News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by ISL on Monday April 27, 2020 @04:02PM (#22999404)
Reading the opinions, it is a breath of fresh air to see one of the branches of government relying upon fact and logical argument when discussing the issues. This is how America is supposed to work.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by btown on Monday April 27, 2020 @06:10PM (#23000698)
Reading and listening to https://www.oyez.org/ - a fantastic resource for Supreme Court transcripts - it's clear that regardless of their backgrounds and circumstances of their appointment, each justice is incredibly intelligent and engaged.

The problem is that when it comes to the really sticky, complex issues that affect huge swaths of human rights, it's very possible for justices, in your words, to "rely upon fact and logical argument," but base their end goal/optimization function on either "what did the founders of the country factually and logically intend" or "what do the norms and ideals of modern society suggest would be factually and logically sustainable" without regard to the opposite viewpoint.

A real balance between these viewpoints keeps the pendulum from swinging out of control; it serves as a low-pass filter on the often-wild steering of policy, or the whims of a short-term-focused electorate. But it's equally important that the ultimate power reside long-term with the people. And one very possible outcome is that our justices succumb simultaneously to a pandemic, during an administration that, to be as charitable as possible, does not seem particularly concerned with nuance, system stability, or universal enfranchisement. And it's a lot to ask of a justice to hold both the meta-meta-viewpoint and legal precision in mind, especially as it seems likely that constitutional questions will be in play as November approaches. All we can do is hope they will rise to the occasion.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by baybal2 on Monday April 27, 2020 @07:22PM (#23001371)
FYI: a lot of US supreme court opinions are not even written by justices, but by their law clerks and assistants. Similarly, judges deputise their legal research to them at rate that would be rather unsettling for most of us outside of US.

Anything like that would not be something expected from country's best laywers. A judge given a quarter million USD salary must be the best of the best in performance, and not to deputise his most important duties.

> it's clear that regardless of their backgrounds and circumstances of their appointment, each justice is incredibly intelligent and engaged.

I heard of much less charitable descriptions of the process, with the most frequent being about the well known mental decline of some judges.

> The problem is that when it comes to the really sticky, complex issues that affect huge swaths of human rights, it's very possible for justices, in your words, to "rely upon fact and logical argument," but base their end goal/optimization function on either "what did the founders of the country factually and logically intend" or "what do the norms and ideals of modern society suggest would be factually and logically sustainable" without regard to the opposite viewpoint.

This is one of very many problems. US court system has become too much more than just a legal institute it should be.

The point my law instructor told me was that a judge just a lawyer on the government payroll, and half of them should be sent back to the law school so bad their skill level was. Then, if you can not trust half of them with most basic judicial duties, why should you entrust them with the fate of society, moral guidance, and big matter topics?

Basically, the elites in the West tend to think too many things about lawyers, when they shouldn't.

He was a lawyer by trade, and he was not happy with society putting lawyers in charge of running itself at all.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by foxbarrington on Monday April 27, 2020 @08:05PM (#23001761)
> Anything like that would not be something expected from country's best laywers. A judge given a quarter million USD salary must be the best of the best in performance, and not to deputise his most important duties.

$250k is what 4th year lawyers at big firms like Cravath make. Partners can make 10x or more, and a lot of the work of partners is done by associates. [0]

If an associate has clerked for a supreme court justice, they can expect bonus of $400k. [1]

I don't know of a justice who has gone back to private practice, but it doesn't take too much to imagine that their salary would be much, much more than a quarter million USD.

[0]: https://abovethelaw.com/2018/06/first-firm-matches-the-new-a... [1]: https://abovethelaw.com/2018/11/400k-is-now-the-official-mar...

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by LunaSea on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @07:32AM (#23005944)
Doesn't really matter in the end.

If you accept a salary for a job you actually do the job. Period.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by sk5t on Monday April 27, 2020 @11:58PM (#23003210)
$250k is indeed not big money in DC / NYC / Boston. Consider that such a single income, after taxes, would be just about adequate to quality for a mortgage on a well-appointed toolshed in Nantucket.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by patmorgan23 on Monday April 27, 2020 @09:54PM (#23002506)
The justice still gets to decide what language and arguments make it into the final opinion. The clerks are their to take some of the load off their shoulders. The supreme court produces a lot of writing every year for nine people and they cam be very hairy technical issues, of course they have a staff to assist them in research and drafting.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by rayiner on Monday April 27, 2020 @05:32PM (#23000333)
The judicial branch is supposed to rely on facts and logical arguments. That is not how “America” writ large, however, is “supposed to work.” If that’s what the framers anticipated, they would have have had the other two branches likewise run by unelected subject matter experts with life tenure. But they didn’t.

