I suspect this is indeed the root of the problem; people tend to just pick any hardware first and then try to run Linux on it, whereas in reality they should pick hardware to run Linux on.
They seem to get this when it comes to Mac, but not Linux for some reason.
The reason seems pretty obvious.
Well, you have literally no choice for macOs supported hardware. Only apple devices.
Whereas for Linux, you can in theory buy any laptop (there is no official list of supported laptops).
So it's not that they get it for Mac, it's just the lack of choice.
You don't really have a choice of just any random hardware anywhere, not on Linux, not on macOS, not even Windows.
The only difference is that most BestBuy laptops come preinstalled with Windows, so of course they're going to support Windows. The support is often not excellent either, but in Windows world that's somehow just dismissed as expected or something.
Also, try picking a TALOS II POWER9 workstation and installing Windows on it. Would not go well.
My point being, people should buy Linux-supported hardware, preferably from a reputable Linux-friendly vendor, which would spare them a lot of trouble.
They're already doing this with macOS and they're doing it with Windows too, just not realizing it because that's what comes with the majority of PCs.
What you're asking is for people to do it on purpose, which is harder, and requires a lot of thoughts into it, reading about hardware vendors, ..
unfortunately, for linux users, hit-or-miss may be your best option.
[0] i guess my eyesight started degrading, and now i find low res screens confusing. glasses help but hidpi is important too.
What frustrates me is that these lists get posted every year and never seem to get updated. It's like it's not from daily experience, but still the same list compiled when they tried Mandrake Linux 15 years ago.
There are many problems with that:
- a casual user will just not do it. They don't have the know-how, but would they have it, they don't care enough to do so. They just want something that works. For now, Linux is and remains a tech saavy user systems, which is and will always remains a niche. Which of course means less resources will be put into it.
- it's hard, and time consumming. It take no joy in hunting down "that one laptop" that will work everytime I want to buy a new machine. Then being stressed out when I actually install the system, because of course I will never be 100% be right. There will always be something.
- you get twice the constraints. Search for a quality machine AND search for machine that will work on Linux.
- it's not permanent. Upgrade may just break support.
- it's not total support. I love my 2in1 xps. I chose it knowing I couldn't use the webcam and that I would have to forgo the tablet mode use. It's a compromise I had to make. Which a windows user doesn't have to make.
- it means I have 300 great laptops I could potentially buy, but in reality probably only 10 among the most recent ones.
- it means you never get to enjoy modernity. You always have to wait one year or two after a tech is popular to get decent support.
None of this is a deal breaker for _me_. They are mostly 1st world people problems, meaning problems I'm happy to have :)
But hand waving is not how we should approach this.
I do not undertand what you guys are talking about. It works flawlessly 100% of the time on my Librem 15 and Lenovo T400 both in Debian and Qubes OS. Just find proper harware to run GNU/Linux.