News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by Pewpewarrows on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:28PM (#2280840)
So... a dual core processor, two cameras, and... that's it? I was honestly expecting a LOT more considering how much competition they're getting this year. The new cover is neat, and it seems like they did a great job with the Movie and Garage Band apps, but the new iPad 2 is pretty underwhelming. Same old low resolution, no USB ports, and no desperately needed UI changes (I'm guessing iOS 5 wasn't ready yet and you'll have to wait for the new iPhone announcement).

The only good thing still going for it is the price, and if the past few years of the smartphone market has taught us anything, we'll soon see a flood of a variety of cheap tablets on all the service providers using Android. Can the iPad 2 compete with that? We'll see.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by gfodor on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:36PM (#2280887)
Did you really expect Apple to add USB ports to the iPad? Also, new iOS wasn't part of this announcement.

All in all it's a pretty solid hardware refresh (the thinner case being the highlight.) The screen probably will be in v3, since the cost is probably still too high.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by billmcneale on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:46PM (#2280934)
> Did you really expect Apple to add USB ports to the iPad?

Doesn't seem unreasonable coming from the company that claims to have popularized USB:

http://www.apple.com/thunderbolt/

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by mattparcher on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:02PM (#2281025)
Thunderbolt is actually based on the Mini DisplayPort specification. If anything, Apple will add this to the iPad, but it will look quite different than USB.

The next iPad, rumored for September of this year, is more likely to include major new features, including a higher-resolution display and more connectivity (i.e. Thunderbolt).

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by fdb on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:29PM (#2281419)
September!? Really? That's ridiculously quick.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by danilocampos on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:05PM (#2281309)
It's doubtful that the iPad is going to refresh that dramatically by September. It's even more doubtful that Thunderbolt would be in such a refresh – they would have to add PCIe support to their ARM SOC and that doesn't seem trivial.

(Though it's entirely possible it's in the new A5 and they said nothing about it)

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by rtc on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:44PM (#2281483)
I think Apple went out of their way to make it seem like iPad2 is a long-running product: - end of video, Ive saying "iPad2 will define the category for years to come" - 2011: the year of iPad2

Both of these are, I believe, explicit attempts to make people NOT think a new iPad3 is coming soon (so people won't wait, and will buy now instead), but in reality these two things perhaps support the iPad3 in September rumors...

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by gfodor on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @05:25PM (#2281650)
Spoken like a true conspiracy theorist.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by catch23 on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:37PM (#2280890)
USB would add a huge power drain to the ipad. plus I'm not sure if most people would need it. What's wrong with bluetooth add-ons?

Also, where are these cheap tablets running honeycomb? The only one I've seen available so far is the Xoom and that's $800 for their starter model.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:25PM (#2281129)
In the UK the 32GB Xoom WiFi is the same price as the 32CB iPad WiFi. There was a leaked ad with a price that was the same as the 16GB iPad, but they officially announced it after the iPad 2 anouncement and raised it £50.

Of course that's not counting the $40 dollar HDMI dongle that's not needed for the Xoom.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by Pewpewarrows on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:18PM (#2281095)
The Xoom is $600, not $800, and my comment said soon. Android smartphones started out slow as well as you may or may not remember.

Apple Fanboys were all too eager to laugh at the first model or two of phone running on Android, and now look who's running the market just a short time later. If you don't see any correlation between what happened then and what's happening now I honestly don't know what to tell you.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by achompas on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:06PM (#2281313)
> and now look who's running the market just a short time later.

Can we stop with the "market share" talk? No one is "running" the smartphone market. What is this, Engadget?

Android benefits from mass adoption, since Google makes money on ads. So they license their OS for free to a bunch of manufacturers. They're doing pretty well.

Apple benefits from a simple, walled-off platform because that's their design philosophy. So they update a few products a year. They, too, are doing pretty well.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by rimantas on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:23PM (#2281393)

  > and now look who's running the market
How about looking who is making money?
[deleted]
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by cryptoz on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:39PM (#2281462)
NO! The WiFi model is $600, the 3G model is $800. The 3G model was released last week, the WiFi model is coming out soon.

The Xoom is $600! Really, it honestly is. Here, I'll cite the CEO of Motorola as proof!

http://www.google.ca/search?sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8&...

