In a true free market scenario with freely floating currencies, currencies in countries like Spain, Italy, Ireland, Greece would have devalued. Germany's currency would have strengthened. This would have made German exports (to other EU countries) much less competitive than they currently are.
However, the Euro tightly integrates these other countries with Germany and makes it very difficult for them to revive their economies.
Using a single currency without a single federal government was a risk for all countries involved. Germany has a huge interest in keeping the Euro alive and the EU as a single unit. It shouldn't be surprising that many people in other European countries expect something in return (for having given up the options that they had before the Euro)
Well, even without free-floating currencies, countries like Greece could just lower the wages, which would in turn reduce the price-level of Greek products, making them more competitive.
In a truly free market situation the bond market likely would have stopped buying Greek bonds because of the fear of currency devaluation long before their structural problems became overwhelming. Sometimes though the bond markets make a bad bet and currency devaluation becomes necessary. That's the free market. There's risk in buying bonds. However, in the EU the bonds have an implicit guarantee from the ECB, Germany, and France.
There's a reason why this kind of thing might be true, because bond holders might hope for intervention, as indeed happened. But I doubt it in this case: (i) the Euro treaty forbade intervention, and (ii) the CDS markets, which one would think would be very sensitive to risk of default, were not worried until shortly before the bond markets proper were.
But note that the Euro is for the purposes of this situation equivalent to the gold standard. Fixing exchange rates means trading the risk of currency depreciation for an increased risk of default, as we seem to be assuming the bonds are issued in the local currency.
The issue here seems to have been ignorance on the part of bind investors to the reality of the Greek situation.
I'm from Germany, I'm not pissed. I wouldn't vote against the currency and was actually glad when it was introduced. qed.
Jeder Zweite will zurück zur D-Mark
Every second german wants the D-mark back
Date: 27.12.2010
That doesn't sound inaccurate. Tabloid != incorrect, you know. Tabloid is merely a pejorative label applied to newspapers which don't attempt to hide their opinions.
They reach (according to Wikipedia. YMMV) > 12 million readers. If after their anti Euro campaign (again, ignoring the facts at all) still 50% of the population are in favor, how does this even remotely make the non-supporters a majority?
Having done the numbers: The track record for facts from that specific newspaper is poor. Even if you like their agenda in this point, please don't implicate that they are NOT largely misleading (to avoid harsher terms).
Likewise the German opposition to default is not widely examined: weak German banks, esp. the Landesbanken, are heavily exposed to peripheral Euro debt (who was better placed to offer loans for those shiny German exports?), and the farce that was the stress tests would quickly be exposed if there were defaults in Greece, Ireland, let alone Spain. Why was the Germany finance ministry to openness about the stress tests.
The problem is a hangover from a slack money culture that existed before the crash, and slack money requires more than feckless borrowers, it also requires irresponsible lenders. There may be a morality tale in here somewhere, but it's not the simple good country bad country one from the Bild.
The Euro may not have been welcomed by the people but it was welcomed by corporations and banks. Corporations and banks had (have) more power.
Personally, I find the success of Germany not terribly surprising given that they were going okay before union. The thing that perplexes me is these other countries that are falling apart, as they didn't strike me as so terribly fragile either.
People say "oh, they are lazy", but laziness creates a vacuum, and somebody will step in to take advantage of the opportunities.
try politicians, imposing their priorities on the population. soeculation has about zero relevance to this question. it's a matter of political will.
Ironically the states most in need of help have been saying "Nope, don't give me any stimulus money. Don't give me money for high speed rail"
And (stupid?) sources of these commentaries keep forgetting that Germany and France (but AFAIK mostly Germany) are footing majority of "european" expenses. German workers are the ones willing to tolerate lower wages so that others will be able to develop and compete with them easier.
I mean think of it - these guys dug themselves out of shit, while bailing out the rest of Europe. Using mostly common sense and hard work. They also had a retirement plan reforms, which changed retirement from 65 to 67 (!!!!!) for men and they took it with grace, no riots no thrashing of commonwealth (Greece? France??).
Disclaimer: I am not German, but I wish that my national leaders would have the integrity and vision of German leaders.
unions, pensioners, students, etc... got their own leaders which are defrauding the people they should lead.
Thats the difference between Germany and the rest of the Europe. Maybe in industry the fact that workers get to share the board with investors help, I don't know. But I know that Germans manage to not shit in their plate time and again.
Edit: Why am I getting down voted on this?
What I care for is the counterview or an explanation that might help me perfect my worldview :).
Still, I think, it is deplorable how little respect the Germans get for simply making what others want. They're doing that very well and other European nations should ask themselves how they do it instead of complaining about a two speed economy. Get up to speed guys!
It isn't paper that the world is borrowing from Germany; its the labor of Germans.
If the rest of the world stops subsidizing credit and balanced their budgets, the principle effect will be a decline in interest rates in Germany. And Germans will find it more reasonable to consume more or start new companies at home.
Its not a problem. Germany wins either way.
And those that keep consuming more than they produce will continue to lose, just as individuals do that behave unwisely.
(There were people who benefited from the economic growth - I count myself among them - but that doesn't invalidate the argument regarding the whole work force)
The net lender countries didn't experience the same wage growth. But they didn't see their currencies inflate either. Except for those otherwise soundly managed countries that for some reason share a currency with a bunch of poorly managed countries. These countries got the stable wages and the privilege of subsidizing their partners.
