News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by H8crilA on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:25PM (#22623388)
Please just stay at home. At all times. I've locked myself in weeks ago, before the government of my country ordered lockdowns. Even if the true fatality rate in your age range is low - you'll kill some old person out there. Perhaps dozens. It's the most you can do. Bill Ackman does a good job of explaining why you should do that (and why should all countries be shut down):

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/18/bill-ackman-pleads-to-trump-...

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by erik_seaberg on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:12PM (#22623720)
This is not a selfless thing to do (if it were, we could isolate only high-risk groups rather than everyone). If we all get it simultaneously, and run out of nurses and ventilators, the fatality rate might not be low.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by hnburnsy on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:57PM (#22623625)
He walked that back later and said he was buying stocks. From his Twitter...

'Some investors have been confused by remarks. To clarify, I am confident the president will do the right thing in temporarily shutting down the country and closing the borders. If that happens, we can win the war against the virus and the markets and the economy will soar.'

' That is why we are buying stocks. These are bargains of a lifetime if we manage this crisis correctly.'

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by H8crilA on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:59PM (#22623641)
Yeah, basically if the virus spreads doesn't matter what you're holding now. And if the country is shut down now then things will eventually improve. He said he's buying even in that interview and explained this position very clearly.

Kind of an "undefined behaviour" sort of thing - one branch of the conditional "cannot" happen, so you can assume it doesn't.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by divbzero on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:08PM (#22623693)
I don’t think his tweet walks back the needed actions he described earlier on CNBC. The tweet just expresses his confidence that President Trump will take those necessary actions.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by 6nf on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:28PM (#22623416)
Shutting down the country destroys everything. I'm not sure it's worth it.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by banachtarski on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:32PM (#22623439)
> I'm not sure it's worth it.

It is. The quarantines/border-restrictions are not permanent measures, and acting swiftly is the correct way to nip it in the bud.

> Shutting down the country destroys everything.

Empty hyperbole. Death tolls in the tens of millions is a far worse outcome, as is stressing our current healthcare systems well beyond their capacities.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by gpm on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:47PM (#22623542)
What do you think the death toll of shutting down the economy is going to be? I'm willing to bet that it turns out to higher than 10s of millions long term.

Nearly 10 million people die every year from hunger [0]. How much progress are we going to lose on that by putting the economy into a recession?

Global warming is an incoming emergency that threatens global stability. What are the odds that it leads to widespread war, widespread famine, or both? How much are we increasing those odds by starting a recession instead of continuing our R&D work at full speed hoping to find a (actually implementable) solution?

How many lives will be lost due to less funding for medical care and research? Both in the US where poor people can't afford it, and the rest of the world where less wealth means less taxes means less funding for the health care system? What if the next virus that comes along is more akin to the one that wiped out the American Chestnut trees (100% death toll) instead of just doubling your chance of dying when you get it?

[0] https://www.theworldcounts.com/challenges/people-and-poverty...

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by H8crilA on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:41PM (#22623500)
Mind boggling that someone could think that a month or two months shutdown "destroys the economy", but all Americans infected and several % dead doesn't "destroy the economy".
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by nostromo on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:44PM (#22623524)
We’ve had one week of shut down in Seattle and there’s already been a huge wave of layoffs.

Two months? It’s difficult to think what will happen.

Economies don’t have a pause button. Companies, banks, and families quickly become insolvent.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by H8crilA on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:46PM (#22623541)
I agree, this clearly needs a govt bailout. Fed already rains liquidity into the treasuries like a madman, just wait till it buys corporates and God knows what else. Treasury should now simply guarantee salaries. The unconditional helicopter money is a good idea too. This will bridge the discrepancy between financial time (which has not stopped) and economic time (which is stopping, slowly, but has to come to a full stop).

But at any rate, lives > economy. Only one of those is a renewable resource.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by 6nf on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:04PM (#22623670)
> lives > economy. Only one of those is a renewable resource.

