News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by 0d9eooo on Sunday May 17, 2020 @06:41PM (#23216183)
One thing that struck me at an exhibit of Leonardo's notebooks is how totally wrong he was about so many things. It wasn't mentioned in the exhibit but for every one thing he was correct about, it seemed like there were many many, dozens perhaps, that he was completely incorrect about. Some of the ideas seem preposterous now, although it's difficult to view them appropriately as they would have been at the time.

This could be seen positively or negatively. One way of spinning it is that he was persistent in exploring ideas. Another way, though, is that something -- mythmaking, hype, his art, whatever it is -- has allowed history to ignore the fact that he seemed to have been wrong more often than he was right, along the lines of a broken clock being right twice a day.

In either case, I think there's something to be said for some kind of cultural and social context playing a strong role in how all of this is interpreted. A different person in the wrong place or wrong time might have been interpreted as a crackpot.

Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by chongli on Sunday May 17, 2020 @08:17PM (#23216813)
Same goes for Isaac Newton. He’s practically been elevated to godhood for his contributions to calculus and physics. What about his occult studies, alchemy, and chronology [1]? It seems only historians (academic and amateur), Newton buffs, and compulsive Wikipedia clickers know or care about these weird ideas that were so important to Newton.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isaac_Newton%27s_occult_studie...

Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by freyr on Sunday May 17, 2020 @08:53PM (#23217057)
Were these studies inconsistent with a curious mind and the limitations of knowledge at the time? In any research, some avenues of investigation are fruitful and others are not.

When people look back on us 300 years from today, they'll likely find many cases of geniuses working on things that seem naive or misguided in retrospect.

Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by sunstone on Sunday May 17, 2020 @10:14PM (#23217505)
Someone once described genius as taking a shot in the dark and hitting something. In which case, taking more shots does increase your odds.
Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by onemoresoop on Sunday May 17, 2020 @09:05PM (#23217111)
You can say the same thing about the limitations nowaadays. Looking back from the future we’ll have learned a lot of things that we are thinking now will be seen as preposterous when more knowledge is covered.
Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by freyr on Monday May 18, 2020 @05:05PM (#23228370)
That’s exactly what I wrote.
Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by perl4ever on Sunday May 17, 2020 @08:52PM (#23217047)
I don't think this sort of thing is rare, or a reflection of the time period he lived in or his status as an extreme outlier in historical influence.

Many scientists spend a portion of their time in oddball or fruitless pursuits and sometimes it takes them over, particularly as they get older.

Linus Pauling and Vitamin C is one thing that comes to mind.

There was some scientist whose name I can't remember, was asked how he could be occupied by crazy ideas or obsessions and he said that these ideas came to him in exactly the same way as his deep scientific insights.

Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by msandford on Sunday May 17, 2020 @09:59PM (#23217407)
Suggesting that Linus Pauling was wrong about vitamin C is an interesting choice. In my opinion he's looking more and more prescient.

https://nypost.com/2020/03/24/new-york-hospitals-treating-co...

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5996765/

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3937164/

Just because someone looks silly to their contemporaries doesn't mean they're wrong. Look at Semmelweis. He figured out germs well before Pasteur. Doctors didn't accept it because they didn't like the implications: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignaz_Semmelweis

Sagan says it best. https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/85171-one-of-the-saddest-le...

Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by perl4ever on Sunday May 17, 2020 @10:55PM (#23217798)
I wasn't stating that he was "wrong", I was suggesting that regardless of whether you can find any merit to any of his opinions, it was kind of an odd, dubious obsession that people don't uniformly respect unlike other accomplishments he had.
Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by tinalumfoil on Sunday May 17, 2020 @08:42PM (#23216981)
10 successes and 1000 failures is more valuable than 1 success and no failures.
Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by Hokusai on Monday May 18, 2020 @02:48AM (#23219144)
> Same goes for Isaac Newton. He’s practically been elevated to godhood for his contributions to calculus and physics.

The way British write confuses many people. "Newton is the greatest of the greatest", "Shakespeare is the mos prolific writer that ever lived", ""... British writers love hyperbole. The fact that the writing style aligns with national pride helps to create a positive feedback of "grandiose writing".

That does not mean that there is ill intent. The target consumers of the writing are the British readers themselves, and almost all societies have a good self esteem. The fact that globally we communicate in English has tip the balance towards sharing American and British views of the world over the rest and created an over hype of some charismatic national myths.

Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by throwaway_pdp09 on Monday May 18, 2020 @04:01AM (#23219619)
Such excessive writing only occurs amongst very few people, them who feel their job is 'culture'. I've heard far too much of it about shakespeare, and I think it undeserved. He's not that great. Emperor/clothes etc.

I've really not heard anything similar about newton though.

Don't confuse those very few who surf their own hyperbole with the average brit (I'm one).

Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by chongli on Monday May 18, 2020 @10:55AM (#23223094)
There are loads of people who don’t like Shakespeare (possibly due to being forced to read his plays in school) and that’s fine. Everyone is entitled to their opinion of him.

What is much harder to argue against is his influence on the English language. Shakespeare introduced, into everyday use, a monumental staggering number of words, phrases, idioms, metaphors, and ideas. And that’s just the text of his work. His influence on the institution of theatre and its role in the development of actors is equally staggering.

The comparison with Newton (and his influences on mathematics and physics) is apt.

Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by Izkata on Monday May 18, 2020 @08:33PM (#23230031)
> There are loads of people who don’t like Shakespeare (possibly due to being forced to read his plays in school) and that’s fine.

