News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by chrisco255 on Friday May 29, 2020 @07:59PM (#23357067)
No, sorry, states that never locked down (WY, SD, AR, etc) have followed the same curve as those that did lock down. States that re-opened early (GA, FL, TX) have not seen a huge spike in cases. Vast majority of deaths were caused by nursing home incidents. Almost half the deaths are in three states (NY, NJ, and MA), which have had strict lockdown procedures. The curve was flattened back in April. There is no objective criteria being used to justify masks or lockdowns. There has been no threshold set where once hospital usage is below a certain amount, all restrictions are set. For this reason, I cannot support arbitrary lockdowns. They are violations of liberty and an abuse of state of emergency policy. In the meantime, 40 million people are unemployed, our economy is in tatters and it's going to take a decade to recover.
Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by Spooky23 on Saturday May 30, 2020 @01:28AM (#23358717)
New York was pretty simple, the lockdown started late, when community spread had already started. At one point nearly 800 people a day were dying.

New York saw the curve decline start consistently in the beginning of May. Metrics are defined for reopening and that is in progress.

Armchair quarterbacks get the benefit of 20/20 hindsight, but at the time the scope wasn’t understood and officials were worried about the impact of shutting down school breakfast/lunch programs, etc.

Places like South Dakota and Wyoming are lucky, there’s less people in those states than in my upstate NY county, and they aren’t big travel hubs. No surprise there. With other places, you should hold judgement until time has passed, the data is pretty awful in places like Florida. With political factors involved, you won’t know impacts until you have good vital record data re deaths.

The liberty argument is bunk, protecting the general welfare of the people is a core tenet of US governance. We were headed to a recession already and may be heading to a depression, but the rationale behind the lockdowns was the preserve life, and it worked.

Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by dmonitor on Saturday May 30, 2020 @05:37AM (#23359817)
New York sent Covid-infected patients into nursing homes, which massively inflated their death toll by subjecting the most vulnerable demographic to the disease. There’s a reason they account for 10-20% of the death toll.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/new-york-sent-recovering-corona...

Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by ken on Friday May 29, 2020 @11:07PM (#23358129)
Wyoming and South Dakota never locked down, and had the same infection curve as New York and California, which did? That sounds like a great argument in favor of lockdowns. To a virus, here is a strategy which turns Times Square into the Great Plains. That's amazing.
Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by tripletao on Saturday May 30, 2020 @01:10AM (#23358647)
New York has 1,529 deaths per million population, California has 105, Wyoming has 26, and South Dakota has 67 (using the Worldometer numbers). So they certainly didn't follow the same curves, nor did the lockdown turn Times Square into the Great Plains.

On average, stricter measures seem correlated with higher mortality, not lower. That doesn't mean the measures kill people, just that governments don't tend to impose them until stuff gets bad. It's very difficult to disentangle the effects of the intervention from the effects of the pre-existing environment.

Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by akiselev on Saturday May 30, 2020 @02:15AM (#23358940)
Viruses spread due to close contact so these stats need to be normalized for population density. The relevant number is deaths per million people per person per sq mile. New York state's population density is ~400 people per square mile, California ~250, South Dakota ~11, Wyoming ~6. So California's deaths per million are four times Wyoming's and less than twice of South Dakotas despite having ~40 and ~24 times the population density, respectively. New York is an anomaly because of New York City (~26,000 people per sq mile) and specifically Manhattan (~67,000 people per sq mile) - an order of magnitude more densely populated than the most densely populated cities in Wyoming (Jackson, ~3300 people per square mile) and South Dakota (Piedmont, ~3000 people per square mile or Sioux Falls with ~2000). The big states have several dense cities with populations larger than both Wyoming and South Dakota combined.

It's also disingenuous to include New York because it was the initial epicenter on the Western hemisphere and the majority of those dead were infected before complete lock down procedures could be implemented or from unavoidable close contact with family or building tenants.

Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by tripletao on Saturday May 30, 2020 @02:45AM (#23359053)
Except that Japan has high population density, no significant lockdown, contact tracing that misses ~80% of the cases (estimating the total case count from their death count, using the IFR from serology elsewhere), and 7 deaths per million. So maybe it's the masks? The general culture of hygiene? The weather? Something else?

There's a lot we don't know here. I wish people would admit and accept that, instead of looking for false confidence, finding it, and then arguing with people who found a different falsely confident answer.

Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by akiselev on Saturday May 30, 2020 @03:10AM (#23359163)
> Except that Japan has high population density, no significant lockdown, contact tracing that misses ~80% of the cases (estimating the total case count from their death count, using the IFR from serology elsewhere), and 7 deaths per million. So maybe it's the masks? The general culture of hygiene? The weather? Something else?

According to Worldometer Japan has tested ~284k people while New York and California have combined tested almost four million despite together having half the population of Japan. Last time I saw excess mortality statistics a few weeks ago they were lagging with several prefectures missing and bad normalization for aging and other factors.

Assuming the numbers are accurate, I'm more interested in how South Dakota and Wyoming are doing so much worse than Japan with such a low population density. I suspect the answer lies in the crumbling rural health infrastructure.

> There's a lot we don't know here. I wish people would admit and accept that, instead of turning this into yet another polarized political debate.

Mortality, population density, and basic division are not political and if by themselves they're polarizing, then we're too far gone already.

Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by tripletao on Saturday May 30, 2020 @03:41AM (#23359276)
I'm not sure what you intend by those test counts? Japan has 874 dead. Assuming IFR of 1%, that implies about 87k infected. But they report 17k confirmed cases, so they're missing ~80% of the cases. I mentioned this to head off any suggestion that Japan's trace and test operation was responsible for their success, since at best it's decreasing R by that ~20%. Perhaps Japan is failing to catch some deaths too; but they're an open society with freedom of speech, so I don't expect their numbers to be grossly wrong.

So what could South Dakota and Wyoming's public health system be doing that's worse than Japan? I don't know the answer, but it's not clear to me at all that the difference is in their government responses vs. some aspect of their initial situations.

I gave deaths per capita because that's the probability that someone in that state will have died of coronavirus, which is what most people care about directly. Your (deaths/people)/(people/area) has no corresponding direct significance. To then call that "the relevant number" overstates the importance of population density, and also models population density badly when it's non-uniform (as you note for NYC). I agree that population density is an important factor, just not as determinative as your post would seem to imply.

Oh, and looks like you quoted my post before I edited it, sorry. But I believe false confidence is polarizing and would like to see less of it, as uncomfortable as the true uncertainty may be.

Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by akiselev on Saturday May 30, 2020 @04:17AM (#23359445)
> I'm not sure what you intend by those test counts? Japan has 874 dead.

I'm saying I believe their numbers are inaccurate because they're undertesting and stats I could use to validate them (overall number of deaths to calculate seasonal excess mortality) are also currently inaccurate for unrelated reasons. I agree that the number of deaths will be impossible to hide in an open society like Japan but for bureaucratic reasons it will take a while to compile and validate those stats before normalizing them enough to compare between years let alone nations. Until then, I'm not convinced and any argument based on Japan as an example is also suspect.

> To then call that "the relevant number" overstates the importance of population density, and also models population density badly when it's non-uniform (as you note for NYC).

Uhm, what? Deaths per million lumps Wyoming in with New York City, making it even less accurate to what people care about. Manhattan will not be reopening on the same schedule as some town on the outskirts of Fargo. Someone in the middle of a dense city does not face the same risk as someone whose closest neighbor is 2 miles away. Also, it's a virus. There's almost a century of medicine and public health expertise that shows that all things being equal, density is the dominant factor.

I thought ending quarantine is what people cared about. Your false confidence about Japan's comparability to the US is not helping. Population density is why NYC and Wyoming aren't comparable yet you're trying to compare another country.

Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by tripletao on Saturday May 30, 2020 @04:51AM (#23359606)
So what do you think explains the difference between Japan and NY? It's not population density. Even if Japan's death count is understated, there is zero chance that all of Japan's medical staff and press have somehow failed to notice and report NYC-level mortality.

