The reality is that too many VC funded companies hire too eagerly and can operate perfectly fine (in some cases better) with a smaller, more focused workforce.
There is no coming back from a major across-the-board paycut, which is why no company chooses that option.
BTW your question is answered in the last paragraph of the article.
Are we in a competitive job market still? For whom?
Of course, this piece has been written to provide advice in the face of the current situation, so I'm not simply dismissing it: just asking the question.
I think you’re right that layoffs allow you to take a more targeted approach and retain top talent to the extent that it’s possible. However, really in-demand employees aren’t generally going to want to work at a financially unstable or insecure company, and layoffs would probably be a sign for them to start looking even if they weren’t impacted.
The people that were left survived three rounds of layoffs.
I know this time it’s different than 2008-2011. But no job is stable. The only hope you have is to keep your skillset in line with the market and to have a strong network.
What do you mean?
You're likely to lose your best employees because they know what they are worth and are unlikely to live with a pay cut because working with you is no more special than working for someone else. Losing great employees is not where you want to save money. It's extremely expensive to find, hire, and train people, and once you lose them you also lose their domain knowledge within your company.
If you lose the engineer that built the product that makes you money, good luck modifying or fixing any issues with it in a short amount of time.
Layoffs are about survival, doing what you suggest is a sure fire way to kill your company.
Do you consider restaurants heartless for laying off staff? Cruise lines? Hotels? Entertainment businesses?
It's a tough decision, but failing to make it could be the difference between laying off a few people and laying off everyone because the company goes bankrupt. The key is to do this in a respectful manner so the bridge isn't burned.
I asked payroll if our final check would be affected by the pay cuts and am still waiting an answer.
Some employees will immediately start looking for another job, but that seems totally fine and reasonable to me, both for the employee and the employer. They get to retain most of their income and all their benefits while doing so, and if they do leave successfully that just saves you more money too.
With all of that said, it does occur to me that with small startups there just may not be enough employees for paycuts to help much. The above is really written with 100+ person companies in mind I suppose.