News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Progress on Plasma by kevinherron on Sunday May 10, 2020 @02:01PM (#23134594)
I wish KDE had the same level of resources behind it as GNOME does.

I keep occasionally trying new versions of GNOME but it feels like a DE optimized to look good in screenshots and always falls short when actually using it.

KDE on the other hand looks relatively good and is infinitely more usable to me. It's got some rougher edges and a weaker application ecosystem but still comes out ahead for me.

I also vastly prefer using apps written in QT to those written in GTK and despise CSD...

Re:Progress on Plasma by the_angry_angel on Sunday May 10, 2020 @02:42PM (#23134930)
I switched some years ago to KDE from Gnome. The only thing I wish I had from Gnome is the quality of text rendering.

Maybe it’s subjective, maybe it’s a measurable thing. I’ve not looked, but I feel KDEs text rendering is worse on my daily driver.

Re:Progress on Plasma by mixedCase on Sunday May 10, 2020 @03:10PM (#23135203)
Linux apps pretty much universally do font rendering via FreeType. Have you tried switching to Cantarell? I for one fell in love with Inter UI back when I used Plasma.
Re:Progress on Plasma by the_angry_angel on Monday May 11, 2020 @06:15AM (#23140560)
I haven't, I'll give it a go :) Thank you!
Re:Progress on Plasma by the_angry_angel on Tuesday May 12, 2020 @04:19AM (#23151666)
FWIW if anyone else comes back to this I spent a little time last night and I've addressed my font rendering issues by;

* Removing an errant font-config lcdfilter configuration entry (this was a left over from when I was running "infinality" and should have been removed)

* Switching font from Noto Sans to Ubuntu

Its not perfect, but its a lot better. I'll probably play with oversampling (rendering X at a higher resolution and scaling down like OSX) at some point to see if I get the quality I want.

Re:Progress on Plasma by flyingpenguin on Sunday May 10, 2020 @02:18PM (#23134732)
I don't want to defend Gnome because I also can't stand it over KDE most of the time, but I think GNOME is built for one actually useful thing... laptops.

Gnome feels good on a computer with a single small display.

Re:Progress on Plasma by kevinherron on Sunday May 10, 2020 @02:59PM (#23135090)
I actually find that GNOME is worse on laptops. My X1C6 is running at effectively 1600x900 and the amount of vertical space wasted by the height and padding of GNOME/GTK titlebars and widgets drives me crazy.

With KDE on a laptop I just set up the dock vertically on the righthand side and I'm good to go.

GNOME's workspace switcher/overview thing is better than anything KDE has though. It's much closer in function and polish to macOS than KDE is.

Re:Progress on Plasma by aibara on Sunday May 10, 2020 @04:24PM (#23135840)
Maybe there's some extension to fix this now, but I always hated how GNOME's workspaces were just small boxes on the opposite side of the overview button/hot corner. And even more so that they were a row, not a grid. KDE's exposé-like grid that separates all the windows on all the workspaces is so much more useful to me (not sure if that's enabled by default though).
Re:Progress on Plasma by CoolGuySteve on Sunday May 10, 2020 @02:36PM (#23134879)
I'm probably the last person who still uses Unity and it's for this exact reason. I set the launch bar to auto hide and use the compiz Expose clone hot corners to switch windows.

It all just gets out of the way.

I don't know why Gnome didn't adopt the Unity menu bar integration, instead you get to waste space on the taskbar on the bottom AND that useless status bar on the top.

Re:Progress on Plasma by huftis on Sunday May 10, 2020 @03:44PM (#23135479)
FYI, KDE/Plasma supports all of those features you mentioned:

1. You can set the launcher/taskbar/panel to auto-hide. 2. You can set up the screen corners (or a keyboard shortcut) to show an Exposé-style view of all running applications/windows. 3. You can have a global menu bar.

Re:Progress on Plasma by aibara on Sunday May 10, 2020 @04:21PM (#23135812)
You can get pretty close to emulating Unity's interface with Plasma, especially if you use Latte-dock. But there are still certain things that can't be done; the biggest to me is having the menu bar (File, Edit, etc.) in the title bar of all the windows (a global menu at the top works though). You can get a button that then gives you those options, which is close but an extra click.
Re:Progress on Plasma by mroche on Sunday May 10, 2020 @03:05PM (#23135144)
> I don't know why Gnome didn't adopt the Unity menu bar integration, instead you get to waste space on the taskbar on the bottom AND that useless status bar on the top.

Are you referring to the Window List extension? Why not use Dash to Dock instead, or even Dash to Panel (not sure if it’s current state, I don’t use it) which will also replace the main top status panel.

I’m a GNOME user on a single display (X because NVIDIA and 3D industry apps) and it works well for me. I do like the other DE’s though, I’m pretty agnostic in that sense.

Re:Progress on Plasma by CoolGuySteve on Sunday May 10, 2020 @03:13PM (#23135236)
No I'm talking about how the "File Edit " etc menu is drawn in one and only one place like in MacOS so that every application doesn't waste screen space drawing their own menu.
Re:Progress on Plasma by mroche on Sunday May 10, 2020 @03:25PM (#23135343)
Oh, right. It’s been such a long time since I’ve used unity I completely forgot that was a thing, my bad.

Most of the time when I think about Unity these days I think about the sidebar launcher and the maximized window mode integration, not the rest of the features it provided; I didn’t get to spend a lot of time in Ubuntu.

