News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OS X Isn't for Developers by kstenerud on Thursday March 10, 2011 @07:20PM (#2311449)
I don't understand. What does an accounting compliance law have to do with charging for previously free tools? And how were they able to release free tools in the years after 2002? What makes 2011 so special that they are compelled by law to start charging $5?
Re:OS X Isn't for Developers by dubious_1 on Thursday March 10, 2011 @07:27PM (#2311472)
Previous major upgrades to XCode released with new versions of OSX and required that newer version to install/run. OSX 10.7 (Lion) has not released yet, so upgrading from 3.6 to 4.0 (Major upgrade) is not considered a maintenance release by Apple's accounting department. Paying members of the Apple Developer network subscribe ($99 per year) and one of the benefits is access to Beta releases of OS and tools. XCode 4.0 was available to members of the Developer network prior to this official release, and after the release, non-subscribers are given access through the App Store. Apple is in no way preventing anyone from developing for Mac at this point since XCode 3.6.5 is still available for download and installation by any users of OSX 10.6 (Snow Leopard), and as evidenced by the availability of the iOS 4.3 SDK for XCode 3.6, they are not forcing anyone to upgrade to the new IDE just to develop for their various platforms.
Re:OS X Isn't for Developers by kstenerud on Thursday March 10, 2011 @07:33PM (#2311504)
Ok, but where in this scenario do the SOX compliance laws compel them to charge money for a "major upgrade"?
Re:OS X Isn't for Developers by bzbarsky on Friday March 11, 2011 @12:34AM (#2312275)
The problem is Sarbanes-Oxley requires compliance with certain accounting practices (to be set by regulators; these are not spelled out in the act). I'm not an accountant, but as I understand the problem arises in this situation:

2005: Company X sells product Y to person Z for $1000. Company's books show $1000 in revenue. 2006: Company X gives Z a free significant upgrade to product Y and records no revenue.

The argument could be made that what really happened was that the company actually made two sales to Z; one in 2005 and one in 2006 and that the revenue of $1000 should properly be split across the two years.

Not having such a rule apparently allows various accounting shenanigans in which totally unrelated things are treated as "free upgrades" to something else and revenue can be booked in whatever year you want.

So there are two important things here for all this to be an issue: 1) The initial purchase must have cost money. If you get something for free and then get a free upgrade to it, there's no problem. 2) The magnitude of the upgrade must be such that one could be accused of slipping an unrelated product in as a "free upgrade".

So for example security updates to safari would fail test #2 above. Major updates to iTunes may fail test #1, since iTunes is generally available for free to everyone (even if you don't buy a Mac or MacOS).

It's possible that something makes Apple's accountants feel that XCode is part of the OS in a way that means that when you pay for the OS you're also paying for XCode. And that XCode 4 is enough of a change from XCode 3 that if it were free it would fall afoul of the accounting stuff above.

Again, I'm not an accountant, so I could be getting all this totally wrong...

Re:OS X Isn't for Developers by DougBTX on Thursday March 10, 2011 @09:21PM (#2311866)
So, what you are actually saying, is that this is the cheapest major upgrade to XCode that's ever been released?
Re:OS X Isn't for Developers by thought_alarm on Thursday March 10, 2011 @07:23PM (#2311458)
OS X ships with XCode. Apple has never released a major XCode upgrade in-between OS releases until now.
Re:OS X Isn't for Developers by statictype on Thursday March 10, 2011 @07:34PM (#2311512)
What about iTunes? Why don't they have to charge for iTunes?
Re:OS X Isn't for Developers by nl on Thursday March 10, 2011 @07:56PM (#2311601)
Because the whole "SOX accounting theory" is made up by people who don't know what they are talking about.

In its defense it was initially put forward as speculation ("what about this theory"), but now is being taken as fact.

Re:OS X Isn't for Developers by tvon on Thursday March 10, 2011 @08:43PM (#2311748)
It's the theory for xcode based on Apple claiming it was the reason to charge iPod Touch users for iOS 2 or 3 (I forget which). IIRC.
Re:OS X Isn't for Developers by rbarooah on Friday March 11, 2011 @12:48AM (#2312303)
If you know what you are talking about then you'll be able to tell us the reason why it can't be true.
Re:OS X Isn't for Developers by flomo on Friday March 11, 2011 @12:40AM (#2312287)
SOX became the trendy IT excuse for anything.

As an example from a few years ago, when I hired a contract developer, the company required a "Contractor Request Form". Fine. There's payroll to setup and so on. But then one day the form was renamed to be the "Contractor SOX Compliance Request Form".

I suspect this exercise was only so that some bean counter could show the outrageous costs of "SOX compliance".

Re:OS X Isn't for Developers by dgallagher on Thursday March 10, 2011 @07:52PM (#2311579)
You make a great point; there appear to be some contradictions in their accounting policies. The "App Store" didn't come with OS X, but was free. iTunes and Safari get major updates all the time, yet remain free upgrades. On iOS, you have iBooks, Remote, Find My iPhone, Apple Store, MobileMe Disk, and MobileMe Gallery, all free.

We're not sure what the litmus test is for their accounting practices. We're not even sure if Xcode falls into that category (e.g. maybe they're charging $5 for it now because they want to). It would be nice if Apple shared their accounting algorithm as that would clarify things.

Re:OS X Isn't for Developers by nl on Thursday March 10, 2011 @07:59PM (#2311611)
Business Decisions != Accounting practices

Can you seriously imagine Steve Jobs being told they he has to charge for something he doesn't want to because of accounting practices?!

Re:OS X Isn't for Developers by jsz0 on Thursday March 10, 2011 @08:47PM (#2311756)
Good question. My guess is it depends on what components Apple officially accounts for as being parts of OSX. Keep in mind Apple was under investigation by the SEC for many years so they are probably following the rules extra carefully. After the SOX rules were changed last year (IIRC) Apple immediately changed some of their accounting practices to provide free iOS updates for the iPod Touch so I tend to believe them.
Re:OS X Isn't for Developers by kinofcain on Thursday March 10, 2011 @09:08PM (#2311824)
Perhaps because they can claim iTunes, because of the iTunes Store isn't an end-product so much as a platform upon which people make purchases. They can account for the revenue from the greater iTunes app through each purchase you make in the store. Same goes with the App Store.

Not sure how they deal with people who never purchase anything, but perhaps they don't have to be 100% thorough about it.

Re:OS X Isn't for Developers by seanmccann on Thursday March 10, 2011 @07:35PM (#2311516)
The following was said about Apple charging to unlock 802.11n in MacBooks.

Why don't they give it away for free, say with Software Update? Because of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (which was passed in the wake of the Enron scandal). iLounge quotes an Apple representative: "It's about accounting. Because of the Act, the company believes that if it sells a product, then later adds a feature to that product, it can be held liable for improper accounting if it recognizes revenue from the product at the time of sale, given that it hasn't finished delivering the product at that point."