Re:Why is 70% isopropyl alcohol a better disinfectant than 9...
by beervirus on Saturday May 16, 2020 @04:10PM
(#23206806)
Their table seems reasonable, but the first example they work through is wrong.
>Example 1:
>Suppose a scientist has a bottle of 99% IPA (C1) that they want to dilute down to 70% (C2). To end with 50mL of 70% IPA (V2), how much volume of 99% IPA should they use and dilute with distilled water to create the final solution?
>99% x V1 = 70% x 50mL = 35.35mL
>Thus, adding 35.35mL of distilled water to 14.65mL of 99% IPA creates a 50mL solution of 70% IPA.
(They reversed the water and IPA quantities.)
Re:Why is 70% isopropyl alcohol a better disinfectant than 9...
by Dylan16807 on Sunday May 17, 2020 @12:52AM
(#23209671)
The table's garbage. It's showing the total volume as exactly equal to water volume plus alcohol volume, out to four digits. That's not how it works. A mixture of water and alcohol (whether ethanol or isopropyl) gets more compact because the different molecules can pack together better, by up to a few percent.
Re:Why is 70% isopropyl alcohol a better disinfectant than 9...
by Wistar on Monday May 18, 2020 @11:36AM
(#23223706)
Is it inaccurate enough that it cannot be used to safely create disinfectant-grade 70% dilutions from 99% or 91%?
Re:Why is 70% isopropyl alcohol a better disinfectant than 9...
by beervirus on Monday May 18, 2020 @03:03PM
(#23226945)
If you're measuring things by slopping them into a measuring cup instead of weighing them out to the milligram, you'll never know the difference.
Re:Why is 70% isopropyl alcohol a better disinfectant than 9...
by Dylan16807 on Monday May 18, 2020 @08:09PM
(#23229866)
It won't matter for "eh somewhere between 55% and 75% is fine", but if you have a good measuring cup you could easily see the difference in volume.
I don't know why the chart assumes you're measuring down to thirds of milligrams, though...
Re:Why is 70% isopropyl alcohol a better disinfectant than 9...
by Wistar on Saturday May 16, 2020 @07:38PM
(#23208126)
Good catch!
Re:Why is 70% isopropyl alcohol a better disinfectant than 9...
by azinman2 on Saturday May 16, 2020 @05:28PM
(#23207356)
That didn’t answer my question about what kind of water to use.
Re:Why is 70% isopropyl alcohol a better disinfectant than 9...
by chiph on Saturday May 16, 2020 @05:43PM
(#23207452)
Tap water will be fine. The alcohol you're diluting will disinfect it.
If you want to be ultra-sure, then use distilled. But be aware it's also bought by people who use it for their CPAP machines, so don't go nuts.
Re:Why is 70% isopropyl alcohol a better disinfectant than 9...
by aidenn0 on Saturday May 16, 2020 @07:49PM
(#23208173)
It depends on where you are; my tap water has extremely high mineral (>40 gpg) content, and I could definitely see that interfering with its disinfectant properties (not to mention leaving a residue behind).
https://onsenlabs.com/blogs/blog/isopropyl-alcohol-ipa-aka-i...
Also includes a dilution table for 91%.