Now, notice that I did not mention so far anything about unemployment, bankruptcies, tenant evictions, foreclosures, or any of the other myriad of economic illnesses. I kept the discussion strictly about healthcare, and who dies who lives.
I'm in favor of keeping the lockdown for a bit longer, but keeping it for many months doesn't make too much sense, even if you completely disregard the economic consequences.
But if destroying American society is the cost of containing the coronavirus, we can't pay it.
The US has an immense set of tools and strategies available that would, if used intelligently, certainly prevent America being destroyed without compromising public health.
However, many Americans, as seemingly you do, refuse to consider or admit that these tools exist and can easily be deployed if the political will supports them.
The only thing “destroying America” is right-wing politics refusing to use the tools available to counter the hugely deflationary step-function we are in.
But I've also seen people propose mitigations that would destroy America, and use "political will" as a euphemism for "acceptance of giant quarantine camps for all sufferers and their close contacts" or "willingness to sacrifice all social contact indefinitely". I don't think it's a good thing if political will drives us to do things which are counter to our values.
However, there are downsides to this philosophy. For instance, it means that any amount of resources should be spent equally to keep alive 75 year olds and 25 year olds. This approach can result in some seriously negative outcomes for public finances, which could be better spent on education, etc.
Lives can't be traded, so we can't know the market value of lives. But I'd wager that most people over 75 would trade their life for a 25 year old life, if they could.
That's only one way to demonstrate that most 75 year olds believe their life to be less valuable than a young person starting out. From a more selfless frame, most 75 year olds would also assert that a 25 year old should be prioritized over themselves
I don't know which side you're arguing for, but in addition to egregiously flouting HN's rules, you're discrediting it.
Your comments mark you as one of the people politicizing this. As if small business owners who have seen the data change and question why liquor stores can be open and they can't are all right wingers.
By the way, your comment is naive and foolish. Grown-ups in hospitals make the decision on a regular basis that yes, a 25 year olds life is more valuable than an elderly persons.
The right wingers deny science on climate change. Now I'm seeing left wingers deny science on covid19 antibodies. (They already do it with nuclear power)
I've seen 5 antibody studies all say the same thing, and the left wingers just attack all of them reflexively. Sweden was right. We were wrong.
> As if anyone is arguing this.
The comment I replied to literally argues this in its single declarative sentence.
> yes, a 25 year olds life is more valuable than an elderly persons
You literally just argued it.
> Your comments mark you as one of the people politicizing this. As if small business owners who have seen the data change and question why liquor stores can be open and they can't are all right wingers.
If you don't think declaring old people to be sacrificial is political I don't think you are living in a world that understands what politics is. If you think a policy based on criteria that results in denial of care to most black people, who are at a disadvantage in the "years of health" calculation, while providing care to the majority of whites isn't political, what is?
> The right wingers deny science on climate change. Now I'm seeing left wingers deny science on covid19 antibodies. (They already do it with nuclear power)
> I've seen 5 antibody studies all say the same thing, and the left wingers just attack all of them reflexively. Sweden was right. We were wrong.
This is definitely non-sequitor, and moves toward just ranting. It doesn't add to the conversation.
Are we so great that we have totally conquered disease? That we can keep everyone alive forever?
Certainly not. To assume otherwise shows an astonishing level of hubris.
That's all the Americans to have died in every war combined, roughly.
That is a lot of people and I don't suggest most people would be willing to just allow that to happen.
Are we not greater than that as a civilization?