News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by vivekd on Friday May 15, 2020 @07:57PM (#23198960)
Yes, this was the opinion I came here to post, certainly my own profession of law is like this, at least where I practice in Toronto Canada but I can't imagine other places being much different.

I think one advantage of computers is that what you produce at the end has to work - and if the code doesn't work or you don't know what you're doing, you're quickly exposed as a fraud. This is not the case in other fields like law, academia, politics, and even the corporate world where the results and methods are more abstract and given to opinion.

Unfortunately much of the world is run by people who excel in the abstract fields rather than the technical ones.

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by op03 on Saturday May 16, 2020 @01:12AM (#23200676)
You make a very good point, but I'd like you to believe its not unfortunate.

Most people I know would happily sign a document that states 'We hold these truths to be self evident that all men are created equal', even though the world shows us every single day that it isn't true.

In technical fields, getting that document approved would be a nightmare.

Maxwell's equations on the other hand are easy to get approval for. They are 'self evident'. Because they describe what we see, not what we want to see.

So thank god for Jefferson penning that line down and effecting how everyone thinks, because it shows us for some problems, the ambiguous kind, were truth is what we want it to be, technical fields will struggle to provide answers.

Its very fortunate, esp to make progress on all the ambiguous problems, that society props up a Jefferson now and then.

How did Jefferson get into that position and not some jackass, is the most important question. And the answer to that, with a modern developing understanding of networks and graph theory, has only recently started moving from the abstract and ambiguous to the more technical - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=07KKYostAJ0

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by giantDinosaur on Friday May 15, 2020 @08:50PM (#23199353)
I don't think it's true that computers are great at exposing this. Software ranges from the concrete (does this button do anything) to the abstract (does this statistical program have an off by one error that's invisible to customers other than returning somewhat wrong results?). I think there's two competing definitions of 'work' in software - 'it works' as in 'allows for use' which can compete with the 'implements properly'. Computers and code will brutally expose the former, since it simply will not allow you to do something if it's broken. They don't necessarily expose the latter.
Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by karmelapple on Friday May 15, 2020 @09:31PM (#23199606)
If the software should let me do X, I can click around and confirm that I can do X. I think most people would consider that the definition of “works,” rather than the quality of the code, the validation that the proper thing was built, etc.

Looking at the code can tell you whether it was “implemented properly” - or at least, if it was done reasonably competently.

Relationships, though, can help you know if that properly implemented code was likely a fluke or not. Does the person ask questions? How do they ask questions? How do they communicate? How do they capture requirements? How do they push back when something seems unclear or unwise? etc.

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by hn_throwaway_99 on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:46PM (#23200333)
I don't buy your arguments - at all. At the end of the day people have strong expectation about what software should do. If it doesn't do that, they will quickly notice. If they don't notice (now or in the future) things like your "off by one" errors, then that requirement wasn't likely that important to begin with.

Now, I've seen plenty of "demo-ware" software that has been presented as something that was much more than it actually was, but again, stuff like that always falls over, riddled with bugs and crumbling under load, when it gets substantial use.

Some things you really can't fake, and software engineering is one of them.

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by tangjurine on Saturday May 16, 2020 @04:48AM (#23201657)
Let's say you have a for loop that is supposed to run once, but some "programmer" calls it a hundred times. The program still works, but it's a lot slower.

Input lag on devices has doubled or tripled from the 1980s while clock speeds have increased drastically. Reddit and Hackernews do essentially the same task, yet Hackernews' load times are almost instant while Reddit takes more than a second to load at times.

It's true that you can't fake a minimum viable product, but it seems to me there is a long way from that to actually making something good.

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by WrtCdEvrydy on Saturday May 16, 2020 @05:43AM (#23201991)
We've outsourced the cost of development from the developer to the user.

Noone wants to write low level code because learning it costs money, so instead we just throw more hardware at the problem until it goes away...

