is very hard from a legal/ethical standpoint, so using a method like this to "reach out" wouldn't fly.

On the other hand, user education about the profit motive is certainly something that could bear fruit, and so the first step to educating them is figuring out what the numbers look like in the first place :). That's what we're up to, and trying to find ways to keep spam from being profitable is something we took a look at in our upcoming paper at this May's IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy.

Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by jemka on Friday March 18, 2011 @09:37PM (#2342705)
I never understood why email servers never adopted something like the 3-way-handshake, which ultimately would increase the bandwidth and processing power required per email. It would theoretically make bot-nets easier to find and protect against. However, I admittedly don't know much about the industry, so there's probably a simple answer.
Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by kjksf on Friday March 18, 2011 @11:40PM (#2342904)
Short explanation: network effects and backwards compatibility.

When the SMTP protocol was designed/evolved, spam and other malicious uses did not exist. They didn't even exist for many, many years afterwards.

When the spam really became a problem, everyone was already using smtp and switching the whole world to an alternative wasn't (and still isn't) possible.

Designing email protocol that would eliminate spam is not hard if you start with such goal in mind.

The people who designed smtp were very smart (it is being used decades later), but they were pioneers and unsurprisingly didn't anticipate all of the consequences. When they were designing it, there number of people using the system were in thousands. I doubt anyone in early eighties was anticipating the magnitude of smtp's success and the abuses of the system only became profitable when email started being used by millions.

Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by kooshball on Friday March 18, 2011 @11:35PM (#2342898)
I dont really follow what you're saying. Why do you think a 3 way handshake would make any difference here? Why would it make bot-nets easier to find?
Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by jemka on Friday March 18, 2011 @11:49PM (#2342921)
Spam is a numbers game. If you make it harder for spam messages to be sent out, spammers 1. send less spam by default 2. increase hardware. (realize 2 can also include increase cost if not using a "free" bot-net)

If all SMTP servers were required to receive and send back a token/packet before their original message was delivered, the bandwidth/cpu etc... required to send the message will have increased.

Send original to recipient server, receive from recipient server, send to recipient server. Then the mail is delivered.

Example: A single spammer can send out 50 million emails / month on current system. Introduce a 3-way & that number drops.

If the spammer wants to get back to sending 50 million / month, a significant increase in hardware will be required.

Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by silentbicycle on Saturday March 19, 2011 @01:35AM (#2343045)
In my experience, spamd (http://www.openbsd.org/cgi-bin/man.cgi?query=spamd) is remarkably effective, and its greylisting works by requiring a request/response before the first valid transmission.
Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by hammock on Saturday March 19, 2011 @04:39PM (#2344663)
"Then the researchers calculated an estimate of how much money the spammer grossed per day: about $7,000."

That's great, but gives me absolutely no context to answer the actual question, "How much do spammers rake in." Is 7K high, low or average for a spammer? What's the total revenue of all spammers? How many spammers are there? What is a spammer- an organization of 10, 20, 100 people, or is it one guy?

Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by ique on Friday March 18, 2011 @10:43PM (#2342825)
I'm more interested in ad-spam than this kind of botnet fraud spam.

For instance, if I built a twitter bot replying to anyone saying "iPad" with a link, then the page at the end of that link was absolutely filled with ads. How much money would I make?

It seems to be a somewhat viable method of getting some cash because you see a lot of those bots around.

Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by light3 on Friday March 18, 2011 @09:06PM (#2342650)
0.238 * 0.000127 * 100 * 1700000 * 550 * 0.093 * 0.266 = 7000

So they assume 90.7% of messages get caught by spam filters.

Apparently they send out around 1 billion emails, 23.8% of which gets delivered. Around 2600 people read the emails, and a quarter of them will an average of $100.

Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by aidscholar on Friday March 18, 2011 @07:45PM (#2342480)
I hate how the article doesn't mention any numbers / metrics except for the final dollar value.
Re:Equation: How Much Money Do Spammers Rake In? by brendino on Friday March 18, 2011 @08:11PM (#2342531)
Check the graphic below the article. It's got most of the numbers.