I mean, sure, if i take that code and run it through a debugger - perhaps while also crossreferencing the features it uses at cppreference.com - then i'd be able to follow it. However at that point any relevance to readability would have been thrown out of the window long ago.
For me, this whole spread/fold feature is easy to grok, because I've worked with many similar features elsewhere. In this case, the feature looks almost identical to how `...` is handled in one of the Scheme macro systems, syntax-case (and syntax-rules, by extension)[1]. As mentioned, the use of spread on a comma operator with a side-effect is tricky and maybe too clever, but, otherwise, I don't see anything out of ordinary.
> perhaps while also crossreferencing the features it uses at cppreference.com
That's the thing - if you already knew the meaning and syntax of these features by heart, you'd find the code using them very readable. You also wouldn't need to step through it in the debugger, because there's really not much happening there in terms of control flow.
In general, "readability" is simply a bad word to use: it's too overloaded and means too many things to too many (kinds of) people. Every language can become readable to you if you put enough effort into it; and no, the amount of effort needed is also dependent more on your prior knowledge than on the language in question. So it's just too subjective to be useful as a metric for anything, unfortunately.
[1] https://docs.racket-lang.org/reference/stx-patterns.html#%28...
Yeah, but the effect of this is greatly overstated most of the time. As I said, given enough effort, you can learn - and learn to keep in your head - anything. It matters in the short term, while you're learning, but in the long run, once you've learned and internalized all the required information, it stops being relevant.
It's probably harder to learn to read and write kanji instead of the Latin alphabet. For most people, that difference matters for a few years in their childhood, but once they have the characters drilled into them, it no longer matters: they can read and write as well as any Westerner.
The same is true for (natural) languages: some are inherently more complex and hard to learn than others, yet once you become fluent, you stop noticing the complexity. You simply speak, read, and write your thoughts directly, without thinking about grammar and spelling too much.
It's also visible in sciences and engineering. Mathematical notation is especially notorious: not only every symbol can have multiple meanings, but you're expected to also guess which meaning was intended from other symbols and text around. That's on top of introducing hundreds of made-up words for equally made-up concepts, like a "number", or "monoid in the category of endofunctors".
Finally, it manifests in programming and programming languages. In various ways. For example, there are some people who use APL, K, or J - because it's "easier to read and keep in your head a single line of APL than a 500 loc of equivalent C". If given a chance, they will tell you that something like this is of course very readable and straightforward:
⍝ John Conway's "Game of Life".
life←{↑1 ⍵∨.∧3 4=+/,¯1 0 1∘.⊖¯1 0 1∘.⌽⊂⍵}
You just need to learn a few things first, and that may be hard, but once you do - I'm told - reading and writing code this way becomes effortless, and a thousand times more efficient than writing in C.Basically, if you're going to be switching languages every year, then yes, there's a difference between having to learn the language for a month rather than six before you can ship something. On the other hand, if you're going to stick with a language for a decade or two, then the long learning process becomes irrelevant, as it's dwarfed by the rest of the time where you actually use the language.
> it still is hard to follow the flow
It may be hard if you're not familiar with the common patterns of using higher-order functions. HOF and lambdas are not GOTO: there's a structure there, it's just richer than the basic set of if/for/while statements. You could call such a structure an FP equivalent of OOP design patterns.
> calls to other functions call back to local lambdas
Yeah, but that's also true for every abstraction, starting with a procedure definition. Also, you don't need lambdas to have this problem, it's enough to register procedure as a signal handler, or register an event handler in some async framework. When you pass a comparator function to `qsort`, you similarly don't know when and how that function will be called, even though it's a named procedure.
To summarize: no matter the language, you can learn it, you can fit all of it in your head, and you can make it readable for you. It requires effort, which is an investment: it might not be worth your while, depending on your circumstances. However, if you encounter a code you don't understand or have trouble with reading, because you didn't invest enough time into learning the language, that's not the code's (or features') fault. Just be honest with yourself and don't blame others for what is a result of your conscious decision.
Also of note: yes, the features often do differ in their complexity, and the differences influence the readability (for lack of a better word). However, to see this and to be able to compare, you have to first learn the features in-depth.
Edit: also the default comma operator discards its lhs, it is pretty much always used for its side effects.
