News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by wisty on Sunday February 27, 2011 @04:44AM (#2267586)
I think there's two sides to the story.

Actually, no, there's more than two sides to the story, and the idiots who think there are two sides to the story and making everything worse:

* Some teachers are awful, and the unions protect them. They also manipulate educational policy, both to improve teacher conditions (which is fair enough - that's their job), and to push the pet beliefs of a couple of batty union leaders.

* Most teaching "methods" (fads) suck, and are cooked up by the kind of people who get PhDs in "education" - ivory tower researchers who can't do, and can't teach, but can publish in a naval-gazing journal.

* Most "methods" (fads) require mounds of paperwork, so the teachers can prove they are complying.

* Direct Instruction (DI) was found to be the best teaching method by far, the last time they did any serious research. However, it does cramp creative teachers, and it's quite possible that more serious research will find better methods (possibly based on DI, but not as anal), but the opponents of DI don't want serious research (as their pet "methods" suck, compared to DI, and they know it) and DI fans think the problem is solved.

* Some kids are "special needs". Some kids are dumb. Some kids are smart. Some kids just look dumb because they aren't motivated, and some kids just look smart because they are being pushed hard, and nobody can agree what "smart" and "dumb" means. Mixed classes are good in some ways, but they can't be too big (or the teacher can't help the outlying kids). Big classes are good for the better kids, but only if they are streamed.

* Text books are often terrible.

* School work can be assessed (extrinsically motivated) or un-assessed (intrinsically motivated). Extrinsic motivation drives out intrinsic motivation, but some assessment is necessary. The current trend is to pile on more assessment (both tests and formally assessed homework) under the assumption that kids have already been jaded by the existing assessment, and no longer care about learning for learning's sake.

* We are spending too much, and not enough.

* Finally, there's rarely any end goal in mind. Or there are several end goals, and everyone forgets which ones are important. Feeding universities, creating a skilled workforce, providing opportunities for poor kids, getting good numbers in international tests, and most importantly convincing parents (voters) that something needs to be done, and we are already doing all that is humanly possible to help YOUR child beat the kid sitting next to them.

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by moultano on Sunday February 27, 2011 @04:52AM (#2267589)
>Direct Instruction (DI) was found to be the best teaching method by far, the last time they did any serious research.

Do you have any good links that describe what this is? All I seem to be able to find is pages talking about how good it is, but none with a description of it that made any sense to me.

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by wisty on Sunday February 27, 2011 @04:59AM (#2267596)
It's a faddy method, but one that works. It puts a lot of emphasis on fundamentals, but students who focus on fundamentals (in class) are found to be able to do creative stuff with the material out of class. "Wax on, wax off, now go kick ass".

It's very anal, like I said.

The teachers get a DI textbook (made up by the inventor of DI). The teacher reads from the text book, and asks the whole class to respond on cue.

The whole class responding on cue is an important point, as it keeps the students thinking. "Everybody, what's 12 * 8?"

It uses lots of repetition, and a few standardised instructions to the class.

"Everybody open your books, to page 23. One two three. Everybody should have their books open. Put your finger on the word "MY". One two three ... Now everybody read out load ..."

Interesting factoid - "The Pet Goat" (think 911, George W. Bush in a classroom) was a DI book.

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by patio11 on Sunday February 27, 2011 @05:18AM (#2267616)
This is similar to the Japanese pedagogical style at my university, and our grads ROFLstomp peer schools' grads at speaking ability. "Class, you are going to the cinema this afternoon at five. Where are you going? Everyone." "I am going to the cinema at five.". "Good. Patrick, you." "I am going to the cinema at five.". "Good. Patrick, ask Tom. Tom, you are going to the restaurant at seven."

Repeat an hour a day every day for three years and you get really effing good. (Conversations in the third year are, obviously, more elaborate.)

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by Evgeny on Sunday February 27, 2011 @05:08PM (#2269148)
This is very close to how they taught me English long ago in a Soviet school! I have to say I can't complain.
Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by RBerenguel on Sunday February 27, 2011 @06:56AM (#2267699)
Hard-wiring the fundamentals is also the way Korean go players (go is an oriental board game, you maybe saw it in "A beautiful mind", "Pi" and some other movies, or read about it in Kawabata's "The Master of Go") develop their skills. And they have passed from "amateurs" to dominate the pro levels. Now China and Japan are starting to teach in the same way to their prodigies.
Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by wisty on Sunday February 27, 2011 @07:54AM (#2267750)
There's a book currently on my wish-list called "Why Children Hate School", about a cognitive psychologist's take on education. He strongly stresses how important it is to drill fundamentals. The human brain is terrible at doing things it hasn't practised, and tends to avoid doing things that it doesn't know how to do. That's why people switch off when you talk about statistical significance - their brains don't remember statistics so they go to sleep instead of thinking. The path of least resistance is always ignoring things, unless you already know 80% (made up number) of what's being said.

