Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain
by konschubert on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @06:13PM
(#22754057)
The ICANN .crypto might simply not get launched or fail after launch if the name is already taken.
Re:Opera to support sites using the .crypto top-level domain
by CydeWeys on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @06:35PM
(#22754204)
If they haven't delegated it yet then it's by definition not yet taken as far as they're concerned, and they're the ones that make these decisions.
Let me put it in different terms: ICANN currently has a monopoly on the issuance of new TLDs that has so far banked hundreds of millions of dollars for them. There's no way in hell they're going to voluntarily give up this monopoly and just let any random people start a new TLD without going through them.
Think of what a disaster this is going to be if .crypto is launched for real in a few years. Opera is likely going to go with the real .crypto in the root DNS, thus dumping all these blockchain ones, but even if they don't, there's the problem that now .crypto domains will resolve differently in Opera than in all other browsers. That is a security/usability nightmare.
> If you think ICANN is some sort of magical organization that should get to decide all TLDs
There's nothing magical about ICANN whatsoever, and the normative claim you're making here is irrelevant. They are the organization that decides TLDs, period, and pretending that they aren't when the other 99.999% of users and devices on the Internet do use root DNS and root DNS only is a recipe for disaster.