WF may be seeing tons of applications for home equity lines in order to backstop failing households. If they're not sure that they'll get paid back, then WF won't want to make the loan.
I once was involved with corporate loan negotiations where the lender could have easily taken the borrower up on a proffered deal, but the fate of the borrower's company would have been sealed on the day the loan was signed. The terms were such that the borrower's odds of being able to repay the loan were <10% and the collateral requirements were at least twice the loan amount. The lender would have roughly doubled their money at the expense of a headache, but chose to walk away instead. The borrower would have taken the deal at almost any price. In the lender's words, "We're in the loan business, we want to make loans where people can pay interest."
My thank-you letter to the lender for walking away was one of the first they'd ever received.
As a large mortgage provider, home prices are the best tool that WF has to hedge against large changes in labor value.
- First is the moral/ethical reason - it doesn't matter your religion or lack thereof, causing someone to crash and burn, causing unemployment, and generally ruining lives is bad.
- Second is their business. Banks are in the lending business. Unless the collateral was cash or stocks (unlikely based on explanation), they'd have to figure out how to repossess and then dispose of the assets. Yes, they probably have a group that handles that sort of thing but you're introducing unnecessary headaches.
Either way, walking away sounds like the right and good call.
The core of it is how commercial real estate is financed; it’s financed on a rolling basis rather than a 1 time mortgage, like a home. This means that rather than revenue most commercial real estate owners are more concerned about what their next financing round will look like. For reasons I cannot explain, bankers care less about the rent a building does receive than they care about the rent it could receive. This incentivizes building owners to leave units empty rather than lower rates, as it actually ends up significantly cheaper for them in the long run.
Bet you didn't know this, but there is a company (an REIT actually) that is publicly traded on the stock market, that specializes in loans to nonprofit religious organizations..."American Church Mortgage Company". Currently appear to be paying a sizable dividend.
"The outbreak of the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) has adversely affected many industries in general and resulted in orders preventing congregation which impacts the ability of churches and other non-profit religious organizations normal methods of worship...To the extent that churches and other non-profit organizations operations in the U.S. are materially and adversely affected by the coronavirus, business and financial results of this industry, and thus our business and financial results, could be materially and adversely impacted."
...and yes, they do foreclose on churches:
"As of December 31, 2019, we had ten first mortgage loans totaling approximately $4,074,000 that are three or more monthly payments in arrears. We may incur a loss if these borrowers are unable to bring their payments current and we are compelled to foreclose on their properties. We may be unable to dispose of the foreclosed properties on terms that enable us to recoup our expenses and outstanding balances.
As of December 31, 2019, we held title to one property located in Bethel, Ohio through a 2018 foreclosure process with an outstanding balance of $114,632"
"The business of making loans to churches and other non-profit religious organizations is highly competitive. We compete with a wide variety of investors and other lenders, including banks, insurance companies, pension funds and fraternal organizations which may have investment objectives similar to our own. A number of these competitors have greater financial resources, larger staffs and longer operating histories than we do. We compete principally by limiting our business "niche" to lending to churches and other non-profit religious organizations, offering loans with competitive and flexible terms, and emphasizing our expertise in the specialized industry segment of lending to churches and other religious organizations. Our competitive “specialty” is in offering fixed-rate, long-term loans, which few of our competitors make available to churches."
1) The loan officers were good people, with the borrowers' best interest in mind.
2) The headache would have been substantial.
3) They really are in the loan business, not the foreclosure business.
The loan officers were trying hard to understand how the proffered deal wouldn't kill the borrower's company.
If I ever need a loan that falls into their scope, I'm calling them first.
Italy suspended mortgage payments during their lockdown and (correctly, IMO) forced banks to bear some of the financial burden of the economy grinding to a halt. It’s certainly less likely for the US to pass a similar measure but it’s entirely possible that banks could be required to do significantly more “rehabilitation” on defaulted home loans than they have in the past. That’s an expensive undertaking for a bank even in the best of economic times.
While that's one possible reason for this decision, there are other possible reasons. For example, they may not know how future "payment suspensions" will be handled (https://update.wf.com/coronavirus/home-lending/), may not like it (particularly with HELOCs that they keep on their books, unlike most mortgages), and/or may not want the reputation damage or headache of foreclosing on collateral (even if it would cover the debt). Any of those could completely explain this.
