No. Because tin-pot shitholes -- and the people trying to make them -- have, can, and will always find some new "threat" with which to justify taking away civil liberties. Things similar to what you have said here about "nuanced reality" with respect to civil liberties have always been for me a pretty good smell test for underlying authoritarian beliefs. In ANY context, it's possible to point to something as justification for taking away civil liberties in the name of safety and security. Yesterday it was internet death threats and human trafficking, today the pandemic, tomorrow who knows, but I promise there will be one.
I'm not familiar with the concept of "tin-pot shithole".
>have, can, and will always find some new "threat" with which to justify taking away civil liberties.
So slippery slope, is what you're arguing? "First they make a completely reasonable and temporary restriction of right of physical assembly, next we'll be off to the gulags." Isn't really an interesting argument, is it?
Nice use of quotation marks there, considering that is not what I said.
which part didn't you say exactly?
> "First they make a completely reasonable and temporary restriction of right of physical assembly, next we'll be off to the gulags."
Please find this text in my post.
Look at the circumstance under which the Patriot Act was created
Re:Covid-19’s impact on Tor
by chance_state on Sunday April 19, 2020 @11:08AM
(#22916396)
Could not disagree more.
The entire point of enumerating rights in the constitution and it's amendments is so that they are _not_ subject to changing circumstances.
Let's put it this way: you have a right to life, but this right may be suspended in certain delimited circumstances: if you're posing an imminent threat to someone, or in certain places maybe if you're merely trespassing. You have a right to free speech, yet this is again restricted in many circumstances. You cannot: lie under oath, make a false accusation, make a libelous statement...
Pretending that a small sentence can encompass all the possible nuance of the multiple situations that arise in our messy reality is being an "absolutist".
Pretending that nuanced reality doesn't exist is the definition of "rights absolutism".