News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fukushima: Mark 1 Nuclear Reactor Design Caused GE Scient... by rbanffy on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:25AM (#2332372)
Dear downvoter, would you buy a car that falls apart (or blows up killing the passengers) when it runs out of gas?

If something can go wrong, it will, given time, go wrong. Even if there is one chance in a million for the whole chain of countermeasures to fail in tandem, give it a million chances to happen and you end up with a good chance of it happening.

Re:Fukushima: Mark 1 Nuclear Reactor Design Caused GE Scient... by bhousel on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:56AM (#2332522)
There are some situations where risk may be acceptable.

Would I accept a car that blows up when it runs out of gas? No, but things like airplanes can, and have, killed passengers when they run out of gas. The risk of that happening is offset by the need to occasionally travel faster or farther than a car can take you.

I still think nuclear power is worth the risks of accidents, but I don't think that the proponents of nuclear power have been entirely honest about its safety.

Up until a week ago I was one of those people who would swear up and down that the technology is safe and would shut itself down in the event of an accident, and that all the previous incidents were due to human error anyway. No more. I actually feel stupid for believing that stuff now.

Re:Fukushima: Mark 1 Nuclear Reactor Design Caused GE Scient... by rbanffy on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @07:41PM (#2334458)
> There are some situations where risk may be acceptable.

There are. This is just not one of them. Better: this one involves unacceptable risks derived from inadequate engineering. A nuclear reactor that requires an external source or energy to dissipate the (prodigious amount of) energy it generates after shut down is stupid. Sorry to all engineers involved in this, but I can't find another word. Maybe adequate cooling would make the reactor cost twice as much. Maybe it would take up too much space. Or maybe it would require the reactor to be impossibly compact. Or big. I don't care. If it doesn't work (and it's quite clear this one isn't) it's because the design is not ready. It may not be your fault - it may be so due to what the client demanded, both in cost and space constraints, but that's what professional ethics are for. I have walked out of projects and companies before. This disaster shows not nearly enough engineers did the same.

Re:Fukushima: Mark 1 Nuclear Reactor Design Caused GE Scient... by ceejayoz on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:29AM (#2332388)
There are part/system failures in cars that result in death, just as with nuclear reactors.
Re:Fukushima: Mark 1 Nuclear Reactor Design Caused GE Scient... by eli on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:38AM (#2332431)
They typically don't take out nearby villages as well, but point taken.
Re:Fukushima: Mark 1 Nuclear Reactor Design Caused GE Scient... by ceejayoz on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @03:45PM (#2333558)
Cars kill a lot more people than nuclear plants do, though.
Re:Fukushima: Mark 1 Nuclear Reactor Design Caused GE Scient... by rbanffy on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @07:42PM (#2334461)
They are also a lot cheaper.
Re:Fukushima: Mark 1 Nuclear Reactor Design Caused GE Scient... by rbanffy on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @01:36PM (#2332972)
Indeed there are, but one could suppose nuclear reactors would only fail catastrophically when something catastrophic happened, not when being shut down.
Re:Fukushima: Mark 1 Nuclear Reactor Design Caused GE Scient... by anamax on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @02:01PM (#2333096)
> one could suppose nuclear reactors would only fail catastrophically when something catastrophic happened, not when being shut down.

Shutting down after a tsunami took out much of the support equipment seems somewhat catastrophic.

Re:Fukushima: Mark 1 Nuclear Reactor Design Caused GE Scient... by sorbus on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @02:10PM (#2333145)
I would call an earthquake (which was larger than it was designed to withstand) followed by a tsunami (which knocked out the emergency generators) pretty catastrophic.
Re:Fukushima: Mark 1 Nuclear Reactor Design Caused GE Scient... by rbanffy on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @03:53PM (#2333585)
It was designed to shut down during a quake, something it did. What bothers me is that something that generates so much heat as to require active cooling (something that already indicates less than ideal operating conditions) requires an external system to cool it. The first option should always be to use the reactor to generate power to operate the pumps that cool it. A small turbine mechanically connected to the pumps would be a better option. Operating the cooling system doesn't require more than a tiny fraction of the post-shutdown thermal output.

I am fine with having the independent generators to operate cooling pumps in an emergency shutdown, but I am not very enthusiastic as they being the first line of defense.