News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:14PM (#22668822)
The herd immunity plan was probably the most rational plan any government put forward. Instead, due to the irrational panic of the population, we've got this. I'm fairly confident time will show leadership was right, and the people wrong, as they tend to be in times of overwhelming uncertainty.

The average age of COVID-19 fatalities in Italy is 80, median 82.5, and 99% of them had co-morbid conditions (an average of 3 comorbid conditions). In China the average age was mid-high 70s. Almost nobody outside a risk category has died so far. [1] These folks were on death's doorstep as is. If I'm not mistaken the plan was, rationally, to lock them inside while the problem sorted itself out.

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-18/99-of-tho...

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by patrec on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:38PM (#22669090)
Most people who compare Italy (and soon the UK) to say, South Korea or Taiwan would probably disagree with you. Also, whilst you might not mind a few hundred thousand or million dead pensioners, I assume at least some of them would rather spend time with their grandchildren than slowly suffocate amidst the remains of a collapsed health care system. Shouldn't the whole overwhelming uncertainty thing predispose you to not trying to infect a few billion people and see what happens? Did it ever occur to you that herd immunity via mass infection might either not work or could cause a lot of long term health problems in people who are not pensioners? If not, what makes you so sure?
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by jskrablin on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:26PM (#22668948)
No it wasn't. Your own scientists came forward with numbers on the cost. And it was too high. Health care system would (it might still) crash, leading to a lot of extra deaths and other unpleasant consequences like backlog of non urgent checkups which can turn out to be urgent several months later.

And please f*ck off with 'only old people die from COVID-19'. Old people with 3 comorbid conditions deserve better than to be left to die because some smartasses feel like it. And there are other groups of people risking dire consequences of COVID-19. Like people with weak immune system. Or ones with diabetes. Or ones being treated for cancer. Should we write off them too?

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:28PM (#22668969)
> And please fck off with 'only old people die from COVID-19'. Old people with 3 comorbid conditions deserve better than to be left to die because some smartasses feel like it. And there are other groups of people risking dire consequences of COVID-19. Like people with weak immune system. Or ones with diabetes. Or ones being treated for cancer. Should we write off them too?

Nobody said that, you didn't read my post.

(1) People in risk categories are at risk. One of which is being old, and another is having a comorbid condition, and a huge one is having 3 comorbid conditions while being 82.5. That's a risk category for getting out of your bed in the morning.

(2) Those people, the old, and with comorbid conditions, were to isolate, as they are doing literally right now.

(3) The whole point behind the process was to create a protective buffer around them, otherwise they wouldn't be calling for their isolation.

Take a deep breath.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by AlexMuir on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @01:46AM (#22672329)
Your answer is coherent and rational and doesn’t deserve to be downvoted. I also agree with you. This situation is taking weeks from absolutely everybody’s lives.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by DanBC on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:31PM (#22668999)
Where "risk category" includes "has diabetes and high blood pressure" -- these are not what most people think of as high risk conditions.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:37PM (#22669071)
Yeah. Did you not think someone was going to tell them before they kicked off the plan?
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by bonzini on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:46PM (#22669165)
Did they organize a way to get them groceries in the 2 weeks before giving in to lockdowns? Or was granny supposed to shop online?
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @12:31AM (#22671956)
Did they say they wouldn't? If grannies getting groceries was the only blocker, I'd deliver them myself.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by bonzini on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @04:03AM (#22672939)
They should have done it already by now, shouldn't they? Granny has been shopping for two weeks while she was supposed to stay home.

It's not the only blocker, just an example of the incompetence with which the UK government has been operating thus far.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by DanBC on Monday March 23, 2020 @06:05PM (#22669311)
They aren't being told. Did you think they were?
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Monday March 23, 2020 @08:11PM (#22670384)
The plan isn't happening.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by DanBC on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @03:55PM (#22678318)
The plan is happening in the UK.

People in vulnerable groups have been told to shield.

There's not much point continuing this conversation: you've been factually incorrect in every single reply you've made to me.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/guidance-on-shiel...

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @10:17PM (#22681400)
(1) This doesn't sounds like their original plan to infect all the youth by locking down the vulnerable and letting the youth out. That is the plan to which I was referring. As you know the UK is on total lockdown for 3 weeks [1]

(2) What is described in this post is what everyone else is doing, keeping the vulnerable inside and providing services such as prescription delivery and at least helping coordinate food delivery. ("Please visit gov.uk/coronavirus-extremely-vulnerable to register for the support that you need. This includes help with food, shopping deliveries and additional care you might need. The government is helping pharmacies to deliver prescriptions. Prescriptions will continue to cover the same length of time as usual.")

