News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by sndean on Saturday May 16, 2020 @01:41PM (#23205502)
Early on this interview [0] he says that his grandfather visited Napoleon in Elba (in 1814). It's always sort of mind-blowing how few generations, albeit long-lived ones, are required to reach to a very different era, where there existed this weird short-lived French empire. In this case just 3 or 4 generations are needed?

Another instance is President John Tyler's grand children still being alive [1]. John Tyler was born in 1790 when George Washington was still around, although I doubt he had any contact with Washington.

[0] https://youtu.be/fb3k6tB-Or8?t=129

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Tyler#Family_and_personal...

Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by joe_the_user on Saturday May 16, 2020 @07:03PM (#23207942)
Well, I think it's also telling that now Napoleon's reign could be thought of as "this weird short-lived French empire", because while it short-lived, the Napoleonic empire in many ways set the stage, created the model for the modern world. Certainly, Napoleon was defeated but the forces of France at that time represented a kind of progress, a kind of progress that other nations were only able to defeat by adopting - the mass army at the service of a centralized state implies a kind of democracy and mass participation in life that a feudal system couldn't manage (to name just one of enumerable example). That's why even in defeat, Napoleon represented a fundamental change in the world.
Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by sndean on Saturday May 16, 2020 @07:13PM (#23207996)
Oh yeah, no disrespect to Napoleon or France. I have Andrew Roberts' Napoleon in my reading queue for later during this quarantine. I just meant that it represents a very foreign era relative to now, though maybe I should think of it as the start of the current era based on your comment.
Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by joe_the_user on Sunday May 17, 2020 @12:17AM (#23209520)
Yes,

My point is now the Napoleonic Empire can seem a weird little nook of history. Closer to the era, it cast a much larger shadow but things must pass.

Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by BurningFrog on Saturday May 16, 2020 @08:32PM (#23208367)
Yeah, you can think of the Napoleon Wars as "World War Zero", and Napoleon as the Hitler of his time.

As you can maybe tell, the aspect of modernity where mass wars with millions of dead sweep the world because some dictator wants it, is not my favorite one.

Still, you're not wrong!

Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by dredmorbius on Sunday May 17, 2020 @04:34AM (#23210595)
The Seven Years' War (1756--1763) has been described as the first true world war:

It involved all five European great powers of the time--the Kingdoms of Great Britain, Prussia and France, the Habsburg Monarchy of Austria and the Russian Empire--plus many of Europe's middle powers and spanned five continents, affecting Europe, the Americas, West Africa, India, and the Philippines.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seven_Years%27_War

Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by shadowprofile77 on Sunday May 17, 2020 @09:39AM (#23211891)
It was a global conflict that involved all of Europe's Great Powers, but the 7 Years' War just wasn't exceptionally lethal or even that destructive.

On the other hand, the 30 Years' War was much less global in its geography but absolutely devastated central Europe, and caused at least 8 million deaths, most of them civilian. This makes it 10 times or more deadlier than the 7 Years' War.

The older conflict was also a crucial game changer for world history because it led directly to the Treaty of Westphalia and the entrenchment of the modern, much more formalized nation state.

Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by dredmorbius on Sunday May 17, 2020 @10:08AM (#23212093)
Classifications are endless and arbitrary.

What I'd noted was that the 7YW has been called the first true world war (to my knowledge in Manfred Weissenbacher, in Sources of Power, (2009) https://www.worldcat.org/title/sources-of-power-how-energy-f...), and represents the first time a single conflict and set of belligerents spanned the globe. The argument isn't based on intensity of conflict or consequent significance but areal scope.

Previously, multi-continent conflicts either represented contiguous spillover of generally localised battles (e.g., a few millennia of scrapes between southern & south-eastern Europe and Asia Minor), or what were largely maritime conflicts more properly considered as focused on a body of water, most often the Mediterranean (literally, the middle of the world), positioned between Europa, Asia, and Africa. Notable during Roman times but extending well before and since.

The 7YW represented the first time global force projection, even if weak by subsequent or current standards, was even possible.

Its role in setting up Britain and the English-speaking world for global dominance may well be greater than you're allowing for as well.

Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by shadowprofile77 on Tuesday May 19, 2020 @08:03AM (#23233896)
Very well, in terms of literal global spread of conflict, the 7YW was undeniably closer to being "the first true world war" but I argue that this is secondary to impact and destructiveness if we're measuring these pre-World War candidates for World War. If global involvement is a candidate, why not also include the American Revolutionary War. It too involved multiple belligerent states and conflict scattered across most of the globe.

The 30YW was on the other hand both fantastically destructive even by modern standards and of huge impact to the whole world even up to the present day. True, it was by no means a literally global conflict and couldn't be claimed as one, but the political systems that it led to were also a crucial factor in both the 7YW happening, and the rise of French power which partly made the latter global: The 30 Years' War was one of the factors that led to the ascendant France which later partly forced the English-Prussian alliance in the 7YW.

