News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by bradleyland on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @09:57AM (#2331993)
Don't sell yourself short, Vladimir. If you're going to work for free, try contributing to an open source project you find interesting. If you're going to work for a for-profit company, you should be paid :)
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by mattdeboard on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @10:39AM (#2332173)
This does seem to be a mantra on HN. I can't speak for anyone else, but where I live "junior developer" positions are looking for 3+ years experience, "Preferably" a masters degree in computer science, expert Linux, HTML and JavaScript, and so forth. While globally it is a hacker's job market, those of us who are not currently free to move to where the jobs are (I'm a single parent and don't want to uproot my kid again) sometimes have to try to get our foot in the door in this employer's market by begging for the chance to work even for free.

Not trying to be a Debbie Downer at all, by the way. I moved from the valley to the Midwest (I know, I know...) so I know that there are tons of jobs for people like me (and Vlad, probably). However in my opinion "Don't work for free for a for-profit company!" isn't advice everyone is in a position to follow. I wish I could.

(Disclaimer: I am a junior dev with Django/js experience in both personal and open-source projects, without a degree. So take my whining for what it's worth.)

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by Homunculiheaded on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @12:00PM (#2332545)
This advice is contrary to my personal experience. I live in a part of the US with a similarly craptastic market for programmers. In a recent job search, with very little formal experience as a software developer, I was turning down offers and taking my pick of interesting positions. From what I could gather this was almost entirely due to a github page with lots of code and a portfolio of interesting projects.

However I originally did think the market looked like you describe until I realized this amazingly valuable insight: My resume was almost instantly rejected by any company where an HR person/recruiter got my application; Any company where an engineer was the first to read my resume I was eagerly contacted in less than a week. A related insight: I don't want to work for companies where engineers aren't doing the hiring.

I also had no interest in moving and found, much to my surprise, that there are a lot great telecommuting options out there these days.

edit: I just want to clarify the tone/message here a bit, I'm not saying "your doing it wrong" but that it's easy to be discourage by being rejected by companies that aren't worth your talent. There was definitely a point in my search where I felt completely doomed, but then I realized that I actually wasn't aiming high enough and was underselling myself.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by jshen on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @01:35PM (#2332966)
"From what I could gather this was almost entirely due to a github page with lots of code and a portfolio of interesting projects."

I've been a hiring programmers for almost 10 years. It's so rare to get a resume with something like a link to a github page. You're pretty much guaranteed a phone screen with me if I see this. I know it's hard for people just starting out to understand this, but demand far exceeds the talent pool. You will always run into the managers that want to see "oracle blah blah blah" experience. When you get rejected by them because you couldn't answer how to solve some oracle specific problem in an interview you just ignore it, and keep applying.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @02:14PM (#2333164)
It's so rare to get a resume with something like a link to a github page. You're pretty much guaranteed a phone screen with me if I see this

Yes, yes, a billion times yes!!!!!

Even if it's some tiny little project that went nowhere, the fact that you actually have some code that is yours and that you can discuss intelligently puts you well ahead of 99% of the people I see.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by kgo on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @07:41PM (#2334457)
you actually have some code that is yours

That's the important thing. Sometimes the initial excitement of seeing that github account wanes when you realize 8 projects are forks of existing projects with one change, and the other two are a stock rails project with only three or four minor commits on top of that.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by dublinclontarf on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:51PM (#2335006)
What about an application server that was abandoned after padrino became available. I built it on top of sinatra, it was to include authentication and authorisation as well as a few handlers.

I'd generalised it from another webapp I was buildingfor someone else (that didn't pay) summer last year.

https://github.com/dublinclontarf/SchoolOut

This is pretty much some of the only code I've made available in public. Should I put up the entire webapp that I built during the summer? It's not doing anything.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by robeastham on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @10:02PM (#2334789)
My new résumé app/service aimed at hackers has integration with github, hacker news and stackoverflow. You can see at a glance what people have been up to on these sites by looking in the sidebar of any Mighty CV powered résumé. Though integration with these sites must have been switched on by the owner of the résumé for this to work.

I'm hoping to finally launch the private beta this weekend, there are still some invites left. You can sign up for one if you like at:

http://www.mightycv.com/

It has some other cool stuff like auto PDF generation and private cover letters/videos.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by mattdeboard on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @02:20PM (#2333209)
Really? Damn. Maybe I need to rethink my position.
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by joeyespo on Saturday March 19, 2011 @11:50AM (#2343861)
I've been doing this recently: gathering up my recent and old code and putting it on GitHub. I'm employed currently but this is still something I've been pushing off for a while.

