Cars aren't a luxury. Being a "city folk" at all is the luxury. Being able to afford a place, where you can outsource all of your errands to poor people, is the luxury. Being able to live in a place where "you can walk everywhere you need" is a luxury. (Not just in location and housing, but in job flexibility and leisure time, and in safety). Having the lifestyle flexibility to completely re-write your entire life around extreme high expense and very limited options, is the luxury.
> shave off $1000 from your rent, and instead spend that same amount on your car, in addition to now having to sit in traffic jams for an hour or two every day? No, thanks.
For a regular average American, it's more like "pay ~$400/month TCO to own a car, to save $1200/month off your rent". Generally speaking, no one actually spends money on a car, because unless you've made a terrible mistake (or are especially poor), a car earns you more money than it costs.
And that's before you get to all the other benefits -- (cheaper housing, larger housing, higher-quality housing, safer transportation, free personal distancing, disease-resistance) -- most of which are especially relevant now that we live in a never-ending-pandemic society.
Edit: would also like to point out that the billions that they spent to widen that freeway 10 years ago did not reduce congestion because more people built in sprawling suburbs 30 miles from Houston: http://cityobservatory.org/reducing-congestion-katy-didnt/
The ZipCar model seemed like it was going to be a big deal at one point. But it seems to have been too much of a niche between Uber and occasional traditional rentals. (I know a couple of folks who use it and they find it a bit of a hassle.)
I'm hoping someone manages to make this as effortless as calling an Uber. Otherwise the alternative is that $10k/y expense on a rapidly depreciating asset you're not really using.
You don't have to run out and buy a brand-new Tesla just to own a car.
Most people own nice reliable vehicles for half that price. I drive a 2013 Chevy Volt, on pure electricity most of the time, and my TCO is only ~$6k/yr (including gas, insurance, maintenance, registration, car payment + interest, electricity to charge it, fancy winter tires every two years, etc).
Frankly, even that expense was a bit of a luxury. If I hadn't been so obsessed with EV's, I probably could have easily shaved $1,000/yr off that price with zero effort.
What more tends to happen in practice is that urban folk who decide not to own a car just minimize activities that require one unless they can can draft off friends.
$10k/y seems very high. Are parking fees $5k/year or something, or frequently buying a new car for some reason?
They're including new cars (20-30% value gone in the first year) and large vehicles like SUVs and trucks (Ford F series is the best selling vehicle in America) in those statistics, along with average mileage (13k/y) numbers for average fuel and maintenance costs, which would be much less for a minimal use vehicle.
At $10/work-day parking ($2,600/year), the remainder is under 13k miles at the IRS standard mileage rate, which is presumably a reasonable actual total expense rate.
I actually can get into the city for 9-5 fairly easily by rail. Just not door to door.
I currently do not own a car and don't really feel any desire to get one. I had to change my lifestyle slightly, cycling and PT is not a drop in replacement for a car but I feel the things I have let go are less important than the things I have gained.
I find that sitting in traffic is a huge negative on my mental health, working from home currently has made me much happier and if work tries to drag me back to the office I'll be looking for a new job.
The thing I hate about doing zipcar / getaround / etc. is the amount of time and hassle I have to spend making sure the car isn't damaged and reporting it BEFORE I hop in and drive off.
In my early 20s, living in Cincinnati, I used to hate the stress of being tethered to car maintenance and ownership. So I moved into “The City” (Chicago, then SF) and got rid of my car. Well, that worked great in my able bodied youth days.
At some point in my early 30s, frustration with having complete dependence on someone else (MUNI/BART, Uber, Lyft) or worrying about having rentals available to get me from point A to point B became too much of a burden; too much of a time suck. At some point spending an hour a day total on transportation aggravation made the suburbs look appetizing. I told myself I would never settle for that commute again.
Staying in the city, I bought a car. I still hate maintaining cars, and EVs don’t require very much long term maintenance. Going EV simplified getting a car.
Renting in western San Francisco, everybody has a garage. It’s all suburbanesque mid century tract housing. Parking at home is not a problem.
What is? A 30 minute walk to Forest Hill station or :15 minute bus ride to Forest Hill station. By driving myself, In 15 minutes I could be in Civic Center without having somebody from Stockton get lost In SF In their rental Nissan Sentra with loud sales bro taking a conference call in a Uber Pool.
I can say the convenience of living in the city with a car is unparalleled. In (especially western) San Francisco, the transportation infrastructure is geared toward driving.
Hearing that BART stops at 9 PM now reinforces the practicality of my decision.
I think you're taking for granted that everyone who lives and works in the general area of a city is commuting to the very center from a long way away. My reaction is "well, don't do that!"
I briefly worked in the DC area, and I still had a 10-15 minute commute as I am used to. That's because I was living a few miles from the center, in NOVA, and going outwards another mile or two in the morning.
Right now, I'm living just barely within the city limits of a smaller city, so technically you could say it's not a suburb, but practically it is, and again, my commute is (or was) about 10 minutes.
Any time you actually are living downtown in a significant urban area, it seems like a luxury to me, wouldn't you expect rents to be expensive when housing is competing with office space and fancy restaurants? I was able to afford that in Richmond, but in major, desirable cities, there's no way.
I think this is an extreme anecdote which I find hard to believe the RTD at fault for.
i'm just waiting for someone in the on-demand transportation sector to realize that the killer app for self-driving is not 100% level 5 autonomous driving, but a service that can self-drive to you from a cheap parking lot/structure and return to it after a trip.
(to be fair, i think many do realize this and are working on it already.)
On the other hand, Lyft is now trying to get into the car rentals game...
I realize that if you live out in the countryside or in the suburbs, the car is your lifeline. But for city folk cars are a luxury. You can walk everywhere you need, you can use Instacart and Amazon to handle groceries and shopping, and, if you're lucky, you can work on distributed teams. You never need to get behind the wheel, and even then you're better off getting a Lyft.
$250/mo for a parking spot where random people can still scratch up, dent or break into your car. $100-200 for insurance, $x for gas, $300+ for financing or leasing a car, $y for repairs and maintenance, $z for tickets and parking meters.. This stuff adds up. If you only need the car occasionally, let's say a couple of times a month on the weekends, then this system is horribly inefficient.
Of course you end up paying more for living close to work in say.. downtown Seattle, NYC, SF, LA etc... but the tradeoff is to move to the burbs, shave off $1000 from your rent, and instead spend that same amount on your car, in addition to now having to sit in traffic jams for an hour or two every day? No, thanks.
I'm hoping networks of press-a-button-on-phone-receive-car systems like Zipcar keep expanding. Seems like their growth has been sub-linear at best this last few years.