News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by econcon on Thursday May 21, 2020 @10:20AM (#23258660)
There is shortage of 3D printing filament because of virus, so I've been creating filament and selling it.

https://medium.com/endless-filament/make-your-filament-at-ho...

This activity also help recycle waste plastic.

Production cost of filament is $7.5 per 5kg and filament roll has 850 gram filament and can be sold for $20-30 per spool

It's trivial to get the quality right.

You can sell rolls on Amazon, eBay and Etsy or your own Shopify store and use Facebook ads/Google Ads to advertise your website.

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by kube-system on Thursday May 21, 2020 @12:06PM (#23260160)
> It's trivial to get the quality right.

Is it really? I've looked into this a good bit myself and it seems that many who have tried this have trouble keeping the diameter consistent.

I suspect that if it really was trivial, then you'd think just about any commercial supplier could get it right, there's a lot of junk filament out there. Maybe you are just very good at it; +-0.02 is pretty good even by commercial standards. The entire first page of Amazon best sellers are +-0.03 or +-0.05.

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by econcon on Thursday May 21, 2020 @12:33PM (#23260633)
>Is it really? I've looked into this a good bit myself and it seems that many who have tried this have trouble keeping the diameter consistent.

If you'll check my medium post, I've linked a video where I am extruding filament.

Problem with those hobbyist machines is motor torque/power rating. And second, they don't use a special screw and barrel.

The motor used in professional extruders used in real filament factories starts at 5 horsepower for the smallest machine.

If you miss those two things, there is no way you'll get within 0.03mm

Without any PID feedback loop, I can get within 0.03 by setting puller speed manually.

>I suspect that if it really was trivial, then you'd think just about any commercial supplier could get it right

There is no reason to believe that junk filament is coming from people with good machine design. That could be coming from hobbyist underpowered extruder machines like filaestruder and likes.

>Maybe you are just very good at it; +-0.02 is pretty good even by commercial standards. The entire first page of Amazon best sellers are +-0.03 or +-0.05.

At higher extrusion speed you'll get more output per extruder machine time but you'll have lower filament dimensional stability.

So the trivial part is have a powerful motor, use a good screw+barrel and don't extrude too fast.

That said I've offered my telegram in medium post and YouTube video. So anyone who gets stuck can reach out to me. I am not leaving them hanging on their own.

Also, I am looking to make a microcontroller firmware for extruders which basically measures the filament then sets the puller roller speed based on thickness measured. It pulls filament faster if it's thicker than target and pulls filament slower if filament is coming out to be thinner than expected. This will help us reach 0.0020mm accuracy easily!

The problem I am facing is:

1. I am not good with micro controller and control algorithms

2. Laser guage which measure the filament without distorting it is expensive and starts at 2K USD.

So anyone who can help solve these technical challenges are welcome.

But you might not need this much dimensionally accurate filament. Selling within 0.03mm is easy.

Anything better not sure how much it will help FDM quality but yes microcontroller firmware approach will help get more output out of this machine as biggest problem with extruding too fast is that dimensional stability goes haywire.

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by jgable on Thursday May 21, 2020 @06:08PM (#23266067)
I can help you with the microcontroller and control algorithm side. It’s what I do. If you’re a software developer you can do it yourself with a small amount of guidance from someone like me. Email is my username plus 79 at gmail if you want to set up a quick discussion.
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by bsirkia on Monday June 01, 2020 @12:09PM (#23380046)
Hey @econcon, I think my friend and I will give this a try. We're starting to spec everything out, and probably want to start out with laser gauge to have high accuracy. Would love to ask a couple questions if you have time, my email is just my username at gmail.com
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by AxiomaticSpace on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:53PM (#23265119)
Instead of a laser gauge, you could try using a camera hooked up with some edge detection software and use that to estimate the width. It probably wouldn't be as accurate, but it would definitely be cheaper.
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by nitrogen on Thursday May 21, 2020 @06:01PM (#23265987)
You'd be looking at very subtle variations in the color of single pixels, so you might as well just use a single optical sensor and light source into a single high res adc, using intensity to measure thickness.

At some point dust in the air will be a limiting factor.