(3) It specifically says that everyone in a risk category is getting a letter by March 29th ("The NHS in England is directly contacting people with these conditions to provide further advice.")

I don't really know what you're asking for, or what you think is factually incorrect.

[1] https://www.standard.co.uk/news/health/boris-johnson-coronav...

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by gpderetta on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:32PM (#22669022)
Yes. Old people are still people. And a lot of people that don't die still end up in ICU and can look forward to long term damage.

Having spent a few days in hospital last year for a comparatively mild pneumonia, I'm definitely not looking forward for a repeat.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by lonelappde on Monday March 23, 2020 @09:49PM (#22670993)
Without ICU capacity they die.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by llukas on Monday March 23, 2020 @06:03PM (#22669295)
We written off much larger groups without a blink of an eye. At least in US unexpected expense of $400 puts 1/3 households in financial hardship [1]. What happens with workers when we shut down entire sectors of economy?

[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/23/millions-of-americans-are-on...

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by lonelappde on Monday March 23, 2020 @09:48PM (#22670985)
Hardship beats the hell out of death.

Money is imaginary. It's easy to defer rent payments and mail checks so people can focus on food, medicine, and heat for a while.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @12:14AM (#22671846)
I'll be sure to pass on the "money is imaginary" line to my landlord when they're asking where the check is.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by esotericn on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @03:24AM (#22672786)
In the UK you can now indeed do that.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by mathw on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @03:51AM (#22672892)
Not if you're renting you can't. Renters and the self-employed still largely ignored by the government's support package.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by esotericn on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @04:21AM (#22673027)
Evictions have been halted. The fall out can be dealt with later.

If you're between leases that's quite the pickle.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by spiralx on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @08:25PM (#22680623)
You can't be between leases easily in the UK as without actively signing a new lease the existing one rolls over into standard rental terms (one months notice from tenants, two from landlords) automatically.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by esotericn on Wednesday March 25, 2020 @05:35AM (#22683130)
Two-ish months ago I was staying in an AirBNB and had no rental contract.

I have a secure one now, thankfully. I've actually been pretty lucky with the entire situation as I generally play these things fast and loose.

It's not that hard to just not rent or own a home - tons of people are in unofficial house shares etc :)

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by PopeDotNinja on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:26PM (#22668954)
> The herd immunity plan was probably the most rational plan any government put forward.

It was rational in a parallel world free & infinite healthcare workers + ventilators.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by dingaling on Monday March 23, 2020 @06:20PM (#22669421)
Or rational where ICU beds and ventilators would only be used for those with a chance of survival.

Brutal, but rational.

Tying up resources on an 82yo with two underlying health conditions is not rational.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by dijit on Monday March 23, 2020 @09:14PM (#22670775)
I'm trying to find a polite way to word this and failing:

The moral stance you are taking here is abhorrent and I disagree with it to my very core.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @12:18AM (#22671875)
As do I, as that was never their plan. Their plan was to isolate the aged and the at-risk, well away from those who may infect them, and send everyone else who wouldn't get horribly sick out. This would create a protective barrier around the old and sick. Nobody has proposed what dingaling has suggested.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by lordnacho on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:17PM (#22668858)
Irrational panic, signed by hundreds of experts? It's clear that if we'd just allowed the disease to take its course, the hospital system would be overwhelmed.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by Malcx on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:23PM (#22668921)
How many of those experts were epidemiologists or virologists? Iirc there was 1 microbiologist there but mostly people from math and physics departments. 20% or so were still PhD students...
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by Daishiman on Monday March 23, 2020 @08:38PM (#22670554)
All the pandemic experts who studied and worked with other SARS varieties have the message. I'm not seeing any of those guys saying the threat of COVID-19 is overestimated.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:19PM (#22668877)
Are experts not human, and therefore immune to panic?
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by lordnacho on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:24PM (#22668925)
Really? Hundreds of them? Writing and signing a letter together, based on years of research?

But the cool heads in charge who studied classics are right of course.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:31PM (#22669003)
> But the cool heads in charge who studied classics are right of course.