And I'm not sure what you think is my "false confidence about Japan's comparability to the US"? I certainly don't believe Japan's response would work equally well in NY, considering that NY applied stricter measures and ended up with 200x the death rate. I believe the susceptibility of individual regions to the coronavirus varies greatly with factors we don't yet understand, including population density, cultural and behavioral factors, weather, maybe air pollution, maybe genetics. I'd guess these factors explain much more of the variation in mortality by region than variation in the governments' responses, though I'm not sure.

And you're missing my point about deaths per capita. That's an intrinsically meaningful number, because people care about the probability that they die (or get seriously sick, etc.). Other numbers are valuable only to the extent they predict something people intrinsically care about. Population density is one such input to the prediction, but it's clearly not the only factor, and your simplistic focus on that isn't useful.

Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by akiselev on Saturday May 30, 2020 @06:20AM (#23360005)
> So what do you think explains the difference between Japan and NY?

There are a thousand factors but my bet is that Japan experienced SARS firsthand and just like South Korea or Vietnam, they learned their lesson. It became the epidemic case study for public health officials and doctors in the entire region (and Canada). Regulators went out of their way to make reporting easy and doctors were all trained to look for and treat viral respiratory diseases early. Wearing masks went from being an oddity to wide spread cultural acceptance. For those reasons, you can't compare the effectiveness of measures in California to those in Wyoming using Japan as a measuring stick.

There are far more differences between Japan and California than there are between California and Wyoming. The latter share their language, the majority of their healthcare regulations, political differences, the CDC, and so on. Right now, traveling from Japan to Wyoming is practically impossible but traveling from California to Wyoming is a medium length road trip or one hop in a a tiny plane with zero enforceable travel restrictions.

> Even if Japan's death count is understated, there is zero chance that all of Japan's medical staff and press have somehow failed to notice and report NYC-level mortality.

I'm not an expert on Japanese culture but I've got enough first hand experience to know that is a failure of imagination and the definition of false confidence. Read about Tepco, the Japanese nuclear regulators, and the series of unfortunate events that led to Fukushima containment failures. It was a systemic failure that shares many parallels to Japans's coronavirus response.

> And I'm not sure what you think is my "false confidence about Japan's comparability to the US"? I certainly don't believe Japan's response would work equally well in NY, considering that NY applied stricter measures and ended up with 200x the death rate.

You (imo) falsely believe that Japan's death rate is accurate (let's wait a few months for accurate general morality). You also falsely believe that their death rate can be used to draw conclusions about the effectiveness of measures in the United States. I'm not sure about the former but certain about the latter. New York had "stricter" measures based on cultural expectations that were practically cultural norms in Japan. There is simply no baseline or control group possible between the two demographics.

> I'd guess these factors explain much more of the variation in mortality by region than variation in the governments' responses, though I'm not sure.

There is less variation within nations than there is between them. That's why they became nations instead of going to war amongst themselves (modulo some geopolitics that apply to the Middle East and the Balkans, not Japan).

> And you're missing my point about deaths per capita. That's an intrinsically meaningful number, because people care about the probability that they die (or get seriously sick, etc.). Other numbers are valuable only to the extent they predict that. Population density is one input, but it's clearly not the only factor, and your simplistic focus on that isn't useful.

People care about ending the quarantine. The quarantine will end based on public health policy. Public health decision makers aren't basing their decision on deaths per capita, they're basing them on localized deaths per capita, which depends on the density in each city, metropolis, and states.

I honestly don't even know what point you're trying to make. Are we trying to end the quarantine or are you trying to make some ideological point?

Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by tripletao on Saturday May 30, 2020 @12:44PM (#23362420)
Sorry, are you claiming that Japan might have experienced NY-level mortality but not noticed? Did you see pictures from NYC's hospitals? You can't not notice that. I'm not confident of much, but I'm very, very confident that coronavirus mortality in Japan has been dramatically lower than NY. If you disagree, then we're not in the same consensus reality, and there's no point in discussing further.