Under basically no point does Wells Fargo want to foreclose on a house. They will get pennies on the dollar for it independent of macro price differences.
So in analyzing risks a 10% increase in foreclosures is going to weigh dramatically more than a 10% decrease in home values.
I remembered this: https://www.theguardian.com/business/us-money-blog/2016/oct/...
"disclosed that it would fork over $185m in penalties to regulators after an audit discovered that employees opened as many as 2m deposit and credit accounts in customers’ names but without their consent"
But do agree, however much of the market is driven by such actions and if they are right or wrong, their move will make it more inclined to happen than had they made no such move. Which is an aspect that plays out in many financial markets in various forms.
I really doubt that. Home values are high in urban areas because of high demand and low supply. The buyers are actually qualified and can afford to pay their mortgages. Mortgages are not being handed out like candy like they were in 2008.
Right now the situation is kind of the inverse of 2008. In 2008, a recession triggered mass job loss. Today, mass job loss resulting from the virus lockdowns has triggered a recession. No bubble burst.
I would bet Wells Fargo is more worried about people who are otherwise creditworthy suddenly being unable to make payments because they lost their jobs, or the government suspending payments. In a situation like this, credit history is not very useful in evaluating risk.
While what triggered this is different, because one has a direct impact on the other the OP is still right about the housing bubble IMO.
Trigger (virus) --> mass job layoff in directly affected industries (e.g. travel) --> recession --> more job losses in second order affected industries (e.g. advertising, food supply) etc. ... --> ultimately impacting asset prices like houses which grew too much too fast
If the government is guaranteeing one type of residential real estate loan and not the other it makes no sense for a bank to offer the one that isn’t guaranteed when they can just pursue practically risk free lending.
First lien mortgages get the house. Second lien gets whatever's left over, and guaranteed that the process is painful.
Chase did the same thing a while back, for the same reasons.
We may absolutely be in for a housing market correction because of COVID's impact on consumer cash flow and its impact on the housing market.
Maybe you're just referring to the last handful of months? In that case, I think it's sort of nuanced (we didn't know exactly how long shutdowns would be needed or how significant the impact would be in early February, certainly) but maybe reasonable.
I don't believe this supports the idea that there was a bubble prior to COVID (say, February or March 2020 for the US).
Home value increases have not been particularly steady. And to the extent there is a sustained effect, it is in part due to long-standing government priority of individual home ownership, implemented in a policy of subsidizing home ownership, and in part due to concentration of jobs and people in cities as part of a labor shift.
Edit: almost_unusual makes a good remark that some locales are probably in bubbles and others not; it's something specific to any given region rather than some sweeping statement about the national market.
"AirBNB or something like it will exist in 2 years."
"Monetary policy will not begin to dry up the glut of cash which has objectively ballooned asset prices since 2008."
"Covid will not permanently change certain habits which would otherwise cause a devaluation of property in major cities."
"Some major economic entity will not collapse in the next 2 years."
>it is in part due to long-standing government priority of individual home ownership
This strikes me as a commonly-bandied, well-debunked talking point.
> [remarks on US promotion of homeownership] strikes me as a commonly-bandied, well-debunked talking point.
Please provide a "debunking" of the idea that the US government does not explicitly prioritize, as a matter of policy, and subsidize, home ownership. Here are some facts that run counter to that idea:
1. The US literally has a "National Home Ownership Month" (it's June).
2. The mission statement of HUD's Office of Housing includes "Maintain and expand homeownership."
3. FHA loans.
4. Mortgage interest deduction on primary residences.
5. Capital gains exemption on (a large portion of) primary residence sales.
>Here are some facts that run counter to that idea:
Well, first, I'd like to see facts that actually run counter to that idea. What you've shown is that the government supports and promotes home-ownership for a portion of the population. They don't prove that the government prioritizes home ownership over other policy that could be contributing to asset value increases - say, signals to our national bank to manipulate the money supply. One way to check would be to compare the amount of funding vested in pro-home ownership policy to the amount related to the aforementioned.
Suffice it to say, I'd love the government to invest in the average American to the degree that they've invested in the people who can most directly access the benefits of liberal monetary policy.