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by citrik on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @06:05PM (#2281829)
Seems like a lot of people are overlooking the Camera Connection Kit which gives the iPad USB. Works with MIDI too.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by marklabedz on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:00PM (#2281013)
What competitors are shipping their tablets by March 11? Last I saw for RIM was April. Loaded question perhaps, but the "iPad killers" based on Honeycomb aren't out en masse yet.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by Pewpewarrows on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:21PM (#2281110)
This is a tablet that has to stand against the next entire year of competitors, at Apple's current release schedule. It's not even caught up to the Xoom in terms of hardware specs. Like the iPhone before it, it'll be tough competition against the wave of competitors that have faster release schedules.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by marklabedz on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:05PM (#2281307)
For the general public, it doesn't have to keep up with hardware specs when the experience already out-paces it.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by Pewpewarrows on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:20PM (#2281376)
The general public doesn't buy Apple products by way of rational decision-making. They buy it because it's Apple and to be part of the community and culture of Apple fans.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by stcredzero on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @05:01PM (#2281553)
Buying on specs over usability is not rational decision making from the point of view of most users.

http://www.amazon.com/Inmates-Are-Running-Asylum/dp/06723164...

Highly skilled techies are largely immune to usability problems, so buying on specs may be rational for us.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by rbarooah on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:31PM (#2281153)
What hardware specs? Battery life? Gyroscope? Graphics Performance?
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by zyb09 on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:44PM (#2281217)
well Gruber said they're releasing another one in fall ;)
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by kenjackson on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:27PM (#2281138)
The only good thing still going for it is the price

Price + Quality. Plus the existing app store. Honeycomb has no apps and it seems really really buggy. Feels like Google rushed it out. iOS on the iPad feels polished and refined.

Two things need to happen for Android in 2011. Honeycomb needs to get stabilized. No more crashing or freezes. AND we need to see a $350 high quality tablet. Until then Apple will continue to clean up.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by danilocampos on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:49PM (#2280950)
Sounds a lot like...

"No wireless. Less space than a nomad. Lame."

This kind of thinking is what has allowed Apple to sweep up so much damn money, along with ownership of the DAP and tablet markets. Give people what they actually need instead of filling out spec lists to appeal to the nerds.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by spamizbad on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:07PM (#2281051)
But that statement was a fair (albeit glib) criticism of the original iPod. It never really had it's breakthrough moment until the 3rd generation.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by lurch_mojoff on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:46PM (#2281225)
But that was not because the iPod had no wireless, neither because it had less space than Nomad. I hope we can all agree, with the benefit of hindsight, that the reason for the slow uptake of the iPod was a combination of it being Firewire only, it being Mac only, Apple not being the brand they are now, and the fact that people were not really familiar with and didn't quite understand the concept of digital music.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by spamizbad on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:57PM (#2281531)
I think we're both making the same point here - the original iPod had a lot of friction holding it back with consumers. What I was attempting to elude to was this: until the iPod had better connectivity options (USB and PC support) in addition to reaching storage parity (40gb by gen 3) it finally blossomed and took over the market. It's not that the 1st gen iPod was garbage - it wasn't - it just lacked some crucial components before it could conquer the market.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by danilocampos on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:47PM (#2281236)
The iPod got wireless and more storage than a Nomad in the 3rd generation?
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by stcredzero on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @07:27PM (#2282120)
Those original iPods were amazingly well made. Lots of them are still going strong, modulo a replaced switch, headphone jack, or battery.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by Pewpewarrows on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:41PM (#2281199)
Apple doesn't have to do much to appeal to the mass market of people that purchase their products. The iPad 2 could have only added a camera, and it would sell by the millions this year.

Apple has very good PR. It's allowed them to create a nice ecosystem of brand loyalty where people will always come out to buy their "next great thing" year after year. They've made a good profit from it, so it must be working.

When you go beyond the people that buy Apple products because they're Apple products, to people that actually make a conscious and informed decision about what they buy, there are definitely several valid concerns and reasons not to buy into it. Pointing to large sales numbers as a counter-argument to criticism is just plain silly.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by danilocampos on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:55PM (#2281258)
> Apple doesn't have to do much to appeal to the mass market of people that purchase their products.

Of course they do. They're not selling $20 pairs of jeans, here. They're selling expensive stuff that requires a conscious decision to purchase. Apple needs to provide a compelling case to move their product. It's not practical to buy something just because it's from Apple. It has to actually do something for you as a user.

> Apple has very good PR.

This line is exhausting. Apple has very good products. The great marketing and PR is a result of having very good products.

You can't sell 15 million units of a brand new, $500 product in nine months on the strength of TV ads and magazine pieces. It has to actually work well. There may be an initial element of brand trust to grease the skids for launch but sustained sales require something real.

My parents aren't Apple fans. They're not nerds. They spend a lot of time frustrated with technology. They're nuts about their iPad because it works really well. That's it. Adding a USB port isn't going to make them like it better. It's going to make it more complex, which is going to degrade their experience in using it.