Clearly not, as evidenced by their lack of proceeding with the plan. That's my point.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by addicted44 on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:43PM (#22669138)
Random HNers though are obviously the best authorities though.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by makomk on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:36PM (#22669058)
Possibly. The press keep pushing South Korea as a better alternative, but to be honest I'm not sure even the South Korean government believes their model is sustainable or viable. New clusters of cases that have escaped contact tracing keep popping up no matter what they do and are causing concern, folks are starting to worry about an autumn second wave there, and I don't think their testing has been as extensive as media reports have implied in important areas like nursing homes and hospitals. (There was a 75-person cluster at a nursing home in Daegu, probably the most heavily tested city in all South Korea, that they only discovered some time around Thursday.)
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by maverick2007 on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:37PM (#22669076)
Honest question (I initially reacted strongly against their herd immunity idea but I've started to rethink my position):

Isn't there evidence that a high enough proportion of those low risk people would require hospitalization too and that would overwhelm the capacity? That's my only remaining concern about the idea.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by alexisread on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:55PM (#22669239)
From what I've read of the statistics yes. In addition, 38% of hospitalizations in the UK are in the 20-54 age range, and this is also ignoring the fact that there isn't enough aftercare to discharge certain patients, again reducing capacity.

FWIW I don't think herd immunity will work given that other corronaviruses (the common cold) mutate frequently, it is too early to tell, but TBH a risky move for any government which can see positive results from other approaches elsewhere.

The current approach is really bourne out of a failure to act early - that $1 antibody testing kit was overlooked by ministers until it was pointed out to them by a journalist. That airports weren't locked down immediately with a 2 week mandatory quarantine, drafting ex-NHS staff only last week was 3 weeks late etc

A cynic might point out that this virus is likely to kick the can down the road wrt pensions /ageing populations /finding an economic model not based around GDP/having more kids. There is a rumour that a senior MP made comments about collateral damage, if you were really cynical it might be pointed out that this constitutes a large portion of some parties' voter base.

There are some silver linings- after all of this teachers are likely to be appreciated as is a national health service (Medicare anyone?), remote working will be easier, and there are some amazing stories of compassion out there!

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by patrec on Monday March 23, 2020 @07:15PM (#22669904)
Great, then you must be the perfect person to alleviate the following additional concerns I still have:

- Isn't there a significant risk that immunity after infection might wear of too soon after infection for herd immunity to be practicable, at least without driving up the deaths yet further?

- Isn't there a significant risk that we end up with a lot of people who survive but have long term health problems?

- Wouldn't the fact that no one else seems to think herd immunity is such a hot idea any more mean the UK faces a high risk to be completely quarantined off by other countries? Brexit probably doesn't reduce the chances of that happening either. Could that not have a few bad economic and other effects?

- Isn't there a significant risk that isolating vulnerable people or the infected in ICUs may not work as well as intended? What if a lot of nurses and doctors get infected and pass it on to other people who have no chronic problems but are temporarily weakened? What if it turns out that seeing a lot of people die miserably without being able to do much about it for weeks on end takes its toll on the current crop of health care professionals or the UK's ability to recruit future generations?

- Wouldn't that most likely mean giving up on eradicating Covid-19 completely? Is it really desirable to permanently reduce life expectancy by keeping it around forever?

- What if the virus changes in an unanticipated direction? Would the herd immunisation strategy not put exactly the type of evolutionary pressure on the virus that you don't want? Namely to become more virulent? Is that not a bit risky?

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @12:19AM (#22671883)
> Is it really desirable to permanently reduce life expectancy by keeping it around forever?

That ship has long since sailed.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by patrec on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @07:47AM (#22674038)
People keep saying so, but I have yet to see compelling evidence. Can you provide some?

For what it's worth, I think eradicating something world-wide that has already spread widely beyond the relatively competent and affluent countries is going to be tough. But personally, I'd much rather see it eradicated in just competent and affluent countries than not at all.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @10:23PM (#22681439)
> But personally, I'd much rather see it eradicated in just competent and affluent countries than not at all.

With something this infectious all it takes is one visitor from one of the have-not countries to put the have-country into total lockdown. That's not a realistic plan moving forward either.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by patrec on Wednesday March 25, 2020 @02:31AM (#22682433)
Two points:

1. People don't just start to magically teleport around if you restrict their travel. I know that defies common wisdom, which is presumably why the UK and others kept (keep?) importing people from disease Epicentres like Milan or Teheran en-masse right up the point of total lockdown. But if, for example, Japan, the UK or Australia decide they don't want Iranians to visit their shores for a while, at least not without on the spot testing, automatic two week quarantine or other heavy restrictions: what is the would be Iranian mass-infector going to do about it? And is greatly restricting travel from incompetent countries really going to wreck your nation?