Not sure I follow. Are you saying the economy is not a renewable resource? Cause I'm creating a new life as we speak.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by xeromal on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:48PM (#22623555)
If we're going to be frank, I doubt 70+ year olds are contributing to the economy in a huge way.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by H8crilA on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:49PM (#22623565)
We live in a deflationary environment (just look at what are the interest rates doing, world-wide). There's no supply problem, there's a demand problem. "Killing Boomers" will actually make things worse.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by wueb3behd on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:15PM (#22623736)
Empty would imply devoid of content, it's pretty obvious they were speaking metaphorically. As for if it's a good idea, you're insane if you think some of the timelines being discussed, like the 18 month one, are realistic. Americans might put up with this for a couple months tops but taking a full year off is for the Europeans with nothing better to do.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by treis on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:51PM (#22623582)
>It is. The quarantines/border-restrictions are not permanent measures, and acting swiftly is the correct way to nip it in the bud.

It's wayyyyyy to late for that.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by anoncareer0212 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:42PM (#22623514)
Nip what in the bud? The article seems to indicate the fear is of the 3.5% to 11% of 80 year olds who will die
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by pikma on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:49PM (#22623562)
Seeing the replies, it seems that most people agree that it is worth it.

But in the last few weeks I keep wondering if our reaction to covid-19 is consistent with our reactions to other causes of mortality. For example:

- 1.25 million people die in road crashes every year, yet we have collectively decided that abandoning cars is too large a sacrifice to make.

- global warming has the potential to cause huge devastations and millions of death, yet we fail to make the adequate sacrifices to limit our emissions.

So, is there something different about covid-19 that warrants these differences? Is the fatality rate higher, for example?

Or could it be a difference of game theory? For example for global warming, everybody has to participate in order to see gains.

Or maybe humans have a natural fear of germs and react stronger to contagious diseases than to other risks? I remember reading that argument in Factfulness.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by kortex on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:58PM (#22623632)
Global warming is too abstract, hard to reason by some due to the distance of cause and effect.

Car driving fatality is fairly bounded. 124 ppm/year in USA.

Coronavirus 19 has the possibility to mutate and keep waving over the world, killing an unbounded number of people, which is downright terrifying. The best-case estimate of fatality is 5000 ppm and >50% of Americans getting it, that's 20x more deadly than cars.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by gpm on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:06PM (#22623683)
That's substantially less deadly than cars. 20 years of car crashes are equivalent to this virus, and we've had and will continue to have a lot more than 20 years worth of car crashes. 5000ppm by your estimate die once, and then the virus probably stops being a problem.

We can have some faith that this virus is a one time event because

- A vaccine will probably be invented before long.

- Effective treatment will probably be discovered.

- If there is no vaccine and no treatment for some reason. You probably can't catch it twice, maybe everyone gets it once, but after that only kids get it, and kids don't die from it anyways.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by leetcrew on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:01PM (#22623655)
to prevent the 1.25 million auto deaths, we have to stop (or drastically curtail) driving forever, or until we invent reliable autonomous driving systems (quite a long time from now). the drastic measures to slow the outbreak of are only expected to be in effect for a couple months or a year at most.

people are willing to take drastic measures over a short period of time to prevent a large number of deaths. this doesn't imply they are or should be willing to take the same drastic measures indefinitely.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by divbzero on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:18PM (#22623747)
Agreed that COVID-19 is a serious threat worth countering.

Our under-reaction to other serious threats is probably both psychological and evolutionary. Psychologically, COVID-19 is salient because it’s a novel threat and our brain is hardwired to notice and react to changes. Evolutionarily, humans have encountered and survived infectious disease, but car crashes and global warming are historically new.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by H8crilA on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:52PM (#22623588)
You got your numbers wrong.

In 2016 in the US 37k people died in car crashes.

At 2% fatality rate and 70% infection rate the virus will kill 4.6M Americans.

That's over a 100x difference.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by pikma on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:55PM (#22623611)
The 1.25 million is worldwide.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by H8crilA on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:58PM (#22623629)
7.7 billion people * 0.7 * 0.02 = 108 million people

Now show me a cause of death that involves 108 million people that's not taken seriously.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by spectramax on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:11PM (#22623712)
Also, in a matter of short period ~4 months.

This is a serious pandemic.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by dismantlethesun on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:30PM (#22624141)
If COVID continues to kill people at the same rate in Italy as it does today, it will kill about ~150k people.