One of the things that held me back though was that I wanted the projects to be "ready." To get them to a point where I can show them off instead of having several abandoned and "poorly written" projects. (Quoted because you really are your own worst critic.)

I now think it's much better to show you can ship on your ideas. To build, publish, and move on to your next idea. It's a much stronger indication of your passion for programming than words alone. Saying "I like to hack in my spare time" without further evidence just doesn't have much impact.

Does anybody disagree? Are there cases where publishing imperfect code and abandoned projects alongside your best was a disadvantage to you?

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by dekz on Thursday March 17, 2011 @06:34AM (#2335655)
I have github and bitbucket on my resume. It was only noticed and mentioned by a smaller "startup". So if you're applying for a job at a much larger company with your "average" (the ones who toot about this new CVS technology) manager, they might not even know what github is. YMMV
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by nigelsampson on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @04:28PM (#2333741)
I started to include links to my website on my resume as it contained a lot more interesting work and code than my day job.

It didn't seem to be helping, however it turned out that most recruiters were scrubbing it from the version they passed on to prospective clients.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by jshen on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @04:58PM (#2333885)
apply to companies that don't use recruiters :)
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by kgo on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @07:18PM (#2334397)
I'm at a start-up now, but before that I got sick of developing professionally and took a break. Probably because I was one of those people who didn't look good enough on paper, and only got through the resume pile at corporate jobs or body shops, and got fed up with the bs you see there.

So after my break, I honestly listed that as 'funemployment' on the resume, with a brief human understandable explanation. (I actually was working on some of my own non-programming related projects, and explained as much.) In the email cover letter, I basically said "Here's my resume, but I think my website does a better job of explaining my real strengths as a developer."

An interesting thing happened. Without exception, any company with an HR department totally blew me off. And without exception, any company where the owner screened the resumes, I got a phone screen and a real interview.

I also think that's something where having a custom domain for your email really helps. If any tech-savvy person gets a resume from [email protected], they're pretty much going to instantly open up a browser and type http://not-gmail-or-yahoo.com.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by nigelsampson on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @07:54PM (#2334495)
Haha that was certainly the lesson I took from that, however the market I'm in (Auckland, New Zealand) they're a necessary evil sometimes.
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by bmelton on Thursday March 17, 2011 @12:16AM (#2335060)
Agreed. My resume was recently shopped, and I got hits from everywhere, just for having had my github repo in my 'contact' information.

That it's populated with tiny little projects that only work exactly for what they were intended, didn't seem to be much of a deterrent to anybody.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by Stwerner on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @05:27PM (#2334013)
Definitely what I've seen from the applicant's side as well with regards to the Github link. I was told that I got the phone screen for my current job because of it. Before adding it to my resume I hardly had interviews for an entire year.

I'm surprised more people don't have it on there.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by bendmorris on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @01:25PM (#2332929)
My job search experience in a small western college town has pretty much mirrored yours. I'm a grad student so I'm only looking for part time work, and about twice a year I send out a few applications for development positions and almost always get as many offers as I applied to, from which I either take a better position or use as leverage at my current position. I'm not a CS student, but I think my resume (where I list tons of projects completed and programming languages I'm comfortable with) stands out against the CS student/new grad resumes they're probably swamped with.

Occasionally I'm turned down for something like not remembering some syntax triviality, something that could easily be looked up; that's a sure sign that I wouldn't want to be working there.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by mattdeboard on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @02:01PM (#2333102)
Hey, thanks. I actually do include my Github page (though admittedly I don't do much interesting I'd say) on my resume, but I'd never considered the difference between an HR manager and an engineer seeing it. Great insight, thanks.

(For the record, I wasn't giving advice :P )

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by Luyt on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @01:08PM (#2332842)
Could I have a peek at your resume, please? (Your profile page doesn't list any website).
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by remthename on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @01:52PM (#2333049)
Do you think closed-source projects are just as good? I can never think of an undone open source thing that I would be able to do.
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by mattdeboard on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @02:07PM (#2333133)
I am working on a large open source project right now via a connection I made on HN. By hanging out in their IRC channel and listening, I've been able to fix a couple of problems before they left the "complaining about it in IRC" stage and percolated up to the "file a bug report" stage. If you're the first to move on it you get to fix it.

My recommendation is find something in open source you use and see if they communicate in IRC or some other open medium. Probably not great universal advice but it has worked for me.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by gnosis on Thursday March 17, 2011 @01:49AM (#2335224)
You can't find an undone open source project?

There are no undone open source projects!

They're all undone.

