News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by jjtheblunt on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:22PM (#23009338)
How was $1000/month for anyone over age 18 supposed to be funded?

Without exact details answering such, do voters believe this is more than seeking voter-attention. Are there actual plans of implementation whose economics/numbers work?

I see people discuss such but never see answers.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by cultus on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:26PM (#23009399)
The same way we are funding massive corporate bailouts. Sovereign government debt does not work like personal debt, for the simple reason that money can be printed. Fears of inflation in a time like this are completely unwarranted.

edit: Back of the envelope math shows that 1000/month for the US population is about $4 trillion/year. The Fed has pumped more than that into financial markets since this pandemic has started, alone. That is why the S&P is back up to where it was in 2018, despite the world suffering the greatest demand shock in history. Pumping up the financial markets is doing nowhere near the economic good that a UBI would right now.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by throwaway894345 on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:28PM (#23009418)
Why are they completely unwarranted? I'm not an economist, so it's not obvious to me why printing money wouldn't lead create an inflation problem that is worse than the unemployment problem. I would be very interested to know the details that allow us to say such things so confidently.

EDIT: Thanks to those who provided such insightful answers! Very helpful for a layperson like me.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by zhte415 on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:36PM (#23009540)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equation_of_exchange

The velocity has dropped rapidly in recent weeks. To not increase supply would be deflationary.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by cultus on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:39PM (#23009585)
It's completely unwarranted because you essentially can't have inflation in a depression. There isn't enough demand competing for supply to raise prices. That is why governments and central banks usually try to inject money into the economy in lean times, and take it out to keep it from overheating. It's the basis of essentially all macroeconomic management.

The real danger in times of low demand is a deflationary spiral. Those are fiendishly hard to get out of, as the last few decades for Japan have demonstrated.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by guerrilla on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:44PM (#23009653)
Inflation is caused by "too many dollars chasing too few goods" not literal money printing. The demand for basic goods as needs are going unmet is actually pretty high. A lot of the printed money would actually go to paying off debt and thus actually destroying money.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by xur17 on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:28PM (#23009417)
I agree that worries of inflation are unwarranted (if anything we are at risk of deflation), but what happens after the economy returns? Aren't we at risk of inflation from all of the new money dumped into the economy?
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by cultus on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:42PM (#23009629)
We'll have to wait and see. If it winds up being too much government spending to avoid inflation, then taxes would have to be raised to cut down the inflation. I don't think this would be such a bad thing, since the income redistribution would be a benefit anyway.

My guess is that it wouldn't cause much inflation, since much of the demand destruction we've seen will be permanent.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by guerrilla on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:47PM (#23009700)
US consumer debt is exceptionally high [1]. This was true long before the pandemic. There is plenty of demand for money on the books and the underclass has a long way to catch up even after that.

1. https://www.thebalance.com/consumer-debt-statistics-causes-a...

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by LaEc on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:54PM (#23009789)
If inflationary pressures get to high, the Fed will raise the Fed Funds rate, affecting the market interest rates, incentivizing saving, decreasing inflationary pressures.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by pxue on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @06:10PM (#23012748)
QE is not magically injecting trillions into the economy. Feds really don’t give a shit about the economy of dinners and rents of the little people. They care about macro employment rates. Shit, we could have a country 100% employment rate and people can’t pay rent, feds would still be patting themselves on the back for a job well done.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by legitster on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:37PM (#23009561)
The Fed did not just print money - it added liquidity into the market via long term term obligations or asset swaps.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by cultus on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:59PM (#23009854)
That's money that wasn't in the economy before that is now. They are growing their balance sheet with bonds and other assets, and paying for it with money they make.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:48PM (#23009709)
Isn't that the approach that Venezuela took? To me, any proposal to fund UBI by printing money has to explain why Venezuela failed, and how the new proposal is different in a way that matters.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by bsanr2 on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @05:05PM (#23012014)
Venezuela - and, frankly, the rest of the world - is reliant on monetary policy set by outside parties, who can also impose explicit (import/export) and de facto (loan terms) sanctions should their political positioning be undesirable.