2. Vaccines are cheap. If it's possible to create a vaccine that is sufficiently safe and covers enough strains of the virus, you can just vaccinate enough of your population that the disease will, effectively, no longer be very infectious. Then you can intelligently spend some comparatively trifling sums to make such vaccination programs available to countries that genuinely can't afford them.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by Dylan16807 on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @12:45AM (#22672040)
> Wouldn't that most likely mean giving up on eradicating Covid-19 completely? Is it really desirable to permanently reduce life expectancy by keeping it around forever?

If herd immunity would have worked, then a vaccine will work. That might be 2022, but it's definitely not forever.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by patrec on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @08:54AM (#22674421)
The problem is that the more cases you have, the higher the likelihood that you will need to end up with multiple strains and need more than one vaccine, which may be fatal to eradication.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by addicted44 on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:42PM (#22669127)
Of course they would.

I won't even claim that severe lockdowns (which is not what anyone in the US or UK is facing) is the best solution.

However, in the absence of almost any reliable knowledge, it's probably the ONLY rational plan based on the fact that the one thing we do know is the method of spreading, and locking down will prevent that spread.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by mathw on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @04:01AM (#22672928)
The only thing we know for sure about this virus is that if people catch it they might die, and various people are at higher risk.

Everything else is still up in the air. We have to buy time, time to find effective antivirals (work in progress), time to get an effective vaccine (work in progress), time to understand the virus enough to know even such a simple thing as how long somebody who's had it and recovered might be immune for. That one critical number you have to know in order to know if a plan like the herd immunity idea is even remotely feasible, that one critical number that NOBODY KNOWS.

Isolation is, from everything I've read, the only strategy currently supported by the available evidence. Maybe in six months we'll have data that says herd immunity would have worked, but we really don't know right now.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by DanBC on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:29PM (#22668978)
People keep banging on about who dies.

That's not the point.

Hospitals become overwhelmed with people who need an ICU bed, and a ventilator, and oxygen, and intubation, for weeks. Sure, they go on to recover, but while they're in those beds it means the health system can't provide other treatment. All those hips and knees go un-replaced; a bunch of cancer care gets cancelled; people involved in accidents go without care. Even if you ignore anyone over 80[1] you still have hospitals full of people who need intensive care.

Watch this video. It's not 80 year olds lying on the floors. This is in Spain, a country with a world-class healthcare system: https://twitter.com/shuja_2006/status/1242161754768953344?s=...

This video shows a mix of ages. https://twitter.com/WellingMichael/status/124145219842648474...

Here's Spain building a field hospital to cope with the numbers: https://twitter.com/VOANews/status/1241882351115939847?s=20

Herd immunity hasn't worked. It's been a catastrophic failure that's flooded hospitals with very ill people.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:36PM (#22669053)
> People keep banging on about who dies. That's not the point.

That's 100% the point. If you know who they are you can isolate them.

> Herd immunity hasn't worked. It's been a catastrophic failure that's flooded hospitals with very ill people.

I assume that you know many people with Polio then?

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by addicted44 on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:46PM (#22669161)
Well, the obvious answer is they die.

So even if young people do not die of Coronavirus (which we do not know for sure) they die because they cannot get medical treatment after cutting their finger on a rusty table edge, or get into a car accident and cannot get medical help, etc.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by bonzini on Monday March 23, 2020 @06:44PM (#22669582)
> > Herd immunity hasn't worked. It's been a catastrophic failure that's flooded hospitals with very ill people.

> I assume that you know many people with Polio then?

It's disingenuous at best to ignore that the parent comment referred specifically to seeking herd immunity (as opposed to early lockdown) of COVID-19.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by DanBC on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:38PM (#22669087)
> That's 100% the point. If you know who they are you can isolate them.

What do you do with everyone else?