[1] https://github.com/milessabin/shapeless/wiki/Feature-overvie...
var person = new Person();
var car = selectCarById(carId); // Car
if type is not obvious, it should be explicitly declared.`doSomethingToACar(selectCarById(carId));`
Kind of weakens the argument. I'm not sure what's the best approach, but I'm usually ok with autos even when the type is not explicitly known - when reading code, I do not really need to know what exact type a variable has ("it's a car, goddamnit, it says so in the name!"), just how it's used (and then meaningful function names become very important).
for(auto iter = vec.begin(); iter!=vec.end(); iter++)
for(std::vector<project_namespace::class_name>::iterator iter = vec.begin(); iter!=vec.end(); iter++) for (auto i : vec)Especially when that "auto i : vec" should have instead been "auto& i : vec" or "const auto& i : vec" and now you are at best wasting cycles and at worst writing to copies that will soon be discarded, ending up with a bug that can be very hard to spot.
Generation of a single solution: 3 easy lines (calling on a few hundred lines of goofy math that actually describes the structure, but that's common to all of these approaches)
Writing a for-loop to fill a std::vector of solutions -- about 10 lines of a familiar stack-walking pattern which could confuse a novice.
Making a fake container that defines a begin() and end() along with a nested iterator class: about 20 lines of necessary boilerplate, another 20 lines to replicate the stack-walking, now sprinkled about the boilerplate. The novice is completely bewildered, so we add another 10-20 lines of comments to explain it.
So I have this strong urge to keep the first two implementations in place, just to provide a gentler ramp. But I won't use the code in the end, so it would only add maintenance overhead, so a lone tear rolls down my cheek as I delete the clear, readable code.
In python, this is often as easy as changing square brackets to parentheses to change a list comprehension into a generator.
for(Class entry : container)
This is still an uncontroversial improvement over having to typedef or use auto for the iterator.The debate is about all the other cases.
I know i do not use any of the languages you mention, for example - and if i did, i'd explicitly write any type names.
How do you reconcile that world view with the fact that people are shipping billions of line of codes that obviously work in languages where until recently you couldn't even write any type anywhere (JS, Python) ?
But honestly i can only talk about me here, i can't guess why some imaginary other developer who dislikes a feature does dislike it.
For others, it was worrisome because it made code easier to compile, and rightly so. If it complies it doesn't mean it's correct.
I already wrote that there are some cases where auto is necessary (usually when used with more recent C++ features).
> especially if an IDE is there to expand complex type information
And i also already wrote that this information is not only often cumbersome to obtain but also such an IDE is often not available - e.g. in a web-based code review tool which also happens to be an environment where you want the code to be most understandable.
This usually means types that are from inside the scope of another class. Compound types that are used frequently can actually be aliased.
Also writing programs that are clear when reading from plain text is great, but I don't think that should ever be a higher priority then what it is like to work with inside an IDE. The days of writing programs with notepad are over thankfully. Languages aren't the only way to make programming easier and aren't even where the low hanging fruit is. People get caught up in languages, but tools can help much more without the herculean effort of redoing decades of work, so I lean on them whenever possible.
However, about IDEs, you still ignore that code is not only worked with inside IDEs - i already wrote twice the case of a code review tool... have you ever worked on a team with code reviews done by a web-based tool? Or even with a source control program that you want to check the differences between commits that someone else made long ago (they may not even be at the company anymore) and the diff tool obviously has no idea about types and such?
There are many reasons for why you need to work with code outside of an IDE and none of them have to do with using Notepad to write the code.
Now not all features are bad, lambdas are OK when used as local functions and can make the code more readable if the alternative is to define some static function outside the current method (e.g. you want to pass some custom filter or comparator). They can certainly be abused though, but it is one of those cases where their usefulness is greater than their abuses (and i can't say the same for "auto").
For the example given... it might be a bad example, but honestly i was looking at that code for a bit and i simply cannot read it - i do not understand what is going on just by reading the code, i'd need to run it in a debugger and go through it step by step (and i've actually written texture atlas packers before). It completely fails to sell me on the "fold expressions" and "parameter packs" and it certainly doesn't look at all "elegant" to me (but note that it might be that the example is awful, not the language feature itself).
And it did make me skim through the rest of the article though since after completely failing me on all fronts at the introduction bits, i couldn't get the feel that i have any common grounds with the author.