"Oh, well, that whole 12 hour battery thing? Doesn't count if you use the USB port. Then it's something else."

"What? Why?"

"USB uses power."

"Why?"

etc.

> Pointing to large sales numbers as a counter-argument to criticism is just plain silly.

You continue to miss the point. The criticism isn't valid. Apple has sold a shitload of iPads on the strength of its simplicity. You're talking about making it less simple. In that case, its success is more than ample refutation of your assertion that adding junk to its spec list is going to somehow improve things.

It's like saying, around 1950 "Hey, turn the automobile into a Rhinoceros – then it'll be able to hit things with its horns."

"But people don't buy cars to do that. Look how well they're selling."

"Sales are not a valid refutation of my criticism that cars have no horns to hit things with!"

etc.

But like I said: Chalking it all up to clever marketing, instead of painstaking investments in software design, hardware fabrication and supply chain optimization is how everyone else keeps dropping the ball while Apple sprints all the way to the bank year after year.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by jrubyer on Thursday March 03, 2011 @01:13AM (#2283062)
>>My parents aren't Apple fans. They're not nerds. They spend a lot of time frustrated with technology. They're nuts about their iPad because it works really well. That's it. Adding a USB port isn't going to make them like it better. It's going to make it more complex, which is going to degrade their experience in using it.

This is interesting. I'm curious, how do they manage the music/photos/videos in their ipad? Doesn't syncing by cord with the computer a messy thing? Or do you do it for them? How do they use it?

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by recoiledsnake on Thursday March 03, 2011 @04:20PM (#2285835)
If Apple had added a USB port, the same folks would be singing praises on it. Same thing happened with the G5 to Intel switch. The exact same people who were railing on Intel and praising the G5 for speed/features etc. did a complete aboutface.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by Pewpewarrows on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:17PM (#2281359)
You honestly don't believe that most Apple customers just buy Apple products because of the brand name on the box?

Go survey anyone buying the products in the store or online. See how long it takes you to get an answer along the lines of: "I researched all my options and this seemed like the best choice."

> You can't sell 15 million units of a brand new, $500 product in nine months on the strength of TV ads and magazine pieces. It has to actually work well.

The iPad by any other name and company would not have sold close to that amount.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by arn on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:58PM (#2281536)
>You honestly don't believe that most Apple customers just buy Apple products because of the brand name on the box?

This is a ridiculous stance. It is dismissive and doesn't explain how Apple turned around from being an almost bankrupt company to what it is today.

You ignore how that brand was built. Esp when Apple was on the verge of death in the late 90's. They couldn't rely on their brand at that point, could they? Apple as a powerhouse is a relatively recent phenomenon.

It's like saying Zappos customers are only loyal to Zappos because of their brand, and not their customer service. Their customer service is how they built their brand. Similarly, Apple built their brand on some really great products.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by danilocampos on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:27PM (#2281410)
> The iPad by any other name and company would not have sold close to that amount.

That's definitely true. An iPad by another company would not sell anywhere close to 15 million units in nine months. Why?

* Low standards for overall product quality, along with short term gotta make Wall Street happy this quarter thinking, so products get rushed to market

* Sloppy software/hardware integration

* No access to 20 years of NeXTStep/OS X libraries and tools to build an awesome developer experience, so apps will suck

* No supply chain optimization to provide an outstanding form factor at a compelling price

* No consistent, worldwide retail presence to allow users to experiment with the new product and have questions answered

* No culture of absurd exhaustive prototyping to ensure that the user experience works well once the product is in the hands of customers

> You honestly don't believe that most Apple customers just buy Apple products because of the brand name on the box?

I honestly believe the Apple brand gets people into the store. Once they're in the store, the actual product sells itself. Any further influence of the brand in the purchasing decision comes down to the simple truth that Apple has been consistently making better shit than everyone else for years. But you can't pay a PR firm for that.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by jarek on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @06:14PM (#2281870)
> consistent, worldwide retail presence

You haven't actually tried being an Apple user outside of the first world, have you?

Apple's consistent, worldwide retail presence in Poland consists of two "Apple shops" in Warsaw [1]. Apple's consistent, worldwide retail presence in Trinidad and Tobago consists of not-officially-authorized resellers [2]. These are not the exceptions.

[1] http://www.apple.com/pl/buy/shop/ [2] http://latam.apple.com/lae/buy/index.php?ctry=TT

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by danilocampos on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @06:52PM (#2282013)
I was in Hong Kong a few months ago. Apple doesn't have any of their own stores there but I was surprised how many third party retailers picked up on doing things their way.

