Great, so all someone needs to do is make a decent Cocoa IDE (don't forget Instruments and an iOS simulator!) and give it away for free. Problem solved.
Yes, the solution to you not willing to pay $5 is for someone else to invest hundrends of thousands of dollars (at programmer's market pay) to re-implement XCode.
I do develop open-source software (SumatraPDF) and give it away for free, but this kind of attitude of entitlement always gets me.
My point exactly. Although if someone really does want to re-implement Xcode, more power to them I say! Me, I'll pay the 5 bucks.
This is a lot harder than just paying $4.99 for Xcode, but I wonder how difficult it would be to adapt GNUstep's developer tools to Cocoa development.
Re:Xcode now costs US$ 4.99
by stcredzero on Thursday March 10, 2011 @02:27PM
(#2310371)
How about a bunch of us pay $5 to do that? Kickstarter project?
> Great, so all someone needs to do is make a decent Cocoa IDE
You can start from here: http://www.gnustep.org/experience/DeveloperTools.html
Not so much if you want to do any iOS work.
If doing iOS work isn't worth five dollars to you, than how much you can be said to "want" to do it is up for debate.
I get the impression everybody is preaching to the choir here for the most part.
JetBrains is working on an IDE for Cocoa developer and guess what it wont cost 5 bucks thats for sure.
> Java came along with tools that weren't 100th as cool
That's one hell of an understatement...
Re:Xcode now costs US$ 4.99
by stcredzero on Wednesday March 09, 2011 @05:20PM
(#2306838)
That's one hell of an understatement...
I just want to relate the experience, not start a flame war. Java tools are pretty darn cool nowadays.
Still, Smalltalk is seriously cool.
I think the pricing was only one factor of Java's success. Smalltalk, for the C programmer, is pretty alien. No source files, no compiler... That takes some to get used to. Java provides a nice path towards OOP that's more forgiving than C++, yet, it's aesthetically compatible with C.
Version control also seemed an issue - commercial Smalltalks had tools like Envy - but all the projects I observed in the telecoms world seemed to have a senior developer doing nothing but merging images for the duration of the project.
Indeed. Having source files helps a lot. Smalltalk images suffer from Amish Bread Syndrome. Not being able to build your image from sources and sources alone is disturbing for me and I learned OOP with Smalltalk (later moved to Actor on Windows, but, still, without source code as text files).
Re:Xcode now costs US$ 4.99
by Turing_Machine on Wednesday March 09, 2011 @07:53PM
(#2307433)
Okay, I'll bite. "Amish Bread Syndrome"? The Googles do nothing.
The Googles lead me to Amish Friendship Bread, which requires a starter that you have to get from someone else. Thus, without the starter you can't compile your bread from sources. At least, that's the best I can come up with in three minutes. :)
Re:Xcode now costs US$ 4.99
by stcredzero on Thursday March 10, 2011 @02:31PM
(#2310390)
all the projects I observed in the telecoms world seemed to have a senior developer doing nothing but merging images for the duration of the project.
Envy had a few pathologies, but I think there were pathologies in the projects as well.
Smalltalk companies did this to themselves, but with a smaller userbase and bigger fees. (Which is worse in both dimensions!) With $5000 seats, the friction was hella high. Then Java came along with tools that weren't 100th as cool, but which were frictionless and free.
It's kinda the playbook for being a superior technology with an earned reputation for coolness, then losing anyhow because your userbase doesn't grow as fast.