How much does the US government subsidize the average US citizen in services, tax rebates, etc.? Is it more or less than what Venezuela offered its citizens in cash payments? I honestly don't know, but I've become more convinced lately that Venezuela's issues have less to do with the efficacy of their policies than they do objections to the nature of their intended distribution of wealth.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by LaEc on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:52PM (#23009761)
The Fed is lending money to prevent a financial crisis, not simply giving it away. Look back at the 2008 crisis and see that the government actually profited significantly from issuing those debts in the long term.

UBI is a giveaway not a loan.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by toomuchtodo on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:57PM (#23009821)
UBI is a generous tax credit. The Fed is printing money by their lending operations, devaluing the dollar in the process.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by cultus on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @02:04PM (#23009905)
Six of one, half a dozen of the other. The difference is that Fed injections benefit the wealthy, and a UBI benefits the poor most. This is not inflationary, since we are in a depression. As far as devaluing the dollar versus other currencies, everyone else is creating tons of money as well. I'd really welcome a dollar devaluation, actually, to help with our trade deficit.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by toomuchtodo on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @02:07PM (#23009926)
No argument from me! It's all just spreadsheet economics, with everyone attempting to shape the narrative to meet their ideology.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by LaEc on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @02:09PM (#23009940)
Let us assume that your concerns about devaluation come true. Let us say that Poor Man has $10,000 and Rich Man has $10,000,000. Devaluation of dollar by 10% means poor man loses $1,000 and Rich man loses $1,000,000.

Who loses out more under devaluation?

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by vkou on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @02:31PM (#23010223)
Poor man typically doesn't have $10,000, what they have is $10,000 and a $200,000 debt.

And not all inflation is created equal. With QE, the printed dollars never make it to Main street, they end up inflating asset prices, while the price of butter stays the same. Whether that's a good thing is an exercise for the reader.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by Reedx on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:27PM (#23009407)
Answers: https://www.yang2020.com/what-is-freedom-dividend-faq/

He also talked about the actual implementation a lot during the campaign.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by olivermarks on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:33PM (#23009506)
After Yang ran out of money to campaign (sic) and joined CNN, Tulsi Gabbard vowed to continue the UBI efforts (which she had also previously championed) with a proposed bill on March 12th as Direct Coronavirus Pandemic Relief.

The DNC old guard, who mostly ignored Yang and ostracized and smeared Gabbard now seem to be slowly grasping some of these ideas and seeing how they could be tetrised into their status quo without disturbing too much...

https://gabbard.house.gov/news/press-releases/rep-tulsi-gabb...

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by jonahbenton on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @02:10PM (#23009969)
In general Andrew intended that proposal to re-orient the conversation about spending priorities and service delivery.

In concrete terms, Andrew proposed a VAT, while also reorganizing existing social welfare programs, of which there are uncountable multitudes, each with highly specific eligibility requirements and screening and fraud machinery, into a more coherent, holistic delivery model that de-prioritized or eliminated eligibility.

His numbers "work" but at that scale they entail such an enormous reworking of federal and state machinery that they're in practical terms a non-starter. Cue up recent conversations about M4A, Obamacare, etc, but on an even larger scale. (disclaimer: I support the idea, but appreciate it is more conceptual value than concrete implementation.)

Right now, Fed govt takes in $3.8 trillion in revenues, mostly taxes, spends $4+ trillion, with two thirds of fiscal dollars going to human-oriented mandatory programs like social security, medicare, medicaid, various federally funded insurance programs, etc and one third going to discretionary, which itself is half military, then half everything else.

A VAT would essentially be a transaction tax that scaled to GDP, so from a model perspective, while GDP is $20T, a VAT would bring in $2T of new revenues, sufficient to begin a conversation about giving $10k/year to 200,000,000 people. In reality- who knows. A VAT would have huge implications and lots and lots of things would change.

A lot of the comments center around credit dollars that the Fed has created- basically large scale loans- to provide transitory liquidity to the financial system. Those comments misunderstand the nature of credit dollars, but IMHO they are not wrong. Credit dollars are a completely different tool than the above fiscal dollars generated from taxes. The US government has essentially infinite credit capacity.

