News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by barking on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:03PM (#23352512)
We care about your privacy notices have become the bane of my life.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Nextgrid on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:15PM (#23352669)
The majority of these aren't actually compliant.

Tracking should be opt-in and consent should be freely given. If your notice is annoying enough that most people click accept (or if clicking decline is harder) then you are already in breach.

A lot of websites also consider analytics cookies as essential and don't provide a way to decline those which isn't compliant either.

These websites can be detected very easily by running a web scraper and looking for one of these non-compliant "consent management" solutions (looking at you TrustArc) and fining every single company that uses it.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by SyneRyder on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:04PM (#23353398)
Here's an example of a broken site:

https://www.europarl.europa.eu/privacy-policy/en

The only two cookie options are "Accept" or "More". But the More option is broken and just brings up the same cookie notice again and again on my browser. It drops cookies on the browser regardless of whether you choose to accept or not (search your cookies in the browser for europarl.europa.eu, you'll find the unique "atuserid" and "atidvisitor" analytics identifiers it has set to identify you).

If that's the result on the EU Parliament's own website, on their privacy policy page, it's safe to say the EU doesn't actually care about privacy.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by XCSme on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:31PM (#23353737)
That's incredible and just shows how stupid this directive was. In my opinion it destroyed the user privacy and user experience: the average user now clicks "accept" as soon as he visits a site. This made it easy to fool non-technical users to subscribe to push notifications, give access to location and other privacy-invading features. I used the phone of my sister for a few minutes and her notification center was bombarded with random push notifications froms sites he visited and to which she unknowingly subscribed to.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Nextgrid on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:47PM (#23353961)
I agree that the current lack of enforcement is bad for the intent of the law and its long-term impact.

Currently the lack of enforcement allows non-compliant solutions (where accepting is easier than declining) to thrive so people get used to accepting everything.

Down the line, even when enforcement catches up and compliant solutions start appearing, users will still be clicking accept because they've been trained to do so.

This is unfortunately good for adtech/martech not just now but in the future, so all of those currently making your money on stalking users, don't cry, it's all gonna be okay.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Mirioron on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:13PM (#23353515)
Maybe all these websites are simply taking the EU Parliament's site as an example on how you should do it? They made the regulation, surely you should follow their example.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by JumpCrisscross on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:55PM (#23353249)
> The majority of these aren't actually compliant

There is insufficient evidence attempting to comply with GDPR is worth the cost.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Nextgrid on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:59PM (#23353309)
Absolutely, given the current lack of enforcement. However, if you're going to be in breach, you might as well improve UX and not bother with the whole "consent management" thing, not to mention that the TrustArc garbage solution doesn't seem cheap.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Mirioron on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:07PM (#23353430)
But then it's much more apparent that you are in breach. If you pretend to care then the chance of being caught is much lower.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Dylan16807 on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:22PM (#23353620)
Do you mean the direct cost of implementing the compliance, or the indirect cost of no longer getting extra ad revenue in an illegal way?

In most cases I bet the former isn't all that much. The latter is a harder nut to crack, with everyone trying to toe the line and referencing what other companies are able to get away with. Lack of good faith is a big obstacle.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by JumpCrisscross on Friday May 29, 2020 @04:08PM (#23354884)
> I bet the former isn't all that much

One of the fundamental problems with GDPR is it contains a federated complain-investigate enforcement model. So your bet would have to apply to each of the EU’s twenty-eight members, now and in the future.

In that context, throwing up notices and calling a day makes sense. One can argue one tried. But not go so far as to potentially create new liabilities by interpreting these enforcers’ current and future preferences too strongly.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by disabled on Friday May 29, 2020 @06:01PM (#23356049)
> There is insufficient evidence attempting to comply with GDPR is worth the cost.

The number of people working at the respective national privacy regulators is appalling. All of them have an extremely scarce amount of privacy auditors that are qualified to extensively investigate privacy breaches. Even Ireland, which has a huge tech hub with the social media companies especially, has a scarce amount of them.

