News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by ISL on Saturday May 02, 2020 @01:22PM (#23053298)
I don't see this as a direct bet against home values, but rather a bet against employment and on turmoil.

WF may be seeing tons of applications for home equity lines in order to backstop failing households. If they're not sure that they'll get paid back, then WF won't want to make the loan.

I once was involved with corporate loan negotiations where the lender could have easily taken the borrower up on a proffered deal, but the fate of the borrower's company would have been sealed on the day the loan was signed. The terms were such that the borrower's odds of being able to repay the loan were <10% and the collateral requirements were at least twice the loan amount. The lender would have roughly doubled their money at the expense of a headache, but chose to walk away instead. The borrower would have taken the deal at almost any price. In the lender's words, "We're in the loan business, we want to make loans where people can pay interest."

My thank-you letter to the lender for walking away was one of the first they'd ever received.

Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by dehrmann on Saturday May 02, 2020 @02:29PM (#23053827)
It's a bet against home values if Wells is worried they wouldn't be able recoup the value of the loan if the borrower default. Alternatively, they're worried that the government will block foreclosures, so they'd rather not load out money they can't recoup, and they'll take their chances with insolvent homeowners sooner rather than later.
Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by ashtonkem on Saturday May 02, 2020 @02:30PM (#23053831)
Home price and labor value are closely tied under most circumstances. If lots of the population loses the ability to pay their mortgages, one would expect home value to drop as fewer can afford to buy foreclosed or distressed property.

As a large mortgage provider, home prices are the best tool that WF has to hedge against large changes in labor value.

Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by rcpt on Saturday May 02, 2020 @07:09PM (#23055605)
I think that's a bit idealized. When the price-rent ratio is high, like now and in every other housing bubble, home values detach from labor as they're driven mostly by speculation.
Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by ashtonkem on Saturday May 02, 2020 @07:23PM (#23055678)
Any rational discussion about price relationships should include a “bubbles excluded” caveat.
Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by omgwtfbyobbq on Saturday May 02, 2020 @01:34PM (#23053412)
They may also lack confidence in their ability to foreclose on homes with delinquent HELOCs.
Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by RhysU on Saturday May 02, 2020 @07:44PM (#23055768)
And the resale value of the foreclosed home would be lower too. Good collateral is important.
Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by anoncareer0212 on Saturday May 02, 2020 @02:28PM (#23053814)
I can't parse from this why you'd turn down a 100% return - it sounds like the implication is the headache of collecting is too annoying, but that's not a very rational approach
Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by caseysoftware on Saturday May 02, 2020 @03:06PM (#23054085)
Potentially two reasons:

- First is the moral/ethical reason - it doesn't matter your religion or lack thereof, causing someone to crash and burn, causing unemployment, and generally ruining lives is bad.

- Second is their business. Banks are in the lending business. Unless the collateral was cash or stocks (unlikely based on explanation), they'd have to figure out how to repossess and then dispose of the assets. Yes, they probably have a group that handles that sort of thing but you're introducing unnecessary headaches.

Either way, walking away sounds like the right and good call.

Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by nostrademons on Saturday May 02, 2020 @04:34PM (#23054696)
There's also risk involved in taking possession of collateral. If you've written a loan such that collateral is 2x the loan amount, but then all potential buyers of the collateral fall on similar hard times such that you have to sell it at 10 cents on the dollar, then you've still lost 80% of your loan value. Prices aren't static, and they reflect what's going on in the market at any given moment. If the market basically evaporates right as your loan comes due, then the value of your collateral isn't what it was when the loan was written, it was what it is when the loan defaults.
Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by caseysoftware on Saturday May 02, 2020 @04:58PM (#23054855)
Good point. I bet that "prime retail space" in January is looking more like a liability than an asset right now. Thanks for getting me to be more pessimistic. ;)
Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by ashtonkem on Saturday May 02, 2020 @07:51PM (#23055804)
Retail real estate doesn’t look anything like home real estate financially, which is why it does “weird” things compared to homes, such as leaving units empty for months in desirable areas.

The core of it is how commercial real estate is financed; it’s financed on a rolling basis rather than a 1 time mortgage, like a home. This means that rather than revenue most commercial real estate owners are more concerned about what their next financing round will look like. For reasons I cannot explain, bankers care less about the rent a building does receive than they care about the rent it could receive. This incentivizes building owners to leave units empty rather than lower rates, as it actually ends up significantly cheaper for them in the long run.

Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by perl4ever on Saturday May 02, 2020 @09:42PM (#23056243)
"it doesn't matter your religion or lack thereof"

Bet you didn't know this, but there is a company (an REIT actually) that is publicly traded on the stock market, that specializes in loans to nonprofit religious organizations..."American Church Mortgage Company". Currently appear to be paying a sizable dividend.

"The outbreak of the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) has adversely affected many industries in general and resulted in orders preventing congregation which impacts the ability of churches and other non-profit religious organizations normal methods of worship...To the extent that churches and other non-profit organizations operations in the U.S. are materially and adversely affected by the coronavirus, business and financial results of this industry, and thus our business and financial results, could be materially and adversely impacted."

...and yes, they do foreclose on churches:

"As of December 31, 2019, we had ten first mortgage loans totaling approximately $4,074,000 that are three or more monthly payments in arrears. We may incur a loss if these borrowers are unable to bring their payments current and we are compelled to foreclose on their properties. We may be unable to dispose of the foreclosed properties on terms that enable us to recoup our expenses and outstanding balances.

As of December 31, 2019, we held title to one property located in Bethel, Ohio through a 2018 foreclosure process with an outstanding balance of $114,632"

"The business of making loans to churches and other non-profit religious organizations is highly competitive. We compete with a wide variety of investors and other lenders, including banks, insurance companies, pension funds and fraternal organizations which may have investment objectives similar to our own. A number of these competitors have greater financial resources, larger staffs and longer operating histories than we do. We compete principally by limiting our business "niche" to lending to churches and other non-profit religious organizations, offering loans with competitive and flexible terms, and emphasizing our expertise in the specialized industry segment of lending to churches and other religious organizations. Our competitive “specialty” is in offering fixed-rate, long-term loans, which few of our competitors make available to churches."

https://www.marketwatch.com/investing/stock/acmc

Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by ISL on Saturday May 02, 2020 @02:37PM (#23053890)
I think there were three reasons:

1) The loan officers were good people, with the borrowers' best interest in mind.

2) The headache would have been substantial.

3) They really are in the loan business, not the foreclosure business.

Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by Optimal_Persona on Saturday May 02, 2020 @04:07PM (#23054512)
4) They couldn't see a way to make money by fraudulently opening millions of fake accounts in the process.
Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by ISL on Saturday May 02, 2020 @04:34PM (#23054702)
I was in the room. 4) wasn't a factor.

The loan officers were trying hard to understand how the proffered deal wouldn't kill the borrower's company.

If I ever need a loan that falls into their scope, I'm calling them first.

Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by ashtonkem on Saturday May 02, 2020 @07:53PM (#23055812)
In one case, WF cared about the customer. Given that they literally got caught perpetuating one of the largest consumer banking frauds in human history, forgive me if I don’t trust them to do the right thing consistently.
Re:Wells Fargo temporarily suspending applications for home-... by jhayward on Saturday May 02, 2020 @02:39PM (#23053900)
I think the question is one of ethics or morals, and not predation.