Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by chasingsparks on Saturday March 12, 2011 @08:24PM
(#2317997)
I think catastrophes demonstrate interesting properties of human communications. All of these reports on imminent meltdown are plausible to people ignorant of the plant's design and even those who are experts on nuclear energy . The levels of distrust and recognition that there is probably noisy communications increase simultaneously.
From a sensationalist viewpoint, the plausibility and terrifying nature of the consequences are seductive, so these stories are widely read; from the expert standpoint, seeing a system with so many redundancies in such a wounded state calls into question just how many things might be going wrong.
At this point, unless your dealing directly with the reactors, your really in the dark and if your one of these people, you're focused on preventing further degredation, not managing the message. Even for organisations that do manage the message based on a team of experts (e.g. nuclear regulatory agencies) things move at such a frantic pace, things are wrong by the time you say them.
Regardless, it really does show that people like watching car crashes.
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by pyre on Saturday March 12, 2011 @07:51PM
(#2317928)
It's unfortunate, but not surprising that the headline is 'meltdown a
possibility,' ignoring things like:
> "What we have seen is only the slight indication from a monitoring post of
> cesium and iodine," he said.
> "We have some confidence, to some extent, to make the situation to be
> stable status," he said. "We actually have very good confidence that we
> will resolve this."
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by scott_s on Saturday March 12, 2011 @08:26PM
(#2318003)
People who may be held responsible for Very Bad Things tend to downplay the probability that the bad thing will occur and express confidence that they have it under control. That an official admits a meltdown is possible is the most noteworthy thing. When I run what he said through my public-official-Bayesian-filter, what comes out is "There is a non-trivial chance a meltdown will occur."
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by foobarbazban on Saturday March 12, 2011 @08:52PM
(#2318052)
This particular official (or his office, honestly) doesn't have much to gain from downplaying the possibility of a meltdown.
He is part of the regulatory agency, not the plant management. They are already going to have to revamp all of their regulations with regard to coolant water pumps (whoever screwed up there, be it someone writing regulations or an inspector, is already in trouble).
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by earl on Saturday March 12, 2011 @10:18PM
(#2318188)
This particular official (or his office, honestly) doesn't have much to gain from downplaying the possibility of a meltdown
This is the same Japan, you'll remember, that actually doctored video footage to downplay a previous accident at a nuclear reactor -- see Monju[1] -- with the direct involvement of the government. Or when they had to take the extraordinary step of forcing the shutdown of 17 reactors because a major (the major?) utility falsified safety records [2].
A cursory googling of japan nuclear safety would have immediately informed you that officials often downplay and conceal information.
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by Someone on Sunday March 13, 2011 @06:40AM
(#2318909)
I think the only fact in that article is "we saw radiation levels of X but we do not know what caused them".
The rest could be interpretation. The press will want to hear more than that 'we do not know', so it presses on, and asks, "do you have a meltdown?", A good PR Guy would probably say 'we do not want to speculate at this time', and nothing else, but holding that line is hard. It is way too easy to (especially for an engineer) to follow that by 'it very, very probably is 100% safe, but of course, since we do not _know_, it could be a meltdown'. Guess what part of such a statement would make the news?
So, to draw any conclusions from this, I would want to know who were present at that phone call, and what exactly was said.
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by Getahobby on Saturday March 12, 2011 @07:55PM
(#2317933)
This may be a gross understatement but this is going to end very badly and probably have negative repercussions long term for nuclear energy in this country.
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by icarus_drowning on Saturday March 12, 2011 @11:11PM
(#2318289)
Because it isn't certain that it is going to end badly. And because it is axiomatic that if it does there will be major repercussions on the power industry.
If it ends well, it might have positive repercussions-- "even in the worst case, these are still safe" will probably be the line.
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by Tycho on Saturday March 12, 2011 @08:45PM
(#2318038)
Is this the 'ultimate test' for nuclear power? And if so, and if the Japanese escape unscathed from radiation, will the global anti-nuclear contingent give credit where credit's due?
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by OpieCunningham on Saturday March 12, 2011 @09:09PM
(#2318084)
And the inverse, if the Japanese don't escape unscathed from radiation, will the global pro-nuclear contingent become anti-nuclear?
