DI is better than more appetising methods (i.e. ones that teachers think they would enjoy learning in), because it drills fundamentals, but I think that better methods could be built using cognitive principles.
Musicians stress practising scales, martial artists practice basic techniques, programmers practice Fizzbuzz every damn time someone links to that article, and everyone practices speaking in front of the mirror. But school-kids don't practice learning.
Creative, open-ended homework is a huge time-sink.
That's why it's important to know something of whom you address¹. "Do you follow me?", then give a review, simplification or expansion based on the response.
Your previous description of DI sounds like brain washing intended to wipe out individual identity and sounds as if it makes no effort to consider individual abilities or characters at all?
--
1 - that's probably bad grammar, I was never taught grammar