News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by Cyph0n on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:36AM (#23193392)
> Gardening, home improvements

Not if you’re living in an apartment.

> personal or side development projects

I write enough code at work, thanks.

> online courses, playing music

Sure, those are good options.

> the utter stagnation that is television and video games

The fact that you decided to lump watching television (passive) with playing video games (active, engaging, sometimes social) tells me that you have no idea what you’re talking about.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by josefresco on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:30AM (#23193315)
> Gardening, home improvements, personal or side development projects, exercise, online courses, playing music, etc.

I've done all those things AND have spent more time gaming than ever before (well at least since college). Don't hobby shame, celebrate your differences and support those who have unique interests.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by ssully on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:41AM (#23193465)
I have a group of four friends and we have a video game night twice a week. Outside of my wife, it's probably the only social contact I have now that feels "normal".
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by C1sc0cat on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:48AM (#23193561)
Like wise for Roleplaying (TTRPG) - for my groups its a way to keep in touch and have human contact.

I have three game sessions for the upcoming week and we are supposed to be starting Startrek at half term.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by ryneandal on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:32AM (#23193348)
This is a tired and archaic take.
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by rosseloh on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:51AM (#23193599)
Makes you wonder what their response would be when I bring up that one of the more common games I play is Stormworks, where I spend most of my time in the engineering screen figuring out how to build fuel control and PID systems to run jet engines properly. Not quite to realistic levels, sure (it's one of my gripes about the game). But it's not on the level of mindless shooters by any means (which I also occasionally enjoy).
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by ryneandal on Friday May 15, 2020 @12:57PM (#23194413)
Even "mindless shooters" have a tangible benefit to cognitive and social function -- https://www.avondwenm.nl/images/avonden/avond-2019/studiemat...

The benefits of implementing play are vast and are emphasized in evolutionary psychology. Video games are just one means to leverage play.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by smabie on Saturday May 16, 2020 @12:38AM (#23200526)
Games like CS:GO, Valorant, and Overwatch are far from mindless. In fact, they take so much brain power that I have trouble even speaking when playing. But if you mean single player shooters, then yeah, I kind of agree.
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by rosseloh on Tuesday May 19, 2020 @10:44AM (#23235401)
Trust me, I'm on your side. When I say mindless I'm just talking about the classic corridor shooter (which, again, I also can enjoy sometimes).
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by otachack on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:33AM (#23193362)
It's not total stagnation. Sometimes you need to lay back and play some mindless game. Other times it's fun to team up with friends/coworkers and play a co-op game. Or maybe you just want to play some visual novel, which can be on par with reading a book.

I definitely would love to put my focus more on something harder like a side project or blog but it can almost feel like a side job at times. I'm trying to tackle those projects by just chipping away at them. Latest has been a blog. I started with Hugo, didn't like the templates, then went for a straight HTML approach to do it bare bones. I'm starting to get ideas of just making my own personal Markdown parser since I start seeing patterns in my HTML that can be generated. I think this way will be more fun!

To each their own.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by watwut on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:16PM (#23194676)
This comment being downvote is incredibly odd. Yes, I can confirm that there are plenty of activities programmer can do at home that are not gaming.

Preferring gaming is one thing, getting offended over suggestion it is actually possible to be happy at home without gaming is ... odd.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by seattle_spring on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:25PM (#23194774)
It's obviously (and rightly) being downvoted because of how condescending it is to people who choose to spend any amount of their time with video games.
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by detaro on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:20PM (#23194729)
Except the comment didn't just suggest alternatives, so don't pretend that's what it was downvoted for.
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by Grimm1 on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:28AM (#23193286)
Your thinking is so antiquated name me a good novel and I'll give a video game that matches it in narrative content. And playing music and gardening? Please.
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by billfruit on Friday May 15, 2020 @12:26PM (#23194007)
While I don't agree with any attempt to see games as lower form of culture, I don't think that story telling/ narrative is something that games do well.