The fact is that the world is too complicated to figure out via facts and logical analysis, and that’s why ultimate control of policy rests with elected politicians. We’re seeing this play out at a grand scale right now. In the US, classes are cancelled for the rest of the year. Meanwhile, German students went back to school a week ago. And in Sweden, lower schools were never even shut down in the first place. Logical analysis doesn’t tell you what are the appropriate trade offs between keeping the economy running and keeping people safe. What the purposes of the welfare state should be isn’t a fact waiting to be discovered through empirical methods. These are all political judgments. Even where facts and logical analysis could play a role, it often doesn’t, because experts don’t agree on often very simple facts, or the experts’ answers are too complicated to be actionable.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by harryh on Monday April 27, 2020 @07:18PM (#23001339)
Hey, you're back! Glad to see you didn't leave forever.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by rayiner on Monday April 27, 2020 @09:19PM (#23002261)
Thanks! (I didn’t quit really, just took a break from Internet forums for lent.) Hope you and your family are okay in NYC.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by harryh on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @08:29AM (#23006319)
I actually moved to Chapel Hill, NC in 2017 though I was planning to move back to NYC in June of this year. That plan is now delayed though for the obvious reason.

Fam is doing about as well as one could expect with two working parents and a 4yo stuck in the house.

Hope you and yours are holding up as well.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by rumanator on Monday April 27, 2020 @06:08PM (#23000681)
> Meanwhile, German students went back to school a week ago. And in Sweden, lower schools were never even shut down in the first place. Logical analysis

Where do you fit Italy, Spain, or even Portugal in your logica analysis? Because arguably the US is being hit harder than any of those countries and yet they are respecting their quarantine with notable results.

Meanwhile, neither Germany nor Sweden has suffered as much as neither Spain or Italy.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by rayiner on Monday April 27, 2020 @06:35PM (#23000931)
The US has not been harder but than Italy or Spain, or even Sweden.

Sweden has had 2,300 COVID-19 deaths for 10 million people. The USA has 25 times as many deaths, but 32 times the population. Indeed, American cities with similar population and density to Stockholm have far fewer deaths. Washington DC is a little smaller and has similar density, but has had 165 deaths, versus over 1,100 in Stockholm. (Deaths are doubling in both countries every two weeks, so they seem to be at similar points in their overall trajectories.)

Similarly, the death rate in the US outside of NYC is comparable to that of Germany. (NYC has no counterpart in Germany; it’s almost three times as dense as Berlin, and more than twice as tense as Munich.)

But that’s a political decision the Swedes have made, and maybe it will prove to be the right one. It could be that, in the fall, the virus resurges in places where people have been sheltering and have not developed anti-bodies, while Swedes manage to avoid that resurgence because they never shut down. No expert can tell you which way it will be. They can tell you a discrete fact (sheltering in place will save more lives than otherwise), but are in no position to plug that fact into a value framework and reach a decision. But politicians must make a decision one way or the other.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by dredmorbius on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @03:54AM (#23004642)
The folly of using linear scales to score exponential phenomena should be noted here. 32/25 is 1.28, less than one doubling interval.

Which for the US remais about 14 days (a marked imprvement over 2.14 when I first started looking at it), it's about 26 days for Italy.

When looking at exponential (or recently exponential) phenomena, rate-of-change matters vastly more than absolute value.

(And I'm not evev factoring in undercounting, testing failures,and other attempts to game the scoreboard here.)

https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/italy/

https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/us/

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by rumanator on Monday April 27, 2020 @06:55PM (#23001126)
> The US has not been harder but than Italy or Spain, or even Sweden.

You should check the facts. In the past few weeks New York alone reported more covid infections and deaths than Spain's total from the start of their outbreak, and New York has around 25% the population of Spain.

New York also has between 2 to 3 times the number of active covid cases that Spain has, which indicates the death count will only get far worse than what it already is.

> American cities with similar population and density to Stockholm

You may try to cherry pick anything, but the facts are the facts.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by rayiner on Monday April 27, 2020 @07:47PM (#23001614)
These are the facts: https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/?utm_campaign=home.... The US has had a little over twice as may deaths as Spain, but has more than six times the population.

You’re the one who is cherry picking. 97.5% of America doesn’t live in NYC. What’s going on in NYC isn’t a proxy for the USA as a whole. If you want to talk about NYC, we can do that—we could compare to Barcelona or Madrid or something similar. NYC has suffered for some reasons very specific to it. (Due to its role as an international travel hub, it is estimated that up to 100 different people started chains of infection in NYC, versus less than 10 in California). But even including NYC, the USA as a whole hasn’t been as hard hit as Sweden, much less Spain.