There are always features to add and bugs to fix. Except maybe for TeX.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by wheels on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:43AM (#2332459)
The presumption here is that doing open source work does not open doors to employment – in fact, that's quite far from the truth.

If you're a contributor to a well known open source project there are lots of doors that are opened by being plugged into a network of other good developers that are often being pinged by people looking for work to be done. Prior to starting a startup virtually every job that I'd gotten had been either a result of or significantly influence by having done significant open source stuff and to this day, despite having been mostly inactive in open source stuff for about 4 years, I still regularly have people contact me asking if I'm available for contract work.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by mattdeboard on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:46AM (#2332473)
Oh, I don't dispute that whatsoever. I'm working on an open source project via a connection I made here on HackerNews. It's not an employment thing but I'm working with one of the (employed) team-leaders on the project. I know it looks great. But it would be nice programming to pay the bills in the meantime instead of whatever else I've got to do.

(edit: I should say I left a career in another industry to pursue programming full-time, so I'm not complaining about having to do other things. I knew it was a gamble, but it was and still is worth it.)

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by codexon on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @04:10PM (#2333663)
The presumption here is that doing open source work does not open doors to employment - in fact, that's quite far from the truth.

It is in my experience that in large open source projects that anyone is impressed with, the people with commit privileges don't want more contributors.

It is like Wikipedia where if you make an edit to their code or a replacement, they take personal offense to it and will fight you tooth and nail to get it ignored. Or in one case, just ignore me for over a year saying they will merge it and never do it. Or if they merge it, they don't give me credit.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by Ixiaus on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:55AM (#2332513)
I won't ever hire a developer to work for free - I remember being in this boat when I started as a self-educated programmer. The employers that you attract by saying you will work for free in exchange for possible future employment and experience are usually not that great.

The suggestion to contribute to an open-source project is, by far, the best advice. Open-source projects tend to be (but not all) meritocracies; you will learn far more by contributing to an open-source project because of the big-team culture...

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by mattdeboard on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @12:04PM (#2332559)
Yeah I'm contributing to an open source project now. I've learned quite a bit already.
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by zievo on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:15AM (#2332344)
"I'm a single parent"

Respect.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by mattdeboard on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:22AM (#2332363)
Thanks. For bonus points, I'm a single dad raising a little girl with no mom in the picture. She likes science and math, and has a few ideas for a website or two :P
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by mangoleaf on Thursday March 17, 2011 @12:44AM (#2335102)
I'm a single father of an 11yo boy. He started saying things like "I want to make...." when he was 8ish and then I showed him a some html and got him his own domain to play with and call his own. But when I showed him view-source, it really took off. He went to some site that archived sites from 10 years ago of some games/toys/shows that he likes and viewsourced them all and started adding features to his site (actually plural now). After playing with that for awhile, he wanted to make "forums" and etc., and so needed some php. First with text files, then mysql. It has been fun watching him.
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by mattdeboard on Wednesday March 23, 2011 @08:52AM (#2359123)
That's really great. My daughter is more into art right now. I'm already working hard to dissuade her from an art degree.
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by jonkelly on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @02:30PM (#2333251)
Awesome. My daughter is 7 and also loves math - I can't wait to get her coding!
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by mattdeboard on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @03:15PM (#2333439)
I'm taking it slow with her so I don't totally put her off it. She's starting to ask what I'm doing while I'm at my computer, and she was shocked that I actually made a website that she could access and use from a different computer. "You made this? Wow!"
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by bradleyland on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:11AM (#2332330)
Don't sell yourself short either. If you can't get paying work doing what you're doing, take the startup advice and pivot.
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by mattdeboard on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:56AM (#2332517)
If I had a single great idea, I would :P Best I've done is build a pinboard clone.
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by KishoreKumar on Thursday March 17, 2011 @08:16AM (#2335863)
Same as above reply, but in my way. Google for:

intitle:"Idea Dump" OR inurl:"idea+dump" site:jacquesmattheij.com

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by v-t on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @10:11AM (#2332055)
I am considering open source as good place to learn and to generate some value for people. I do love sinatra framework. I pull source and read diffs every couple days. But they have core team which fixes all bugs in seconds, so I cannot find application there. And my goal is more to make some contacts and to know people in this field. I always was a silent reader and now I want to communicate with intresting people.
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by bad_user on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @10:32AM (#2332146)
Vladimir, open source contributions tend to suck unless you're scratching an itch for yourself. You don't contribute for the sake of contributing, that's not going to work.

That's why you shouldn't work on Sinatra and other open source tools meant for developers.

Instead, build an app for a much wider audience. Do what an entrepreneur trying to sell his app would do, but with open-source - i.e. the end goal being to have real users that appreciate your work.