Applied to the whole world, the risk is killing easily 10x as much as cars.

If cars suddenly became 10x more dangerous, I'm sure it'd cause mass panic. Especially if cars became 20 to 30x more dangerous specifically to our parents or grandparents.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by madeofpalk on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:35PM (#22623463)
Everyone dying destroys everything. I'm not sure saving a cafe is worth thousands or millions of deaths.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by nostromo on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:38PM (#22623486)
People work at that cafe and use their income to feed and house their families, and to provide them with healthcare.

Don’t be dismissive of these concerns, they are very real.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by madeofpalk on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:44PM (#22623528)
I partially own, while my parents run, a cafe that's pretty fucked. I'm incredibly aware of these concerns. I just think that health comes before economy. Without healthy people, you don't have an economy.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by smallgovt on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:07PM (#22623688)
> I just think that health comes before economy.

I don't think we can make such a blanket assertion. The US markets have lost 10T in value over the past month. If the virus infects 70% of the US population with a 2% mortality rate, 4.2M ppl will die. It's obviously not so simple, but we're sacrificing $2.4M in market cap per life saved. At some point, the tradeoff makes no sense in light of the fact that we could invest in life saving technologies/solutions that save more lives down the road.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by madeofpalk on Thursday March 19, 2020 @06:17AM (#22626102)
Are you saying 4.2 million people should die?
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by smallgovt on Thursday March 19, 2020 @10:49AM (#22627983)
Yes, I'm saying at some point we should make the choice between a lot of people dying now and even more people dying later.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by 6nf on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:05PM (#22623678)
What about 97% healthy people. Is that sufficient for an economy?
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by applecrazy on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:42PM (#22623512)
Which is exactly why social safety net programs exist and continue to function during these times. Not to mention the checks that will be mailed out to every taxpayer soon.

We can and should essentially shut down the country

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by 6nf on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:48PM (#22623552)
We don't have a safety net that can feed the whole country. Some people still have to work to actually grow the food, do the distribution, and feed everyone. How is that going to happen if everyone sits at home for 2 months?
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by aianus on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:40PM (#22623495)
~57 million people die every regular year for whatever reasons

Even doubling that does not "destroy everything"

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by edmundsauto on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:47PM (#22623543)
Similarly, shutting down non-essential jobs for a couple of months does not destroy everything.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by madeofpalk on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:46PM (#22623539)
I think that an extra 57 million people dying is devastating, and we should do everything in our power - even if it means shutting down restaurants - to prevent 57 million needless deaths.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by 6nf on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:57PM (#22623623)
Problem is the current plan will not save 57 million people. Not even close. The mortality rate will still be 3.6% and we still expect 70% of the population to get infected.

So if it was as simple as you say, then sure. Let's shut it all down. But shutting it all down is not going to save us from Covid19.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by jungturk on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:42PM (#22623511)
But the death rates suggest everyone won't be dying, so we needn't ascribe too much concern to this outcome.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by owaislone on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:00PM (#22623649)
But infection rate being so high when left unchecked means the small % of deaths could be hundreds of thousands or even millions all over the world. Also Italy almost had a death rate of 8% yesterday which is huge.

Plus when hospitals get overloaded, patients needing critical care for problems other than covid-19 will die as well.

https://www.imperial.ac.uk/news/196234/covid19-imperial-rese...

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by lowbloodsugar on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:00PM (#22623646)
The US GDP is $19 trillion. If we just stopped everything, we would be missing $1.6t per month. Conceivably, the government could pump that much money into the economy by just writing checks to everyone so that they could pay their rent, their mortgage, and their landlord could pay their mortgage. We'd need to write checks to businesses too. And this is worst case. The economy hasn't shut down. Many of us are still employed and getting paid and I certainly am very grateful for that. But I'm not going to the pub every weekend so those people need cash.

If we can treat this as hitting the pause button on the economy, and find a way to fund it during this period, then we can press the play button and carry on where we left off. Of course that would require Russia, OPEC and the US to stop pumping oil. And a billion other details. But there's a lot of us, and we don't have much else to do.

This could be an economic disaster, but it doesn't need to be.