The Financial Times wrote an article about this awhile back, which tends to have good reporting on tech and privacy issues.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by JMTQp8lwXL on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:36PM (#23352977)
On mobile, some of the opt-out toggle switches don't even function. You literally cannot disable the toggle in iOS Safari.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by SilasX on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:02PM (#23353358)
Yeah but that says more about the clumsiness of iOS. Since upgrading to 13, a ton of stuff is broken, like tap to zoom, and significant ability to edit text fields. Web pages randomly freeze, forcing a kill and reopen, which I rarely saw before.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by shadowgovt on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:29PM (#23352875)
> A lot of websites also consider analytics cookies as essential

For a lot of websites, they are.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by lmkg on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:33PM (#23352934)
Under PECR, a cookie being essential means necessary to provide the requested service, not necessary to stay in business. If the user wants to view a news article, and you can serve the article without using analytics cookies, then PECR doesn't allow the cookie. (The situation for paywalls is complicated.)
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by cameronbrown on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:45PM (#23353098)
Providing the service assumes staying in business, no?
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by p_l on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:52PM (#23353195)
No, there's no protection for failed business models, as there should not be.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Mirioron on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:15PM (#23353541)
A business model that fails because you explicitly make them illegal isn't exactly a failed business model. The lawmakers made them fail and they either knew it was going to happen or were incompetent.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by growse on Friday May 29, 2020 @03:31PM (#23354484)
> A business model that fails because you explicitly make them illegal isn't exactly a failed business model.

It literally is, by definition. Any business success has to happen within the legal context it exists in.

> The lawmakers made them fail and they either knew it was going to happen or were incompetent.

I could reword this as "the elected representatives of the people decided that certain business models were undesirable and anti-consumer, so legislated against them".

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Mirioron on Saturday May 30, 2020 @04:02PM (#23364152)
>It literally is, by definition. Any business success has to happen within the legal context it exists in.

Yes, and they had business success until the rules were changed from under them.

>I could reword this as "the elected representatives of the people decided that certain business models were undesirable and anti-consumer, so legislated against them".

And I could reword this as "lobbying groups have bought our politicians and use them to enact laws to put our competitors out of business".

I'd say my rewording is closer to reality, because of course the two biggest ad networks increased in size while the smaller ones decreased as a result of this regulation.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Fargren on Friday May 29, 2020 @04:13PM (#23354933)
A goal of the GDPR was to make these business models illegal, because they are considered bad. It has not been successfull at this, mostly due to lack of enforcement.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Mirioron on Saturday May 30, 2020 @04:03PM (#23364159)
Or maybe that's what the voters are told. Why do so many people suddenly believe politicians? Do you think European politicians don't constantly lie through their teeth?
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by shadowgovt on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:58PM (#23353292)
The business model of Google isn't a failed business model.

What the GDPR does do, quite successfully, is build a moat around Google so wide and deep as to minimize competition with them, because they're one of the few firms that can both (a) afford the engineers with the technical expertise to comply with the law while accomplishing their goals and (b) afford the lawyers to address the issue when they fail at the former.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by p_l on Friday May 29, 2020 @04:29PM (#23355121)
They are a giant and those can be hard to topple in one go, but the fact that a giant can continue a failed business model for a longer time does not make it a not failed model.

Hell, at least around 2017, there were voices from Google that they considered ads to be unsustainable long term and sought to diversificate income streams.

The fun thing is, GDPR didn't actually introduce much change in law. It just gave, for the first time in history, existing laws a real set of teeth, even if they are still baby teeth.

So yeah, all that data companies had been vacuuming for no sensible purpose? It was always illegal

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Nextgrid on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:03PM (#23353382)
> afford the engineers with the technical expertise to comply with the law while accomplishing their goals

Google is in breach of the GDPR as it stands, so no.

> afford the lawyers to address the issue when they fail at the former

Potentially, though again a clear-cut breach like theirs should result in a fine regardless of how much money they throw at the problem.

As far as building a moat, I'm not sure. Whether it's Google or a one-man shop, neither can accurately track users without being in breach. There is no moat that I can see, you either break the law or you don't.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by shadowgovt on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:11PM (#23353483)
> Google is in breach of the GDPR as it stands, so no.

I don't believe that is true. What is your source?

They were fined in Jan 2019, but are they still out of compliance? If yes, why are they not being continuously fined?

> you either break the law or you don't.

That's the result on the other side of a trial, sure.

Which is why good lawyers are so important.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Nextgrid on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:25PM (#23353652)
> They were fined in Jan 2019, but are they still out of compliance?

They were fined on one specific thing and they maybe fixed it (or silently replaced with an equivalent, non-compliant thing once they went out of the spotlight), however they are plenty of other things they do that are in breach and those are not being investigated nor fined which is why we're discussing the lack of enforcement.

> Which is why good lawyers are so important.

