We're much better off right now with the government seizing the means of production and figuring out how to make as many as possible.
https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1239675564199481347.html
>The President said today that governors should try to get things like respirators and masks on their own. The problem with that approach is that suppliers will have to emergently engage w 50 different state purchasers who would in effect be competing for supply. 8/x
>Instead, the US fed gov should be central buyer and partner to this industry. It brings substantial immediate resources, and clarity. And when manufacturers make new ventilators in a mass effort, the fed gov would help organize their distribution around the country. 9/x
>What we need is a massive fed gov program to buy ventilators on unprecedented scale and with unprecedented speed. They don’t need to be the fanciest ventilators on the market. They need to be able to keep ARDS pts alive through course of COVID infection. 10/x
>This @forbes article gives snapshot of vent industry and a sense of what might be possible. It quotes one US manufacturer from 2 days ago saying he could ramp up production 5 fold but he hasn’t been asked to do it yet.
Why would we give them a choice?
The last thing we want is for "the government" to go around seizing production capacity from companies that have successfully produced these units for decades. When you imagine "the government", don't imagine your ideal policitian in a cape - you should imagine the bloke down at the local tax office who keeps opening obvious malware emails.
Corporations are not your faceless enemy, they're the ones who've helped your hospitals become amazing in the last few decades.
There's no way the current problem is only the price, for sure they are already trying to sell the most they can, they simply can't produce enough of them. Allowing some kind of shadow production, handled by the manufacturer can only means much more product made thus sold. It's a win-win for both the manufacturer and the government.
> We're much better off right now with the government seizing the means of production and figuring out how to make as many as possible.
Sure that would work, but that's always been true for anything. If the government could seize production, it would be "cheaper" to produce because the cost of R&D and production has been already done. That's not healthy though, that will now be an added risk in the industry that will have a cost to be mitigated.
Lets works together, not against eachother.
The arrangement does actually work fairly well in a crisis; you just need the sense of urgency to get everyone in the private sector all cranking on the same problem.
Or at least it has worked well before. Things like the F-22, F35, and Littoral Combat Ship aside... There is a point where stuff turns into a nightmare. The medical equipment needed though isn't really a problem where you should run into the sort of slog those projects ran into though.
You don't know how happy I am to see you say that.
Because capitalism only works with a functioning economy. If everything goes all pear shaped, and we have tens of thousands of people dying because we don't have enough ventilators (and the numbers suggest that this is quite possible), these companies that have been filling their bathtubs with cash are going to have angry gun toting mobs of newly homeless and bereaved Americans using their office windows for target practice. This will happen regardless of what's right or wrong, legal or illegal. We haven't seen this here before because we haven't had a strong enough economic collapse yet (excluding the Great Depression of course, where some of this did happen). It's happened in many other countries, and may happen here too if CEOs don't take a more long term perspective on pricing.
Also, government is much less effective at producing things than private companies.
Pricing signals are also bad at some things.
Saying "the government is bad at producing things" is an overgeneralization. It'd be bad to put it in charge of producing everything. But putting markets in charge of producing everything has points of failure too, which is why we're having this conversation.
No it doesn’t. As soon as governments clearly states that they want to purchase a hundred billion masks and ventilators, market will react very quickly.
They government did not post that request yet.
If these rocket engines are cheaper, why not buy something from someone who is producing them below production cost? Good for US, they save money.
I thought this was common knowledge for 30 years.
There are also risks to having someone else manufacture a widget that incorporates technology you'd rather not spread around.
This is why there will always be at least one domestic chip foundry, and most of the critical components of ICBM's /nuclear weapons are manufactured domestically as I understand it. Medical equipment also falls under that umbrella. Hell, even taps and dies do. God bless Admiral Rickover in that regard.
Somehow? With captured German rocket scientists.
Same as USA.
That said, there are reasons why USSR was first in space. For example, USSR deliberately ignored human life cost. In particular, they seriously considered first human flight to be a failure, so they announced it publicly only after Gagarin landed successfully.
British empire did war mostly on the sea, so US and British Empire were much better at producing ships, aircrafts, and also radio, radars and other electronics.
Tanks is good but it is much less important than strategy, logistics, food, drugs and saving human lives.
USSR killed a huge number of own citizens (including execution of so called deserters). Well, good for the rest of allies.
Stalin fleeced the Kuleks to pay for Americans to build factories just before WW2, after Ford's River Rouge industrial city was completed.
He did a good job on T-34 production, but around half of Soviet armaments came from the USA during WW2. The tanks were directly driven to the front - no parking lot needed! :)
Stalin is portayed as a monster because he was. But he was also the great leader his country needed at that time.