To my eyes credit dollars are both a better and more appropriate funding source for something like UBI, particularly if UBI is tweaked to focus on the liquidity needs of children, women, and those whose current fiscal value is low relative either to future value or to the fiscal value of others. I would love Pelosi to consider that as a concrete option, the politics seem ideal for it.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by petermcneeley on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:36PM (#23009543)
Its called redistribution. I understand and appreciate that that answer is not palatable to many people but that is the clear answer.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by missedthecue on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:48PM (#23009710)
Even if you took all the money from all the billionaires, and we're assuming frictionless transaction and 100% liquidity, you can't afford it for more than a couple years. The money just runs out.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by petermcneeley on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @02:15PM (#23010027)
USA gpd per capita is ~60k a year right? And your saying 12k per year per capita is impossible?
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by missedthecue on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @02:29PM (#23010191)
It's certainly possible to tax the average person $1050 monthly in order to pay that average person $1000 every month, but i really just don't see the point. There are just not enough rich people to transfer $2.5 trillion from annually.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by petermcneeley on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @03:43PM (#23010969)
I think your arguing against some position that I am not even suggesting. You think im saying "if we took the money of billionaires we would have enough to give the whole country 1k/month forever"

Im suggesting that there is enough money when you think in totality so this is merely a question of how comfortable you are with redistribution. Your saying 2.5 trillion annually; ok thats only like 12% of GDP. It is also completely logical that in the 21 century that only about 10% of value generated is enough to keep everyone fed clothed and sheltered.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by missedthecue on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @03:50PM (#23011061)
You're saying redistribution. Meaning taking money from people with more to give to people with less. (I assume youre not just talking about moving figures around but leaving everyone with the same amount in the end).

I'm saying there are not enough people with more than people less to provide that $12,000 transfer to each person in a way that benefits most people.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by petermcneeley on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @04:29PM (#23011564)
https://www.statista.com/statistics/203183/percentage-distri...

If you just took 20% of people making over 150k it would be enough to give 1k a month to the bottom 50%. (and yes i understand this is household)

And this of course is the silly idea that your giving people making 50k a year 12k more for some reason. This also doesnt include the real money up at the top top end. It also doesnt include any wealth transfers (scary)

I think (with respect) you just dont realize how much wealth is out there.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by missedthecue on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @06:16PM (#23012813)
But UBI doesnt only pay those making less than the median
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by petermcneeley on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @07:28PM (#23013397)
Sure but using any definition you want at some point you will be at the end of the distribution that will be contributing not gaining from UBI. This function could be described as a graduated income tax. (Sure on your tax form you might be getting 12k a year in but your getting like 30k going out for UBI)

I think you are describing some system that is sorta some sorta economically inconsistent plan. Everyone gets 1k a month and nobody pays for it doesnt make economic sense.

The people that push UBI dont think in these illogical ways. They know very well that some people will have to pay for it. Some people wont see any gain. And some people will see gain.

Your confused about how this system is a win for everyone. Its not! Thats what I said at top ; its redistributive.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by missedthecue on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @07:57PM (#23013619)
Yes but there aren't enough people that can contribute to make it cause much sense to implement. The following is a graph distributed by Andrew Yang's campaign. (The most popular proponent of UBI)

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EQi8jWpWkAMQ_5d?format=jpg&name=...

Examine that graph and you'll clearly see you're taking $500 billion from net contributers and paying out $1.55 trillion to net beneficiaries. AND THIS IS ACCORDING TO HIS OWN CAMPAIGN. He's literally planning to pay out 3x what he's taking in.

In the fine print he admits that he has to pay for it with "future economic growth", i.e. debt. (you cant pay out cash for something now by hoping the economy grows in the future, it's physically impossible... you need debt to bridge the gap)

But explain to me how taking $1050 from the average person in order to pay $1000 to the average person grows GDP?

The simple fact of the matter is that this cannot be achieved without perhaps scrapping every other social program (Medicare, medicaid, social security) AND raising taxes in addition.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by petermcneeley on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @10:47AM (#23019895)
I agree this sounds a bit odd. So we at least agree that america has a great deal of wealth. Certainly enough that if it really wanted to support its citizens with basic essentials it could. This kind of ubi is welfare or EI with no strings attached. This is a neutral statement about the health of the economy.

The policies of say Yang are not that interesting as for the most part he isnt really talking redistribution and I think he himself is ideologically opposed to it.

