News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by chippy on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:06AM (#22933531)
In England, unanimous juries were relaxed in 1967 to allow majority ones (i.e. 10/12). The reason for this was because there was a number of jury intimidation cases. A criminal conspiracy need to get to one juror to make the whole case fall apart.

Was this consideration discussed by the supreme court in the USA?

(edits - no results ctrl-f for "conspiracy", "intimidation", "mafia", "organized" in https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/19pdf/18-5924_n6io.pdf )

Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by pc86 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @09:17AM (#22934659)
This sounds like a feature, not a bug. The impact of letting a criminal go free (presumably to commit more crime, and have more chances to put them away) is minuscule compared to the impact of locking an innocent person in prison.

Yes, it means that guilty people will go free. But relaxing the constraints of what "convicted" means that by definition there will be innocent people convicted by 7-11/12 juries.

Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by notahacker on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @11:22AM (#22935702)
> The impact of letting a criminal go free (presumably to commit more crime, and have more chances to put them away) is minuscule compared to the impact of locking an innocent person in prison.

This depends to a large degree on the nature of the crime, as well as the implied reduction of risk of committing them. Abolishing criminal sentencing altogether would clearly reduce the number of innocent people convicted, but few would argue it would result in a net reduction in social harm.

Genuinely interested whether anyone's done some sort of study on whether dissenting jurors tend to be more 12 Angry Men style heroes who focus much more carefully than their peers on the standards of evidence rather than prevailing prejudices against the alleged perpetrator, or more stubborn contrarians whose prejudices against evidence presented by certain types of people or in favour of certain types of defendant haven't been uncovered by the jury selection process.

Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by stared on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @09:56AM (#22935010)
In liberal democracies, we have the line of (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio):

"It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer."

In the language of statistics, it is a trade-off between precision vs recall. In general, we cannot create a system that makes sure no innocent is behind the bars (other than not convicting anyone).

Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by ApolloFortyNine on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @10:22AM (#22935178)
>"It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer."

I believe this is by far the best way to handle it as well, but I did recently read a book that brought up an interesting point.

The line above is almost always the justification given. But, what if those ten were murderers, and by letting those ten escape, each one ended up killing another innocent? Now in your efforts to stop one innocent from going to prison, ten innocents have died, versus the one that would have been falsely imprisoned otherwise.

Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by leetcrew on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @10:51AM (#22935412)
the objective is not some utilitarian maximization of wellbeing; it's to prevent the state specifically from bringing harm to an innocent person. the implication is that it's worse for the state to directly harm an innocent person than for the state to allow harm to come to that person through inaction (eg, failing to imprison murderers).
Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by stared on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @01:06PM (#22936868)
Well, Stalin had a habit of executing not only the suspected, but also their friends, family, and neighbors. He cared more for recall than precision.

...

Utilitarian arguments (to which I adhere to, in general) are hard. There are so many consequences, including ones that are not immediate.

With putting people under arrest we often go for recall. Yes, it is a nasty experience for an innocent, but at the same time, it may avoid the case you mentioned.

Which long-term consequences? First, just because someone is a murderer, does not mean he/she is going to go on a rampage. Second, if precision is high, people can trust the system in the long term, and give some feeling of safety. Compare it with a lynch mob scenario, where it is easy to mishandle justice (and, long term, a lot of innocent are at risk).

Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by SquishyPanda23 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @09:27AM (#22934737)
The impact of systematically allowing criminals to go free if they can sufficiently intimidate or blackmail a single juror is also very high.

If courts are unable to punish well connected criminals then it's difficult to keep a healthy democracy.

I'm not sure what the solution is, but it seems like there should be some redundancy in the system.

Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by pc86 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @09:28AM (#22934750)
I'm not saying the impact is low, only that it's lower than locking up innocent people for crimes they didn't commit, potentially for years or decades.
Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by Retric on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @09:54AM (#22934990)
The tiny number of people who can intimidate jurors, can simply intimidate multiple ones if you’re changing the rules. Much simpler to simply isolate them so they are unaware of such attempts thus keeping juries and their families safe.
Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by bluGill on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @08:55AM (#22934497)
That is one of the reasons not to have professional juries (I don't think England ever had them but I see it come up once in a while). If you have a random jury you don't have enough time to gather dirt on everyone so you don't really know how to intimidate which ever one you happen to get. With a professional jury (or judge but there are other reasons to have professional judges) you know who to look at long before you are caught and so you can figure out what blackmail might work and have it ready when you need it.

