News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by CydeWeys on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:01AM (#22748087)
This is going to turn out to have been a huge mistake once the actual .crypto is added as a real TLD to root DNS come ICANN's round 2 expansion of new gTLDs.
Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by drcode on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:39PM (#22751392)
Are we supposed to care that ICANN's feelings are hurt? Hopefully this is a step to replacing ICANN with something better.

If you think ICANN is some sort of magical organization that should get to decide all TLDs, just vote with your feet and don't use Opera.

Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by CydeWeys on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @03:34PM (#22752720)
ICANN's feelings are irrelevant here. The point is that they control the DNS root servers and no one else does, so anyone claiming to operate a TLD that isn't actually in the root servers is gonna have a bad time.

Think of what a disaster this is going to be if .crypto is launched for real in a few years. Opera is likely going to go with the real .crypto in the root DNS, thus dumping all these blockchain ones, but even if they don't, there's the problem that now .crypto domains will resolve differently in Opera than in all other browsers. That is a security/usability nightmare.

> If you think ICANN is some sort of magical organization that should get to decide all TLDs

There's nothing magical about ICANN whatsoever, and the normative claim you're making here is irrelevant. They are the organization that decides TLDs, period, and pretending that they aren't when the other 99.999% of users and devices on the Internet do use root DNS and root DNS only is a recipe for disaster.

Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by konschubert on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @06:13PM (#22754057)
The ICANN .crypto might simply not get launched or fail after launch if the name is already taken.
Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by CydeWeys on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @06:35PM (#22754204)
If they haven't delegated it yet then it's by definition not yet taken as far as they're concerned, and they're the ones that make these decisions.

Let me put it in different terms: ICANN currently has a monopoly on the issuance of new TLDs that has so far banked hundreds of millions of dollars for them. There's no way in hell they're going to voluntarily give up this monopoly and just let any random people start a new TLD without going through them.

Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by bdcravens on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @05:45PM (#22753841)
> the system is riding on top of the existing DNS rather than operating as an alternative

I assume that if .crypto becomes a TLD, Opera will default to DNS lookup first.

Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by dmurray on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @10:50AM (#22749166)
If it has enough adoption, hopefully ICANN would reserve it for Opera or Unstoppable Domains, in the same way they wouldn't sell me .coke or .google.
Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by CydeWeys on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:12PM (#22750272)
ICANN wouldn't sell you .google because we already own it. They wouldn't sell you .cocacola because that's an unambiguous brand name that would only go to the rightful TM holder. They would sell you .coke depending on your use case; that's a generic word that has plenty of non-brand meanings, particularly in mining and refining: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coke

But ICANN would have no qualms whatsoever about selling a TLD just because some other people claimed authority over it they didn't actually have and started misusing it.

Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by contravariant on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @11:37AM (#22749763)
Why on earth didn't they try to use a TLD for it though? Why would you use a feature of the protocol you're trying to replace?

It would have made much more sense to define a new URI scheme.

Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by CydeWeys on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @12:16PM (#22750332)
A new URI would have made a lot more sense. This current plan, intentionally causing collisions with actual real DNS, is a disaster in the making. .crypto is one of the most desired and anticipated strings for the next round of gTLD expansion, and ICANN is not gonna forego the revenue from that auction. This is all a guaranteed disaster in the making.
Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by labawi on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @02:23PM (#22751920)
Did you mean a new scheme? AFAIK both http, https, and ftp, ssh, rtp, whatever protocols refer to names in their URIs. Names, which may be resolved by different, configurable methods, a few of which are popular, DNS among them, but also hosts files, avahi, netbios, maybe others. There are usually at least 2 of them active.

ICANN is a corrupt organization that has usurped the power to delegate all names, relegating all of them¹ to their² DNS system where, ever since gTLDs, they may be expected lend just about any name. In effect, you are expected not to use a hostname, even on a local network, without paying tribute.

IMO, ICANN needs to be put down, or put to its place, as they do not have a natural right to all hostnames. If they wish to remain an authority on hostnames, they should reserve names for other uses besides DNS.

And stop with the gTLDs - it they give out all interesting TLDs, then there can't be non-colliding alternatives. IMO, if they collide, both are to blame, but ICANN more so than Opera, as they apparently reserve 0 viable host name hierarchies for uses other than DNS.

Please correct me if I'm wrong, some details may be incorrect.

¹ AFAIK exceptions are reserved TLDs: test, example, invalid and localhost. Not really a place for an alternate name system.

² AFAIK there used to be alternative DNS roots.

Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by CydeWeys on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @03:37PM (#22752746)
You've got quite an agenda here, but the nitpicks don't change the simple fact that making a fake TLD that isn't in root DNS, when the vast majority of users and devices out there will continue using root DNS and root DNS only, is a really bad idea. I'd even go so far as to call it foolish. That's why using a different URI scheme would be smarter: you can control it. You can't control root DNS because that's ICANN's job. At best you can control stuff at the TLD level, if ICANN lets you by delegating you a TLD.
Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by labawi on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @04:44PM (#22753310)
Hostnames and DNS are not equivalent. Those are not nitpicks.

People use alternative name systems. They can be used with existing protocols and URIs. It's explicitly supported - neither local hosts file nor avahi are DNS. Problem is you need names to use, and you can't really pick non-conflicting ones, if any new gTLDs may be issued by ICANN.

There are alternative name systems, mostly using unique alternative TLDs and AFAIK none of them are registered or reserved at ICANN. I presume ICANN doesn't support it, or they want payments as in gTLDs. Payments for protection against future conflicts, not for a service as they do not resolve in DNS.

The article may not be clear, but AFAICT *.crypto are in fact resolving domains (among doing other things). When I install support for crypto names on my system, am I supposed to use something like:

  ping crypto:<domain>
  ping --crypto <domain>
How would an alternate URI scheme help?

I agree appropriating .crypto in particular may be a bit presumptuous. At the same time, one might expect .crypto to be administered by crypto, in whatever chaotic way people side with, along with the ensuing brokenness.

Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by CydeWeys on Friday April 03, 2020 @02:02PM (#22772259)
People shouldn't be using alternative name systems. It causes a huge amount of pain and has been known to do so for several decades now. See: https://jdebp.eu/FGA/dns-use-domain-names-that-you-own.html

The best advice is to use a REAL name, that you own. The second best advice is to, if for some reason you insist on using a fake name, pick something with a low probability of causing collisions. .crypto has a very high probability of causing collisions and is thus a terrible choice.

Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by Wilya on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:09AM (#22748143)
Yeah. After the .dev disaster, you'd think people would have learned their lesson...
Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by mercer on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:22AM (#22748234)
I have a .dev domain and completely missed this. What happened?
Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by OskarS on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:29AM (#22748281)
Google owns the .dev TLD, and they bought it for entirely internal use. People got upset about this (any company owning a TLD for internal use only is pretty weird, and especially one as generic as ".dev") so they started to offer it to the public.

The bigger issue is that a lot of people use .dev for internal/development uses, and it should therefore never been made into a "real" TLD in the first place. It's like deciding to sell "example.com" to someone.

Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by toxican on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:38PM (#22755454)
If anyone's curious, there's a shortlist of "official" TLDs to use for local development https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc2606#section-2

I could've swore .local was okay, as that's what I use. But maybe not. Apparently it can cause issues with Macs, but that's new to me seeing as how I primarily develop on one.

Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by mercer on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:42AM (#22748396)
I registered a .dev for my company, but because it's a company of one I imagine this won't affect me then. Good to know though. I do recall using .dev for local/internal development years ago...

EDIT: so would this mean that registering a .dev for some BigCo domain could potentially cause problems? Curious what the real-world implications might be.

Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by eugeniub on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:48AM (#22748433)
I don’t think there are really any implications moving forward. It only affected developers in the first place. Developers have since been forced to stop using .dev for development, thanks to the existence actual .dev domains.
Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by OskarS on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @11:15AM (#22749500)
Yeah, at this point the horse is out of the barn, so don't worry about registering a .dev. Any damage that would be done has already happened. The point is it shouldn't have happened in the first place.
Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by judge2020 on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:57AM (#22748487)
Developers have been using <something>.dev as their localhost hostname even though the .dev TLD wasn't a designated test/reserved TLD[0]. Everyone's non-https development environments broke when Google added the TLD to HSTS preload, forcing browsers to load it in HTTPS.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15268701

0: https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc2606#section-2

Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by efdee on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:25AM (#22748253)
Many people were using the .dev tld as some sort of local tld.
Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by beefhash on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:36AM (#22748343)
And I guess it was probably cheaper for Google to just buy the TLD and not fix their internal processes?
Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by untog on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:42AM (#22748398)
Well I think buying it was also to the benefit of everyone else using .dev locally. But oh well.
Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by efdee on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @01:36PM (#22751359)
Not really. Suddenly, .dev is a real TLD instead of a fictional one we use for local hostnames.
Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain by diggan on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @10:13AM (#22748635)
I think ICANN will continue with more disasters, you just wait :)