I personally find narratives in games actually detract from the experience, and many games are better from having no or only minimal story built into it, and more like being sandboxes:

-Cities: Skylines

-Just Cause 2

-Prison Architect

-Kerbal Space Program

-Pool Nation

-Blood Bowl

-Hexcells

-Sins of a Solar Empire

-Elite: Dangerous

-Dungeons of the Endless

-Rocket League

-Sonic Allstars Racing

Literature has immensely more complex narratives than it is likely possible for films and games can hope to achieve. But to be able to provide interactive sandboxes with unlimited possibilities is perhaps one that only games can provide.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by Grimm1 on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:10PM (#23194599)
I can offer some counters to that off the bat,

Nier Automata, Deus Ex, Destiny, The Witcher, Stanley Parable, Undertale

If anything I think games with the right attention can have better narratives than literature because they aren't limited to words in assisting the narrative with visualization and depiction of events / emotion.

Much like pulp fiction and early sci-fi were treated as second class literature games range the spectrum as well. I think we can likely both continue to find examples to fit our points and it just shows the range games have as a medium.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by billfruit on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:58PM (#23195202)
That literature does not use visual images is its advantage: it isn't contstrained or restricted to a single visual realisation; every on who reads it's reconstructs in their own unique manner, also same reader may imagine it in a different manner at a different time. Also that mental image is out of the bounds of normal space and time; such freedom is what makes it special in that regard.

Take witcher for example, the games offers a single model of Geralt of Rivia, while someone reading the Witcher novel is free to construct their own model, their own landscape,..etc.

My point is that narratives are not a strong point of games, rather it might even be a weak point; they are not what makes games unique or different from other forms of culture. The more games move away from a narrative structure, the more unique and compelling experiences they are able to offer, is my view of the matter.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by hnick on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:04PM (#23200122)
Is the best literature then a blank page?

Or maybe I should edit to sound less dismissive because that wasn't my intent.

How little can you say and how much work should the reader/viewer/player have to do before we stop really considering it a narrative? And if those gaps exist, couldn't we argue they aren't really part of the narrative? Unless, of course, the gaps are intentional but I'd argue as one example that vague character descriptions are a lack of fidelity in written language rather than intentional.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by Cyph0n on Friday May 15, 2020 @02:26PM (#23195568)
Do you also think narrative is a weak point of movies and TV? Everything is constructed (filmed) for the viewer there, too.

I also enjoy the visualization and imagination involved with reading books, but if you are limiting the definition of "narrative" to how much visualization is involved, then I don't think it makes sense to directly compare books to movies and games.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by billfruit on Friday May 15, 2020 @03:33PM (#23196389)
Yes I do believe movies and TV offer lesser narrative scope than literature. When you read you get your own visualisation, when you watch a movie/tv series you get somebody else's and often simplified visualisation/construction.
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by scollet on Friday May 15, 2020 @05:00PM (#23197337)
If you get the chance (it is exclusive), I consider Bloodborne to be a contender for narrative excellence in games.

There is complete mechanical proof of the player's knowledge and understanding of the narrative and there is no wrong way to play. You simply get a different interpretation of the story depending on how curious you are and how closely you examine the textual evidence they elude to.

The storytelling can seem obtuse. I argue it works in support of the world design. You are the narrator.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by hnick on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:03PM (#23200117)
The Souls series in general. I'd argue the world is the main character, but you have to pay attention to learn about it. And no matter how hard you try there will be gaps and conjecture.
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by Grimm1 on Friday May 15, 2020 @02:14PM (#23195423)
I got your point, I disagree and continue to.
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by watwut on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:19PM (#23194718)
From those I played Deus Ex (I decided to not play games anymore) and narrative in that rather average ordinary scifi book with rather normal storyline. I am not saying bad book, but it is not some kind of narrative masterpiece.
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by Grimm1 on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:27PM (#23194793)
I can only speak to the reboot, and I found those fantastic, but we are now in the realm of opinion which ultimately is where the conversation is going to wind up anyway so I'm not going to push back on it just that we had different experiences.
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by hnick on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:01PM (#23200108)
I think the important distinction is games that have a story in them, compared with those that use the medium to tell the story in a way that other mediums cannot.

I can't attest to Destiny and my memory of Deus Ex is hazy but all the other games you listed are firmly in the second category.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by burntoutfire on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:38AM (#23193416)
> our thinking is so antiquated name me a good novel and I'll give a video game that matches it in narrative content.

"Brothers Karamazow"?