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:47PM (#22669174)
Well, everyone's isolated now, so you let the young ones out.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by DanBC on Monday March 23, 2020 @06:07PM (#22669329)
Please just go look at the fucking videos I've already posted, which show hospitals overwhelmed by people under 60 who need a variety of beds, including high dependency ITU beds with intubation, but also less intensive beds with ventilators and oxygen.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @12:21AM (#22671896)
Videos are anecdotes not statistics. I'll wait for the papers.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by zozbot234 on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:52PM (#22669219)
Young folks can still get the disease and end up in the hospital ward or even the ICU. The only ones who might be safe from significant consequences are small kids, who by definition are sharing their household with someone who might be at risk.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by throwawayspain on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:25PM (#22668943)
You have no clue whats going on in Madrid right now. The worst is yet to come. Learn from your neighbour's mistakes. Exponential is real bitch.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by bonzini on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:17PM (#22668860)
It was the most rational. However it also involved the death of hundreds of thousands of people in the process.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:20PM (#22668885)
It did not involve the death of hundreds of thousands. They did not elect Thanos prime minister.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by bonzini on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:37PM (#22669073)
Sure it did.

Let's assume the infected population grows as s(x)=1/(1+e^-x). About 99% of the curve lies from -5 to 5, so let's ignore the rest to simplify the math. Let's then assume that 99% of the people are infected over the course of 180 days, so 1 day is h=10/180=0.055 on s(x). That's a decent attempt at "flattening the curve".

The curve goes from 0 to 1, so if for example s(h/2)-s(-h/2)=0.014, this tells you that around the peak of the infection, 1.4% of the infected population will get the disease in a single day. With 70% of the population getting infected, that's a lot of people (about a million in a single day).

Let's be super optimistic and say that 70% of people getting it means 7% having symptoms and 0.7% needing an ICU bed (younger people also get bad cases, even though the median age of death is high; they just survive thanks to the treatment). Problem is they will need it for 3 weeks (~20 days) so you need a lot of beds.

Specifically s(10h)-s(-10h) = 0.27, that is, 27% of the infected population will get the disease in the 3 weeks around the peak. At this point 27% * 70% * 0.7% of the UK population needs ICU beds at the same time.

That's 80000 people, but the country has just 4000 ICU beds. Those that couldn't be treated would die, and that's just in the 3 weeks around the peak.

It's safe to say that for most of those 6 months the NHS would be so overwhelmed that close to 0.7% * 70% of the UK population would die. It's a back of the envelope calculation, only the order of magnitude makes sense. But still, it's in the hundreds of thousands.

So yes, unless Johnson could find tens of thousands of ICU beds in the next few weeks (because the numbers would reach 10000 or so long before that peak point) those many people would die from lack of treatment. And the NHS would be completely clogged, so more people would die preventable deaths due to lack of room for treating non-COVID-related patients.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by tomarr on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:47PM (#22669171)
Well, it sort of did:

https://www.imperial.ac.uk/media/imperial-college/medicine/s...

Hence the change in tact.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by disgruntledphd2 on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:16PM (#22668840)
The only (small) problem with the herd immunity plan was that it would overwhelm the capacity of the NHS to deal with it.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by dijit on Monday March 23, 2020 @09:17PM (#22670797)
The other (small) problem with herd immunity is that it assumes immunity for a long period, which has no evidence to support it.

Another (small) problem is that there is permanent tissue damage in the lungs in those that recover.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @04:17AM (#22673001)
> The other (small) problem with herd immunity is that it assumes immunity for a long period, which has no evidence to support it.

True that we don’t know that conclusively here yet, although I wonder if we could base it off other similar viruses. Nobody to my knowledge has been reinfected.

Speaking of no evidence...

> Another (small) problem is that there is permanent tissue damage in the lungs in those that recover.

There is no evidence of that in COVID-19 yet. That doesn’t mean it won’t show up, but it doesn’t mean it will. You’re referencing something that happened in related SARS and MERS diseases which killed over 35%, not 0.35%, of those infected. It’s easily a 2 orders of magnitude worse disease.

If you have data or studies share them. Otherwise, stop fearmongering.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by dijit on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @07:02AM (#22673788)
Succinctly; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BtN-goy9VOY

Their very nice citations: https://sites.google.com/view/sourcescorona

Mine:

Coronavirus' (common cold) and immunity: https://text.npr.org/s.php?sId=819038431

COVID-19's permanent impact to the lungs: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/mar/24/coronavirus-wh...

--

On a more personal note: "fearmongering" is preferred over loss of life here. We will never know if we did too much to prevent this. But we will definitely know if we did too little.