Sure, another alternative is we kill all the old people and all the doctors and nurses. Apparently some people aren't worried about the old people, but surely their self interest benefits from not killing all the doctors and nurses?

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by zamalek on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:42PM (#22623513)
Millions dying is pretty damaging, too. We can plan and mitigate with one strategy, nature dictates the outcome of the other.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by dboreham on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:51PM (#22623581)
Probably is especially as effective drug therapies may be available in the short term.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by 1996 on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:32PM (#22623442)
Some people are already calling the virus the "boomer remover"

I'm not sure I want to be in their camp.

Even with all the generational resentment in the world, destroying the economy may be better than destroying lives.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by snapetom on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:45PM (#22623532)
Oh please. When this is all over, the economy is going to come roaring back. Too many people, too much pent up anticipation in all sectors. American businesses will start looking to diversify their supply chain so this won't happen again. That alone will start a ton of new business initiatives around the world.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by H8crilA on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:37PM (#22623476)
The economy will not be destroyed. It will merely change.

It will be actually "destroyed" if the virus is not stopped.

For God's sake people stop thinking about your S&P500 index funds for a second. Also, if you still want to be selfish, your index funds will go down to ~zero if the virus is not stopped.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by nostromo on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:41PM (#22623503)
Looking at this in dispassionate economic terms...

It’s not clear to me that letting the virus run it’s coarse would hurt the economy.

Some (but certainly not most) very old people would die, but they are not in their productive years. Their assets would pass to younger people who would be more inclined to put them to use in the economy.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by 6nf on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:49PM (#22623568)
This is how I see it too. We are not going to able to stop the virus, it's everywhere already. Shutting down the country may delay this a bit which is good for hospitals but terrible for everything else.

The difference in death toll would be minimal, but the difference in the economic recovery will be substantial.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by H8crilA on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:55PM (#22623614)
Have you noticed that China has stopped it? And that new cases stopped growing in Italy? Unless you assume the US will be especially bad at handling the problem it seems like there is a solution - do what other countries did.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by 6nf on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:06PM (#22623681)
China is just lying about their numbers. Not sure you can call Italy a success just yet, their 3 biggest increases in new cases were the last 3 days.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by majos on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:46PM (#22623878)
> their 3 biggest increases in new cases were the last 3 days

As raw numbers but not percentages. 13% each of the past 3 days is better than the 15-25% (mostly nearer 25%) of the past few weeks.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by 6nf on Thursday March 19, 2020 @03:56PM (#22631016)
https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/italy/

I dont think Italy is over the hump yet

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by kortex on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:06PM (#22623680)
Not everything is about dispassionate economics. In the "we do nothing" scenario, everyone with 150 friends loses 1-5 of them, and about as many will have decreased quality of life.

That is a huuuge emotional toll.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by 6nf on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @10:16PM (#22623739)
What's the death toll with the 'shut it all down' scenario? Not much better! It's already spreading uncontained everywhere. Shutting it all down will not stop all the deaths. Not even close.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by gpm on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:55PM (#22623610)
This virus roughly doubles your chances of dying this year, if you catch it. It's not the bubonic plague. It will not by itself stop the economy or cause us all to starve to death.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by nostromo on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:36PM (#22623471)
Boomers are too young in general.

But “Silent Generation Remover” is equally distasteful and doesn’t rhyme.

Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by lonelappde on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:36PM (#22623467)
I've been wondering, all the kids pushing the nonsense stereotype prejudice against "boomers" -- do they all hate their grandparents?
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by forkexec on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @09:37PM (#22623475)
That's some serious ageist hate coming from people who may get to be old themselves someday, with younger generations cheering for their death. The Golden Rule didn't get learned, I guess.
Re:Severe Outcomes Among U.S. Patients with Covid-19, Feb 12... by dismantlethesun on Wednesday March 18, 2020 @11:19PM (#22624086)
Wouldn't it be easier and perhaps better to only quarantine the old and those most at risk, then spend millions of dollars and community time to support them utterly through the next 3-6 months till the virus dies out?

The other approach is what we have now in the US, which is rolling quarantines as we put out virus outbreaks like brushfires. It disrupts everyone's life and makes it harder to get supplies to those most at need as everyone is constantly preparing themselves for a personal lockin.