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by elcritch on Friday May 22, 2020 @05:29AM (#23270175)
For high accuracy, the brightness is really more the limiting factor, as most of the edge finding/binarization algorithms use a intensity factor for cutoff. I used camera measurement for small pieces of tissue samples in biomechanical measurement (~1mm x 5mm). We had a small window in our lab, and cloudy days would distort measurements. I solved it mostly by going to a SLDR camera from a handheld and a backdrop with a type of luminance chart. Much more accurate than calipers for soft squishy (and wet) samples. See [1] Figure 2E (pg 22), you can average out small variations pretty readily.

1: https://pdf.sciencedirectassets.com/274145/1-s2.0-S175161611...

Though your idea of a light source and adc could work well if you put it in a darkened enclosure. It’d probably require a bit more hardware design or tuning but the software / microcontroller side would b simpler. A RPi PiCam with a macro lens would work well too, but the reverse with less hardware tweaking and more software.

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by londons_explore on Friday May 22, 2020 @03:08AM (#23269422)
You'd make the filament go slightly diagonally across the field of view of the camera, and then you'd have thousands of part-filled pixels.

As long as your material is consistent (no bubbles, shiny spots, etc.), You should be able to build a very accurate sensor this way.

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by econcon on Saturday May 23, 2020 @07:36AM (#23282121)
I found this video https://youtu.be/kpsN78mQ6YY

They use a laser pointer to measure width of a hair.

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by quickthrower2 on Friday May 22, 2020 @12:29AM (#23268634)
In 2 weeks time:

There is a shortage of Extruders because of the people making 3D printing filament at home. So I've been creating Extruders and selling them.

:-)

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by nineteen999 on Friday May 22, 2020 @02:29AM (#23269223)
You're all good until somebody starts selling a pre-packaged Extruder factory.
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by econcon on Friday May 22, 2020 @04:37AM (#23269879)
There are companies who sell packaged extruder:

https://www.noztek.com/product/noztek-xcalibur/

The 13k listed machine produces 2kg per hour.

Extruder are heavy and low demand item, even cost of shipping will double the price of the machine which I've made.

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by pat_space on Thursday May 21, 2020 @10:24AM (#23258709)
Thanks for the link. Where are you selling your finished product?
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by econcon on Thursday May 21, 2020 @01:17PM (#23261392)
Amazon for now
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by soared on Thursday May 21, 2020 @11:29AM (#23259571)
I don’t think someone working at a call center has the technical aptitude and financial resources to source and build there own extrusion machine.
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by TrackerFF on Thursday May 21, 2020 @12:35PM (#23260673)
Lots of technically gifted people working dead-end jobs, due to things like location, family situation, lack of formal education, personal issues, or whatever :-)
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by HeyLaughingBoy on Thursday May 21, 2020 @01:16PM (#23261378)
Exactly.

As the saying goes "talent is evenly distributed; opportunity is not."

I've known lots of very smart people working what would be considered dead-end, or at least, lower-end jobs.

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by econcon on Thursday May 21, 2020 @01:22PM (#23261489)
Yes, I know a lot of people who don't have opportunity or have some sort of mental roadblock that makes them not put efforts into area which can potentially produce result. I am not sure if there is some name of this phenomenon.

But usually they need a visionary who can make them believe in the idea and then they can put their work/efforts/mind into it with confidence and they do end up achieving the result at the end.

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by xeromal on Thursday May 21, 2020 @11:58AM (#23260028)
Hard times can make hard people. You don't know what someone is capable of until they're backed against a wall. I was a computer repair man until my parent's divorce and the 2008 market collapse which forced me into a CS degree.
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by soared on Thursday May 21, 2020 @12:29PM (#23260562)
Computer repair -> computer science.

Call center -> building machines from scratch based on a medium post.

Sure it’s possible but I don’t think the suggestion really makes sense. You can be blind to the fact that hn is in the 1% of intellect/ability, but it should be obvious that effectively no one can honestly take that suggestion. Unemployed, low on cash, and then in a low-skill industry it doesn’t make sense to risk $500 to $1000 on a project that you likely won’t be able to build.