So I'm asking why they're different. You make a lot of statements, most of which are true but which don't specifically explain that difference. For example, you state that Japan's doctors have experience with SARS, and they do; but how is that helping stop the spread? What are they doing that Americans should copy? It's not the contact tracing, except for that ~20% reduction in R at best--and if deaths are undercounted, then they're missing an even greater share of the infections.

And then you seem to say that Japan and NY can't be compared anyways because they're so different? I agree they're different in many ways; so why not think about all those factors, and what we can learn from them? Would a heavy public campaign training people to correctly use masks (and enforcing their use) have brought us to Japan-level mortality with a Japan-level lockdown? Imagine the lives (and jobs, and hours of children's education) that could have been saved if yes. I agree that Japan has very different cultural norms, and those might explain much of the difference. So what are those norms, and how can we adopt them?

Or maybe the dominant factor is neither masks nor lockdowns but weather, and there's nothing in our response that could have helped? Maybe it's something about our speaking habits, and language really does directly make a big difference? That last one is deliberately outlandish, but I'm not even totally sure it's false.

The point I'm trying to make is that we know very little about this disease, and what we do know is confusing and contradictory. Unfortunately, most people seem to have latched onto preferred simple explanations, disregarding the evidence that doesn't support them. Given the earliness of our knowledge here, I believe that's likely to cause important opportunities to control the disease to be missed, and therefore harmful.

Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by tripletao on Sunday June 07, 2020 @07:50PM (#23452147)
> except for that ~20% reduction in R at best

And following up to note the above is wrong--assuming heterogeneous spread (most patients infect no one, but a few super-spreaders infect many), contact tracers will naturally find those super-spreaders disproportionately, with disproportionate benefit. I still doubt that's the dominant difference, though.

Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by pdonis on Saturday May 30, 2020 @02:52AM (#23359097)
> It's also disingenuous to include New York because it was the initial epicenter on the Western hemisphere

No, it wasn't, Seattle was.

Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by akiselev on Saturday May 30, 2020 @03:25AM (#23359217)
In this context the epicenter is where something is most intense, not where it starts. New York City and Seattle peaked roughly around the same but NYC was seeing ~10,000 new cases a day at one point whereas King County was seeing 600 a day at most. Maybe if you normalize for population size and density it's comparable but epicenter is colloquialism that usually implies absolute numbers.
Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by pdonis on Saturday May 30, 2020 @06:15PM (#23365273)
> the epicenter

The post I responded to specifically said initial epicenter. The post claimed that it was "disingenuous" to include NYC in statistics because, since they were the "initial epicenter", they basically didn't have any warning. Since NYC was not the "initial epicenter", this claim is false; they did have warning and it is perfectly fair to include them in statistics.

Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by otoburb on Saturday May 30, 2020 @09:55AM (#23361208)
The context is important because most people have heard the word "epicenter" from earthquake stories, where the epicenter is usually singular and never migrates, thus strongly correlated in people's heads as the "start" of a major event.
Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by kittiepryde on Friday May 29, 2020 @08:06PM (#23357129)
Nearly every law is a violation of liberties, I don't think that's a good argument.
Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by roenxi on Friday May 29, 2020 @08:30PM (#23357279)
While that is true a 'right to work' is recognised in the International Charter of Human Rights as one of the big ones. Along with free movement and probably there is an implicit if not explicit right not to be mandatorialy isolated from other people.

These aren't "I want a house with 3 stories and I can only build two" style liberties. These are the "if I don't have these I literally do not have any liberty" incursions on liberties. The important ones.

Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by CGamesPlay on Friday May 29, 2020 @08:11PM (#23357162)
Any thoughts on any of the other mentioned points against the lockdowns?
Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by kittiepryde on Friday May 29, 2020 @09:50PM (#23357750)
Nope, I don't necessarily disagree with OP's overall conclusion. I just thought that one point wasn't very good.
Re:The nightmare that colleges face this fall by sosborn on Friday May 29, 2020 @11:58PM (#23358350)
What role do you think population density plays in the spread of communicable diseases?