News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by crazygringo on Thursday May 21, 2020 @03:52PM (#23264110)
Does this mean that, broadly, under GDPR if anyone in any photo you've ever taken and put on social media complains, you have to take it down?

Or is this because the subjects are minors? Or some other technicality, like whether or not the photos were taken in a public place or similar?

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by karatestomp on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:17PM (#23264489)
I think being asked to stop distributing magazines with people's photos in them, when you didn't get prior permission to publish them, is reasonable.

That people are so casual about what they post publicly online is nuts. That sites that exist pretty much solely to enable that bad judgement keep operating is nuts.

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by kube-system on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:27PM (#23264665)
I'd have to disagree with that. The press shouldn't need permission to engage in photographic journalism. The restrictions we place on them should be very narrow and specific.
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by M2Ys4U on Thursday May 21, 2020 @05:35PM (#23265695)
The key point is balancing the rights when they are in conflict.

There's obviously more weight put on the freedom of expression side of the argument when it concerns journalistic endeavours than, say, a grandmother wanting to post pictures of her kids.

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by josefx on Thursday May 21, 2020 @05:06PM (#23265333)
Germany has exclusions for persons and events of public interest. So journalists can still do their job.
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by kube-system on Thursday May 21, 2020 @05:54PM (#23265901)
The "public interest" is often a very politically sensitive subject to define. While I'm sure that works great 99% of the time, is that last 1% worth the sacrifice?

Personally I prefer the default to be legality, and make exceptions for things we want to be illegal, rather than reverse.

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by tephra on Thursday May 21, 2020 @05:21PM (#23265537)
Journalism is in many ways excempt from the gdpr (although it does vary by member states IIRC)
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by rsynnott on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:10PM (#23264379)
There's a public interest exemption, so of it's news you might be in a stronger position. But yeah, generally.
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by rhizome on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:15PM (#23264457)
When FB first had tagging and there began to be problems with people not wanting pictures of their topless beer-bonging to show up on Grandma's wall, I thought a good approach would be that all pictures with multiple people should only be visible to those who are tagged in it until everybody is tagged and everybody consents to public display.
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by bilbo0s on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:05PM (#23264309)
Yes. People can coerce you into taking down their PII, including photos, in Europe. (Assuming they know of it's existence on your social media account, never gave you permission to use it, and object to it being made available.)

But I know some people who believe that a workaround involves both you and the information being physically in the US, and the information not actually being displayed anywhere in Europe. I don't know if such a case has actually been litigated, but I'd wager you'd be OK in that scenario.

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by nelaboras on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:23PM (#23264586)
It's more nuanced. If it's in a public place and not invasive (eg taken through a street window) you have little case to get anything taken down. So no stranger appearing in your Disneyland pictures can force you to delete them.
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by btilly on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:57PM (#23265206)
It is more complicated than that.

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Street_View_privacy_con... for issues that arose in practice from pictures taken in public by Google.

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by grandmczeb on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:20PM (#23264548)
If I post e.g. the Eric Gartner video[1], can the involved officer force me take it down based on his privacy rights?

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/video/2014/dec/04/i-cant...

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by renewiltord on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:39PM (#23264863)
Art 6 (1) (e). You may have to fight but you'll win. IANAL.
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by grandmczeb on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:53PM (#23265116)
> (e) processing is necessary for the performance of a task carried out in the public interest

Right, so it’s not as absolute as the original comment made it sound.

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by renewiltord on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:55PM (#23265165)
The full nuance of the law can only be gleaned from the law itself. Any shorter comment on the Internet is guaranteed to leave out one of the meanings. So, yes, I think you're right but that's always going to be the case.
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by grandmczeb on Thursday May 21, 2020 @05:12PM (#23265409)
Fair, but IMO there’s not even a hint of nuance in the original comment. Even a “It’s complicated but...” would be better.
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by renewiltord on Thursday May 21, 2020 @05:48PM (#23265845)
Fair, fair.
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by M2Ys4U on Thursday May 21, 2020 @05:37PM (#23265718)
This should be the disclaimer put on every discussion of the GDPR on here, to be honest
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by lgl on Thursday May 21, 2020 @05:12PM (#23265407)
"Coerce" has a negative and unlawful connotation/definition. There is legislation for this so it's basically a lawful request for removal.
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by gumby on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:26PM (#23264654)
This is an interesting problem. I typically don't post pictures of other people; though I don't generally ask I don't do it if I think the person might not be happy with it.

