Re:Fukushima: Mark 1 Nuclear Reactor Design Caused GE Scient...
by rbanffy on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @07:41PM
(#2334458)
> There are some situations where risk may be acceptable.
There are. This is just not one of them. Better: this one involves unacceptable risks derived from inadequate engineering. A nuclear reactor that requires an external source or energy to dissipate the (prodigious amount of) energy it generates after shut down is stupid. Sorry to all engineers involved in this, but I can't find another word. Maybe adequate cooling would make the reactor cost twice as much. Maybe it would take up too much space. Or maybe it would require the reactor to be impossibly compact. Or big. I don't care. If it doesn't work (and it's quite clear this one isn't) it's because the design is not ready. It may not be your fault - it may be so due to what the client demanded, both in cost and space constraints, but that's what professional ethics are for. I have walked out of projects and companies before. This disaster shows not nearly enough engineers did the same.
There are. This is just not one of them. Better: this one involves unacceptable risks derived from inadequate engineering. A nuclear reactor that requires an external source or energy to dissipate the (prodigious amount of) energy it generates after shut down is stupid. Sorry to all engineers involved in this, but I can't find another word. Maybe adequate cooling would make the reactor cost twice as much. Maybe it would take up too much space. Or maybe it would require the reactor to be impossibly compact. Or big. I don't care. If it doesn't work (and it's quite clear this one isn't) it's because the design is not ready. It may not be your fault - it may be so due to what the client demanded, both in cost and space constraints, but that's what professional ethics are for. I have walked out of projects and companies before. This disaster shows not nearly enough engineers did the same.