France could have perhaps only with difficulty have become such a global colonial and dominant European power had the earlier conflict not slowed the formation of centralized authority in the German-speaking states for decades.

The ramifications of Westphalia still reverberate today, the ramifications of the 7YW less so.

Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by Koshkin on Saturday May 16, 2020 @09:06PM (#23208520)
I think Napoleon was more similar to Caesar than to Hitler, and that modern universal sense of disdain towards Hitler is a sign of progress.
Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by shadowprofile77 on Sunday May 17, 2020 @09:24AM (#23211798)
That's not as much of an improvement as you might think... Caesar was absolutely murderous and no stranger to ordering ethnic genocide either.. During the Gallic Wars, his armies butchered off at least a million and a half people, while enslaving a few hundred thousand others, partly for the crude sake of boosting Caesar's political career and paying off his debts. Paving the way for smoother Roman colonization was another benefit of this genocide. These things should remind you much more of Hitler than they do of Napoleon.

Bear in mind also that this was done without modern weapons and killing techniques. Hardly a humane ruler. That Caesar happened to be much more rational and erudite than the German dictator certainly helped his long-term image, but just because 2000+ years of history and some good political observations for posterity blot out the mass murder of civilians doesn't make it any less grotesque.

Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by BurningFrog on Saturday May 16, 2020 @10:35PM (#23209022)
Maybe. The winners write history, and we've always hated those who lose wars.
Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by anaphor on Saturday May 16, 2020 @04:35PM (#23206981)
I think this is one of the most fascinating things about him to me, because he was born in 1872 and lived to 1970, so he went from living in a society where it was still common to travel by horse and buggy to one where we had nuclear energy and easy air travel, etc, and he never lost his sharp mind, so you get to hear the perspective of someone who went through all of that. I highly recommend giving his autobiography a read to anyone interested in his life.
Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by netcan on Saturday May 16, 2020 @05:44PM (#23207461)
You don't need to have been very long lived to see that.

My grandfather was born in 1914. Cars existed, but most people hadn't seen one yet. The Wright brothers' maiden flight was 10 years prior. He went to med school before WW2. Penicillin did not exist yet, not even in labs!

In the 50s (his 40s), he traveled commercially on a 747...

1950s futurism predicting flying cars and moon cities by 2000... they weren't being as silly as we tend to think. They saw planes go from nonexistent sputnik within half a lifetime. The projection was linear.

Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by jdkee on Saturday May 16, 2020 @07:10PM (#23207979)
Probably a 707. First flight of the 747 was in 1969.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_747

Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by netcan on Sunday May 17, 2020 @09:19AM (#23211776)
My mistake.
Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by ianai on Saturday May 16, 2020 @06:00PM (#23207573)
The futurism probably could have stayed true if the political impetus had stayed toward space development instead of Cold War and oil concerns. But planting the US flag on the moon and probably other factors I don’t realize made the Soviets being on the moon less of a reality.

Edit-really wish we had O'Neill cylinders though.

Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by Amezarak on Saturday May 16, 2020 @07:23PM (#23208053)
There's no guarantee that the futurism would have come true for the simple fact it doesn't seem likely that flying cars and moon cities are technically or economically feasible.

There seems to be an unspoken assumption behind a lot of techno-futurism that everything we've dreamed up - flying cars, space colonies, starships - are possible simply because we dreamed them up, that everything we can imagine is possible.

In reality, they may not be physically possible, or if possible, not desirable, or if desirable, not economically feasible. At any rate, the point is probably moot: the damage our obsession with technology and consumption has already caused is probably irreparable, and more techno-futurist dreams coming would have just accelerated it. We have been completely blind to the second-order effects of our industrial and technological development; climate change is only the tip of the iceberg.

Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by netcan on Sunday May 17, 2020 @07:28AM (#23211249)
I disagree, kinda.

There are lots of possible reasons for progress, or lack thereof. Political will is the easy answer, but it's not always true... or the biggest factor.

Space programs did get a ton of funding for the few short years of the moon race. Unsustainable funding really, given the gdp in 1965. But... they were still funded. NASA's budget is currently 2/3 of what it was in the 60s in constant dollars.

Maybe they hit a plateau with the tech. Maybe it was the lack of Russian competition. Maybe it was the lack of a massive goal. Maybe organisations age, and get less creative over time. Maybe in the 60s NASA just hit a genius groove that happens occasionally but can't be sustained forever.

Re:A Conversation with Bertrand Russell (1952) [video] by dddbbb on Sunday May 17, 2020 @05:13AM (#23210741)
The oldest person in the world was born in 1903, before George Orwell, Frida Kahlo and Lyndon Johnson. It's genuinely hard to fathom.