I think there is a lot of speculation about the Bay Area and SF being in a bubble due to high prices. The demand is still there though and it’s actually grown quite a bit in recent weeks ( SF specifically ).
Cities with a lot of service and factory workers will see a larger correction.
If lots of people were buying 1BR condos because they saw a profit opportunity arbitraging the difference in rent vs. mortgage payments, then a small drop in rents might mean that a large number of people can't make their mortgage payments. That's a big problem, because it implies a foreclosure wave that'll put further downward pressure on prices.
Luckily, or not depending on how you look at it, SF properties and rents tend to be fairly predictable as compared to other markets in large part due to the artificial supply constraints imposed by city council, and the huge demand of the tech industry which tends to weather downturns pretty well. If you can afford $4500/month in rent for a 1 bedroom, chances are you're not going to be fired first.
A similar unit is on HotPads renting for $4500/month (https://hotpads.com/855-folsom-street-san-francisco-ca-94107...).
So with 20% down, 30 Year Fixed, 3.905% Interest, you're paying $3353 in mortgage, $903 in taxes, $605 in HOA and $163 in homeowners insurance. Set aside 1%/year for damages and repairs - $74/mth. (total $5100).
66% of your mortgage in the first year and all those fees are tax deductible, so you can deduct a total of $3900/month. [2] Depending on your tax bracket you can expect to get back $1500.
So your total expenses ($5100) minus tax deductions ($1500) is $3600/month, and it's renting for $4500. You could realize $900 free cash flow, assuming you're a well paid tech worker. Not to mention you'd have your renter building equity in your unit for you -- another $1106/month. Depending on how you account for that, your monthly realized profit could be about $2000.
NOTE: That's after-tax cash flow, which is the model I went with when I was running numbers on my own unit, and it depends on your tax bracket. I picked pretty generous numbers so YMMV.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanley_Saitowitz
[2] https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...
[*] I doubt that you can rent such a unit at 4,500. Its well above market, so it either has high rotation or high closing costs. Also really hope the US cleans up their act with their tax policies on housing.
Remember 20%-down mortgages are 5X leveraged investments in real-estate so even a 1% appreciation in the underlying works out to a ~5% ROI. To the extent they break even on rental I could easily see why they'd rather take the appreciation.
OpenDoor would have a heck of a time in SF, buying units sight-unseen. On the one hand it would be lower risk thank Phoenix, but it would tie up an ungodly amount of capital.
Re [*]: Totally. $4,500 is a lot, no question, though in it's favor units at 855 come with deeded parking -- in the building, which is ~$300/month in extra value for downtown condos. They're also new, super-modern lofts, and quite large, and SOMA lofts are very reasonable on a $/sqft level. 10 minutes walk to the IG and FB buildings too. I think factoring in all the +'s it's not uncompetitive with similar units nearby without parking in the low 4000's range.
The big advancements in tech happened in the mid-20th century with suburban developments that made construction into something of a factory, on site.
In recent years, there have been a few startups trying to make a factories for multi family housing. The idea is to construct modules in a remote factory where you can drive economies of scale, and workers have consistent schedules with steady employment. Then ship modules to the site and stack the blocks in a tiny amount of time to minimize disruption.
Traditional construction management is some absolutely hellish logistics, involving all sorts of waiting for just the right contractor, and everybody carrying risk in weird ways. It's amazing that anything even gets built.
And then the planning stage is even more hellish, especially in places with high cost of construction like California. Only single-family-home builds have any sort of guarantee that if you meet code and zoning, you will be allowed to build. For any thing that is more affordable, like townhomes or apartments, the political process takes priority over the planning department. California cities are also completely cash strapped because of insane unfair property tax breaks for old wealth, meaning that impact and permit fees can easily eat of 10%-25% of the entire project cost. And that's after huge expense of re-planning many times according to community and politician whim, and it only takes a tiny number of housing opponents to force builders into a game of multi-year delays to try to stop all development, by running out the clock on financing that was secured to begin the whole process.
All this is to say is that our housing problems are, at the moment, a political problem much akin the US's healthcare problems. Intractable conflicts between entrenched interests prevent common sense wins for everybody. Technology can seem like a solution (e.g. EHRs) but seldom have any impact, either positive or negative.
