In most cases I bet the former isn't all that much. The latter is a harder nut to crack, with everyone trying to toe the line and referencing what other companies are able to get away with. Lack of good faith is a big obstacle.
One of the fundamental problems with GDPR is it contains a federated complain-investigate enforcement model. So your bet would have to apply to each of the EU’s twenty-eight members, now and in the future.
In that context, throwing up notices and calling a day makes sense. One can argue one tried. But not go so far as to potentially create new liabilities by interpreting these enforcers’ current and future preferences too strongly.
The number of people working at the respective national privacy regulators is appalling. All of them have an extremely scarce amount of privacy auditors that are qualified to extensively investigate privacy breaches. Even Ireland, which has a huge tech hub with the social media companies especially, has a scarce amount of them.
The Financial Times wrote an article about this awhile back, which tends to have good reporting on tech and privacy issues.
There is insufficient evidence attempting to comply with GDPR is worth the cost.