How I tend to think about the economy is very much like a game. If you have played say a game like "Banished" (https://store.steampowered.com/app/242920/Banished/) you can see how the economy works without the notions of money/debt/politics. Obviously it doesnt represent the real economy but it comes close to getting a taste. If you send me your Steam ID I will buy you a copy.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by throwaway287391 on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:26PM (#23009401)
Yang proposed to fund it using a 10% VAT, which just about works out to the right amount if you assume you can enforce the VAT on the entire $20T US GDP. I doubt Pelosi has made a concrete funding proposal. (Edit: I answered specifically about Yang's/Pelosi's funding proposals because I thought that was what parent asked -- not sure if I'm crazy or they edited their post.)
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by jjtheblunt on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:43PM (#23009643)
Thanks for doing that; i edited the post realizing several had spoken of such.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by therealdrag0 on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:24PM (#23009370)
What are the options? - Taxes - Debt - Money printing
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by mister_hn on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:29PM (#23009427)
By really applying taxation to rich?
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by war1025 on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:50PM (#23009733)
In almost all instances, the readership of this site would count under "the rich" for the purposes of government programs.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by ardy42 on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @03:30PM (#23010838)
> In almost all instances, the readership of this site would count under "the rich" for the purposes of government programs.

However, there are different degrees of "rich" (which, if you want to quibble, can include things like having a yard full of chickens and plenty of time to read [1]). The taxes to pay for expanded social benefits should fall progressively across that whole range.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RBHZFYpQ6nc

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by xyzzyz on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:42PM (#23009623)
What’s your definition of “rich” for purposes of funding UBI? How much exactly do you want to tax those rich? How much money do you expect to extract?

These are ideas seldom entertained by UBI proponents, because as soon as they are seriously considered, it becomes clear that there aren’t even nearly enough rich to pay everyone $1000 a month.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by mister_hn on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @03:33AM (#23016443)
mmm..someone that earns more than $150K/200K per year?
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by basch on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @03:38PM (#23010921)
Or a tax on natural resources, extracted from America. Instead of a few people owning the mineral rights to everything underneath the country, you make American oil, coal, natural gas, sunlight, wind, nuclear energy something the people own. It's something that already happens in part of America, and it works in Europe. Supplement it with a VAT on luxury items above a certain threshold (yachts, jewelry, property) and a sin tax against sugar and other drugs. Cap it off by replacing agriculture subsidies with the tax break + a "heath discount" on the purchase end of the transaction.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaska_Permanent_Fund

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_Pension_Fund_of_Nor...

I would even advocate taking it a step further, and replacing HSA's and Social Security with individual savings accounts, a la Singapore. Approved purchases (up to a certain amount of rent, food stamps like foods, medical expenses) qualify for tax free or subsidized purchase (this is mostly psychological, giving people a "discount" vs depositing more money in their account, but it can also steer their behavior.) The government invests a certain amount in each person, and then they can contribute an additional amount from payroll. Segregate the money into two tiers, allow money in the "long term" side of the account to grow through some kind of investment, but minimize or eliminate the choice of how it is invested. Cap per year spending on everything except medical. Make it closer to a CD than SP500 investment. Everybody gets the same glide, per a single factor such as age or retirement date. Returns are guaranteed. Allow certain penalized/taxed hardship withdrawls.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Central_Provident_Fund

Plan: America First Sovereign Fund (mineral/luxury/sin tax), deposits into Forced Savings Account at USPS, which includes a tiered account that subtracts the qualifying part of a purchase from Savings Account, the rest gets charged to a Debit/Credit card on file. Allow the reverse, where Chase, WF, BoA, Citi can link their cards to your Savings Account, and automatically deduct qualifying purchases from it. Allow opt in for digital receipt tracking, or receipt scanning a la expensify, so you don't have to maintain records of purchases for disputes. If you use your bank card, you control what records are forwarded and stored in your USPS account.

This does five things. It pays for the program. It gives everybody some individual responsibility to manage their account, while helping them save. It steers their purchases towards healthy. It gives everyone access to a public bank account that is tax exempt. It lets them not have to manage multiple swipes at the register.