But the way GDPR is written someone could come back years later, having changed their mind, and have a picture taken down. Perhaps a couple broke up and one party wants all photos with them together removed. I suppose that's OK, but implies a kind of curation (and an obligation) that isn't always easy.

The second is random passers-by who appear unintentionally (by all parties) the background of photos. On one hand, what expectation of tangental privacy should you have when you're out in the option and people can see you with their eyes? On the other hand, permitting this seems like it would open a mass surveillance loophole.

I can imagine a relatively easy fix for the latter, which is an automatic blur filter for those who aren't the "subject" of a photo, similar to what street view uses.

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by TeMPOraL on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:22PM (#23264572)
> Does this mean that, broadly, under GDPR if anyone in any photo you've ever taken and put on social media complains, you have to take it down?

It goes against what we've been used to on-line, but it does make sense. Even without GDPR, I'd say basic manners would oblige you to take a photo down if a person featured on it asked you to.

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by aphextron on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:00PM (#23264239)
>"Does this mean that, broadly, under GDPR if anyone in any photo you've ever taken and put on social media complains, you have to take it down?"

We can only hope. No one has the right to post a picture of me on the internet anywhere ever for any reason.

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by koboll on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:06PM (#23264315)
This is silly. You don't retain any claims on images just because they include you. Extrapolating this idea leads to absurd conclusions.

If I take a photo of a crowd at an NBA game and publish it in a book of NBA photos, should any member of that crowd be able to force the publisher to stop selling the book until they've removed the photo? If not, why should it work differently on the internet?

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by Thaxll on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:07PM (#23264342)
Laws are different per country but usually it has to do with the intent of the picture, if I'm in background of your NBA photo I'm not the main subject so it's ok and I have not right to ask you to take it down.
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by Tomte on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:10PM (#23264374)
Again, only speaking for my country (but I'd expect other European countries to be similar):

pictures of a crowd don't give individual people depicted any rights, unless they are somehow the focus of the picture (say portrait shot with a crowd in the background).

Also, when you take a photo of a building the passer-by doesn't get rights to demand you not publish it, if he is merely an insignificant chance addition.

Unsurprisingly, all those "easy edge cases" that internet commenters believe to have found as the first person ever have already been thought through and handled.

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by xphilter on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:09PM (#23264362)
Not to be a stickler, but if you’re at an NBA game you contractually agree to allow that photo to be taken and displayed (under US law). Obviously it’d be different under EU law though.
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by closeparen on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:15PM (#23264465)
GDPR consent cannot be a condition of accessing the service. It also has to be revocable.
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by xphilter on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:57PM (#23265209)
That’s why I put in the disclaimer. I don’t think you would rely on consent in that instance. Probably would have to use the “legitimate interest” and have some rules around how photos are taken and used (e.g., people in the background where the soccer player is the target of the photo vs taking a photo of a single fan in attendance).
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by kube-system on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:31PM (#23264731)
Does anyone know how EU sports handle this? Do they blur faces of people in the crowd on request?
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by xphilter on Thursday May 21, 2020 @05:12PM (#23265420)
It would be a terrible solution if they did that I hope they don’t). I imagine they have specified what the legal basis is for collecting and using the photos and have an exemption outlined for when they receive a deletion request.
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by M2Ys4U on Thursday May 21, 2020 @05:40PM (#23265757)
In the UK there's the common law notion of a "reasonable expectation of privacy".

If you're in public then you don't, generally, have a reasonable expectation of privacy, but if you're at home or at work then it's a different story.