DI is better than more appetising methods (i.e. ones that teachers think they would enjoy learning in), because it drills fundamentals, but I think that better methods could be built using cognitive principles.

Musicians stress practising scales, martial artists practice basic techniques, programmers practice Fizzbuzz every damn time someone links to that article, and everyone practices speaking in front of the mirror. But school-kids don't practice learning.

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by lutorm on Sunday February 27, 2011 @11:37AM (#2268152)
This is fine. Just don't forget that training independent thought is just as crucial.
Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by wisty on Sunday February 27, 2011 @04:04PM (#2268959)
People tend to be pretty good at this anyway, especially if your education system has enough drill work in class that you can reduce the amount of homework kids do.

Creative, open-ended homework is a huge time-sink.

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by pbhjpbhj on Sunday February 27, 2011 @08:42PM (#2269670)
>That's why people switch off when you talk about statistical significance - their brains don't remember statistics so they go to sleep instead of thinking.

That's why it's important to know something of whom you address¹. "Do you follow me?", then give a review, simplification or expansion based on the response.

Your previous description of DI sounds like brain washing intended to wipe out individual identity and sounds as if it makes no effort to consider individual abilities or characters at all?

--

1 - that's probably bad grammar, I was never taught grammar

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by RBerenguel on Sunday February 27, 2011 @04:35PM (#2269041)
As a guitar learner, I can't stress enough how boring scales are... But they are fundamentals. Unless you know them better than your hand, you can't play safely.
Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by michaelchisari on Sunday February 27, 2011 @11:35AM (#2268146)
However, contrast that method with the Finnish system, which is nothing like that, and the top education system in the world.

http://online.wsj.com/public/article/SB120425355065601997-7B...

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by wisty on Sunday February 27, 2011 @04:22PM (#2269007)
It's hard to say whether the Finnish system is really that good.

You have a few confounding factors:

* a middle-class society with no language problems

* less pressure on the students regarding exam scores.

Things that Finland seems to do well (from your article):

* "What they see is a relaxed, back-to-basics approach."

Really, education gets screwed up terribly by all the pressure.

But can you imagine the uproar if teachers stopped teaching the tests?

* "The Norssi School is run like a teaching hospital, with about 800 teacher trainees each year. Graduate students work with kids while instructors evaluate from the sidelines."

When is the last time you heard of a US schools training their teachers? I know teacher-training happens, but it's really half-assed.

And like I said, DI isn't necessarily the best method possible. But there hasn't been any decent research since.

It's like we've found that washing hands saves lives in hospitals, but nobody has bothered to break anything else down statistically, or research why washing hands is good (hint - germs), or even wash hands!

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by vacri on Monday February 28, 2011 @05:58AM (#2270858)
Why do you say no language problems? They have different problems - educating in two languages, Finnish for home use (a unique language no-one else uses) and English to be competitive in the wider world. The article even makes mention of the issues of English.

I think the confounding factor is not "a middle-class society" rather than "a democratic socialist society", where everyone is given the chance to perform instead of being damned by the location of their birth within their country. None of this 'born in poor location, local schools don't have funding' crap.

If the US could get rid of it's endemic Just World fallacy, half of it's problems would be solved...

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by aik on Wednesday March 02, 2011 @12:04AM (#2278526)
To add on to the language problem - all Finns have to learn Swedish as well as English. I came from a strictly Swedish speaking part of Finland, and had to learn Finnish and English from the very start.

And the primary thing that the Finnish society does well: - Everyone respects the teaching profession. - Teachers, who most often are at the top of their class and have a Masters, are given much autonomy and trust.

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by yummyfajitas on Sunday February 27, 2011 @10:24AM (#2267966)
It also makes teachers more or less interchangeable and easily replaceable cogs in the education machine.

I wonder why most educators oppose it?

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by shareme on Sunday February 27, 2011 @05:52AM (#2267648)
You have to go back to how we got here:

1. Prussian Indoctrination Training..that is the model that the USA adopted from Prussia. Prussia wanted to break the control of churches so they came up with this new teaching method and it was made to indoctrinate, not teach.

2. We USA people layered on that indoctrination system some other non-goal aligned stuff like school organized sports rather than have the community pay for the off-school hours sports that they will support.

3. Ones deciding budget have no kids in the local school systems.

4. The original geo-area that was Prussia finally saw the errors of the indoctrination approach and moved to a two-tiered education system. Both vocational and university prep share the same 1-6 grade school classes.

You take some corrective measures like remove sports and have the community pay for the off-time school sports they want to support frees up money to make rest of the changes.

Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by pnathan on Sunday February 27, 2011 @11:53AM (#2268187)
Can you provide a link to #1 please? I would like to know more.
Re:I Don't Want to be a Teacher Any More by joshkaufman on Sunday February 27, 2011 @12:48PM (#2268340)
John Taylor Gatto's "Underground History of American Education": http://www.johntaylorgatto.com/underground/