You’re talking about the balance statement, which it would benefit but unrelated to profit.
In other words, yes they have more money, but no, it does not make them more profitable.
In other words, yes they have more money, but no, it does not make them more profitable.
They're not profitable in either Scenario because they don't have any income in either. But in one scenario, they have $100k spendable cash, and in the other all they have is sweat equity that they claim is worth $200k compensation. With spendable cash, you have runway and the opportunity to acquire external products or services that they need for the business. With sweat equity, you have sweat and dreams of success.
2nd point: GP said "invest 100k/year", thus he do make additional investments.
At the simplest level, you can buy things and services with the $100k cash in Scenario 2 at the start of the year as soon as the investment is made. You don't have that cash in Scenario 1.