News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fear of an impending car-price collapse grips auto industry by ghaff on Monday April 13, 2020 @07:53PM (#22861470)
Many city folks I know do (normally) still go to visit friends and attend events in the suburbs on a regular basis. And they head well outside the city frequently--2-3 times a month on weekends. Even though it doesn't make direct economic sense, if you can afford it, it may make sense in terms of convenience given the hassle of renting a car on a regular basis. Especially if you have specific vehicle requirements for sport activities. I know quite a few people in that position.

The ZipCar model seemed like it was going to be a big deal at one point. But it seems to have been too much of a niche between Uber and occasional traditional rentals. (I know a couple of folks who use it and they find it a bit of a hassle.)

Re:Fear of an impending car-price collapse grips auto industry by BadassFractal on Monday April 13, 2020 @07:57PM (#22861490)
You're hitting the nail on the head here though: it's currently still inconvenient to have access to the kind of vehicle you want on a moment's notice. Getting a car through a traditional rental company is excruciating, and services like Zipcar and Maven are still not snappy enough. Their inventories tend to be limited in many places too, compounding the issue.

I'm hoping someone manages to make this as effortless as calling an Uber. Otherwise the alternative is that $10k/y expense on a rapidly depreciating asset you're not really using.

Re:Fear of an impending car-price collapse grips auto industry by maxsilver on Monday April 13, 2020 @09:15PM (#22861882)
> Otherwise the alternative is that $10k/y expense on a rapidly depreciating asset

You don't have to run out and buy a brand-new Tesla just to own a car.

Most people own nice reliable vehicles for half that price. I drive a 2013 Chevy Volt, on pure electricity most of the time, and my TCO is only ~$6k/yr (including gas, insurance, maintenance, registration, car payment + interest, electricity to charge it, fancy winter tires every two years, etc).

Frankly, even that expense was a bit of a luxury. If I hadn't been so obsessed with EV's, I probably could have easily shaved $1,000/yr off that price with zero effort.

Re:Fear of an impending car-price collapse grips auto industry by ghaff on Monday April 13, 2020 @08:13PM (#22861582)
Part of the problem is that demand is spiky. A lot of people are going to want these rentals on weekends. So, for a reliable on-demand weekend rental, you're probably going to spend a decent chunk of a weekly rental fee if this became common.

What more tends to happen in practice is that urban folk who decide not to own a car just minimize activities that require one unless they can can draft off friends.

Re:Fear of an impending car-price collapse grips auto industry by nomel on Monday April 13, 2020 @09:03PM (#22861821)
> $10k/y expense

$10k/y seems very high. Are parking fees $5k/year or something, or frequently buying a new car for some reason?

Re:Fear of an impending car-price collapse grips auto industry by Marsymars on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:22PM (#22862177)
Average cost of car ownership in the US is in the $10k/yr range: https://www.investopedia.com/articles/pf/08/cost-car-ownersh...
Re:Fear of an impending car-price collapse grips auto industry by nomel on Monday April 13, 2020 @11:00PM (#22862360)
And the average sugar intake is 65 lbs/year. You don't have to eat that many cookies, just as you don't have to spend that much on a car if you don't want to.

They're including new cars (20-30% value gone in the first year) and large vehicles like SUVs and trucks (Ford F series is the best selling vehicle in America) in those statistics, along with average mileage (13k/y) numbers for average fuel and maintenance costs, which would be much less for a minimal use vehicle.

Re:Fear of an impending car-price collapse grips auto industry by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 14, 2020 @12:06PM (#22867648)
> $10k/y seems very high. Are parking fees $5k/year or something

At $10/work-day parking ($2,600/year), the remainder is under 13k miles at the IRS standard mileage rate, which is presumably a reasonable actual total expense rate.

Re:Fear of an impending car-price collapse grips auto industry by Polylactic_acid on Monday April 13, 2020 @09:29PM (#22861959)
Being in the city makes public transport much more useful. At least where I am virtually all public transport lines have one end in the city and one end in the suburbs. So if you are in the suburbs you can get to the city and if you are in the city you can get to anywhere.
Re:Fear of an impending car-price collapse grips auto industry by ghaff on Monday April 13, 2020 @09:41PM (#22862005)
Getting from commuter rail stations to suburban locations is often difficult even with Uber/Lyft. In any case, even with relatively good commuter rail--I'm about a 7 minute drive from a station--it's basically useless for evening activities. Outside of rush hour it runs about every 90 minutes. And this is a good commuter rail system.
Re:Fear of an impending car-price collapse grips auto industry by Polylactic_acid on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:13PM (#22862134)
At least where I am the bus stop is never more than 30 minutes walking from wherever I want go. If I am visiting a suburb I am never in a rush and a 30 minute walk is quite nice.
Re:Fear of an impending car-price collapse grips auto industry by ghaff on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:18PM (#22862160)
There's effectively no public transit out where I live. I mean, there's some sort of regional transit presumably for poor people who don't own cars but it's not really practical otherwise. The one time I looked on Google Maps, it would have taken me 4 hours to get into the city, including walking along a busy street with no sidewalks, to get to a bus to take a train. And this is about an hour drive.
Re:Fear of an impending car-price collapse grips auto industry by Polylactic_acid on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:24PM (#22862184)
Stories like this make me feel that large chunks of the US are fundamentally broken. I just find it interesting that Americans assume that public transport is impossible rather than their current layout was designed purely for car transport and that it can be fixed.
Re:Fear of an impending car-price collapse grips auto industry by ghaff on Monday April 13, 2020 @10:29PM (#22862212)
OTOH, the context is that, although I'm only about an hour drive from Boston, I live in a largely rural town in a property that's between an apple orchard and a christmas tree farm plus conservation land. (With easy driving, but not walking, distance from a commuter rail station.) I'm not sure why it would be the norm for me to have a frequent/easy public transit option or whether that would be the norm in most of Europe either.

I actually can get into the city for 9-5 fairly easily by rail. Just not door to door.