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by digitaltrees on Thursday May 21, 2020 @06:21PM (#23266189)
BS. For most of human history there was no manufacturing, people made stuff by hand. Every human is Capable of learning and making this machine. And it’s awesome that people are trying to teach others.
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by econcon on Thursday May 21, 2020 @01:24PM (#23261536)
Yea but OP is trying to help his friend and I am pretty sure they've some friend who might have experience working with mechanical things, maybe they know a mechanical engineer and JV, produce output and turn it into a mini factory, we never know!
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by xeromal on Thursday May 21, 2020 @01:32PM (#23261661)
I definitely get it from the capital perspective. I just want you to give underemployed a fair shake before making a judgement.
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by droptablemain on Friday May 22, 2020 @04:30AM (#23269847)
I'm pretty sure the people down-voting you to Hell don't know a single working-class person working a dead-end job for peanuts.
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by __s on Thursday May 21, 2020 @12:53PM (#23260945)
Have you worked at a call center?

In a past life I worked at a place where my manager & IT guy were originally call center workers. The manager was a crafty guy, does nice woodwork. My ex happened to also work at that call center & is now an illustrator. Another friend from that place eventually went to college to be a machinist

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by uoaei on Thursday May 21, 2020 @03:42PM (#23263927)
It's almost like some people don't attach their identity to their job, and make an income to pursue their interests in other hours.
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by gumby on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:32PM (#23264760)
Indeed. I've always hated that question "what do you do" (meaning your job) and usually answer it with "about what?"

I understand it's a pretty straightforward way to look for common ground and introductory topic of conversation, but there's a massive implication which I consider socially corrosive.

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by RhysU on Thursday May 21, 2020 @07:22PM (#23266806)
What is the implication and why is it socially corrosive?
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by gumby on Thursday May 21, 2020 @09:50PM (#23267910)
The implication is that one's worth comes from one's job, with the corollary that one's role in society is that of "worker" and "consumer", or if not simply just "consumer" then worthless.

It is socially corrosive because it is removes any concept of social relationship from the calculus of social worth.

And you see this in the discussion of "opening up the economy" as though that is the #1 parameter of existence. Certainly without a functioning economy there is no food or other basic needs, but the objectives are complex functions, not simplistic ones. The implication is that those who were not lucky enough to have a job that generates income during a time of pandemic must needs put themselves at risk while others need not. Disgraceful.

It's the same reason I cringe when people talk or write about "consuming content", as if "content" is fungible and that peoples' roles are to "consume" it -- when information is not "consumed" (destroyed) by being enjoyed.

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by RhysU on Friday May 22, 2020 @07:06AM (#23270771)
> It is socially corrosive because it is removes any concept of social relationship from the calculus of social worth.

I don't see how that follows from "What do you do?" because one could answer:

A) I volunteer at... B) I take care of... C) I love... D) etc.

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by __s on Thursday May 21, 2020 @07:35PM (#23266933)
The implication is that you define someone purely by their career. It's socially corrosive because we end up with people valuing themselves based on their vocation, & consequently we judge a man's worth on the salary he brings home
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by blackguardx on Thursday May 21, 2020 @03:23PM (#23263683)
I used to work in a call center and now work as an EE with a masters degree.
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by cosmodisk on Thursday May 21, 2020 @04:30PM (#23264719)
I work for a call centre of sorts.You wouldn't believe the kind of skills people have.
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by setr on Thursday May 21, 2020 @12:26PM (#23260520)
Technical aptitude is probably not significantly required, as a guide exists, forums exist, and shop employees exist -- you should be very far away from "starting from scratch". The main risk in low-knowledge is that you're liklier to fail at finding "cheap but good condition", instead obtaining "cheap and breaks in a few months"

Cost is the bigger concern, but at 600-700 $, it's hardly mind-numbing.

Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by quickthrower2 on Friday May 22, 2020 @12:31AM (#23268646)
Reminds me of the people who think if you have C# experience you can't handle other programming languages. Amazing how having a skill can be seen as a negative! Yes on average people who can do X can't do Y might apply, but in this situation and the interview one too, you are talking about a specific person not an average.
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by pascalxus on Thursday May 21, 2020 @05:38PM (#23265729)
People are a lot more capable than you think. There's a pretty vast oversupply of talent and not enough jobs to fill them. As a result, you have people who are capable of becoming so much more ending up in menial, low end jobs.
Re:Ask HN: Ways to generate income when you're at home witho... by digitaltrees on Thursday May 21, 2020 @06:17PM (#23266156)
Crisis is the mother of invention and motivation. This thread is awesome because it’s the sharing of knowledge that will give people opportunities. Even if they don’t currently have the ability it’s amazing to teach each other.