Obviously I'm not asking people to panic, in fact, the opposite. Calm, reasonable and responsible actions do not preclude worry and having a healthy amount of fear for you and your loved ones.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Tuesday March 24, 2020 @10:33PM (#22681486)
> Obviously I'm not asking people to panic, in fact, the opposite. Calm, reasonable and responsible actions do not preclude worry and having a healthy amount of fear for you and your loved ones.

Out of the 4 links, I skimmed the YouTube video, read the citations, and both of your links. Neither of your links refer to permanent effects after recovery. The only thing in the citations they're referencing to back up their claim is a one-line exerpt from the WHO report:

'Quote: “Lung tissue also displayed cellular and fibromyxoid exudation,desquamation of pneumocytes and pulmonary oedema.”' This appears to describe the actual condition of people with the disease as they have the disease, not after.

They they go on to cite a study about the much more dangerous SARS-COV-1.

As I said, nothing so far indicates that we will see permanent lung damage, certainly not in the vast majority of cases. It may happen, it may not, but it remains too soon to know for sure.

> On a more personal note: "fearmongering" is preferred over loss of life here.

As you may have noticed people tend not to react well in panic/fear situations, saturate very quickly and become very much irrational. It isn't always true IMO that fearmongering should be the go-to in difficult times when we have to make life or death decisions with limited data.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by dijit on Wednesday March 25, 2020 @03:32AM (#22682660)
To your last point specifically: You might not have noticed, but while some people bought toilet paper in the UK, the majority treated this as some kind of holiday, taking kids out to holiday destinations and playing on the beach and crowded parks.

Businesses were doing everything they could to remain open, even if they were non-essential, forcing employee's to come into the office (often on even more crowded public transportation)

It was so bad that the UK government had to forcefully lock everyone in.

That is not a reasonable approach to a virus of which we don't know the full effects and whos' closest brothers (SARS-1, MERS, Cold) are incredibly dangerous, incredibly re-infectious and whos' current infection rate is more than double or even triple that of flu.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by addicted44 on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:40PM (#22669100)
Except those people followed strict lockdown policies that are even greater than this.

You're talking about rationality and completely ignoring the fact that your numbers are based on areas where people have already taken the policies that you're saying are irrational.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by dijit on Monday March 23, 2020 @09:19PM (#22670814)
Keep an eye on the deaths not the cases (since cases depend on access to testing), and bear in mind they lag about 1-2 weeks.

In 2 weeks we'll know the true extent of how much the virus has spread today. We're behind always.

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by pjc50 on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:17PM (#22668852)
How many dead are you expecting?
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:30PM (#22668998)
Depends where you slice the group to go out as normal. If it's under-40s, then 0-0.1%, which is likely a blip compared to things like smoking, driving, heart disease, obesity, diabetes, etc.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by bonzini on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:49PM (#22669186)
That % assumes a perfectly functional healthcare system. If it gets clogged, the ICU % is a much better proxy for how many people would die.

Do you have stats for the frequency of hospitalizations in the 20-50 years old range?

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by DanBC on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:31PM (#22669011)
It's a simple question and it deserves your honest answer.

How many dead people are you expecting?

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by arcticbull on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:45PM (#22669156)
Well, based on this chart aggregating data from South Korea, China, Spain and Italy [1] (and while from Twitter, I have verified the data points line up)

People under 10, nobody has died yet. In the 10-19 category, the CFR is between 0 and 0.45% In the 20-29 category, the CFR is between 0 and 0.31% In the 30-39 category, it's between 0.1 and 0.3%.

So let's say they decide anyone under 40 with no co-morbid conditions should go out while the rest remain indoors. I'd say we're looking at a CFR of 0 to 0.1% so in terms of numbers, that would be between 0 and (33% of the population * 0.1% * 66M) ~20K people, max. That's in line with the ~15K flu deaths per year in a bad flu season in the UK. And that's assuming young people with co-morbidities do a bad job of staying inside.

[1] https://twitter.com/AndyBiotech/status/1241741127205572609?s...

Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by Gibbon1 on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:22PM (#22668909)
I think he's not expecting the dead to include himself. So he's okay with it.
Re:Strict new curbs on life in UK announced by PM by ben_w on Monday March 23, 2020 @05:22PM (#22668903)
It is not rational to ignore entirely predictable parts of human crowd dynamics.

Even if you could override human behaviour, there is still concern that the virus will mutate to fast for anything remotely similar to herd immunity to be possible.