True, but a good law should be one that you can't lawyer your way out of and so far the GDPR outcome of that is inconclusive given there is barely any enforcement at all.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Dylan16807 on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:54PM (#23353218)
Not for this regulation. Business considerations do not matter, only technical ones.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by shadowgovt on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:57PM (#23353275)
The true hallmark of an ill-conceived law.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Nextgrid on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:08PM (#23353456)
In this case you could say anti-drug-trafficking laws are ill-conceived because they go against the cartels' business models.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by shadowgovt on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:14PM (#23353529)
You may want to choose another example. US drug law is a case-study in how law divorced from consideration of ramifications to existing businesses and societal norms is a disastrous way to craft law.

https://www.aclu.org/other/american-drug-laws-new-jim-crow

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Nextgrid on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:34PM (#23353769)
Drugs by themselves are indeed a bad example (I am personally in favor of legalizing drugs), but let's substitute them with violence:

Would you say that anti-violence laws are ill-conceived because they go against cartels/mobs' business models of extorting money from people under threat of violence?

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Dylan16807 on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:07PM (#23353446)
Letting companies opt-out of a regulation purely because it hurts their business model sounds much more ill-conceived to me.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by shadowgovt on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:17PM (#23353571)
Good law doesn't "let companies opt-out;" it is crafted with consideration for what is already happening and the consequences of the law.

it doesn't appear, 2 years in, GDPR passes that test. If the goal was to minimize "privacy violation" by FB and Google, it's failing. FB and Google are stronger than ever, but their competitors are starved out of the market trying to comply with an onerous suite of policies.

It's such a ladder-pulling set of laws it's surprising Google and Facebook didn't craft it.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Dylan16807 on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:27PM (#23353678)
Did we read the same article? Most fines are tiny. It hasn't fixed everything (yet) but that doesn't mean it's hurting competition.

> Good law doesn't "let companies opt-out;" it is crafted with consideration for what is already happening and the consequences of the law.

And sometimes the outcome of that consideration is "stop doing that".

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by edynoid on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:55PM (#23353235)
You'd have a hard time arguing that breaking GDPR is the only way to stay in business. There are enough compliant news websites to undermine that argument.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by msla on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:00PM (#23353323)
Internet Explorer was absolutely essential for Microsoft Windows to provide the requested service.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by andrewla on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:55PM (#23353238)
> The majority of these aren't actually compliant.

The title of the article is "Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced enforcement".

So sure, maybe they're not complaint, but nobody is enforcing anyway.

EDIT: removed unnecessary pejorative statement from last paragraph

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by SpicyLemonZest on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:25PM (#23352821)
I've seen a lot of people say this, but I'm just not convinced it's actually the law. It's not obvious to me that analytics cookies categorically can't be essential or that "freely given" implies strict UI neutrality between accepting and declining.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Nextgrid on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:46PM (#23353113)
The majority of websites use third-party analytics that collect way more information than necessary and may use it for their own purposes (surprisingly a lot of these companies' main business is ad-tech). The problem here is that not only do you get analytics but the third-party (with whom the user has no relationship and their interests might be against the user's) is now able to track that user across other websites.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by chris_engel on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:55PM (#23353232)
Well, essential means that a web service cannot technically work without it. For example, a session cookie.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Nextgrid on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:01PM (#23353337)
The law explicitly has exemptions around purely functional cookies so you are free to set session cookies without requiring consent/disclosure.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Tomte on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:33PM (#23352925)
Yesterday the highest German court (BGH) ruled that "default accept" in cookie dialog boxes is illegal.

It was a pre-GDPR case, but the court said it interpreted the them-in-force law in a GDPR-friendly way.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by XCSme on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:33PM (#23353763)
Found this Chrome Extension: I don't care about cookies - Remove cookie warnings from almost all websites!

https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/i-dont-care-about-...

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by ianlevesque on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:04PM (#23352529)
Just pair them with cookie notices for extra effectiveness!
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by briandear on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:05PM (#23352538)
Right up there with emails from software companies with “our response to Covid-19.”

You are a software company. Unless the server has the virus, I really don’t care.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Causality1 on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:11PM (#23352623)
Indeed. Frankly I miss the days when my popups had breasts in them.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by tjoff on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:15PM (#23352674)
Disrespectful web developers have become the bane of my life.

Be thankful that GDPR exposes them, and look for alternatives.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by microcolonel on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:19PM (#23352742)
Setting aside GDPR for a moment, the cookie thing just means that if I want to use these websites, I have to enable cookies so that I can dismiss the cookie dialog.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by legitster on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:32PM (#23352909)
You are allowed a cookie that tracks their opt in to your other cookies, so long as it is anonymous (or so our lawyer tells us).

On our site, we ping whether that cookie is set before we load the rest of the cookies.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by microcolonel on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:36PM (#23352975)
Is it acceptable to store a cookie that defaults to "false" provided it is generic? That would solve the problem of not being able to detect if cookies are enabled in the browser until you try to store them.

added: person down thread indicated that there's an API for determining if cookies are enabled for the host on your page's origin called navigator.cookieEnabled which I am shocked I've not seen nor heard of even once before today. Hallelujah. I now agree that everyone who doesn't check that before pestering people about cookies, when JavaScript is available, is literally satan.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by legitster on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:54PM (#23353215)
We didn't trust using the host cookie settings because most users don't know they exist.