Re:Progress on Plasma by Beldin on Monday May 11, 2020 @04:20AM (#23139977)
After installing Ubuntu 18.04 I tried staying with Gnome. I installed extensions to get closer to the behavior I wanted. I realised i basically had a cheap, slow knock-off of standard Unity functionality. I installed Unity and never looked back. I'm no longer waiting for the window manager when switching virtual desktops. Load on the system is now once again due to me using it, instead of the window manager.
Re:Progress on Plasma by Quekid5 on Sunday May 10, 2020 @02:51PM (#23135014)
KDE works much better for me, personally. Just avoid the aboslute shitshow that is Kubuntu. (I know they try hard, but...)

Go for a distro that follows upstream more closely.

Re:Progress on Plasma by kevinherron on Sunday May 10, 2020 @03:01PM (#23135109)
Yes, I've settled on Manjaro KDE since the demise of Antergos. Do vanilla Arch once for the experience and then find better things to do with your time after that...
Re:Progress on Plasma by Quekid5 on Sunday May 10, 2020 @03:55PM (#23135585)
I honestly don't understand the idea that Arch is time-consuming or weird... but maybe my needs are less esoteric than the rest of the world.

I'm just a bit mystified, but... whatever makes it work for you.

Re:Progress on Plasma by kevinherron on Sunday May 10, 2020 @04:01PM (#23135647)
I'm not implying that Arch is time consuming once you set it up... but if you can't see how installing Arch is more time consuming than installing Manjaro you're just being intentionally dense and contrarian.
Re:Progress on Plasma by reddotX on Sunday May 10, 2020 @03:04PM (#23135138)
KDE neon?
Re:Progress on Plasma by blinkingled on Sunday May 10, 2020 @02:38PM (#23134900)
Yeah but I hope it's not the same kind of resources - https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=HarfBuzz...

Gnome developers have their head buried deep and firm in sands at this point.

Re:Progress on Plasma by cycloptic on Sunday May 10, 2020 @02:47PM (#23134963)
Harfbuzz isn't a GNOME project. It's used by GNOME, KDE, Chromium, LibreOffice, and several other projects. The entire open source text rendering stack depends on it at this point.
Re:Progress on Plasma by blinkingled on Sunday May 10, 2020 @05:02PM (#23136148)
https://blogs.gnome.org/mclasen/2019/05/25/pango-future-dire...

> Using Harfbuzz for font loading means that we will lose support for bitmap and type1 fonts.

It's not as straight forward.

Re:Progress on Plasma by cycloptic on Sunday May 10, 2020 @06:01PM (#23136684)
That is not related to the other article that you linked. The Type1 format is extremely old/deprecated and has been superseded by OpenType. And bitmap fonts don't even have a concept of hinting, they are just bitmaps.
Re:Progress on Plasma by blinkingled on Sunday May 10, 2020 @06:49PM (#23137054)
Pango is a Gnome project. They moved to using Harfbuzz and as a result dropped support for bitmap fonts. That hurt not just Gnome/GTK users but whoever else uses Pango and there was user pushback about it.

Pango prior to version 1.44 used kerning hints provided by FreeType but now makes use of the hints provided by HarfBuzz. But HarfBuzz doesn't support all of the hints supported by FreeType and thus a regression for some users depending upon their font hinting preferences and what visibly looks the best to them and their displays.

Remember Pango is a Gnome project.

Re:Progress on Plasma by cycloptic on Sunday May 10, 2020 @07:49PM (#23137401)
The original article you linked was not about Pango or Gnome and did not mention those things at all other than a vague reference to a different bug which may or may not even be related. As far as I can tell no developers have done a full (and time-consuming) investigation of this issue to actually get a full picture of what is going on. I would encourage you to actually read the articles you link and their primary sources, because what you're saying is somewhat contrary to what has already been said. Repeatedly airing grievances about decisions that have already been made years ago is, in general, not helpful to you or anyone else.

The user pushback was unnecessary because this is a deeper technical issue than just these fonts. Additionally bitmap fonts are still usable as long as they are appropriately converted to OpenType.

Re:Progress on Plasma by blinkingled on Sunday May 10, 2020 @08:42PM (#23137733)
I’m not sure what point you’re trying to disagree / take issue with- I thought it was the point about Gnome developers and their heads for which I gave plenty of backing information - there was no technical reason not to continue to use Freetype hinting until Harfbuzz supported it or give distros option to choose. But instead in both cases they just said screw your users who need that. Nothing you have said so far refutes my point that Gnome developers don’t care about their users.
Re:Progress on Plasma by cycloptic on Monday May 11, 2020 @07:32AM (#23140986)
It is not helpful to try and conjecture whether or not upstream "cares about users". There is no reason for me to refute or agree with your point on this matter; if there is some other desktop environment that you prefer to use instead, then my agreeing or disagreeing with you wouldn't change your ability to go use that. I will not join in an angry mob for or against these developers either, that won't help anything get done. I politely request that you avoid trying to make these type of arguments about some other person's motivations in the future, because the only real outcome is to turn people against each other and create enemies, when what you really want seems to be just to get the bug fixed in a friendly way.

Just from looking at the bug report there was a technical reason given related to other bugs and deficiencies in freetype. Please read the bug report in full detail, no developers are deleting features for no reason. Distros always have the option to choose whatever solution they want in response to user complaints. They can stay on an old version of whatever package they want or they can patch Harfbuzz and contribute the patches back upstream. You should take it up with your distro if the problem persists and they've not bothered to do either of these. Either way you have to be prepared to deal with the consequences which are: missing out on other newer features because you stayed on an old version, or spending the time/money to get the work done to add back in the features to the new version. Or you can upgrade anyway and do the workaround which is to convert your fonts.