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by toomuchtodo on Saturday May 16, 2020 @10:05AM (#23203460)
Sort of. Would a user use all of that compute if it all wasn’t wasted? Probably not. What we’ve done is “inflate away” (similar to fiat and central bank policy) the need for additional human developer time through Moore’s law. We all pay for this through annual tech spend, which keeps the advancement treadmill running.

Human time is expensive, so it makes sense to throw anything cheaper at the problem first.

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by giantDinosaur on Saturday May 16, 2020 @12:07AM (#23200415)
Perhaps we have different conceptions of 'fraudulent'. I don't think it necessarily implies 'fake', but something more along the lines of using inferior building material. Perhaps it 'wasn't important all along' or perhaps it'll lead to catastrophic failure in 25 years, who knows? Software 'engineering' may be hard to fake, but that's because you're probably defining it as the proper way to develop software. A lot of software is certainly not built in a way familiar to an engineer.
Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by akiselev on Saturday May 16, 2020 @01:41AM (#23200784)
Building materials are judge based on the standard of "survives for at least three decades without crushing those inside" not "survives the next reorg or pivot." What would be the equivalent of inferior building materials failing over 25 year timescales in software? C isn't even twice that age and the oldest running mainframe software is probably only a little older whereas we've had millenia of experience constructing buildings.
Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by dba7dba on Friday May 15, 2020 @08:57PM (#23199390)
I know friend of friend who went to Harvard Law like 15 years ago and she told me there is SO MUCH butt kissing going on there.

You'd think people who got that far would be confident enough to rely on their own skills/study to get ahead BUT even at that level, there is a lot of butt kissing to get ahead.

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by throwphoton on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:40PM (#23200314)
It's the correct asses though.
Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by tangjurine on Saturday May 16, 2020 @04:50AM (#23201667)
Is choosing the correct butt to kiss NP-Complete?
Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by KittenInABox on Friday May 15, 2020 @08:27PM (#23199155)
> I think one advantage of computers is that what you produce at the end has to work - and if the code doesn't work or you don't know what you're doing, you're quickly exposed as a fraud.

Is this actually true? You can bullshit coding...

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by oneplane on Friday May 15, 2020 @08:39PM (#23199266)
Take the old guestbook example: if you can't add entries to the guestbook the code apparently doesn't work. No way around that.
Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by heavenlyblue on Saturday May 16, 2020 @05:33AM (#23201928)
Also we can take this idea even further: what if only 1% of the entries in the guestbook don’t show? Does the code work? What if it’s so badly written it take someone with a really good experience to be able to prove that bug exists at all?

How do you go about proving this? In the real world people are going to dismiss it. If you are playing against a politician you will be told that you simply have a bad memory thinking that some things exist that really don’t.

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by heavenlyblue on Saturday May 16, 2020 @05:31AM (#23201912)
If you are a lawyer and can’t write you probably wouldn’t be able to sell yourself as a lawyer. However being able to write doesn’t make you a lawyer.

Same with the guestbook. It may even work. But on the inside it’s a pile of unmaintainable crap.

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by earthboundkid on Friday May 15, 2020 @10:12PM (#23199872)
Subcontract it to someone who writes it with security holes.
Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by didibus on Friday May 15, 2020 @09:24PM (#23199564)
This is one reason I believe computer science should be thought in school just like mathematics. The experience is very humbling, you've got all this logic, all the rationale, to you, it must work, but the computer knows it doesn't make any sense.

I've learned that most problems are easily dismissed by people as being "easy", "simple", just do this, just do that. I've found software forces you to really think through, "just do this" is easier said then done, how to do it?

Real problem solving is hard, and I do think computer science humbles you in that sense.

Here's an example, my friend always tells me he thinks we shouldn't take anymore refugees. Alright, I'm not even going to debate the the morals or anything like that. He just think, whoever is letting the refugees in is dumb and shouldn't do that. That's surface level thinking to me. How do you do that? There's a boat arriving to the shore, full of refugees, it's not turning around? What do you do?

