Still, Smalltalk is seriously cool.
I think the pricing was only one factor of Java's success. Smalltalk, for the C programmer, is pretty alien. No source files, no compiler... That takes some to get used to. Java provides a nice path towards OOP that's more forgiving than C++, yet, it's aesthetically compatible with C.
Version control also seemed an issue - commercial Smalltalks had tools like Envy - but all the projects I observed in the telecoms world seemed to have a senior developer doing nothing but merging images for the duration of the project.
Indeed. Having source files helps a lot. Smalltalk images suffer from Amish Bread Syndrome. Not being able to build your image from sources and sources alone is disturbing for me and I learned OOP with Smalltalk (later moved to Actor on Windows, but, still, without source code as text files).
Re:Xcode now costs US$ 4.99
by Turing_Machine on Wednesday March 09, 2011 @07:53PM
(#2307433)
Okay, I'll bite. "Amish Bread Syndrome"? The Googles do nothing.
The Googles lead me to Amish Friendship Bread, which requires a starter that you have to get from someone else. Thus, without the starter you can't compile your bread from sources. At least, that's the best I can come up with in three minutes. :)
Re:Xcode now costs US$ 4.99
by stcredzero on Thursday March 10, 2011 @02:31PM
(#2310390)
all the projects I observed in the telecoms world seemed to have a senior developer doing nothing but merging images for the duration of the project.
Envy had a few pathologies, but I think there were pathologies in the projects as well.
I just want to relate the experience, not start a flame war. Java tools are pretty darn cool nowadays.