I won't call their approach a "start-up" or even unique one, especially considering they made a huge component of this (Raptor) in a pretty standard way. Building in a "tent" just means they don't need anything more than it being a tent right now, not that they won't ever need more.
For some reason, rocket engineering has that reputation of being a complete waterfall process. It isn't deserved and doesn't make sense. Rapid iterative development and quick discarding of failing prototypes in the early phase is as common in space industry as it is everywhere. It just doesn't usually make headlines and isn't that visible.
[1] https://www.amazon.com/Skunk-Works-Personal-Memoir-Lockheed/...
The industrial revolution made iterative design possible because it made the time and effort of producing something far cheaper.
This is a failure, and failure is perfectly ok working on something like this, but what drives people to volunteer their time to spin such things as positively as possible or even signal boost ? I can’t believe it’s purely investor driven. It’s almost as if people are finding personal purpose in sacrificing their time to this cause.
Many people like to dream big, but most of the time life is mundane. SpaceX's efforts are the embodiment of sci-fi fantasy with a chance of becoming real. Why not cheer?
Let people enjoy things.
Regarding the cost, the aerospace industry needs some scrappy young start ups. However, quality pedigree is a large chunk of the cost of flight and SpaceX has shown some gaps in the past. I think a big question is whether they can keep that scrappy startup up culture while also building processes robust enough to meet space flight quality standards
Say they have a check valve in their titanium system that fails. They could spend a lot of research dollars on the fundamental science of why that valve failed or just replace it with a burst disk. From an operational engineering point, they may feel like they solved the problem. But from a scientific standpoint we haven’t learned much other than “check valves are bad”.
It’s akin to the old joke about a mathematician, physicist, and engineer trying to find the volume of a cow. The mathematician tries to formulate a triple integral for the cow’s shape. The physicist drops the cow in water and measures the displacement. The engineer says, “let’s suppose the cow is a sphere...”
Point being, often in engineering they’re shooting for “good enough to get the job done” not to increase fundamental understanding
What has convinced you that this is optimal, or even "good", in either software or space technology?
>This fundamental difference is why SpaceX is slowly coming to dominate the industry.
They're making progress in the industry, sure. But dominating it? In what sense is this true?
In addition to capturing most of the commercial market that makes sense for them.
They are NASA most trusted partner, for both cargo to ISS. They will be the first private company to fly humans into orbit.
They are by far the cheapest, and even the rockets that are in development can't really compete against their lineup.
They are operating the largest launch vehicle on the planet.
They are universally considered to be the global leader in rocket engine design as both their Merlin and Raptor engines break many records and did stuff people thought was not possible.
They are in prime position to capture the single most valuable space market, LEO internet.
They are clearly the dominant player in the industry, every other player has admired it. Russian are out of commercial launch, Europeans are spending 2.5 billion to develop the Ariane 6 (who already has problems finding missions), ULA is dropping both their Atlas and Delta rocket to have a chance against SpaceX, and they have a very clear strategy to focus only on military and NASA launches.
This is a silly loss, as it sounds like it was a test procedure error and not a valuable experimental failure. But even then, how much is lost? The rocket was built on-site in a tent, welding some cheap steel together. They've got more test articles being built. The engine is probably salvageable. This is a month or two set-back at worst.
And just like when our software fails in a silly way, I'll bet you there will be new automatic tests, procedures, etc, so that this kind of error can't happen again. They'll learn, iterate, and continue to move fast (and break things).
With nearly all of their competitors, any kind of failure like this would be millions of dollars lost, months or years of setback. This fundamental difference is why SpaceX is slowly coming to dominate the industry.