This is a hard problem, no matter what you think you want the features or use case to be, how do you do it? The logistics are difficult, how do you scale it? What about all the edge cases? What about the cost?

In that sense I think CS can help you learn how to really think through a problem from understanding the full implications and complexities and the challenges. We learn this by trying to model problems and their solutions very formally.

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by tasogare on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:02PM (#23200111)
> Here's an example, my friend always tells me he thinks we shouldn't take anymore refugees. [...] That's surface level thinking to me. How do you do that? [...] What do you do?

It’s funny you take this example because your point of view is precisely surface thinking too. I bet you don’t have any concrete plan to fund housing, education, healthcare for those people, nor you have one for them to become productive members of the host society. They are dozens of factors that makes irrational to allow any of them, and a lot of countries (Australia, Japan for instance) have in fact a successful policy of allowing only a bunch of them.

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by didibus on Saturday May 16, 2020 @01:47PM (#23205558)
You're misquoting me. The surface level thinking refers to this segment: "He just think, whoever is letting the refugees in is dumb and shouldn't do that".

When people are coming to your border in large trove, not letting them in is easier said then done. You can't just "not let them in". To keep my analogy going, this requires an algorithm of some sort. First you need to find something that works, and then you need to take into account cost consideration, scaling, etc.

Your example would work as well. Someone who were to say, whoever is stopping them from coming in is stupid. This would also be surface level. What do you do with them once they're in? Housing, education, integration? Does our system have the capacity to handle such load or will it collapse? Just letting them in may not be enough, it could cause problems down the line, what are we doing to prevent those.

The right conclusion to take from my comment is that problem solving is hard, there's a lot of variable at play, a lot of considerations to take in, and it is never as easy as you assume at first. Recognizing this is part of being humble, and I think computer science teaches you that.

Thinking you have the answers because you thought about it for 5 minutes and not realizing you skimmed and hand waved over all the direct and indirect complexities and considerations and are skipping multiple steps of the solution. Thinking that there is an easy solution and then advocating for it strongly when you haven't begone to recognize and understand the complexity of the problem itself. This to me is an indication of a lack of some form of critical thinking. I think computer science can to some extent teach people better about this, by having them practice concrete problem solving exercise on a computer which can assess to the solution working or not. And learning formal problem modeling techniques and validation strategies. It's a useful skill.

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by arczyx on Saturday May 16, 2020 @01:15AM (#23200694)
>It’s funny you take this example because your point of view is precisely surface thinking too

But they're not...? GP didn't say he want to take refugees in, they merely said their friend want refuse refugees without specifying how exactly they want to accomplish that.

>I bet you don’t have any concrete plan to fund housing, education...

I don't think this assumption is fair.

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by reedwolf on Saturday May 16, 2020 @04:39AM (#23201603)
>and a lot of countries (Australia, Japan for instance) have in fact a successful policy of allowing only a bunch of them

I don't know about Japan, but Australia allows in large numbers of immigrants.

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by devdas on Saturday May 16, 2020 @05:28PM (#23207355)
Immigrants are not refugees.
Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by reedwolf on Sunday May 17, 2020 @06:14PM (#23215984)
Australia took in many refugees from the war in Sudan.
Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by FpUser on Friday May 15, 2020 @08:46PM (#23199326)
> I think one advantage of computers is that what you produce at the end has to work - and if the code doesn't work or you don't know what you're doing, you're quickly exposed as a fraud.

This is very naive point of view. Think of how car repair shops bullshit customers (especially what was before some mitigating laws) and then multiply it by Pi or more

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by heavenlyblue on Saturday May 16, 2020 @05:38AM (#23201960)
This goes so well against the “free market hypothesis”.

There are industries where lying is simply a stable equilibrium.

You need law to keep those businesses going and fair. Otherwise the lemons spoil it for everyone.