I suspect the answer to both questions is no. Firstly because unscathed is vague: 0% radiological impact? 3% impact? How much damage is allowed in the definition of unscathed? Secondly because the true impact will be debated, challenged and studied for decades. And thirdly because the pro contingent will insist that with knowledge gained from this failure, we now have enough knowledge to safely implement nuclear power.
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by Tycho on Saturday March 12, 2011 @09:13PM
(#2318093)
Well I was thinking in terms of 'completely unscathed' as in the failsafes etc. ultimately did their job and the radiactivity was contained (or kept within normal operating limits).
If there is 'some' fallout, then of course the debate will rage on indefinitely. Which is why I did not suggest the converse position that you put forward.
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by OpieCunningham on Saturday March 12, 2011 @10:07PM
(#2318172)
I'm not sure I follow. Are you suggesting that if there is no fallout, the anti-nuclear contingent should accept they are basically wrong, but if there is fallout, the pro-nuclear contingent should continue to fight (i.e. the debate will rage on)?
Why should one outcome produce a change in behavior from one crowd, but the opposite outcome should not produce a change in behavior from the opposite crowd?
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by icarus_drowning on Saturday March 12, 2011 @11:25PM
(#2318322)
I think the suggestion is that this represents a pretty 'worst case' scenario-- an old reactor of obsolete design that is dramatically less safe than many modern designs (at least as I understand it)and one of the worst earthquakes on record. If the "no fallout" situation does occur, it seems like a pretty powerful argument on the "pro-nuclear power" side of the debate.
And no, I don't suspect the anti nuclear crowd will buy it at all.
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by Tycho on Saturday March 12, 2011 @10:19PM
(#2318194)
If there is 'some' fallout, then it will be on a spectrum which will be interpreted very subjectively by different groups. However if there is 'no' fallout, then there is no spectrum, and no room for subjectivity. Those against nuclear power would have to admit this whole episode is not ammunition for their argument. Until 'the results are in' there will continue to be a lot of nuclear apocalypse sensationalism, I'd just like to see it retracted afterwards when/if it turns out to be unfounded. Put another way, we already know that it's possible to have nuclear accidents, what we don't know is whether it's possible for nuclear facilities to withstand major disasters with no such accident occurring. If that's the outcome, then to ignore it would be sort of like a type 1 error.
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by OpieCunningham on Sunday March 13, 2011 @12:41AM
(#2318464)
I'll put aside the fact that before you had even posted your original comment, the situation was already at the stage of debatable fallout.
Until the results are in there will also continue to be a lot of nuclear-is-perfectly-safe sensationalism (in the past hour I saw a couple of them on CNN). Do you expect and/or hope for retractions on those wildly optimistic statements by "experts" if there is "some" fallout, as you'd like to see in the reverse scenario? If so, I suspect you won't get them, though it does not really appear you'd be looking for them anyway.
Additionally, it's not clear to me why one case where there are no adverse affects (again, ignoring the fact that there are already adverse affects) is of monumental importance (a type 1 error), but the numerous cases of historic failures are not valid considerations in the same degree. Put another way, why should the hypothetical of a positive outcome of this situation have any more weight than the negative outcomes of numerous previous situations?
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by chc on Sunday March 13, 2011 @06:08AM
(#2318862)
Anecdotes of how things happened long ago are less relevant than this incident. With the methodology you're proposing, we'd have to conclude that modern medicine doesn't work because medicine had such a horrible track record in the Middle Ages.
Also, "safe" is relative. Walking down the sidewalk in a good neighborhood is generally considered safe, but it is dangerous relative to sitting in a fortified bunker. If the impact is several orders of magnitude less than we'd expect from, say, coal, then we can say this was very safe indeed.
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by OpieCunningham on Monday March 14, 2011 @01:41PM
(#2323497)
How convenient! If the situation hadn't turned out bad, we could have rejoiced the safety of nuclear power. Since things did turn out bad, we'll just brush it aside as ancient technology, nothing to see here, move on.
Except there are numerous "ancient" plants in full operation today. Except Japan is one of the most organized, efficient and technically advanced societies on the planet.
Most importantly, you fail to address my actual question: why should nuclear doom sayers have to recant their concerns in the event they are mistaken but nuclear cheerleaders do not in the event they are? You and the OP wouldn't answer that question because you have no logical answer.
