News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: I lost my job by gwbas1c on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @08:51AM (#22748030)
(Can't stop thinking about this thread)

> In retrospect, higher ups did mention in passing about an year ago about how I need to speak up in meetings etc.

That's a critical point. If you have 15 years experience, even if you don't have a "leadership" title, you are expected to demonstrate some leadership in meetings.

First: In the meeting, you should be able to discuss tradeoffs, explain why certain things are easier, safer, or more dangerous. You should be able to give context and have an opinion. Your opinions need to be fair and unbiased, or you should be able to point out that you're biased towards a particular approach. You're in the meeting for your experience, both career experience, and (if you've been in the job for awhile,) experience with the product(s).

Second, and this is more critical, but harder to do: You need to be able to stop bad meetings. In some cases, this is a matter of just telling someone that their 20 person invite list is too long. In other cases, you need to interrupt people and force them to make their point or move on; or you need to interrupt a meeting to politely excuse half of the people in the room who don't need to be there.

Yes, it's technically management's job to stop bad meetings, but it's also your job too. Stopping bad meetings is everybody's job, but it falls on the most experienced people on a team to lead by setting an example.

Re:Ask HN: I lost my job by _jal on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:25PM (#22755377)
> Stopping bad meetings is everybody's job

Maybe in a perfect world, but this is heavily context-dependent. Ignore office culture/politics at your own risk.

Re:Ask HN: I lost my job by bargl on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:01PM (#22755228)
This is really great advice. But it's important to know your audience too. I'm a fairly (very) blunt person. I'd follow this advice to the letter with most of my bosses and deal with fallout when necessary. At least that's my go to method.

But I've found that at times it's better to work within the system a little bit like. IMing my boss if we're in the meeting to check with him first.

Re:Ask HN: I lost my job by eyegor on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:44PM (#22755488)
What makes a meeting bad? Is it getting off-topic, non productive, that sort of thing? If so, wouldn't it make more sense to re-orient the group than to stop it?

Stopping a meeting seems like a massive waste of resources, especially when you've already gathered the folks that can fix it.

Re:Ask HN: I lost my job by topkai22 on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @10:56PM (#22755853)
A good meeting should generally be transmitting information effectively or driving to a decision. If a meeting is unable to do that, it should be stopped.

Stopping a meeting in the middle of the planned duration is a bit dramatic, but if it’s clear after 15 minutes the group collectively doesn’t have the information needed to make a decision, its worth stopping.

I’m currently spending a quarter of my day or more in status meetings of various types. I will absolutely tell people I’m dropping (which is a the “lite” version of stopping a meeting) if they stop providing value.

Re:Ask HN: I lost my job by gwbas1c on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @11:40PM (#22756007)
Sometimes the meeting turns into a discussion among 2-3 people with a large audience, sometimes the discussion turns circular where everyone just repeats themselves.

> when you've already gathered the folks that can fix it.

Far too many people gather the wrong people, and stopping to excuse people is critical.

Re:Ask HN: I lost my job by sys_64738 on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @10:22PM (#22755674)
Bad meetings usually don't have agendas. Don't attend a meeting without an agenda.
Re:Ask HN: I lost my job by p1esk on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:10PM (#22755278)
You need to be able to stop bad meetings

This is a really bad advice, especially in this context. Don't annoy or confront your coworkers. Tell your manager if you feel like stopping some meetings. It's strictly their job, and they will be happy to step in and do that. Besides, any meeting of 20 people should have a manager present.

Re:Ask HN: I lost my job by danielvinson on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:35PM (#22755426)
It really depends on the company. At every company I've worked at, either the company was too small to be able to invite that many people (it would basically be an all-hands) or the management was the ones planning these meetings.

In my experience, the way to handle this is usually a quick Slack conversation with the meeting organizer starting with "hey, I saw you invited all of team X to the meeting - do they all need to be there or just Y". The response is almost always "I don't know anyone on that team so I just invited them all", and by initiating the conversation you are offering to help.

Re:Ask HN: I lost my job by timClicks on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:40PM (#22755466)
That's the point. Doing this effectively means interrupting the meeting without annoying coworkers. Everyone stuck in an unproductive meeting wants to do the rest of the items on their list. But no one feels that they have the authority to act as a circuit breaker.
Re:Ask HN: I lost my job by gauravjain13 on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:51PM (#22755524)
Valid point, but I wouldn’t be so prescriptive. It’s also about understanding other variables — the culture of your workplace, the particular meeting/situation — and calibrating your approach accordingly. Of course, easier said than done.
Re:Ask HN: I lost my job by gwbas1c on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @11:30PM (#22755975)
The point of being a leader is you don't need to go through your manager when someone's wasting your team's time.
Re:Ask HN: I lost my job by 2bitencryption on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:30PM (#22755395)
I'm constantly in awe of my manager's ability to fix a bad meeting in real-time. It's amazing. And he's never even slightly rude about it.
Re:Ask HN: I lost my job by fekunde on Wednesday April 01, 2020 @09:40PM (#22755465)
Any anecdotes as to how they do it?
Re:Ask HN: I lost my job by 2bitencryption on Thursday April 02, 2020 @03:31PM (#22762743)
Hard to say any specific anecdotes for how he does it. It's mostly in attitude; how he says things rather than what he says. You can tell from his attitude that when he challenges you, it's not to put you down or exert authority, it's because he genuinely wants everyone to come to the strongest conclusion. (Even if most people think they also act this way, probably they don't, or they don't express it that well).

There will be a discussion that starts meandering, going down rabbit holes, and somehow he'll find the perfect question to ask, which is always a very simple one, to set everyone back on target. Sometimes I don't think people even realize this is happening.

The reason it's hard to explain is because it comes across as an innate character trait, a skill that's just core to his personality, which is why it's so hard to emulate.