Here's the perfect example: https://github.com/michaeldv/fat_free_crm

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by yawniek on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @12:54PM (#2332781)
have you looked at http://padrinorb.com its based on sinatra and has still open tickets.
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by codeslush on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @10:13AM (#2332063)
It seems to me that what he's doing is rather smart. It gives him an chance to be exposed to more opportunities than if he was trying to get hired and he can pick those on which he wishes to take a risk.

I would certainly change the wording a little to weed out the people who will just try to take advantage, but the overall strategy seems quite appropriate.

This will work very well for a person who's confident in their skills, but maybe having a hard time finding income from traditional sources. Get in, kick butt, make a statement and earn income.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by bad_user on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @10:28AM (#2332130)
Working on open-source has the same benefits, and while a good profitable gig coming from that would probably take longer than 1 or 2 months, the benefits of being a known open-source author will last for much longer and fare much better going forward.

I swear, every time someone (with a known/useful open-source contribution) came to an interview for any company I worked for, everybody was drooling uncontrollably and thinking "how the hell could we please this guy to stay, after all, he's Google material".

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by tomlin on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @10:33AM (#2332148)
Unfortunately, more often than not, this mentality is taken advantage of. To the pressured manager, Vlad provides an easy-out. It also sets a bad tone for the relationship between employer and employee.

It's also a negotiation uphill battle to go from $0 to $50,000/year. Any looming economic crisis multiplies the battle, and in turn, valuable enthusiasm for the industry.

His work is probably better than most, but his self-esteem regarding his abilities is apparent - especially to an employer.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by codeslush on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @10:44AM (#2332199)
While I don't completely disagree with you, I think his chances of success are better than spending x amount of time applying for jobs trying to get an interview.

I don't recall which company, but in the last two weeks, one of the big name startups put out a competition to solve a problem regarding log file parsing. It was an opportunity, basically, to get a job with them. Now, with this approach, the OP might be competing with thousands of others - and his chances of standing out are reduced. He's taken the inverse approach, and HE can pick the challenges he wishes to solve, with same end goal: income.

It's not unique - it's what a lot of driven people have done in the past to get in the door somewhere.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by zem on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:10AM (#2332327)
> I don't recall which company, but in the last two weeks, one of the big name startups put out a competition to solve a problem regarding log file parsing.

reddit

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by v-t on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @10:24AM (#2332106)
My idea is to do exactly what you say.
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by Vivtek on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @10:46AM (#2332205)
You can also do work for non-profits or charities. Sparked.com always has some Web-related work that you could easily do in a couple of hours at a whack and build up a portfolio. (Sparked.com being a site I learned about here, and I've done a couple of little tasks there.)
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by futuremint on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @10:03AM (#2332021)
He does say that after a few weeks he expects to get hired.

But he should totally charge an hourly rate instead of free. I know people would pay for it.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by jarin on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @10:11AM (#2332053)
Exactly, there's a big difference between pro bono and paid work. And trust me, the people you do free work for will expect A LOT MORE from you.

I would say the exceptions would be: a) it's a charity or a cause that you like, or b) you really need to improve a particular skill and it's more of an internship you're looking for.

Either way though, I give you mad props for initiative.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by latch on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @10:08AM (#2332037)
he says after a few months.

I generally agree with your parent that he ought to spend that time doing something that can showcase his skills and increase his chance to get hired. He can gain more exposure working on something in the open (a personal project, an OSS project) than doing some work for a single company.

Re:Web developer will work for you for free by tmachinecharmer on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:30AM (#2332391)
Do startups that are not making profit qualify as non-profit organizations?
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by jat850 on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @11:39AM (#2332440)
That's probably tongue in cheek, but in case it's not: No, absolutely, definitely not.
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by viralinfection on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @12:55PM (#2332783)
while that's generally good advice; i think vlad goal is lead generation, he hit the top of HN, im sure he'll find gainful employment
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by v-t on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @01:55PM (#2333063)
To be honest, I was looking at filled submit link form about 10 minutes, thinking that my offer don't worth people time. I hoped to get something like 3 comments. So much attention is amazing to me. This was not planned as clever lead gen trick.
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by paolomaffei on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @02:42PM (#2333304)
I believe it is called an "internship"
Re:Web developer will work for you for free by swecker on Wednesday March 16, 2011 @04:50PM (#2333846)
Many people have a misconception about this. An intern is a hired position (albeit temporary), and working for free is simply volunteering. There are unpaid interns, but there are probably more misconceptions about that. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/03/business/03intern.html?_r=...