In the IFC, an awesome knockoff of a real Apple store sells Macs and iPads in a bright, open space, letting users kick the tires.

A Fortress store in Macau wasn't nearly as Apple-like as all that, but you could still poke around at a real iPad.

They may not be, themselves, in every single country, but 300 stores on four continents and in eleven countries is a much bigger hands-on presence than other competing tablet manufacturers can claim, without even getting into the third party distributors that cover even more of the globe.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by jarek on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @07:03PM (#2282047)
Try handling a warranty claim on a Dell and an Apple, or a Nokia and an Apple, outside the first world.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by joezydeco on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @06:01PM (#2281811)
There's a history of well-respected companies that made cheap and inferior products with the honored brand label on them.

And guess what? People figure it out. Shall we build a list? I'll start: Cadillac Catera.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by afterburner on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:08PM (#2281055)
35% thinner, 15% lighter, HDMI out, plus the improvements you mentioned... it's not revolutionary, but it's a strong second showing I think. It'd be nice if it was a lot lighter, but that's battery tech and the 10 hour choice speaking.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by ary on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:33PM (#2280863)
I suspect that when iOS 5 is announced there will be more to say about the iPad 2's abilities. We'll see I guess.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by potatolicious on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:29PM (#2281414)
They really need to fix the notification system and the multitasking model. Now that we have a CPU that screams while sipping power, there's not a large case against it.

The constant waiting (IM apps in particular) when task-switching is aggravating, and the one point where Android can really whip the hell out of the iPad.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by ary on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @05:33PM (#2281682)
Agreed. Judging from banter on the web the iOS notification system is approaching "Fix The F Finder" levels of frustration.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by vyrotek on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:35PM (#2280880)
They needed to give you reasons to buy the iPad 3 of course.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by rbarooah on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:48PM (#2280947)
Does anyone seriously think they are deliberately holding back?
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by ghshephard on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:01PM (#2281020)
Apple is well known for coming up with ten prototypes, bringing it down to three potential shipping products, and then selecting just one.

You can be certain that somewhere in mid 2010, there was a higher resolution version of the iPad 2 that was either in the first group of ten, or possibly even down selected to the final group of three. For reasons of cost, power consumption, or, perhaps competitive pressure (Nobody else was coming out with a tablet with a high resolution, so they could hold off until the iPad 3, or possibly 4) that was not the product you saw today.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by rkudeshi on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:00PM (#2281288)
I've never heard of that (whittling 10 prototypes to 3, then picking 1) - source?
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by kbutler on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @05:43PM (#2281733)
http://www.pragmaticmarketing.com/publications/magazine/6/4/...

10 to 3 to 1. Take the pixel-perfect approach and pile on top of it the requirement that Apple designers expect to design 10 different mockups of any new feature under consideration. And these are not just crappy mockups; they all represent different, but really good, implementations that are faithful to the product specifications.

Then, by using specified criteria, they narrow these 10 ideas down to three options, which the team spends months further developing…until they finally narrow down to the one final concept that truly represents their best work for production.

This approach is intended to offer enormous latitude for creativity that breaks past restrictions. But it also means they inherently plan to throw away 90% of the work they do. I don’t know many organizations for which this would be an acceptable ratio. Your CFO would probably declare, “All I see is money going down the drain.” This is a major reason why I say you can’t innovate like Apple.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by SandB0x on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @02:58PM (#2281002)
Well, they don't have any serious competition at the moment. Why push prices up or profit margins down with a high res screen when they can introduce one at a later (and cheaper) date?
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by rbarooah on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:28PM (#2281141)
Pushing prices up or margins down would make them less competitive. More importantly, they have to be able to manufacture with quality in increasingly gigantic volume. Sure they're making choices, but that's not the same as holding back.
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by jokermatt999 on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:50PM (#2281243)
It's also a nice trump card to pull out if a nice shiny new tablet looks like it will begin eating into Apple's marketshare. If they think the iPad 2 can already comfortably take on the Xoom (etc), why would they try to add too much now?
Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by niallsmart on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @03:59PM (#2281283)
USB? What, exactly, do you want to plug into it?

It will run iOS 5 when it's ready (good luck getting the latest Android releases on non-Google hardware).

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by Pewpewarrows on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:26PM (#2281402)
Nearly every Android device has been made to run up to almost the latest version of the OS.

Good luck with iOS 5 practically bricking the all but the latest hardware coming out of Apple because the phone slows to a crawl.

Re:Live from Apple's iPad 2 event by marknutter on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @04:59PM (#2281541)
USB Ports? Really?