And excluding NYC (where, again, 97.5% of Americans live), the USA has been even less hard hit. My state is about the size of Switzerland, and has had half as many deaths.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by RobAtticus on Monday April 27, 2020 @08:01PM (#23001730)
>You may try to cherry pick anything, but the facts are the facts.

I enjoy the irony of criticizing someone for cherry-picking, while using NY as a proxy for how the whole of the US is doing.

Perhaps you could've picked the state that is most directly comparable to Spain in population and land size, California: 1/10th as many people dead per million. (But that too would be cherry-picking)

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by stx on Monday April 27, 2020 @07:54PM (#23001674)
Your ignoring population size and focusing on totals. We are talking about the USA overall. According to https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/ as of now:

Country, Deaths / 1m pop, Cases / 1m pop

USA 171, 3,045

Spain 503, 4,907

Italy 446, 3,298

Sure if you cherry pick the worst city in the US and compare it to Italy or Spain then yes you can make it look like there are more cases in the US and be technically correct but overall the US is doing better then Italy and Spain.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by sobellian on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @01:28PM (#23009425)
Fairfield County, CT has 0.77 deaths per 1000[0] which far exceeds Stockholm despite having far less population density. New Orleans also falls short and has 0.78 deaths per 1000. The US is a big country, so I think it's a mistake to look at the whole country's infection curve rather than regional infection curves. Some areas have not yet been hit hard by the virus because their region was not hit first. Hopefully with adequate public health measures their curves will never match NYC or adjacent regions.

It's also worth noting that the death curve probably has a 2-3 week lag behind the infection curve. At a 2 week doubling rate, even if you miraculously came out with a vaccine tomorrow and immunized the whole population you would still have yet to experience half of all deaths from the disease.

[0] https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/04/23/upshot/five-w...

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by matheusmoreira on Monday April 27, 2020 @04:07PM (#22999449)
You mean this is not the norm? The cases I've read seemed quite reasonable. They happened in the 90s and early 2000s though.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by tyre on Monday April 27, 2020 @04:38PM (#22999783)
I read a few case opinions per year. There are ones that are partisan but on the whole are incredibly well thought through, argued, and written.

There are some disasters, but even then you get beautiful rebuttals (e.g. Kagan's dissent in Rucho v. Common Cause)

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by golemotron on Monday April 27, 2020 @05:15PM (#23000115)
It's even more impressive when you realize that in many cases the opinions are largely researched and written by clerks.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by MiroF on Monday April 27, 2020 @06:16PM (#23000752)
I would say less impressive? Many great things can be produced by teams of what are essentially grad students.

A single person churning out brilliant opinions over decades would be more impressive to me.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by ISL on Monday April 27, 2020 @04:14PM (#22999530)
It is the norm for the Court. It's just quite contrary to much of what we see in the news daily.

This ruling split the judges in an uncommon way, which was even more welcome.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by huffmsa on Monday April 27, 2020 @04:10PM (#22999491)
There are definitely more than a few partisan court cases, but most of them are very very logical. Even when it's a partisan, ideological split.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by LiquidSky on Monday April 27, 2020 @04:21PM (#22999580)
Ha. The trick is that what's "logical" and what's "partisan" depend entirely on who is speaking, like how cries of "judicial activism" only ever arise when it's a ruling against a conservative position. If it's a ruling FOR the conservative position, it's obviously logical and sound, and possibly correcting previous evil irrational liberal decisions.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by tyre on Monday April 27, 2020 @05:10PM (#23000057)
This is an easy take if you don't follow the court. The cases that tend to get a lot of press tend to be ones with clear ideological lines.

But not every case is divided 5–4 along the line of which party nominated the justice. There are a lot of ideological currents that don't fit cleanly into political parties

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by CWuestefeld on Monday April 27, 2020 @07:08PM (#23001247)
cries of "judicial activism" only ever arise when it's a ruling against a conservative position