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by Tycho on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @06:21PM
(#2329732)
We aren't dodging your question, we just think you should be able to grasp the point without further explanations. Firstly, it's not a true binary choice, it's not containment vs non-containment - it's containment vs. vastly varying degrees of non-containment. Secondly, non-containment scenarios will likely settle nothing (unless we have multiple 'mega-Chernobyls' or something, in which case then the proponents of nuclear power should admit they were misled) - the damage caused will be disputed, the value of the damage caused will be disputed, the appropriateness of the safety plans will be disputed, the correctness of the emergency operations will be disputed, the analogy to other plants not at risk from tsunamis/quakes will be disputed, the effectiveness of newer designs will be disputed, it will just go on forever because there will be no significant result.
But if the situation blows over without a large number of people being affected by harmful radiation, if the failsafes work despite multiple catastrophes (which almost certainly wouldn't threaten most plants), then the doom sayers really should admit nuclear safety is feasible, if they want to maintain any integrity.
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by OpieCunningham on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @07:00PM
(#2329865)
the doom sayers really should admit nuclear safety is feasible
No, they really should not.
Firstly, you've moved the goal posts - now safety should be accepted up until a "large number of people become affected by harmful radiation". Originally, your goal posts were set to "Japanese people escape unscathed from radiation". And I suspect the definition of "large" will shift accordingly so that you can maintain your view that nuclear plants are safe enough. You had to shift your goal posts because the glowingly optimistic view from your OP hasn't survived reality.
Secondly, if that glowingly optimistic view from your OP had actually come to pass (and now we're operating in a fantasy world), why would anyone consider it more than anecdotal or luck or a combination of factors that are not easily quantifiable and therefore hardly reproducible?
And lastly, once again you failed to address the point I have been making. Your position applies equally to both sides. You can't cherry pick and maintain any integrity. It's not that I believe failure in this situation is ultimate proof of the failure of nuclear energy - but it is your OP that success in this situation is ultimate proof of the success of nuclear energy. Your premise is wrong, independent of whether your conclusion is wrong (which I believe it is, but not ultimately because of this situation).
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by Tycho on Tuesday March 15, 2011 @09:09PM
(#2330238)
I said 'if the Japanese escape unscathed.' If you're wondering where the 'goalposts' are, it's approximate to disasters that could happen at any other power plant: ie. workers injured/killed, maybe a few civilians hurt. That seems objective enough to me when you're comparing the safety of different power sources.
Obviously there can be no 'ultimate, ultimate proof' unless we get a direct line to God, but if you're going to be the person standing on top of the hill saying
'I don't care if you can show nuclear plants can withstand unheard of earthquakes and tsunamis, I don't care if there's 50 years of further research and improvement on those standards, I still wont believe nuclear power is safe. In fact there's pretty much nothing that would sway my assessment of nuclear safety...'
then I don't see why anyone should take you seriously.
edit: oh, and let's just wait for the clear light of day before we decide what exactly 'the situation' really is/was. I've seen many conflicting and retracted reports so far
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by mquander on Saturday March 12, 2011 @09:33PM
(#2318126)
If it doesn't do any good this time, will the global contingent of people who continually and arbitrarily divide the world into static, irreconcilably opposed groups of people do it again anyway in the next discussion?
It seems that if Fukushima stays the third worst disaster we'll be in pretty good shape; Nobody was even killed at Three Mile Island. For some perspective, the San Bruno gas pipeline explosion killed eight people.
Quote: A new analysis of health statistics in the region conducted by the Radiation and Public Health Project has, however, found that death rates for infants, children, and the elderly soared in the first two years after the Three Mile Island accident in Dauphin and surrounding counties.
Quote: Exposure to high doses of radiation shortly after the nuclear accident at Three Mile Island may have increased cancer among Pennsylvanians downwind of the plant, scientists at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill say.
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by Natsu on Sunday March 13, 2011 @06:37AM
(#2318908)
Is there a reason why you didn't quote the other part of the article?
"Various studies on health effects, including a 2002 study conducted by the University of Pittsburgh, have determined the average radiation dose to individuals near Three Mile Island at the time of the meltdown was about 1 millirem - much less than the average, annual, natural background dose for residents of the central Pennsylvania region. Twenty-five years later, there has been no significant rise in cancer deaths among residents living near the Three Mile Island site."
Also, that analysis of health statistics makes no claim of causality that I can find. There could be any number of other explanations, particularly when we know that radiation exposure is linked to cancer and there was no rise in the cancer rates. There's no explanation of how the time frame of two years came about, either, unless they can link it to the half-life of something or something like that.
