News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by JackFr on Friday April 10, 2020 @10:40AM (#22833459)
The points made are fine insofar as they go. At the same time, the current economic situation is, very literally, unprecedented. It has aspects of a war, a natural disaster and a secular recession. Economists should try to estimate its effects, but in this case their predictions need to be taken with an extra large grain of salt.
Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by twelve40 on Friday April 10, 2020 @10:58AM (#22833659)
How is it very literally unprecedented? Spanish flu had much deadlier properties, "work from home" wasn't even possible, there were no antibiotics and almost none of the modern med tech, yet there is no mention of a "1919 economic collapse". Death toll in the US was <700k, which is not great, but actually less than some of the insane apocalyptic predictions you hear about this time around, especially considering that in 100+ years we probably improved just a bit.

So I'd say it looks very much "precedented", and during the last precedent the situation was much much worse, and the world moved on just fine for another decade after that.

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday April 10, 2020 @02:08PM (#22835681)
Another feature of the 1918 economy in most of the world was it was a lot less global, a lot more localized. There was a lot more regional self-reliance, which meant that the nature of the impact on the economy looked very different.

One of the biggest differences is the enormous growth of what is not very usefully termed "the service economy" since 1918 (really, since maybe 1960 or so). A huge percentage of the population now gets paid to do things that had no real equivalent in 1918, things that you can simply stop doing (at least for some period of time). Restaurants, hotels, therapists of many different kinds, artists, musicians, retail .... these have all exploded, emply lots and lots of people and are all inessentiall to basic living (though essential to meaning for most of us).

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by Jagat on Friday April 10, 2020 @02:15PM (#22835766)
Spanish flu was very closely intertwined with the war, because of which people were kept in the dark almost everywhere. Lack of reporting translates to lack of awareness of the pandemic which translates to people working and shopping fearlessly.

The difference now is that people know there's a pandemic, and many would be averse to go out working, or shopping even though the scale is much lower than that of Spanish flu.

Random tidbit:. It's named Spanish flu because that's one of the few places where it was reported, because it wasn't involved in ww1 and had no reason to shut down the press. Everyone thought the flu epidemic was in Spain.

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by hilbertseries on Friday April 10, 2020 @02:25PM (#22835908)
During the Spanish flu pandemic, entire cities and towns would get sick and everything would stop. There were also shelter in place orders given during this time. 1918 wasn’t the dark ages, we had telephones and radios. People knew what was happening.
Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by credit_guy on Friday April 10, 2020 @02:34PM (#22836001)
> and radios

According to wikipedia first news on radio came in 1920.

"The first radio news program was broadcast August 31, 1920 by station 8MK in Detroit, Michigan."

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_radio#20th_century

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by dboreham on Friday April 10, 2020 @06:22PM (#22837918)
Downtown Abbey didn't get either a radio nor telephone until after the war. They had telegram.
Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by jcranmer on Friday April 10, 2020 @11:28AM (#22834006)
> Death toll in the US was <700k, which is not great, but actually less than some of the insane apocalyptic predictions you hear about this time around, especially considering that in 100+ years we probably improved just a bit.

The US population was also only ~103 million in 1918, compared to ~327 million today. Proportionally, we should expect about 2 million deaths from coronavirus to be merely "as bad" as the Spanish flu.

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by UncleOxidant on Friday April 10, 2020 @05:31PM (#22837557)
There was a depression in 1920/21. Of course, there were multiple factors that led to that not the least of which were lots of soldiers returning from WWI.

Also, lots of people worked from home in 1918. 40% of people lived on farms in 1900 so probably not much change from that by 1918.

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by downerending on Friday April 10, 2020 @03:37PM (#22836575)
It's unprecedented in the sense that the world was so different during the Spanish Flu that it's far from clear what lessons can be taken from it.

Yes, life will go on. But it's worth trying to minimize the misery in the meantime.

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by JackFr on Friday April 10, 2020 @03:29PM (#22836502)
I think you misunderstand me. I’m not claiming that a pandemic is unprecedented. I’m claiming that a pandemic in the post modern economy is unprecedented, as is a prophylactic shutdown of 1/3 of the economy.

That being said, my point is that economic predictions are especially difficult given that we’ve never seen this before.

For comparison, consider the many economists who at the time expected the depression to reappear after the demobilization following WWII. Despite their good intentions and good data, they too were dealing with a unique situation, and they turned out to be very wrong.

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by malandrew on Friday April 10, 2020 @04:53PM (#22837233)
> "work from home" wasn't even possible, there were no antibiotics and almost none of the modern med tech, yet there is no mention of a "1919 economic collapse"

Probably because there was no choice but to barrel forward towards herd immunity and deal with the suffering and loss of life.

In 2020, we're delaying and dragging out the tragedy at the cost to the economy.

On top of that, the economy was far more distributed and local. With globalization, things are much more interconnected and interdependent.

Restarting local commerce is much much easier.

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by frosted-flakes on Friday April 10, 2020 @11:10AM (#22833799)
It also occurred during World War I. That changes the situation somewhat.
Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by twelve40 on Friday April 10, 2020 @11:19AM (#22833893)
Changes how? I'd say being in WWI was much much worse, no? And yet you still don't hear about a great 1919 depression.
Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by kazen44 on Friday April 10, 2020 @04:53PM (#22837244)
depression of what?

