95% of game developers will never gonna make $1M from their pet project so it's no different whatever engine code is licensed under EULA or proprietary license with different name.
Excluding commercial use is not helping the growth of OSS, it is falsely claiming to be OSS.
If you want to say that it is being released as "source available" no one would complain. It is the falsehoods that bring out the complaints.
There is no single entity that own the word open source
>If you want to say that it is being released as "source available" no one would complain
Just like everything else, I totally understand that some will like it, some don't.
Is anything less than BSD or MIT license not open source then? I am all for it, but you are publishing some of your work under GNU which mean I can't use in one of my projects without publishing the source code under GNU. Why these restrictions are acceptable but not non-commercialisation?
It seems to be more restrictive to me than the OP's license.
Which definition of "open source" are you talking about in this case? I'm confused now.
Do you mean "Open Source" or source-available?
Plain English is important. People are lazy. People do not like non-obvious meanings. Regardless of intent, any one prompting idea that “open source” means anything other than “viewable source code” needs to reflect on the clarity of their communication and the reality they may be seen as an chest pounding elitist; which to me is not in the spirit of the idles the claim to believe.
Thousands good and one tiny bad thing, you get scrutinized to hell. You literally have to satisfy everybody otherwise theres gonna be a vocal minority(or majority) pointing out how wrong you are(usually due to difference in priorities). honestly, its mentally and emotionally draining to deal with these.
And its also applicable to HN community. Any time theres a tiny bit of good thing done by somebody/some company, theres always gonna be someone pointing out the bad things that someone/company did.
You either have to be full good, or just dont bother being a good guy.
I mean, why bother trying
You literally don't have to. You can just ignore some of them.
Very different from falsely claiming the release is OSI compliant or whatever the legalese is...
I think people have just figured out that "IANAL" goes without saying in any online public discussion, unless for whatever reason it happens to be in a forum where arbitrary participants are especially likely to be lawyers. This is not a commercial context where fraud would be a concern, and even if the speaker was a lawyer there is no reasonable expectation of any attorney-client relationship between random participants in a public discussion. "IANAL" flags are superfluous.
> Very different from falsely claiming the release is OSI compliant or whatever the legalese is...
The de facto accepted way to say that a license is OSI compliant is to refer to it as "open source".
> geez, what's up with all these armchair open source experts on HN? Looks like too many people on this thread thinks this is evil.
This is evil because it's intentional false advertisement. That's fine when some company which is totally new to the field doing it, but these guys have their code published on GitHub for years and they know the difference.This is no different from situation when surveillance sold under names like Patriot Act.
> Lastly, who the hell cares what some website called opensource.org says what open source is? This is all subjective, and from my point of view, if the source code is open, it is "open" source.
Yeah and if I decide that my restaurant make amazing pork dishes I am totally allowed to call them Vegan, Halal or Kosher. Right?Then we'll have amazing products like zoom call their software end2end encrypted. Oh actually it's already happen. And we also have this amazing software called Telegram which is totally encrypted except it isn't (by default). And Apple is absolutely cannot get access to your encryption key, unless you enable this shiny cloud backup option.
What an entitlement. You basically want people to be punished for giving away something for no charge, and has caused you no harm.
This is not about the money.
The source code is open, different people have different opinion about the definition of "open source".
if someone calls a pork sandwich "vegan", that's objectively false. Not the case for the concept of open source because the definition is murky and I refuse to follow some authority's definition of what open source is.
Now you’re instead claiming that the term “open source” was perfectly justified, since the definition is “murky”.
So which is it? Either the term “open source” is fitting, in which case it should not matter if they charge for it or not, or it’s only OK since they don’t charge for it.
A company gave away their app making tool for free, and these people are sitting in front of their keyboard talking shit about how "this is subverting the definition of 'open source'", seriously?
Also what's so evil about the clause:
> "You can not commercialise original or modified (derivative) versions of the Defold editor and/or engine" does not meet (6).
What's so wrong about businesses trying to give back to the community while protecting themselves against the likes of Microsoft and Amazon who will naturally take the code and monetize if there's no clause that restricts anti competition?
Lastly, who the hell cares what some website called opensource.org says what open source is? This is all subjective, and from my point of view, if the source code is open, it is "open" source. There are many reasons people open source their projects, for transparency, for giving assurance to the ecosystem, etc. By trying to box the definition down to a single very narrow minded idea, you're actually hurting the growth of open source instead of helping.