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by OpieCunningham on Sunday March 13, 2011 @06:16PM
(#2320397)
Is there a reason why you didn't quote the other part of the article?
Yes. The claim was definitive that nothing bad happened. I was referencing information that states the opposite of that claim. If the claim had been definitive that everything bad happened I would have referenced information that states the opposite of that. The fact is, the health of the populace post-TMI is heavily debated. If I were attempting to hide the subset of information that supported the claim I would not have included the links.
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by Natsu on Monday March 14, 2011 @01:30AM
(#2321428)
> Yes. The claim was definitive that nothing bad happened.
And that claim was correct. That study, even if one accepts it as absolute fact, does not support the hypothesis that the TMI accident was a contributing cause of death.
Even so, it would be interesting to compare how the increase in the death rate compared to "safe" things, such as traffic accidents, smoking, and other intentional risks that people take.
But that's the key word, isn't it? "Intentional" risks.
Re:Official: 'We see the possibility of a meltdown'
by OpieCunningham on Monday March 14, 2011 @03:03AM
(#2321599)
And that claim was correct.
No, it wasn't. As referenced, there are studies which demonstrate the exact opposite. Sorry, but it's simply a fact that those studies exist. Head in the sand doesn't make them go away.
From a sensationalist viewpoint, the plausibility and terrifying nature of the consequences are seductive, so these stories are widely read; from the expert standpoint, seeing a system with so many redundancies in such a wounded state calls into question just how many things might be going wrong.
At this point, unless your dealing directly with the reactors, your really in the dark and if your one of these people, you're focused on preventing further degredation, not managing the message. Even for organisations that do manage the message based on a team of experts (e.g. nuclear regulatory agencies) things move at such a frantic pace, things are wrong by the time you say them.
Regardless, it really does show that people like watching car crashes.
He is part of the regulatory agency, not the plant management. They are already going to have to revamp all of their regulations with regard to coolant water pumps (whoever screwed up there, be it someone writing regulations or an inspector, is already in trouble).
A cursory googling of japan nuclear safety would have immediately informed you that officials often downplay and conceal information.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monju_Nuclear_Power_Plant [2] http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/3548192.stm
The rest could be interpretation. The press will want to hear more than that 'we do not know', so it presses on, and asks, "do you have a meltdown?", A good PR Guy would probably say 'we do not want to speculate at this time', and nothing else, but holding that line is hard. It is way too easy to (especially for an engineer) to follow that by 'it very, very probably is 100% safe, but of course, since we do not _know_, it could be a meltdown'. Guess what part of such a statement would make the news?
So, to draw any conclusions from this, I would want to know who were present at that phone call, and what exactly was said.
If it ends well, it might have positive repercussions-- "even in the worst case, these are still safe" will probably be the line.
I suspect the answer to both questions is no. Firstly because unscathed is vague: 0% radiological impact? 3% impact? How much damage is allowed in the definition of unscathed? Secondly because the true impact will be debated, challenged and studied for decades. And thirdly because the pro contingent will insist that with knowledge gained from this failure, we now have enough knowledge to safely implement nuclear power.
If there is 'some' fallout, then of course the debate will rage on indefinitely. Which is why I did not suggest the converse position that you put forward.
Why should one outcome produce a change in behavior from one crowd, but the opposite outcome should not produce a change in behavior from the opposite crowd?
And no, I don't suspect the anti nuclear crowd will buy it at all.
Until the results are in there will also continue to be a lot of nuclear-is-perfectly-safe sensationalism (in the past hour I saw a couple of them on CNN). Do you expect and/or hope for retractions on those wildly optimistic statements by "experts" if there is "some" fallout, as you'd like to see in the reverse scenario? If so, I suspect you won't get them, though it does not really appear you'd be looking for them anyway.
Additionally, it's not clear to me why one case where there are no adverse affects (again, ignoring the fact that there are already adverse affects) is of monumental importance (a type 1 error), but the numerous cases of historic failures are not valid considerations in the same degree. Put another way, why should the hypothetical of a positive outcome of this situation have any more weight than the negative outcomes of numerous previous situations?
Also, "safe" is relative. Walking down the sidewalk in a good neighborhood is generally considered safe, but it is dangerous relative to sitting in a fortified bunker. If the impact is several orders of magnitude less than we'd expect from, say, coal, then we can say this was very safe indeed.