I saw a counterexample just this morning. An editorial was arguing that the Court's "interference" in the Michigan election threatens democracy, and the only solution is to pack the court.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by huffmsa on Monday April 27, 2020 @05:08PM (#23000036)
No, I rarely read an opinion from the high court that I can't at least understand the logic and reasoning behind, regardless of if I agree with the conclusion
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by ulkesh on Monday April 27, 2020 @04:39PM (#22999791)
It may be the norm, but they also get some completely wrong: Citizens United, for example.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by rayiner on Monday April 27, 2020 @05:34PM (#23000359)
Citizens United was obviously correct. (While it’s not dispositive, look up which side the ACLU supported in that case.)
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by ulkesh on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @12:39AM (#23003432)
The enormous amount of money now in politics clearly shows just how wrong it was. The ACLU isn’t always right, either.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by icebraining on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @10:06AM (#23007076)
The ACLU has the weird conviction that principles, not just results, matter.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by bhupy on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @11:29AM (#23007946)
First of all, the outcome doesn't speak to the Constitutionality. Maybe the Constitution, as is, doesn't produce the outcomes we want, and Article V lays out a process to amend the Constitution. The outcome of a SCOTUS decision is "wrong" insofar as it incorrectly determines the legality of something, not whether or not it produces politically unfavorable outcomes.

Second of all, in practice, the influence of money in politics is overstated.

Hillary Clinton outspent[1][2] Donald Trump by 2x in the 2016 election, and still lost. In fact, she had far more corporate backing[3][4] than Donald Trump, and still lost.

In the 2020 Democratic Primaries, Michael Bloomberg spent $1 billion[5] (!!) on his campaign, and won just 9.4% of the popular vote (1.38% of pledged delegates).

Tom Steyer (a no-name billionaire), spent $343 million[6] on his election, and won a humiliating 0.38% of the popular vote (0% of pledged delegates). Interestingly, you would think he would have at least 1/3 of Bloomberg's vote, which suggests that the vast majority of the variance in Bloomberg's vote share can be attributed to his existing name recognition as a famous businessman/politician.

Bernie Sanders spent $195 million[7] on his election, having spent less than Bloomberg + Steyer and while having handily beaten both. Joe Biden spent $105 million[8] on his campaign, less than Bernie, and still beat him by 3 million votes.

Elizabeth Warren spent $121.31 million[9] on her campaign, and also handily beat Bloomberg + Steyer while having spent far less than them, while losing to Biden while having spent more than him.

Those are just the anecdotes (of which there are many more).

Decades of research[10] suggest that money probably isn’t the deciding factor in who wins a general election, and especially not for incumbents. Most of the research in the last century found[11] that spending didn’t affect wins for incumbents and that the impact for challengers was unclear[12]. Even the studies[13] that showed spending having the biggest effect, like one that found a more than 6 percent increase in vote share for incumbents, didn’t demonstrate that money actually causes wins. In fact, those gains from spending likely translate to less of an advantage today, in a time period where voters are more stridently partisan. There are probably fewer and fewer people who are going to change their vote because they liked your ad.

So this argument is dubious both legally as well as prescriptively.

[1] https://www.opensecrets.org/pres16/candidate?id=n00000019

[2] https://www.opensecrets.org/pres16/candidate?id=n00023864

[3] https://www.opensecrets.org/pres16/contributors?id=n00000019

[4] https://www.opensecrets.org/pres16/contributors?id=n00023864

[5] https://www.opensecrets.org/2020-presidential-race/candidate...

[6] https://www.opensecrets.org/2020-presidential-race/candidate...

[7] https://www.opensecrets.org/2020-presidential-race/candidate...

[8] https://www.opensecrets.org/2020-presidential-race/candidate...

[9] https://www.opensecrets.org/2020-presidential-race/candidate...

[10] https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2605401

[11] http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0002764203260415

[12] https://www.jstor.org/stable/2138764?seq=1#metadata_info_tab...

[13] http://www.sas.rochester.edu/psc/clarke/214/Gerber98.pdf

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by bpodgursky on Monday April 27, 2020 @05:43PM (#23000459)
Whether you agree with or disagree with the Citizens United outcome, describing the majority opinion as a straightforward "completely wrong" (when, for example, the ACLU supported the verdict) indicates that you have not, in fact, read any of the opinions or dissents, or done research about the specific case that was being litigated.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by Retric on Monday April 27, 2020 @05:52PM (#23000541)
They overturned an at the time recent Supreme Court verdict, which is disruptive and counter to long standing precedent.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austin_v._Michigan_Chamber_of_...

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by rayiner on Monday April 27, 2020 @06:18PM (#23000773)
That doesn’t make a decision “wrong.” Lots of Supreme Court opinions are wrong, and often obviously so. There is nothing wrong with overruling them.

Citizens United was an instance of the government sliding down a slippery slope of precedent, which forced that precedent to be re-evaluated. The facts (the government attempting to punish someone for distributing a political movie about a political candidate) were so stark, they revealed the defects in the precedent that may have been obscured previously. Moreover, the government made clear at oral argument that there was no limiting principle to its position—it acknowledged that, had the Court ruled the other way, nothing stopped the government from book banning and other core free speech violations.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by Retric on Monday April 27, 2020 @07:56PM (#23001694)
Treating the court as a purely political entity which will flip flopping on issues as the majority changes is counter to it’s design.