The end of world war 1 had an enourmous impact on continental europe, with many nations simply ceasing to exist at the end of the war.

Germany for instance, had a state of near constant poltical and economic anarchy during the weimar republic. And the austrian-hungarian empire ceased to exist.

Many people seem to forget that world war 1 was suchs a massive shift in terms of the geopolitical landscape that many nations simply had no functioning economy or proper goverment to speak off.

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by twelve40 on Saturday April 11, 2020 @04:06AM (#22840344)
If I have to clarify down to the last word, I'm talking about the total implosion of US economy, which is what a lot of people are currently hyping up and clickbaiting on. You don't hear about a great 1919 economic disaster in the USA despite a much more vicious illness and no modern tech (no antibiotics, no concept of a ventilator, etc etc etc). I can't answer for Austria, Hungary, Germany or any other collapsed empires past or present, I don't have any data on that.
Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by tathougies on Friday April 10, 2020 @05:40PM (#22837617)
Yes, the Spanish flu led to one of the biggest economic booms in history: the roaring 20s
Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by jameslevy on Friday April 10, 2020 @06:32PM (#22838006)
Correlation doesn't imply causation. This was around the onset of mass production, electrification, and the first time that cheap credit was a thing.
Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by tathougies on Friday April 10, 2020 @07:54PM (#22838587)
That's certainly fair, but the black plague also led to several economic benefits to the working and laboring class, so I do think there are typically economic benefits from a pandemic. Although, we'll see to what extent the stimulus and money creation might affect this.
Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by commandlinefan on Friday April 10, 2020 @01:52PM (#22835462)
> How is it very literally unprecedented?

What's unprecedented is the reaction... some might say overreaction.

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by disgruntledphd2 on Friday April 10, 2020 @03:53PM (#22836728)
The trouble with exponential growth is that if you wait to react, for fear of over-reaction, then it's too late.

For a pretty good example of this, look at Spain and the UK.

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by eli_gottlieb on Friday April 10, 2020 @01:44PM (#22835340)
Antibiotics aren't actually useful against viruses. We are currently in roughly the place with antiviral drugs that we were a century ago with antibiotics: the first clinical and theoretical hints are there, and a few things have been tested and found to work in isolated cases, but there simply is no systematic, industrial-scale way to pump out (antiviral) pills or syrups that can be thrown at whatever new (viral) pathogen comes out of the wilderness this year.
Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by quickthrowman on Friday April 10, 2020 @01:48PM (#22835396)
Antibiotics are useful for fighting secondary bacterial infections that occur as a result of a viral infection.
Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by danielfoster on Friday April 10, 2020 @10:53AM (#22833612)
This. It's pretty clear some aspects of the economy could suffer permanently. For example restaurants may reopen and decide they no longer need service staff. Or maybe warehouses accelerate the shift to automation to prevent closures due to illness. Perhaps commercial real estate will suffer, too.

But other areas of the economy could take off just as quickly and in unexpected ways.

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by epistasis on Friday April 10, 2020 @10:50AM (#22833568)
It's not completely without precedent, in that the 1918 flu pandemic was only a century ago. We don't have a ton of good data, but some researchers are looking at its effects in the US:

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-27/pandemic-...

But I do agree 100% with taken current economic estimates with a huge brain of salt, as our economic machine is far different from the past.

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by umanwizard on Friday April 10, 2020 @01:46PM (#22835369)
Were virtually all businesses shut down for weeks or months during the 1918 flu pandemic? All I can find is reports of localized shutdowns in certain cities.

If not, I don't think you can say it's comparable.

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by clairity on Friday April 10, 2020 @02:33PM (#22835997)
> "Were virtually all businesses shut down for weeks or months... If not, I don't think you can say it's comparable."

that's the (over-)reaction. the precedent is the more-virulent-than-usual infectious disease. the precedent is the need to break the infection chain to slow/stop the pandemic.

you wouldn't expect the reaction to be 'comparable' after 100 years. you'd hope that we'd have developed methods to better assuage fear and panic though.

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by CydeWeys on Friday April 10, 2020 @07:25PM (#22838409)
Yes, there were very large, long shutdowns during the 1918 flu pandemic. And they had more of an effect than what we're doing now, because people couldn't work remotely.
Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by SpicyLemonZest on Friday April 10, 2020 @10:42PM (#22839296)
Do you have a source for that? I've seen charts purporting to show that, but digging in always revealed that they showed "social distancing measures" more broadly, limited to things like public gatherings bans and restaurant closures. I haven't seen any record of general business shutdowns or bans on private gatherings in 1918.
Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by _curious_ on Friday April 10, 2020 @02:08PM (#22835687)
As a percentage of population (and volume of dollars) then vs now: how many are negative net worth? Break even/neutral net worth?
Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by proverbialbunny on Friday April 10, 2020 @03:07PM (#22836312)
If you look at stock market data from the 1910s, when spanish flu ripped everything and everyone apart, the economy then dropped in a similar way today, well, until the Fed started pumping trillions into the market, and now the market is looking different then than today.

The economic collapse from the Spanish Flu was so devastating it was used as a selling point to create the Federal Reserve, which was sold to help a situation similar to today. Today, the Fed's marketing is on the line.

Re:A Long Time Until the Economic New Normal by fullshark on Friday April 10, 2020 @11:19AM (#22833892)
These predictions are so vague as to be basically unfalsifiable, I'm not sure it matters.