The comparision between private households and state households is invalid. That's on of the main errors of Neo capitalism. What is wise for individuals is dumb for states.
Because states households are circuits. They press and rotate money. The money they spend comes back partially.
Private individuals households are linear they receive and spend money. The money they spend is lost forever for them.
Money spent by government comes back as tax income by stimulated economic growth.
You're ignoring the fact that said money was stimulating economic growth before govt took it.
Govt spending is not stimulating. Stimulating spending is stimulating, regardless of who does it. Unstimulating spending is unstimulation, regardless of who does it.
The difference between private spending and public spending is that private spending is usually an attempt to make money while public spending is a combination of keeping govt employees happy and buying votes. (Yes, the two are related.)
Private investors are much more likely to earn a return on an investment. Which means they can keep re-investing it.
Yes, you get all the "stimulating" effect without destroying wealth. Of course, its been that way wherever societies become wealthy.
And government handles all of the "investments" wherever societies become poor.
Of course, the answer is whenever the group becomes large enough so that people lose track of who's taking what.
Government likes to make waves on the pond, point out the highs and distract you from the lows and how much disruption is created.
When the group is small, its a lot easier to identify someone that's just splashing around and claiming to create value.
The motivation of trade is simply comparative advantage. Trade is beneficial regardless of whether the products being traded have equal value.
If other nations became more productive, the German current account surplus would shrink and the global productivity level, by implication, would be higher than now. My argument rests on a simple assumption: Higher productivity equals greater wealth. This can of course be questioned on a philosophical level, but not on the basis of mainstream economics.
I don't, but I believe someone has to buy this production or increased productivity doesn't help anyone.
Your assumption sounds correct, but isn't the base of Germany's economic growth in the last years: Germany didn't increase productivity (at least not by a significant margin), but decreased wages (compared with it's neighbors). And this decreased wealth.
I don't deny at all that there are many short term effects and flucuations that have nothing to do with productivity. But we're talking about the different speeds of European economies and those different speeds correlate very well with different levels of productivity.
And look at the Greek stock market. The biggest non financial companies there are a Coke bottling company and the lottery. The biggest German listed company (I believe) is Siemens, which makes high tech industrial equipment like power plants or health care equipment. The Chinese want that. They need energy, they don't want to play in the Greek lottery and they can bottle their own Coke. That's the reason for the two speed economy.
I agree with your argument -- IIUC you're invoking comparative advantage. But the two concepts above are fundamentally different. Wealth is a stock, while productivity is a flow multiplier (e.g. A(t) in Solow model: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solow_residual). Saying "equals" is a bit adventurous, IMHO. Probably a bit pedantic, but then you do stress that that statement is on the basis of "mainstream economics".
As to the idea that the monetary union was voluntary: the monetary union was a political project, not an economic one. By opting out, nations were to some degree dissenting against the entire EU project. Without some degree of fiscal union, it was probably a mistake; but it's unlikely such a union could have ever occurred without a monetary crisis. In many ways, the monetary union was a leap of faith into greater union, with the idea that we could sort out the problems later (never let a good crisis go to waste, etc.).
I remember the discussion over Greece at the time - about how extra leeway was made to squeeze Greece in a couple of years late. Everybody knew about it. The explicit extent of it was in the news not long after:
Sep 2004 http://euobserver.com/?aid=17351 : "Greece was in breach of the euro rules at the time it joined the single currency, according to new figures produced today by the Greek government."
Re Germany - it was at risk of deflation! German politicians were constantly moaning about how high ECB rates were, and how they had to be lowered, and that was the wide consensus of economists too:
Apr 2003 https://www.economist.com/node/1695123 : "Most economists agree interest rates are too high for Germany"
Jun 2003 http://www.wsws.org/articles/2003/jun2003/doll-j04.shtml : "German Finance Minister Hans Eichel said that the strong euro gave the ECB the opportunity to cut interest rates"
Apr 2004 http://www.economist.com/node/2608090 "Even if Mr Schröder does not get the interest-rate cut he wants [...]"
Aug 2004 http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/2893715/Economi... "It is widely appreciated that rates haven't been cut far or fast enough for Germany."
No-one forced Germany into the monetary union either...
The Greek were not forced or pressured to join the MU. The article does not say that at all. They wanted to join and the other countries didn't want to block them even though they suspected the numbers weren't quite right. The full extent of Greek book cooking was only revealed in 2010 (or 2009?).
Edit: I apologize to readers and commenters - I got out of context, I'm not referring only to the current monetary/fiscal position of Germany, but to the whole process that got everybody where they are.
This ruin was in the making for decades. While germans were busy figuring out how to produce better stuff for cheaper PIIGS were busy figuring out how to sell shit for more.
One strategy is hard short term, but bears long term dividends - the other is awesome short term but spells ruin in the long term and the ruin came.
And now the Germany is at fault for all the years of support, encouragement, warnings and leading by example to these countries? I don't buy it :)
The gains to Ireland from 1990-2000 or so were real; the Celtic Tiger wasn't hype. Much of the gains in the past decade, however, were from too low an interest rate.