Juries are often sequestered meaning that by the time you figure out what to try you can't get at them.

Of course none of the above is perfect. You can get around them if you put in enough effort. Which is why it is a tradeoff as others have said.

Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by matthewheath on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @03:32PM (#22938510)
To my knowledge, England has never had "professional juries", no. What would those be? People who had a career serving on a jury?

We do, however, have the ability to dispense with a jury entirely and have a single judge decide on the case. I suppose that's not much better: a single professional jury of one versus one of twelve.

Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by jedimastert on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @06:53AM (#22933749)
I believe the legal term would be "juror tampering" but that's also not in the ruling text.
Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by frostwhale on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @08:44AM (#22934420)
Yeah its a trade off, as the article mentions, against alienating a minority voting bloc in juries. In the US most relevantly black vs white jurors.

Juries will generally be majority white meaning the opinion of the black jurors would be discounted often.

Neither solution is ideal, and this topic interests me greatly, it seems very similar to the questions of fairness and bias in statistics / ML.

Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by CivBase on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @09:07AM (#22934588)
> Juries will generally be majority white meaning the opinion of the black jurors would be discounted often.

How often do jurry opinions actually split purely along racial lines?

Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by bitcurious on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @09:14AM (#22934644)
I don’t know of any present day statistics, but it looks like it was a motivating factor in moving away from unanimous convictions, at least in the case of Louisiana.

https://www.wwno.org/post/history-louisianas-non-unanimous-j...

Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by papermachete on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @08:55AM (#22934496)
Why is there a racial functional difference between jurors in your mind? Why should black people be judged by black people only?
Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by bluGill on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @08:59AM (#22934526)
There shouldn't be a difference, but in the real world humans are not perfect and we all come with our own biases that we can't always overcome.

People should be judged by a fair impartial jury. I have no idea how to ensure this. Race is one known factor. All white or all black juries are somewhat likely to be partial in the same way and thus not give a true result (as if that is possible) so you want a mix that reflects the community, and also has enough that the one other person isn't intimidated. Easy to say, hard to do.

Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by dd36 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @09:28AM (#22934746)
A solution: virtual avatars.
Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by frostwhale on Tuesday April 28, 2020 @07:01PM (#23013173)
There's a racial difference between jurors in my mind because there's a racial difference between jurors in reality lol. Pretending otherwise is foolish, lawyers literally pick their juries based on this obvious fact.

"Why should black people be judged by black people only?" Is a racist strawman argument. I am saying black people should not be judged by white people exclusively, as can happy if every jury is majority white.

Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by wonderwonder on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @09:35AM (#22934807)
They should not be, but historically and continuing into this day, there are some areas including entire states where there is a clear bias against minorities. This means the defendant is potentially at a disadvantage before the first prosecutor has spoken. Placing a minority on the jury of a minority defendant does not guarantee an acquittal in anyway but it does help to mitigate any ingrained bias the jury may have.

In addition, we are supposed to be judged by a jury of our peers. Considering minorities make up ~40% of the population I don't think its a stretch to say at least 20+% of the jurors should be a minority.

The bar to convict should be high and this helps to ensure that. Rather 10 guilty men go free than one innocent man go to jail.

Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by julianlam on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @09:00AM (#22934537)
Color me uninformed, but couldn't more jurors be intimidated if needed?

It seems like difficulty in intimidating jurors would scale linearly, O(n)

Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by Eridrus on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @09:03AM (#22934555)
No, because not all jurors are equally easy to intimidate, so you should expect effort to be superlinear depending on the distribution, and intimidation itself is not a risk free crime.
Re:Supreme Court says criminal convictions require unanimous... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Tuesday April 21, 2020 @10:12AM (#22935111)
It seems weird to lower the bar for conviction for everybody out of fear of jury tampering.