Finally, I'd advocate for a hybrid FTC/AG managed consumer protection service. Sort of a Consumer Reports / Wirecutter service on steroids that's easy for everyone to track their purchases, warranties, and to comparison shop with. A single place for product recalls, safety warnings, price comparisons, and information regarding what the best purchase to make is.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by LaEc on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @11:09PM (#23014875)
I agree with most of your ideas except energy ownership. However, as a Singaporean I have to say that Singapore has HSAs. They are called MediSave accounts and are separate from CPF although both earn interest. CPF is the retirement plan.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by basch on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @09:26AM (#23018827)
My understanding was CPF was the overarching program, Medisave was the HSA, and CPF MS was the IRA. Medisave is part of the overall CPF program.

What part of energy ownership don't you disagree with? I still wasn't advocating against private industry doing the extraction or creation. Just that if you pull something from underground, it gets taxed and benefits everybody, not just the person who bought it from the person who stole it 175 years ago.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by LaEc on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @10:36AM (#23019742)
I think we are talking at cross-purposes, but I read your comment as suggesting a single account. No one calls our IRA the CPF MS, CPF always refers to the IRA and Medisave is totally separate even if it is partly administered by the CPF board.

What is the purpose of that tax? In public finance, we don't want to unnecessarily distort incentives by picking winners and losers. Taxing natural resource extraction for no good reason chases away companies in those industries and forces them to pursue other businesses, possibly leaving only the most profitable monopolies to survive. If we want to raise revenue, why not just raise VAT, corporate tax, income tax, or property tax more generally.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by basch on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @05:10PM (#23024335)
It's not taxing the company doing the extraction, its taxing the company that owns the mineral rights (the land.) Those may likely be the same thing, but the extraction and refinement itself is still profitable.

It would be akin to the government pulling eminent domain, and saying "the oil under the country belongs to the people, not who owns the deed."

This is basically what Alaska did. They said "if you plunder our natural resources, the profit gets shared with the people whos natural resources you are plundering."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaska_Permanent_Fund

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by zabil on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:32PM (#23009484)
I don't know how the numbers work. But I also don't think the plan is one page document that can be explained to a 5 year old.

Same holds true for universal health care, social housing, subsidies etc etc. They may sound absurd in beginning but governments do implement them.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by CapriciousCptl on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:47PM (#23009688)
By the people under 18. It's worked for 2 decades now-- issue massive debt and let our children figure out how to pay it.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by vkou on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:42PM (#23009631)
By taking $950/month from the middle-class, $2000/month from the upper-middle-class, and $200 from the lower class. And a couple of million/month from billionaires. (If you can't tax the billionaires, increase all the payments above by $40/month.)

You can't squeeze enough money out of the rich to give the middle class a free ride, there's not quite enough of it, and there's too much of a middle class.

Edit:

If you really want to tax the rich, don't tax their money, tax the things they own. Land value taxes. Taxes on stocks. The purpose of doing this shouldn't be to fund a social program, but to align the prosperity of the nation with their prosperity.

If the government were a passive shareholder in ~40% of the S&P 500, then the nation as a whole would directly benefit from 40% of the returns of capitalism. If we had land value taxes, then the nation would directly benefit from the high cost of land (Which currently is nothing but a cost, and a drag on the economy, and funds all sorts of rent-seeking, unproductive uses of land.) And would skim a good slice of the rent-seeking parts of the economy.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by quaquaqua1 on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:32PM (#23009485)
I was typing out a really long response to you with many if...then statements, but then I realized there are too many powerful agencies and institutions that don't want to give up their ability to tax/spend. Medicaid/Medicare, Social Security, IRS, all 50 states etc have defined (and flawed processes) and probably will refuse to give up control over welfare spending or tax revenue generation.

So if you can't completely start from scratch, then ultimately the only source of revenue for UBI would be to cut spending somehow (good luck convincing the Pentagon of that), or to generate additional taxation on businesses (which resulted in them moving crucial facilities to Mexico, Eastern Europe, India, China, etc)

At some point, the USA might be better off if we all have a dividend for every citizen based on our country's profit, like Alaska has currently.

This way it is not a guarantee how much you will make, but it is something.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by SubiculumCode on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:44PM (#23009652)
First off, it doesn't have to be funded. We have a fiat currency. However the extent that new dollars are to be offset because of fear of inflation (not an immediate concern given current deflationary trends), the a partial offset via a VAT tax could work.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by quaquaqua1 on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @06:38PM (#23012978)
I am for a UBI. I think it should replace bureaucracy generated by all these alphabet agencies. Funding sources can all be explored.