But we were told anonymous cookies were totally fine and within the spirit of the law. If you hit the "Accept" button, you got a cookie that allowed more cookies.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by scrollaway on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:51PM (#23353180)
It is acceptable to use cookies in general as long as they are required for the functionality of the site. This includes logging in, shopping carts, gdpr cookiewalls, ...
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by ratww on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:44PM (#23353080)
Even if there was no new API, storing a cookie "just to check if it works" is not against the GDPR. It's a functional cookie.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by tjoff on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:21PM (#23352771)
Again, only because of incompetent and/or immoral developers.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by shadowgovt on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:31PM (#23352902)
How, exactly, is a developer supposed to change state in a stateless protocol to denote that you've dismissed the cookie dialog if the user has disabled the feature that allows the developer to add state to the stateless protocol?
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by Fargren on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:38PM (#23352991)
The law does not forbid you from storing any cookie, even if the user declined. The user can decline cookies that are not needed to provide what the user asked for. Even after the user declines, you are allowed to use cookies to keep track of what's in the user cart, whether the user has logged in or whether the user rejected cookies.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by ratww on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:35PM (#23352960)
I believe his point is that if the user disabled cookies, there's no point in showing the banner. If you don't show the banner you can't track the user, of course.

It's not hard. It's just a matter of checking for navigator.cookieEnabled.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by morelisp on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:46PM (#23353107)
cookieEnabled is not reliable for handling third-party cookies, unless you also load a third-party frame running JS. (And even then it doesn't work like you'd want in many browsers.)
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by ratww on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:51PM (#23353175)
Sorry if I missed something, but AFAIK grandparent wasn't talking about third party cookies, only about having cookies disabled and being unable to store the consent flag, so I don't see how this applies to this specific discussion.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by shadowgovt on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:55PM (#23353247)
It does. Most people concerned about the GDPR are concerned about third-party cookie tracking.

It also highlights how, in general, this is a hard problem. Compliance with this law without creating a dead-static page has subtle complications.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by CuriousSkeptic on Friday May 29, 2020 @03:13PM (#23354289)
I never dismiss those dialogs anyway. Just make sure your site works with the browsers reader mode and I’m fine.

But on the top of my head only display the dialog if the browser cache is cold. Could embed a timestamp in some cachable resource. (Edit: Perhaps this counts as a “cookie“ in the legal sense)

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by microcolonel on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:29PM (#23352876)
How else can you even store a consent for cookies/localStorage? You can go around calling people immoral and incompetent, but what is the actual way to ask for permission to store data?

If your contention is that it is immoral or incompetent to store any data except through some specific user interaction related to those data, sure that's an opinion.

But if your job is literally "tell me which other pages users go to after this one", it's not really that crazy of an ask.

The law seems to call upon you to make it conspicuous, but when you make it conspicuous it is annoying, the law then calls upon you to make it not annoying.

The better solution, in my mind, is just making cookie control features more visible in browsers. They work great, and it's the right place for this form of consent.

Malicious actors abuse the current circumstance, because it relies on there being a responsible party with collateral to complain against. This is one of those times where the engineered solution is better than the social one.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by ratww on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:31PM (#23352904)
> How else can you even store a consent for cookies/localStorage?

You said "the cookie thing just means that if I want to use these websites, I have to enable cookies so that I can dismiss the cookie dialog".

But if cookies are disabled, then there's no point in asking for consent. There should be no cookie banner in this case.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by microcolonel on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:34PM (#23352950)
> But if cookies are disabled, then there's no point in asking for consent.

But the only way to determine if cookies are actually disabled in the browser is to attempt to store cookies, which is the thing you're asking consent for.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by TheCoelacanth on Friday May 29, 2020 @02:05PM (#23353411)
A cookie storing simply whether the person has accepted, declined or not yet responded to your consent dialog does not require consent.
Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by ratww on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:37PM (#23352985)
Not really, there's also navigator.cookiesEnabled now.

And even if there wasn't, attempting to store a cookie with a dummy value just to check if cookies are enabled does not break the GDPR for three reasons: first, if it's a dummy value it's not really personally identifiable information. Second, it's a functional cookie required for the site to work. And third, the site can just delete it afterwards the checking. No consent required in this case.

Re:Two years in, GDPR defined by mixed signals, unbalanced e... by lucassen on Friday May 29, 2020 @01:34PM (#23352941)
what are you referring to? I fear I am one of these incompetent devs since I don’t understand the implied transgression.