The only thing that got us through was that we already had an equity line open and once open, it’s just like a low interest credit card. You don’t pay anything for it if it’s not being used but having it available provides a big emergency buffer.
It’s the primary reason I tell everyone to put down 20% on your home because as soon as you do that, you don’t pay PMI and you qualify for HELOC.
Not saying you're wrong, it's just I don't see what kind of dynamics would lead to that kind of thing, where the economic situation drastically changes to the point where they won't make new HE loans but will gladly honor anyone's exercise of an existing HELOC on (mostly) the same terms they had before.
I could understand if HELOC approval locked in some duration under which the bank couldn't back out, but I don't see why banks would grant such optionality either.
The risks for the bank are the same risk with any type of loan. The difference here is that it’s secured against the home. I believe the max limit on it is 80% of the equity that you have in the home. Applying for an increase is the same as applying for an entirely new loan.
Just think about how many things can happen over a 15-30 year mortgage.
One is incomes. It’s quite plausible that defaults in a year or three will turn out to be extremely uncorrelated with today’s credit scores.
The second one is interest rates, which are spectacularly low.
Those two things combined make it very hard to predict how much profit a line of credit type product will be able to produce.
I think home values are not the point, and all real estate is local, so there is no national bubble. People just want to babble about bubbles because that's all they learned from 2008 is to repeat the word. Or they live in some crazy place like SF or Vancouver.
People also said the same thing about Washington Mutual. And about Bear Stearns.
This is so comically untrue. Giant companies with forcefields of cash, lobbyists and corporate analysts make stupid panic-based decisions all the time. There are chaotic political battles, unilateral decisions made because one executive had a pouty fit over what another executive did, huge layoffs, price changes, project shutdowns, all based on emotions, political favors, vendettas, etc.
It’s the rule. The clean, well-supported decision that came from analysts with statistical rigor is the exception by far. The larger and more bureaucratic the company, the more extremely tilted towards politics it becomes.
These decisions are rarely punished by the market due to regulatory capture, bailouts, outright fraud, etc. which essentially occur continually for most large companies with no meaningful consequences, even when these acts are completely overt and public.
May I mention how absolutely insane is the richest person has more wealth than that?
I think there's some ambiguity in the idea that something people repeat is actually a "widely held viewpoint".
Saying it's bizarre seems to me to be standard shorthand for "if you really think about the implications, which people usually don't".
So-called "ideas" or "viewpoints" are more fit in an evolutionary sense the less people think about them while transmitting them.
Catching up here (original commenter). Your take is spot on as to what I meant. (Probably my fault for being unclear)
I'm not convinced that their strategy is necessarily sound and unbiased or representative of the knowledge base they command.
EDIT: My apologies, I was mistaken. They settled for $175 million. You can remove your downvotes now.
https://www.startribune.com/wells-fargo-pays-175-million-in-...
https://consumerist.com/5283290/affidavits-on-how-wells-farg...
Remember that Wells Fargo is the 26th largest corporation in the world. They have plenty of money. They have lots of smart people (insert your "stupid banker" joke here) working for them. They have lots of highly-paid analysts that make these decisions. These are not spur-of-the-moment, panic-induced decisions. Wells Fargo also has a lot of experience with home values and mortgages, by being the largest Home Mortgage provider in the US (by dollar value), with $126B in home loans [1].
Long story short, they are experienced in home values and mortgages and they have a lot riding on them. They have smart people that have looked at the current and future state of home values and decided, that despite the potential revenue that could be generated from Home Equity Lines, there is too much risk in offering this product and they will stop offering it until further notice.
That's a big deal. Wells Fargo is leaving lots of money on the table by NOT offering these. But their analysts have decided that it is too risky. That to me, means that there is a lot of concern over future home value. We have been living in a housing bubble for a while. We all know it, Wells Fargo knew it, and this could be a signal that at least Wells Fargo is concerned that the bubble might be popping.
(I personally hate Wells Fargo, but did have a Home Mortgage through them until about 3 months ago when I sold my last home. I wouldn't borrow from them again however. This isn't a fanboy piece, but it is important to acknowledge their strengths when looking at signals like this).
[1] - https://www.housingwire.com/articles/41539-here-are-the-top-...