I'm one of them, but after one of my English teachers decided to bring us to see one of his other plays as a treat (Much Ado about Nothing), I can't help but think it's because schools are obsessed with the bad plays. I've never gone out of my way to read/see other plays, but that one was actually entertaining and I think if it was used instead of Romeo and Juliet & etc, less people would dislike Shakespeare.

Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by throwaway_pdp09 on Tuesday May 19, 2020 @04:12AM (#23232507)
Yeah, we did romeo and juliet. We had to pick apart the text to get at it. Shred it, almost. Why, what were we supposed to get from that?

I remember the teacher pointing out the cheap sexual innuendos in there (IIRC 'on the prick of noon' was one). In retrospect I find it hypocritical, she only drew our attention to it because it was shakespeare, and she seemed to laud it because it was shakespeare. In any other contexts she'd have dismissed it, but this was shakespeare! So saddo nob jokes ok.

A few years ago I tried to watch titus andronicus (this one, with Famous Actor https://www.amazon.co.uk/Titus-Blu-ray-Import/dp/B00HGGUO70/). I probably rewound[1] every section of speech at least once, and had the subtitles on, to try to understand. Christ what an effort, and for what.

[1] Thank you VLC for your easy 10 second jumping keys, one of mymost used controls ever.

(but glad MAAN worked for you)

Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by Hokusai on Monday May 18, 2020 @06:06AM (#23220476)
> Don't confuse those very few who surf their own hyperbole with the average brit (I'm one).

I see your point. And, as any generalization, my point does not apply to all British citizens.

But, that grandiose talking is not uncommon (funny thou):

https://www.reddit.com/r/INGLIN/comments/1p76kk/good_to_see_...

Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by david-cako on Sunday May 17, 2020 @11:17PM (#23217954)
Natural philosophy and alchemy were names for science before science. Alchemy had a connotation of being very ceremonial; knowledge had to spread by group gatherings and word of mouth.

Cutting edge science today would have been called alchemy historically. Artificial intelligence, gene editing, etc. Fortunately scientists have a pretty good reputation now, where alchemists of the past had to research and convene in secret.

Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by ColanR on Monday May 18, 2020 @02:33AM (#23219064)
People don't realize, I think, how much modern science owes its tools and methodologies to alchemy.

I like your comparison between alchemy and AI. Even modern neural nets would fit alchemical concepts pretty well - "we flattened a rock, put lightning inside it, and made it speak to us with a human voice!"

Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by ColanR on Sunday May 17, 2020 @07:52PM (#23216675)
I was told by a doctor that in his 1980s biology class, the professor opened by saying, "half of what I'm going to teach you is wrong - we just don't know which half".

I imagine it's similar with Leonardo, and likely with our own state-of-the-art knowledge. We are all broken clocks, and the trick is to figure out which part of our knowledge is wrong.

Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by anticsapp on Sunday May 17, 2020 @08:03PM (#23216739)
They say that about advertising spend too. I think it was David Ogilvy but I'm too lazy to look it up.
Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by m463 on Monday May 18, 2020 @06:47AM (#23220762)
"Half the money I spend on advertising is wasted; the trouble is I don't know which half" - John Wanamaker
Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by onemoresoop on Sunday May 17, 2020 @09:08PM (#23217136)
That is wishful thinking on their part IMO. Saying that half of X is wrong makes X look like half true. It could be false in a much higher proportion
Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by anticsapp on Sunday May 17, 2020 @10:17PM (#23217524)
That's a great point. Never occurred to me.
Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by mercer on Monday May 18, 2020 @03:03AM (#23219222)
That's marketing!
Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by aashiq on Sunday May 17, 2020 @09:36PM (#23217282)
Being right on average isn't that useful for intellectuals. Much harder to be right even once about something important that others are very wrong about. It's easy to be right on average by always following the prevailing consensus.

People like Leonardo and Newton are valuable thinkers because they once in a while produce a really good idea, and it doesn't really matter if they know themselves which ideas are good or bad. This is a really bad trait for a leader or a trader though.

Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by analog31 on Sunday May 17, 2020 @07:45PM (#23216626)
I noticed the same thing in one of Aristotle's books, where he tries to catalog his encyclopedic knowledge of natural phenomena. It might just be a sign of an earlier intellectual era.
Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by kmill on Sunday May 17, 2020 @09:10PM (#23217148)
Is it apt comparing being right about things to a broken clock? Unlike a clock, there's no guarantee that anyone might eventually be right about anything. Sure, a monkey at a typewriter will eventually produce Shakespeare's complete works, but the chance is pretty much negligible.
Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by econcon on Monday May 18, 2020 @01:41AM (#23218773)
He might not actually have discovered or invented everything on his own.

What I most likely think, is that he was more like a Director of a government program or university who's tasked with key projects and allowed to interrogate or gather intelligence from anywhere.

He most likely met a lot of people from both east and west, learned a few things them and decided to document them. Maybe those people also documented it in their own language somewhere but ofc it didn't survive the test of time and only way we know any of those things is through Leonardo's illustrations.

The cities where he lived had influx of traders from all over the world.

It's otherwise seemingly impossible for someone to come up with so many things during his lifetime.

Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by psychomugs on Sunday May 17, 2020 @07:26PM (#23216493)
Of course he was wrong more often than he was right, he was a human being.
Re:The genuine polymath is still one in a million by darkteflon on Sunday May 17, 2020 @07:07PM (#23216373)
You’re saying the issue is more nuanced than it appears at first blush, requiring careful consideration taking into account cultural context then and now?! That’s preposterous, give us your 140 character hot take instead. :)