Re:NYT on why Microsoft should rewrite Windows from scratch
by Feynman on Monday June 30, 2008 @02:42AM
(#231769)
Hmmm, the article starts off with "Windows seems to move an inch for every time that Mac OS X or Linux laps it." Then moves to "A MONOLITHIC operating system like Windows perpetuates an obsolete design."
I'm no OS expert, but I thought Linux was also "monolithic" in terms of kernel design.
I think Mr. Stross should keep to writing about subjects in his expertise.
Re:NYT on why Microsoft should rewrite Windows from scratch
by silverlake on Monday June 30, 2008 @11:21AM
(#232044)
Yes, Linux is monolithic. MacOS X is a micro-kernel, but I believe the BSD stuff runs in kernel space, so it's effectively a monolithic kernel with a nice layered design. I think NT is somewhere between OS X and Linux. The article was terrible.
Re:NYT on why Microsoft should rewrite Windows from scratch
by mattmaroon on Monday June 30, 2008 @04:30AM
(#231821)
Yeah, it's pretty easy to see why MS ignores them. At the same time, even though the methodology is flawed, the conclusion seems pretty accurate. It's time for MS to rewrite from scratch.
Re:NYT on why Microsoft should rewrite Windows from scratch
by rplevy on Monday June 30, 2008 @12:24PM
(#232107)
Forget rewriting, they should open the source. That's just about the only thing they could do that would make their operating system interesting to me. I don't know much about business, but it also might be just the shark they would need to jump in order to reverse their gradual decline.
Re:NYT on why Microsoft should rewrite Windows from scratch
by allenbrunson on Monday June 30, 2008 @01:02PM
(#232160)
a more relevant analogy is apple's mac-to-macosx switch. they completely dumped the old os and replaced it with a new one, relegating the old one to a poorly-integrated emulator.
it was very painful. the wailing and gnashing of teeth from the old guard was loud and angry. but it was good for the company in the long run. now the old macos emulator is all but gone, as are the complaints. it was short-term painful, but a long-term gigantic win.
the same would be true for windows, if it were rewritten from scratch. it's not that the code itself needs a rewrite, it's that the windows api is a patch on a bag on a pile of spit. the fact that microsoft has put such a high priority on backward compatibility is slowly strangling windows to death.
I'm no OS expert, but I thought Linux was also "monolithic" in terms of kernel design.
I think Mr. Stross should keep to writing about subjects in his expertise.
Also, microkernels aren't the end-all-be-all of OS design. And Singularity is more about a managed-code kernel than a microkernel.
Vista is the equivalent, at a minimum, of Windows version 12 — preceded by 1.0, 2.0, 3.0, 3.1, NT, 95, NT 4.0, 98, 2000, ME, XP
Wow, what ignorance. NT and the earlier Windows version are unrelated.
Uhh, how about NT4, 2000, Vista, 7?
Anyway, I thought we all agreed that the Mozilla rewrite wasn't a great plan. Why would it be any better for Windows? What' wrong with refactoring?
it was very painful. the wailing and gnashing of teeth from the old guard was loud and angry. but it was good for the company in the long run. now the old macos emulator is all but gone, as are the complaints. it was short-term painful, but a long-term gigantic win.
the same would be true for windows, if it were rewritten from scratch. it's not that the code itself needs a rewrite, it's that the windows api is a patch on a bag on a pile of spit. the fact that microsoft has put such a high priority on backward compatibility is slowly strangling windows to death.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=231411
and my version only got three votes. people preferred the "rewrite from scratch" title, perhaps?