Scenario C: Company hires an engineer with zero base salary and $200k/year worth of stock that gets paid monthly with the correct number of shares to get $16.7k in value. The shares can immediately be sold back to the company for the full value.
The engineer clearly receives $200k of economic value. Whether the stock is sold or not has no effect on the value transfer.
Does this hypothetical company have 1) a 100% profit margin, or 2) is it losing money?
If you picked 1), let's say the engineer quits and for whatever reason the company needs to pay the replacement $200k/year in cash. To do so, the company sells $16.7k of shares to an investor each month. Is it still a 100% margin company?
You've now got an extra $100k in the bank for other requirements. Effectively the SBC makes the employee an investor also, exchanging labour for equity (instead of just for cash). This seems to me to be different. Obviously there is some dilutive effect to the share allotments, but especially in earlier stage non public companies you probably always want to have more non cash vs cash expenses if you have the option?
As an outside investor, if a company is not profitable accounting for stock compensation then the book value of your stake (or your share of the NPV of future profits, or whatever) is going down.
I interpreted TFA to cast the Buffet quote in a positive light, and not as an equivocation.
>>As an outside investor, if a company is not profitable accounting for stock compensation then the book value of your stake (or your share of the NPV of future profits, or whatever) is going down.
Sounds like you, Buffet and the FASB are completely aligned on this point -- all the more reason to use/weight the GAAP numbers more heavily than the non-GAAPs and adjust our decision models appropriately.
You’re talking about the balance statement, which it would benefit but unrelated to profit.
In other words, yes they have more money, but no, it does not make them more profitable.
In other words, yes they have more money, but no, it does not make them more profitable.
They're not profitable in either Scenario because they don't have any income in either. But in one scenario, they have $100k spendable cash, and in the other all they have is sweat equity that they claim is worth $200k compensation. With spendable cash, you have runway and the opportunity to acquire external products or services that they need for the business. With sweat equity, you have sweat and dreams of success.
2nd point: GP said "invest 100k/year", thus he do make additional investments.
At the simplest level, you can buy things and services with the $100k cash in Scenario 2 at the start of the year as soon as the investment is made. You don't have that cash in Scenario 1.
Consider the difference if the employee quits or is fired before vesting their options.
Consider the difference if the company is sold for less than the strike price of the options.
Then again, the companies that are doing so are generally the ones using GAAP earnings and including SBC. Companies still using options are often private, which means that Scenario B isn't even an option for the general public, and the only way for a non-accredited investor to own stock is to work for them.
Scenario A: Company hires an engineer with a base salary of 100k/year, and 100k/year worth of SBC.
Scenario B: Company convinces an investor to invest 100k/year... and also hires him as an engineer with a base salary of 200k/year.
From a business fundamentals and margins perspective, the two scenarios are identical. And yet, in scenario A, the company is spinning their non-GAAP annual expense as being 100k. Whereas in scenario B, the company wouldn't even try to spin their annual expense as being anything other than 200k.
The above thought experiment becomes particularly powerful if the hypothetical company has no other expenses and an annual revenue of $150k. Using the non-GAAP estimates from scenario A can mislead investors into thinking that the company has a very healthy gross margin, and is a lucrative investment. Whereas the actual GAAP numbers from both scenarios A and B, make it clear that the business is not profitable at all.