The the normal way this is maintained is to have narrow opinions on the specific issue at hand. As such I can agree politically and still say the ruling was unequivocally incorrect.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by SilasX on Monday April 27, 2020 @06:46PM (#23001012)
Well said (about the dynamics of why a precedent would be reversed) ... and welcome back.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by MiroF on Monday April 27, 2020 @06:18PM (#23000772)
> precedent

and just because precedent is overturned doesn't mean it is wrong. I don't like Citizens United as much as the next person, but I think this requires a constitution change.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by ulkesh on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @12:41AM (#23003452)
I’ve read plenty on the subject. I don’t have to articulate bullet points about it just to suit your needs. It has obviously been to the detriment of honest political discourse and is completely wrong. Thanks, though.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by Redoubts on Monday April 27, 2020 @05:27PM (#23000270)
What if it's right, but the constitution is wrong?
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by huffmsa on Monday April 27, 2020 @05:30PM (#23000298)
Then you follow the procedure outlined in article 5 to amend the Constitution.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by DaiPlusPlus on Monday April 27, 2020 @06:53PM (#23001096)
That is much easier said than done.

It’s 2020 and we still don’t have a gender equality amendment even though the majority of states want one.

...let alone amendments for healthcare as a right, abortion rights, and proportional representation.

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by huffmsa on Monday April 27, 2020 @08:40PM (#23002015)
It's supposed to be hard. That's the point. You have to get an absolutely overwhelming majority before you can change a the source code.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by gowld on Monday April 27, 2020 @07:04PM (#23001209)
Are gender equality laws prohibited by the Constitution? Title IX shows no.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by DaiPlusPlus on Monday May 04, 2020 @05:40PM (#23073640)
The issue isn’t that there’s a difficulty in creating gender-equality laws, but that the opposite is true: it’s just as straightforward for a legislature somewhere to enact misogynistic laws. A constitutional amendment to recognise gender equality would mean US laws like these could be struck-down or never get enacted in the first place: https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/sexist-laws-in-the-...
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by harimau777 on Monday April 27, 2020 @09:09PM (#23002210)
At this point that's effectively impossible. To the point where I don't think that's really a viable solution to America's problems.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by thanksforfish on Monday April 27, 2020 @04:05PM (#22999436)
The partisan politics you see on TV is thankfully just the tip of the iceberg.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by FearNotDaniel on Monday April 27, 2020 @04:14PM (#22999536)
I suspect that idiom means just the opposite of what you think it means. By "thankfully" I infer that you are relieved that the vast majority of political activity, "below the surface" of what is seen on TV, is nowhere near as reprehensible. Whereas "tip of the iceberg" is generally used to imply that the visible problem is merely a fractional indication of the much greater and uglier problem that lies beneath, being of the same matter and type of that which has already been seen.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by thanksforfish on Monday April 27, 2020 @06:32PM (#23000905)
Ah correct, I did misuse it. Thank you.
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by softwaredoug on Monday April 27, 2020 @04:13PM (#22999520)
I'm not sure I agree. I think mundane issues become partisan whenever they become political, but many mundane issues are still just dealt with by whatever bureaucrat or official is just doing their job applying the law.

In my experience with the US Federal Gov't (through my wife and family) applying the boring law is the norm, and what's not normal is when political actors inject themselves or create a narrative about an issue to suit their purpose. US Federal Employees are deeply apolitical as a workplace culture.

We see a lot of the latter, but there's only so much bandwidth for it. Most work is boring and getting done in a professional manner

Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by tsomctl on Monday April 27, 2020 @06:06PM (#23000661)
What's your opinion of Gorsuch and Kavanaugh, in regards to them using facts and logical arguments?
Re:Supreme Court rules Georgia state law annotations not cop... by bsder on Monday April 27, 2020 @05:26PM (#23000248)
> Reading the opinions, it is a breath of fresh air to see one of the branches of government relying upon fact and logical argument when discussing the issues.

Your optimism is refreshing, but this is not how law works.

Judges and lawyers start from a conclusion, and then find case law to back up their conclusion.

Now, to be fair, most judges and lawyers who are competent tend not to go far off the established precedents. This is especially true at lower levels where higher judges are going to review your case--nobody wants to be the judge who gets overturned all the time.

Judges are not engineers. The law regards "truth" as subject to negotiation without objective boundaries. An engineer regards "truth" as "the thing that kicks your ass when you contradict it".