Except there are numerous "ancient" plants in full operation today. Except Japan is one of the most organized, efficient and technically advanced societies on the planet.
Most importantly, you fail to address my actual question: why should nuclear doom sayers have to recant their concerns in the event they are mistaken but nuclear cheerleaders do not in the event they are? You and the OP wouldn't answer that question because you have no logical answer.
But if the situation blows over without a large number of people being affected by harmful radiation, if the failsafes work despite multiple catastrophes (which almost certainly wouldn't threaten most plants), then the doom sayers really should admit nuclear safety is feasible, if they want to maintain any integrity.
No, they really should not.
Firstly, you've moved the goal posts - now safety should be accepted up until a "large number of people become affected by harmful radiation". Originally, your goal posts were set to "Japanese people escape unscathed from radiation". And I suspect the definition of "large" will shift accordingly so that you can maintain your view that nuclear plants are safe enough. You had to shift your goal posts because the glowingly optimistic view from your OP hasn't survived reality.
Secondly, if that glowingly optimistic view from your OP had actually come to pass (and now we're operating in a fantasy world), why would anyone consider it more than anecdotal or luck or a combination of factors that are not easily quantifiable and therefore hardly reproducible?
And lastly, once again you failed to address the point I have been making. Your position applies equally to both sides. You can't cherry pick and maintain any integrity. It's not that I believe failure in this situation is ultimate proof of the failure of nuclear energy - but it is your OP that success in this situation is ultimate proof of the success of nuclear energy. Your premise is wrong, independent of whether your conclusion is wrong (which I believe it is, but not ultimately because of this situation).
Obviously there can be no 'ultimate, ultimate proof' unless we get a direct line to God, but if you're going to be the person standing on top of the hill saying
'I don't care if you can show nuclear plants can withstand unheard of earthquakes and tsunamis, I don't care if there's 50 years of further research and improvement on those standards, I still wont believe nuclear power is safe. In fact there's pretty much nothing that would sway my assessment of nuclear safety...'
then I don't see why anyone should take you seriously.
edit: oh, and let's just wait for the clear light of day before we decide what exactly 'the situation' really is/was. I've seen many conflicting and retracted reports so far
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Mile_Island_accident
It seems that if Fukushima stays the third worst disaster we'll be in pretty good shape; Nobody was even killed at Three Mile Island. For some perspective, the San Bruno gas pipeline explosion killed eight people.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010_San_Bruno_pipeline_explosi...
Quote: A new analysis of health statistics in the region conducted by the Radiation and Public Health Project has, however, found that death rates for infants, children, and the elderly soared in the first two years after the Three Mile Island accident in Dauphin and surrounding counties.
http://www.unc.edu/news/archives/feb97/wing.html
Quote: Exposure to high doses of radiation shortly after the nuclear accident at Three Mile Island may have increased cancer among Pennsylvanians downwind of the plant, scientists at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill say.
"Various studies on health effects, including a 2002 study conducted by the University of Pittsburgh, have determined the average radiation dose to individuals near Three Mile Island at the time of the meltdown was about 1 millirem - much less than the average, annual, natural background dose for residents of the central Pennsylvania region. Twenty-five years later, there has been no significant rise in cancer deaths among residents living near the Three Mile Island site."
Also, that analysis of health statistics makes no claim of causality that I can find. There could be any number of other explanations, particularly when we know that radiation exposure is linked to cancer and there was no rise in the cancer rates. There's no explanation of how the time frame of two years came about, either, unless they can link it to the half-life of something or something like that.
Yes. The claim was definitive that nothing bad happened. I was referencing information that states the opposite of that claim. If the claim had been definitive that everything bad happened I would have referenced information that states the opposite of that. The fact is, the health of the populace post-TMI is heavily debated. If I were attempting to hide the subset of information that supported the claim I would not have included the links.
And that claim was correct. That study, even if one accepts it as absolute fact, does not support the hypothesis that the TMI accident was a contributing cause of death.
Even so, it would be interesting to compare how the increase in the death rate compared to "safe" things, such as traffic accidents, smoking, and other intentional risks that people take.
But that's the key word, isn't it? "Intentional" risks.
No, it wasn't. As referenced, there are studies which demonstrate the exact opposite. Sorry, but it's simply a fact that those studies exist. Head in the sand doesn't make them go away.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_of_Ghost_in_the_Shell#Jap...