As far as I'm aware, though, this hasn't been tested in court since the GDPR has come in to effect, but I would be surprised if the (UK) GDPR is not interpreted with that principal if and when it does.

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by asadhaider on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:08PM (#23264350)
Umm, what if I take photos in a public place with you in them and the laws of the country allow public photography? or posting images which are public record such as mugshots/booking photos? (not that I agree with them being public record anyhow, morally I'd agree with you but it would be perfectly legal to do so)
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by skrause on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:30PM (#23264707)
> Umm, what if I take photos in a public place with you in them and the laws of the country allow public photography?

Here in Germany you are allowed to take photos in public, but you may not publish them in all circumstances. If a person is somewhere in the background it's fine. Also if it's a person of public interest. But you can not just follow anyone in public, take photos of them specificially and publish them. You may be required to take them down. Personality rights exist even in public.

> or posting images which are public record such as mugshots/booking photos?

In Germany (and many other countries) mugshots are not public records.

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by gsich on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:10PM (#23264375)
Depends. Public in the sense you want to photograph some monument/building? Then no problem.

Photographing in public for the sole purpose of taking a photo from you? No.

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by kabdib on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:30PM (#23264715)
In the US, if you're in a public place you have no expectation of privacy. Someone can take your photo and do whatever they like with it. (This also goes for photos of "private property" that is visible from a public location, which often comes as a surprise to security guards and law enforcement).
Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by grawprog on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:08PM (#23264351)
Honestly, I feel kind of the same way and i'm not really a big fan when I find pictures of myself online I didn't know about, but it's fairly unrealistic to believe you can stop people from doing this.

Nothing was stopping people from taking your picture and posting it around town, or in a classified ad or something before, nothing's going to stop people from doing it now.

The best thing to do is decide if it's a picture really worth being upset about existing and if it is, kindly talk to the people who posted it, otherwise it's probably not worth worrying about.

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by unfunco on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:12PM (#23264407)
I agree with the sentiment, but for most of history there has been some sort of ceremony when taking a photo, saying cheese for example, it used to be much more obvious when a photo was being taken, and now its discrete in many situations.

People that knowingly smile for a photo aren't really the people complaining.

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by logifail on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:39PM (#23264868)
> The best thing to do is decide if it's a picture really worth being upset about existing [..]

What if you've not seen the photo, don't know who took the photo, or who posted it, or where they posted it?

Last year I had a drink with a group of friends in a pub, commemorating the untimely death of a friend one year before.

The following day, at work, a manager who wasn't present the night before asked me about the event the previous evening. He said he'd seen me "in the photos" on Facebook.

I'm not on Facebook, so I've no idea who took - or who posted - photos.

Suggestions?

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by grawprog on Thursday May 21, 2020 @09:29PM (#23267792)
>Suggestions?

Decide whether it's worth worrying about and if not, don't?

Was your boss angry about it? Or were they just making conversation about it?

One of those is worth worrying about, the other may be annoying but doesn't matter.

You can't control people. I dunno, even before everyone had cameras on them all the time I was taught to assume everything I did in public could be seen and maybe even be recorded by anyone, my dad was a bit paranoid, he taught me this as a child long before cell phones became ubiquitous. It's just the way it is. If you're in a public place, people can see you, people have cameras, the internet exists.

Again, I agree, I dislike pictures of me existing randomly, I try to avoid it. I'll dodge cameras and shit if I see someone taking pictures. But I know, inevitably, there's not much i can do about it. But I also realize, people tend to have short attention spans and memories and live in their own worlds so in the end it doesn't really matter and most people don't care enough to remember some random picture they seen of me anyway.

Re:Grandmother ordered to delete Facebook photos under GDPR by lmilcin on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:13PM (#23264414)
With companies assuming right to use the pictures posted on their platform it is now more complicated matter.

Would you like picture of you posted by your family member on company's X platform to be used by company X for marketing purposes? I get your family member may not mind if their own pictures are used but you were never asked for permission. Would you want to be asked for permission?