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by hkai on Sunday May 17, 2020 @07:35AM (#23211281)
You are correct, although I personally know two programmers who are not able to write basic JavaScript code and have survived for almost a year in their jobs by asking around, copying other people's code and asking for help ("I did this, but somehow it doesn't work!").

I don't know how to raise this issue at work without being insensitive.

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by mettamage on Saturday May 16, 2020 @01:19AM (#23200708)
> I think one advantage of computers is that what you produce at the end has to work

No that's not true, that something works is beginner level stuff in many cases. In some cases you're right though, because what has been asked is a super tough problem to crack.

I'll showcase the moments in which the "it has to work" requirement is not enough.

To show this example, I already have to break 2 conventions that are a no no, in my opinion. To other devs: I'm commenting everything (I can't assume someone who works in law to know code, he/she might, he/she might not) and I'm using globals for easier variable reassignment, to ease the example for readability.

Let's get started. The requirement: print 5 to the console of your browser [1].

Open up Chrome Dev Tools (view -> developer -> developer tools -> console)

Type in the following:

  five = 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 //compute 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 and save it in the computer with the name five
  console.log(five) //outputs 5

  five = 0 //reset

  // loop 5 times, and every time the pc adds 1 to the saved part of the computer named five
  for (loopCount = 0; loopCount < 5; loopCount = loopCount + 1) {
    five = five + 1
  }
  console.log(five)

  five = 5 //save the number 5 in the computer with the name five
  console.log(five) //outputs 5

  console.log(5) //also outputs 5

  FIVE = 5 //all-caps is a convention for that something is a constant, like a constant number such as 5

  console.log(FIVE) //outputs 5 as well, and also probably the way programmers want to see it.
Some of these methods have been really silly and if you catch that during an interview, you won't pass. People can point out that most of these methods happen one way or another, but not when you have a simple requirement such as "output 5". In fact, if that truly is the requirement, then I would go for:

  console.log(5)
And I'd consider the first 2 entries totally nonsensical (unless I asked it with a funny voice or asked them to do whatever / be creative), the 4th entry slightly questionable but fine and the 5th entry fine.

[1] Read the following link to have some context about what the JavaScript console is. Don't worry about not understanding the code or the technical terms. You're not missing anything, as far as context is concerned, I checked. Read it until the first paragraph of "Running JavaScript".

https://developers.google.com/web/tools/chrome-devtools/cons...

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by makapuf on Saturday May 16, 2020 @03:20AM (#23201176)
A question: is really fifth the best ? Seeing FIVE=5 always irks me, as it's an extra indirection for nothing. What do I gain with it ? The ability to change it to FIVE=6 ? OUTPUT=5 maybe but then console.log(OUTPUT) gains you nothing. Maybe NB_LEGS=5 and console.log(NB_LEGS)
Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by mettamage on Saturday May 16, 2020 @04:08AM (#23201409)
This is why I put the word probably in the comment and why I stated that for this particular requirement I actually don't think this is the best approach.

You can always screw around with code, redefining code blocks in C would be fun to do.

But I did have situations where FIVE = 5 changed to FIVE = "five" or FIVE = "5" or FIVE = "vijf" (Dutch) or FIVE = "....." (ok, the last one is hypothetical, but maybe you want five points because you tick them off in a for-loop? I've seen something clever-ish like that in a particular fun Fizz Buzz example).

The layer indirection is indeed a classical trade-off that you do or do not want to make.

Regardless of that, your question proves the point I want to make to kbos87.

Re:So much of academia is about connections and reputation l... by makapuf on Saturday May 16, 2020 @05:48AM (#23202020)
Just continuing the discussion, I fully agree with you on principle. I stand by the fact that FIVE is not really a good constant. You will not change five unless you also change the code to handle it, so it just adds another part to modify. And if you never intend to change it or reuse it.. well the only point for making its symbol is to give it meaning, which FIVE does not. But well at a point it's like discussing colours.