If we dont do this, surely robots will replace most jobs.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by cheez on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:23PM (#23009351)
Yang's was well considered, I'm sure it's still on his website.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by SubiculumCode on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:41PM (#23009608)
Well if it was Andrew Yang's plan, then by a 10% VAT, and other things i.e. a carbon tax. In general, why the taxes are regressive, when paired with the UBI, the product is quite progressive.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by xyzzyz on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:44PM (#23009646)
But Yang numbers weren’t even close to adding up. Last I checked them, even if you are very optimist and assume that he’ll get exactly as much as he expects in taxes, this wouldn’t fund even half of $1000/mo.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by throwaway287391 on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:55PM (#23009793)
How do you figure? A 10% VAT would bring in $2.1T on the $21T GDP. There are about 200M adults in the US. 200M * $12K is $2.4T, which is certainly in the right ballpark.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by xyzzyz on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @08:28PM (#23013850)
Look at countries that actually have VAT. Germany for example has VAT at 19% rate, and it brings 6% of GDP to government budget. For Yang’s plan, he’d need more like 30% VAT. Of course this would be on top of already existing taxes.
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by throwaway287391 on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @09:03PM (#23014098)
Ok, but your previous post said "even if you are very optimist and assume that he’ll get exactly as much as he expects in taxes", so I was operating under that optimistic assumption. Was Yang planning to exempt any part of the GDP from his VAT? Genuine question but I didn't think he was.

Speaking of which, I googled Germany's VAT and it seems there are quite a few exemptions ("food, books, hotel accommodation, cultural services and other goods and services") that only get VATed at 7%, which is much closer to the 6% they apparently collect in practice. But sure, they probably do fail to collect quite a bit of what they theoretically could.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by xyzzyz on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @01:21AM (#23015657)
> Was Yang planning to exempt any part of the GDP from his VAT?

A lot of GDP is exempt from VAT by design. It's easiest to see if you look at the expenditure approach to GDP. For a simplest example, government expenditure is effectively exempt from VAT. Exports are VAT-exempt (though it only matters if you export more than import, because imports are subtracted in expenditure approach to GDP calculation). Another part of GDP effectively exempt from VAT is capital goods: when a business buys a piece of equipment, it technically pays VAT on it, but it also gets the same amount they paid as a credit for the VAT due on their own sales. The business gets to "consume" the capital good by utilizing it in production process, but doesn't pay any VAT for it on net.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by throwaway287391 on Wednesday April 29, 2020 @08:47AM (#23018434)
Thanks, hadn't considered any of that. The exemptions of government expenditures and exports do seem inherent to any VAT, now that you mention them, but I wouldn't think the capital goods sales credit for businesses would necessarily have to be, would it?
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by generalpass on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:26PM (#23009393)
We'll have to pass the bill to find out!
Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by mytailorisrich on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:44PM (#23009647)
They do not give answers because it is very clear with a simple calculation that this is unaffordable in addition to serving no purpose.

Giving $1000 a month to 210 million people costs $210 billion a month, $2.5 trillion a year.

I believe that the annual federal tax revenue is about $3.4 trillion.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by ardy42 on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @03:01PM (#23010518)
> They do not give answers because it is very clear with a simple calculation that this is unaffordable in addition to serving no purpose.

> Giving $1000 a month to 210 million people costs $210 billion a month, $2.5 trillion a year.

> I believe that the annual federal tax revenue is about $3.4 trillion.

If you're going to implement a UBI program (or any kind of large-scale social democratic benefits program), taxes will be increased to pay for it.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by mytailorisrich on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @03:07PM (#23010577)
"just increase taxes" does not work in the real world (especially here it would be close to doubling taxes) and still does not answer why you would want to hand money to everyone across the board.

It also sounds a little circular: Increase people's taxes so that you can use the income to give money back to them.

Re:Pelosi: It's time to consider universal basic income push... by ardy42 on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @03:34PM (#23010878)
> It also sounds a little circular: Increase people's taxes so that you can use the income to give money back to them.

Progressive taxation doesn't work that way. The whole idea is that some would pay in more than they take out; in some cases, far more.