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by Grimm1 on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:47AM (#23193540)
Nier Automata
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by burntoutfire on Saturday May 16, 2020 @02:51AM (#23201061)
Can you elaborate how the themes in this game map onto themes in Brothers Karamazov? I tried doing that myself, based on plot synopsis in Wikipedia, but was not able to.

Not to mention that just equivalence of narrative content does not mean anything in terms of work of art's quality - i.e. one could write the most wretched version of Brothers Karamazov, with technically the same content, but just no substance... The true value of work of art reveals itself in how deep it is - i.e. how much it can deliver to its reader (in terms of richness of characters, jumping points for philosophical thought etc.). BK were studied for over a century now, with countless articles and PhD theses from different angles written about it - a true testament to its richness. One can wonder how deeply "Nier Automata" will be studied.

[dead]
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by Grimm1 on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:14PM (#23194642)
'Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something.'
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by sebiche on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:13PM (#23194640)
Wii Sports
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by Grimm1 on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:19PM (#23194706)
I actually love this comment, because personally, Dostoevsky doesn't rank very highly in terms of literature for me.

Maybe because I feel like his examination of human nature or the bleak reality of things feels less impactful now that its such a common thing to write about. I can recognize his historical importance but in modernity his work I believe falls behind.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by scollet on Friday May 15, 2020 @04:44PM (#23197170)
I just live for the drama of not using the Wii-mote wrist strap while bowling.
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by fctorial on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:59AM (#23193695)
Lisa the painful
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by justwalt on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:35AM (#23193389)
Gardening and playing music are both timeless activities, what do you mean? Kind of unfair to jump down the throat of someone who’s only offering friendly advice.
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by Grimm1 on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:40AM (#23193441)
Both are equivalent leisure time activities that I would never say improve your life as the OP claimed. They improve your life in so much the same way games do, leisure, so their comment is purely "I don't like them so they can't be good" which is complete crap.
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by karatestomp on Friday May 15, 2020 @12:57PM (#23194406)
I do think, say, acquiring the skill to play piano or guitar tolerably well gains one more general social standing (not just with a subset of gamers) than "I'm fairly good at Rocket League" and also builds a better understanding of music generally, which can be useful and/or pleasant, and gardening produces good food and also carries more social benefits than "I caught all the Pokemon".

I'd agree they're not wildly better. Though if I put as much time into one of those activities as I have into games I'd probably be really really good at them, which I bet would open up some doors if I went looking for them, rather than just being alright at games and knowing some stuff about them, for whatever that's worth (nothing at all).

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by Grimm1 on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:22PM (#23194738)
I think pursuing leisure for some end goal loses the point of leisure itself and is an unfortunate side effect of the times we live in.

That said I'm a workaholic with my job and 2 active projects outside of that who likes to lift and go outside so I can't really take fault with that mode of thinking since I've never quite captured my own idea of how I should be doing leisure.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by watwut on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:24PM (#23194765)
> That said I'm a workaholic with my job and 2 active projects

I kind of dont see how you could play The Witcher while working overtime and having two side projects and going outside.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by Grimm1 on Friday May 15, 2020 @01:30PM (#23194841)
You've never taken a week off?
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by watwut on Friday May 15, 2020 @04:40PM (#23197138)
We use weeks off when there is no school to go together somewhere as a family. Around half time with friends too.

I don't have that much time off that I could take week off for the game.

Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by Grimm1 on Friday May 15, 2020 @08:57PM (#23199388)
Yeah, that's totally fair, I believe I'm just in an earlier stage of my life where I don't have a family yet so I can sometimes burn the time like that versus prioritizing my social relationships.
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by gnulinux on Friday May 15, 2020 @04:54PM (#23197267)
I spend a lot of time watching TV. I WISH I could play more games, the fact is playing games is an active activity, that forces you to focus on something, learn new things, interact with people. I get bored of doing this and end up playing less games and watch more shows. I think your view of putting in the same bin is very wrong.
Re:US video game sales have record quarter as consumers stay... by brenden2 on Friday May 15, 2020 @11:41AM (#23193468)
Video games are pretty fun though. They are quite mentally stimulating, and you can play with friends.

I take multiple walks every day (I have a dog), but I also live in a 500 sqft rental apartment in Manhattan which limits the kind of activities I can engage in.